PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions

Expected Annual Risk Cost: Accept, Mitigate, or Transfer?

Choose the lowest total expected annual cost that meets the stated risk appetite. Below: a worked comparison of acceptance, controls, and insurance showing why the cheapest option can fail.

The ruleTotal expected annual cost = residual probability × retained loss per event + annual response cost. Choose the lowest-cost option that meets the stated appetite, using the measure of risk specified.

Try one first

Company X faces an annual cyber-incident risk. Management estimates a 20% probability in any given year of a successful attack that would cause $1,000,000 in direct losses. Management is evaluating four mutually exclusive Year‑1 responses. For each option, compute the expected annual net cost (expected retained loss = probability × retained loss per incident, plus any recurring cost such as a control cost, insurance premium, or outsourcing fee). Which option will have the greatest effect (largest reduction) on expected annual net cost compared with taking no action?
Hint

For each option: calculate retained expected loss = probability × retained loss, then add the recurring cost (control cost, premium, or fee). Compare those net expected costs to the no-action expected loss of $200,000. Don't assume insurance or outsourcing reduces the incident probability.

Worked example

Cedar Co. faces a 10% annual breach probability and a $600,000 loss per breach. Choose one response: accept; controls costing $20,000 annually that reduce probability to 4%; or insurance costing $40,000 annually that covers 90% of each loss without changing probability. Controls leave loss severity unchanged. The board limits residual expected annual incident loss to $10,000. Minimize total expected annual cost within that limit.

1Accept: expected annual cost10% × $600,000$60,000
2Controls: expected loss plus annual cost(4% × $600,000) + $20,000 = $24,000 + $20,000$44,000
3Insurance: retained loss per breach(100% − 90%) × $600,000$60,000
4Insurance: expected retained loss plus premium(10% × $60,000) + $40,000 = $6,000 + $40,000$46,000
5Apply the expected-loss appetiteAccept: $60,000 > $10,000; controls: $24,000 > $10,000; insurance: $6,000 ≤ $10,000Only insurance qualifies

Purchase insurance. Its total expected annual cost is $46,000, and its $6,000 residual expected annual loss meets the board's appetite.

Check: Insurance transfers $54,000 of the original $60,000 expected loss for a $40,000 premium, saving $14,000 and leaving total annual cost of $46,000.

Key points

  • Cedar's appetite limits expected incident losses, not premiums or total annual cost.
  • Insurance changes Cedar's retained loss, not its breach probability.
  • A control can lower total cost yet leave too much residual risk.

How the exam traps you

  • Report insurance's $6,000 expected retained loss as its total annual cost. Add the $40,000 premium to reach $46,000.
  • Use the original 10% probability for controls, producing an $80,000 total. Use the reduced 4% probability, producing a $44,000 total.
  • Choose controls because their $44,000 total is lowest. Reject controls because their $24,000 residual expected loss exceeds the $10,000 appetite.

7 more, each from a different angle

0 of 7 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

MNO Inc. has three risks remaining after baseline controls. Management can afford only one immediate risk response and its objective is to minimize total expected monetary cost (expected loss from risks + cost of the chosen response). For each risk the current probability and loss and the available single-response options are shown below. Which single immediate action should management take to best achieve its objective?
Risk 1
Cybersecurity Breach
Risk 2
Regulatory Non-Compliance
Risk 3
Supplier Disruption
Loss if event occurs$1,000,000$2,000,000$400,000
Probability (after baseline controls)20%3%10%
Current expected loss$200,000$60,000$40,000
Mitigate optionAdvanced monitoring $120,000; reduces probability to 5%Compliance program $80,000; reduces probability to 0.5%Qualify 2nd supplier $100,000; reduces probability to 2%
Transfer optionCyber insurance $150,000 premium; covers 80% of lossNo insurance availableContractual clause shifts 50% of loss to supplier for $30,000/yr
Hint

For each candidate action, add the action's cost to the residual expected loss for that risk (new probability × loss), then add unchanged expected losses for the other risks, choose the action that yields the lowest total.

Question 3

Apex Corp plans to launch a new product with an expected incremental pre-tax profit of $12 million over the product's life. A preliminary legal review indicates that noncompliance with an anticipated regulation could trigger a $30 million statutory fine and a $5 million recall/remediation cost if enforcement occurs. The current probability of enforcement absent new controls is estimated at 10%. Apex can choose one of four responses: (1) proceed without additional actions (accept the risk); (2) implement a targeted compliance program that costs $2 million and would reduce the enforcement probability to 2%; (3) purchase an insurance policy for a one-time premium of $0.8 million that covers recall/remediation costs but explicitly excludes statutory fines; or (4) delay and redesign before launch at a one-time cost of $3 million, which would eliminate the regulatory risk. Assume no other impacts on revenues or costs. Which risk-management response is best to maximize Apex's expected net benefit?
Hint

Calculate expected monetary loss for each alternative (probability × impact), add the explicit costs (compliance, premium, redesign), and compare to the $12M expected profit; note insurance excludes statutory fines.

Question 4

BluePeak Inc. manufactures a specialized electronic module that relies on a single overseas supplier for a critical microchip. Management estimates a 25% chance next year of a supplier disruption that would halt production and cause a one-time lost contribution margin of $800,000. Discontinuing the product line would eliminate the risk but would forfeit an annual contribution margin of $1,200,000. Management is evaluating responses to this supplier risk. Which of the following is the most appropriate response?
Hint

Estimate expected annual costs (probability × loss) for each alternative; include insurance premium plus expected deductible/out-of-pocket, and consider forgone contribution for avoidance.

Question 5

A business analyst (BA) at JaxTech is preparing a Year 1 release of a new customer portal. The BA identifies a risk that a key third-party vendor may not deliver a required integration by go‑live. Without mitigation, the BA estimates the probability of non‑delivery at 60% and the business impact at $250,000 if non‑delivery occurs. Company risk policy states that any risk with expected loss (probability × impact) greater than $100,000 must be actively mitigated by the project team; if the least‑cost feasible mitigation exceeds the project's approved mitigation budget of $100,000, the BA must escalate the risk to senior management for a decision. The BA identifies two feasible mitigations: (1) pay the vendor a $20,000 expedite fee that would reduce the probability to 15% (impact unchanged), or (2) develop the integration in‑house at a cost of $120,000, which would reduce probability to 10% and reduce impact to $50,000. Assume mitigation costs are incurred immediately and take effect as estimated. What is the required response the BA should recommend?
Hint

Calculate expected loss (probability × impact), compare it to the $100,000 threshold, then check whether the least‑cost mitigation is within the $100,000 mitigation budget before deciding.

Question 6

MidCo, a mid-size manufacturer, has identified a ransomware risk. Estimated annual probability before controls is 20% and estimated loss per successful attack is $800,000 (inherent EAL = $160,000). Current controls (endpoint detection and employee phishing training) reduce the annual attack probability to 12%, but MidCo lacks air-gapped backups and a formal incident response (IR) plan. MidCo's board has set a risk appetite that no single operational risk may have a residual expected annual loss (EAL) exceeding $75,000. Implementing air-gapped backups plus a formal IR plan would cost $220,000 up front and $30,000 per year and is expected to reduce probability to 3% and loss per event to $100,000 (residual EAL ≈ $3,000). Cyber insurance that would cap MidCo's net loss at $50,000 per incident is available for $40,000 per year but only if air-gapped backups and an IR plan are already in place. Which is the best conclusion about how MidCo should respond to the ransomware risk now?
Hint

Calculate the residual EAL under current controls and compare it to the board's $75,000 appetite; also check whether insurance is immediately available without first implementing other controls.

Question 7

Company Alpha operates an online sales channel. Management estimates the annual expected loss from a potential cyber data breach at $250,000 if no action is taken. Management is considering four responses: • Implement proposed technical controls that would reduce the expected annual breach loss to $50,000 but would cost $220,000 per year to implement and maintain. • Purchase a cyber insurance policy with an annual premium of $120,000 and a $10,000 retention; with insurance the company's approximate annual expected outlay (premium plus average retention) would be about $130,000. • Discontinue the online sales channel. • Make no changes and accept the risk. Which risk management response is most appropriate based on cost-effectiveness and preserving business operations?
Hint

Compare each option's net annual cost (including residual losses and implementation/premium costs) and consider whether stopping the business activity is a realistic solution.

Question 8

Company M has identified three residual risks (already reflecting baseline controls) with the following expected annual losses and proposed single additional controls. Management has budget to implement only one control and its objective is to maximize reduction in expected annual loss per dollar spent (i.e., expected-loss reduction ÷ annual control cost). Controls are independent. Which control should management prioritize? • Supply-chain concentration (single supplier for a critical component): residual expected annual loss = $1,200,000. Proposed control: qualify and contract a secondary supplier; annual cost = $200,000; expected-loss reduction = 50% of this risk (i.e., $600,000). • Accounts receivable concentration (few customers): residual expected annual loss = $120,000. Proposed control: purchase credit insurance covering 80% of losses; annual premium = $75,000; expected-loss reduction = 80% of this risk (i.e., $96,000). • Ransomware cyber risk: residual expected annual loss = $1,500,000. Proposed control: implement an advanced cybersecurity program; annual cost = $400,000; expected-loss reduction = 60% of this risk (i.e., $900,000).
Hint

For each proposed control, compute the expected annual loss reduction divided by the control's annual cost, then compare those ratios to determine which is largest.

Drill all 111 Risk management questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do you calculate total expected annual risk cost?

Multiply residual event probability by the loss retained per event, then add annual response cost. Cedar's controls cost 4% × $600,000 + $20,000 = $44,000 annually.

How does insurance affect expected annual loss?

Use the loss the company retains after coverage, without changing the event probability. Cedar retains $60,000 per breach, so expected retained loss is 10% × $60,000 = $6,000 before the premium.

Why reject the risk response with the lowest expected cost?

The cheapest response may violate the stated risk appetite. Cedar's controls cost less than insurance but leave $24,000 of expected annual loss, above the $10,000 limit.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Risk management

All Risk management practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.