BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions
Supplier Concentration Risk: Dual Sourcing and Safety Stock
To keep production running, reduce dependence on one supplier and hold inventory that buys time during an interruption. Below: a step-by-step test for choosing an independent backup and a practical buffer before storm season.
Try one first
Hint
Think about which choice reduces the actual chance and impact of a production shutdown, not just the financial aftermath.
Answer D. Qualifying a backup supplier and holding a modest safety stock directly reduces both the likelihood and operational impact of a supply interruption while allowing continued sales. This mitigation approach addresses business continuity (production and customer service), not just the financial consequences, making it the best response given management's goal to keep the product available.
Why not A: Monitoring and accepting the risk may be appropriate when a risk is small or unavoidable, but here the exposure is significant and manageable. An annual review does little to lower the probability or operational impact of a disruption.
Why not B: Insurance can shift some financial loss, but it does not prevent production stoppages or delayed orders. Because management wants to keep selling the product, mitigation that preserves operations is a stronger response than transferring only the financial risk.
Why not C: Stopping the product would remove the supply risk but conflicts with the stated objective to continue selling the product. It is an overly extreme avoidance strategy when practical mitigation is available.
Step by step
- Identify what must keep running
North Co. buys 90% of a critical component from one supplier in a storm-prone coastal region. Management wants to keep selling the product, so the response must preserve production rather than discontinue the line.
- Create another supply path
Qualify a second supplier that can provide the required component, preferably in a different region. This reduces the chance that one regional disruption will cut off North's supply.
- Check the upstream dependency
Determine whether both suppliers obtain a key subpart from the same upstream manufacturer. If they do, that manufacturer remains a common point of failure despite the extra supplier name.
- Buy time with safety stock
Maintain a reasonable component buffer to support production while alternate deliveries begin. Match the buffer to the time needed to activate replacement supply rather than assuming the backup can deliver immediately.
- Act before storm season
Complete supplier qualification and build the inventory buffer before the next storm season. Waiting until shipments stop leaves North exposed during the time needed to arrange replacement supply.
- Separate continuity from reimbursement
Business interruption insurance may reimburse covered losses, but it does not deliver the missing component. Closer monitoring also provides no replacement supply, so neither is the best primary continuity response.
- Classify the response correctly
The independent backup and safety stock reduce risk while North continues selling the product. Some residual risk remains because alternate suppliers and inventory do not guarantee uninterrupted production.
Key points
- Remember: insurance can replace lost dollars, but it cannot replace the component needed to keep production running.
- Count independent supply paths, not supplier names.
- A supplier interruption and a production stoppage are different: backup supply and inventory can keep the first from causing the second.
How the exam traps you
- Buy insurance and leave the single-source arrangement unchanged. Address component availability first; insurance only offsets covered financial losses.
- Assume several suppliers automatically create diversification. Check whether they rely on the same upstream manufacturer.
- Wait for a storm before qualifying the backup. Complete qualification and build the buffer before storm season.
Question 2
| Response | Residual exposure | Within mitigation budget? |
|---|---|---|
| Accept the risk and monitor the supplier | $900,000 | Yes |
| Qualify a second supplier and carry limited safety stock | $340,000 | Yes |
| Purchase contingent business interruption insurance | $520,000 | Yes |
| Cancel the launch | $0 | Not applicable |
Hint
Start by comparing each response's residual risk to the stated tolerance, then consider whether the response still supports the approved strategy.
Answer B. Qualifying a second supplier and carrying limited safety stock is the best action because it is a feasible response that reduces the residual exposure to $340,000, which is below the board's $400,000 tolerance, while preserving the approved strategy and launch timing. Risk management does not require eliminating all risk when an acceptable residual level can be achieved. The option is also within the approved mitigation budget, making it the preferred choice.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may overweight the project's upside and think positive NPV offsets risk. However, monitoring alone leaves a $900,000 residual exposure, which exceeds the board-approved $400,000 tolerance, so it is not an acceptable response.
Why not C: Insurance is a plausible mitigation, but the quantified residual exposure after insurance is $520,000, still above the $400,000 tolerance. Transferring part of the risk is insufficient when residual exposure remains too high.
Why not D: Avoidance fully eliminates exposure but the stem specifies cancelation is appropriate only if no feasible response can reduce risk within tolerance while preserving strategy. Because dual sourcing plus safety stock meets those requirements, canceling is unnecessarily extreme and sacrifices a positive-NPV initiative.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the company's stated objective and identify which fact creates the most direct threat to that objective.
Answer A. Management projects that 65% of Year 1 sales will come from a single retailer and those purchase orders are cancellable until shipment. That customer concentration combined with cancellable orders directly threatens the stated objective of protecting Year 1 operating cash flows, making this the primary risk.
Why not B: Variable-rate financing can affect cash flows, so this is tempting. However, the credit line is described as relatively small, so interest-rate movements are less likely to be the primary threat compared with a potential loss of the bulk of projected sales.
Why not C: Obsolescence is a plausible operational risk with specialized equipment, which makes this attractive as a distractor. The facts, however, give no indication of rapid technological change or an unusually short life for the equipment, and this risk is less immediately tied to Year 1 operating cash flows than the cancellable large customer orders.
Why not D: Forecasting error and inventory risk are realistic concerns for a new product and thus a plausible trap. Still, the fact that 65% of expected sales depend on one retailer whose orders can be cancelled is a more specific and immediate risk to Year 1 cash flows than generic forecast inaccuracy.
Question 4
Hint
Anchor on the stated risk appetite and the company’s delivery objective, then ask which exposure remains most inconsistent with both.
Answer A. The stem emphasizes a very low tolerance for patient-care disruption and an objective to fill 98% of hospital orders within 24 hours. Reliance on one carrier for 85% of critical shipments creates a single point of failure that directly threatens that objective. The improvised, non-scalable workaround after the storm shows the residual operational risk remains significant despite insurance for physical loss.
Why not B: Tempting because hedging resin (under 2% of COGS) looks like poor prioritization. However, the question asks for the primary risk-management concern: a low-impact market hedge is less critical than a high-impact continuity risk that contradicts a very low appetite for service disruption.
Why not C: This attracts candidates who equate risk management with risk transfer. While the insurance gap matters financially, insurance does not prevent operational failures (missed hospital deliveries) or fully mitigate reputational harm. The priority should be reducing the operational exposure that threatens the delivery objective.
Why not D: A recent improvised workaround that is explicitly not scalable is weak evidence of effective mitigation. A one-off near miss does not demonstrate that residual risk is within a declared very low appetite for service disruption.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the company has truly removed its single point of failure or has only shifted where that concentration exists.
Answer C. This shows that a single upstream manufacturer remains a common point of failure: if that manufacturer is disrupted, all four suppliers could be affected at once. Adding more direct suppliers does not meaningfully reduce the disruption risk when the underlying input is concentrated.
Why not A: This highlights implementation effort, which is a real operational burden, but it does not change the underlying exposure to supplier disruption. Administrative setup does not negate the diversification benefit if the suppliers are truly independent upstream.
Why not B: This is tempting because higher cost can make a mitigation less attractive overall, but the question asks which fact most limits the risk-reduction benefit. Slightly higher prices affect cost, not whether the plan actually reduces the chance of a simultaneous supply interruption.
Why not D: Annual renewals may introduce some future uncertainty, but they do not by themselves make the current distribution of purchases ineffective at reducing simultaneous supplier failure risk. The presence of a shared upstream source is a stronger limiting condition.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether Falcon's action eliminates the risk, shifts it completely, or mainly lowers the chance or severity of loss.
Answer A. Falcon's action is a risk reduction or mitigation response. Adding backup suppliers and paying for standby capacity lowers the chance of a production stoppage or reduces its potential severity, but it does not eliminate the underlying supply risk. Because no arrangement guarantees uninterrupted delivery, Falcon still faces residual supply-chain risk.
Why not B: This is tempting because backup suppliers sound decisive. However, risk avoidance means exiting or eliminating the activity that creates the risk (for example, no longer using the component). Here Falcon still needs the component, so the risk has been managed, not avoided.
Why not C: Contracts can shift some risk, but standby agreements typically do not remove Falcon's operational exposure if suppliers fail. Full risk transfer would require mechanisms (like guaranteed delivery with penalties or insurance) that eliminate Falcon's operational consequences; that is not described here.
Why not D: This distractor focuses on cost but misses the mitigation intent. Paying a premium for standby capacity is a deliberate action to reduce exposure; acceptance would mean knowingly retaining the risk without substantive mitigating measures.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on what risk is being addressed by moving away from a single-source supplier, and remember that risk reduction is not the same as risk elimination.
Answer A. Adding a second qualified supplier reduces dependence on a single source and thus lowers supply‑chain concentration and disruption risk. However, using an alternative supplier can raise costs (higher unit price, additional coordination). Risk management often reduces exposure at a cost rather than eliminating risk entirely.
Why not B: This is tempting because diversification improves resilience, but it does not eliminate delay risk, both suppliers could still face shortages, logistics issues, or quality problems. The decision reduces the probability of disruption but does not guarantee zero delays.
Why not C: This answer overgeneralizes by asserting an absolute ('always') effect. While managing multiple suppliers can add complexity, it does not automatically increase residual risk; in this scenario the primary effect is reduced single‑supplier exposure.
Why not D: This misclassifies the risk: supplier dependence and potential production disruption are classic operational risks. Therefore, adding a backup supplier does meaningfully affect the company's operational risk profile.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on which risk is least mitigated by the stated facts and which one triggers the most immediate business consequence within the 90-day contract window.
Answer B. The primary issue is timing and single-source concentration: a regulator-approved critical chip supplied almost entirely from one overseas vendor may be delayed up to 10 weeks, which can prevent meeting the 90-day delivery window and trigger contract penalties. Other risks (foreign exchange, margin pressure, liquidity) are explicitly mitigated in the stem (hedgeable FX, material price pass-through, available borrowing/covenant headroom) and therefore are secondary consequences rather than the immediate ERM priority.
Why not A: This is tempting because the input is imported, but the stem states management can hedge the related foreign currency exposure at low cost, reducing FX as the primary near-term threat; the pressing issue is whether the chip will be available to meet delivery timing.
Why not C: Margin pressure is a plausible concern with fixed-price contracts, but these contracts permit direct material price increases to be billed to customers, which materially weakens the margin-compression argument relative to the supply-timing problem.
Why not D: Liquidity could be a downstream consequence if penalties are incurred, but the stem indicates sufficient borrowing capacity and covenant headroom to absorb a temporary cost increase, making liquidity less immediate than the operational disruption from supplier concentration.
Common questions
How does dual sourcing reduce supplier concentration risk?
A qualified alternate provides another supply path if the primary supplier fails. The benefit is limited if both suppliers depend on the same upstream bottleneck.
Why hold safety stock if a backup supplier exists?
Safety stock buys time while backup deliveries begin. A backup supplier may not be able to replace interrupted shipments immediately.
Is dual sourcing risk reduction or risk transfer?
It is risk reduction because it changes operations to lower disruption exposure. Insurance transfers some financial consequences, but neither response guarantees uninterrupted production.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Risk management
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.