BAR · Business Analysis · 8 practice questions
Expected Annual Risk Cost: Accept, Mitigate, or Transfer?
Choose the lowest total expected annual cost that meets the stated risk appetite. Below: a worked comparison of acceptance, controls, and insurance showing why the cheapest option can fail.
Try one first
Hint
For each option: calculate retained expected loss = probability × retained loss, then add the recurring cost (control cost, premium, or fee). Compare those net expected costs to the no-action expected loss of $200,000. Don't assume insurance or outsourcing reduces the incident probability.
Answer B. Calculate expected annual net cost for each choice. No action: 0.20 × $1,000,000 = $200,000. Controls: 0.05 × $1,000,000 = $50,000 retained loss + $40,000 control cost = $90,000. Insurance: retained loss 20% of $1,000,000 = $200,000; expected retained loss = 0.20 × $200,000 = $40,000 + $70,000 premium = $110,000. Outsource = $150,000 fee. Preventive controls give the lowest net expected cost ($90,000) and thus the largest reduction from $200,000.
Why not A: Insurance reduces the insured portion per incident but does not change event probability; expected retained loss = 0.20 × $200,000 = $40,000, plus the $70,000 premium = $110,000, which is higher than the controls option.
Why not C: Doing nothing yields expected annual loss = 0.20 × $1,000,000 = $200,000, which is larger than the net expected cost under the other actionable options.
Why not D: Full contractual transfer removes retained incident loss but costs a fixed $150,000 annually, which reduces expected cost less than the controls option ($150,000 > $90,000).
Worked example
Cedar Co. faces a 10% annual breach probability and a $600,000 loss per breach. Choose one response: accept; controls costing $20,000 annually that reduce probability to 4%; or insurance costing $40,000 annually that covers 90% of each loss without changing probability. Controls leave loss severity unchanged. The board limits residual expected annual incident loss to $10,000. Minimize total expected annual cost within that limit.
| 1 | Accept: expected annual cost10% × $600,000 | $60,000 |
| 2 | Controls: expected loss plus annual cost(4% × $600,000) + $20,000 = $24,000 + $20,000 | $44,000 |
| 3 | Insurance: retained loss per breach(100% − 90%) × $600,000 | $60,000 |
| 4 | Insurance: expected retained loss plus premium(10% × $60,000) + $40,000 = $6,000 + $40,000 | $46,000 |
| 5 | Apply the expected-loss appetiteAccept: $60,000 > $10,000; controls: $24,000 > $10,000; insurance: $6,000 ≤ $10,000 | Only insurance qualifies |
Purchase insurance. Its total expected annual cost is $46,000, and its $6,000 residual expected annual loss meets the board's appetite.
Check: Insurance transfers $54,000 of the original $60,000 expected loss for a $40,000 premium, saving $14,000 and leaving total annual cost of $46,000.
Key points
- Cedar's appetite limits expected incident losses, not premiums or total annual cost.
- Insurance changes Cedar's retained loss, not its breach probability.
- A control can lower total cost yet leave too much residual risk.
How the exam traps you
- Report insurance's $6,000 expected retained loss as its total annual cost. Add the $40,000 premium to reach $46,000.
- Use the original 10% probability for controls, producing an $80,000 total. Use the reduced 4% probability, producing a $44,000 total.
- Choose controls because their $44,000 total is lowest. Reject controls because their $24,000 residual expected loss exceeds the $10,000 appetite.
Question 2
| Risk 1 Cybersecurity Breach | Risk 2 Regulatory Non-Compliance | Risk 3 Supplier Disruption | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loss if event occurs | $1,000,000 | $2,000,000 | $400,000 |
| Probability (after baseline controls) | 20% | 3% | 10% |
| Current expected loss | $200,000 | $60,000 | $40,000 |
| Mitigate option | Advanced monitoring $120,000; reduces probability to 5% | Compliance program $80,000; reduces probability to 0.5% | Qualify 2nd supplier $100,000; reduces probability to 2% |
| Transfer option | Cyber insurance $150,000 premium; covers 80% of loss | No insurance available | Contractual clause shifts 50% of loss to supplier for $30,000/yr |
Hint
For each candidate action, add the action's cost to the residual expected loss for that risk (new probability × loss), then add unchanged expected losses for the other risks, choose the action that yields the lowest total.
Answer A. Compute total expected monetary cost = chosen response cost + residual expected losses for all risks. Baseline expected losses are cyber $200,000 (20% × $1,000,000), regulatory $60,000 (3% × $2,000,000), and supplier $40,000 (10% × $400,000) = $300,000. Advanced monitoring costs $120,000 and reduces cyber expected loss to $50,000 (5% × $1,000,000), so total = $120,000 + $50,000 + $60,000 + $40,000 = $270,000, the lowest total among the options.
Why not B: Insurance costs $150,000 plus the company's expected uncovered loss of $40,000 (breach probability 20% × company share 20% × $1,000,000), so the cyber-related cost becomes $190,000; adding regulatory and supplier expected losses ($60,000 + $40,000) yields a total of $290,000, which is higher than the $270,000 total under monitoring.
Why not C: The compliance program costs $80,000 and reduces regulatory expected loss from $60,000 to $10,000, making regulatory total $90,000; with unchanged cyber and supplier expected losses the overall total is $330,000, so the program's cost exceeds its expected loss reduction.
Why not D: Qualifying a second supplier costs $100,000 and lowers supplier expected loss from $40,000 to $8,000, giving a supplier total of $108,000; combined with the unchanged cyber and regulatory expected losses the overall total is $368,000, which is the least cost-effective choice.
Question 3
Hint
Calculate expected monetary loss for each alternative (probability × impact), add the explicit costs (compliance, premium, redesign), and compare to the $12M expected profit; note insurance excludes statutory fines.
Answer D. Compute expected monetary outcomes for each choice. Proceeding as-is: expected loss = 0.10×($30M+$5M) = $3.5M, net = $12.0M − $3.5M = $8.5M. Compliance program: cost $2.0M plus expected loss 0.02×$35M = $0.7M, net = $12.0M − $2.0M − $0.7M = $9.3M (highest). Insurance: premium $0.8M plus expected fines 0.10×$30M = $3.0M, net = $12.0M − $0.8M − $3.0M = $8.2M. Redesign: cost $3.0M eliminates risk, net = $12.0M − $3.0M = $9.0M. Therefore the targeted compliance program maximizes expected net benefit.
Why not A: Tempting because it avoids upfront spending, but its expected loss (0.10×$35M = $3.5M) leaves a lower net benefit than the compliance program (≈ $8.5M vs ≈ $9.3M).
Why not B: Eliminating the risk is certain but costs $3.0M upfront; that yields a net benefit of $9.0M, which is slightly less than the compliance program's net (≈ $9.3M).
Why not C: Insurance reduces recall exposure but excludes statutory fines, so expected fines (0.10×$30M = $3.0M) plus the premium leave total costs higher than the compliance option, yielding a lower net benefit.
Question 4
Hint
Estimate expected annual costs (probability × loss) for each alternative; include insurance premium plus expected deductible/out-of-pocket, and consider forgone contribution for avoidance.
Answer A. Mitigation (D) is best because it materially lowers both the likelihood and severity of loss at a much lower net expected cost while preserving the product's contribution. Compare expected annual costs: no action expected loss = 0.25 × $800,000 = $200,000; mitigation = $60,000 annual cost + 0.05 × $100,000 residual loss = $65,000 total; insurance = $160,000 premium + 0.25 × $100,000 deductible = $185,000 total; avoidance forfeits $1,200,000 of contribution. Because mitigation's net expected cost (~$65,000) is lowest, it is the preferred response.
Why not B: Tempting because avoidance completely removes the risk; however it is disproportionate here: stopping the product sacrifices $1,200,000 of annual contribution, far greater than the expected disruption cost, making avoidance uneconomical.
Why not C: Tempting because insurance shifts some event costs to an insurer; however with a $100,000 deductible and $700,000 limit, an $800,000 loss would leave the firm with the $100,000 deductible. The insurance option's expected annual cost ≈ $160,000 premium + 0.25 × $100,000 = $185,000, which is still higher than the mitigation option's ≈ $65,000.
Why not D: Tempting because it requires no immediate expenditure; however it leaves full exposure. The expected annual loss if nothing changes is 0.25 × $800,000 = $200,000, which is substantially higher than the mitigation option's approximate $65,000 net cost.
Question 5
Hint
Calculate expected loss (probability × impact), compare it to the $100,000 threshold, then check whether the least‑cost mitigation is within the $100,000 mitigation budget before deciding.
Answer B. Unmitigated expected loss = 0.60 × $250,000 = $150,000, which exceeds the $100,000 policy threshold and therefore requires active mitigation. Paying the $20,000 expedite fee reduces residual expected loss to 0.15 × $250,000 = $37,500 (below the $100,000 threshold), and the mitigation cost ($20,000) is within the project's $100,000 mitigation budget. Therefore the BA should recommend the vendor expedite fee as the cost‑effective, policy‑compliant mitigation.
Why not A: Tempting because it avoids immediate spending, but it's incorrect: policy requires active mitigation whenever expected loss exceeds $100,000. The unmitigated expected loss is $150,000, so acceptance without mitigation would violate policy.
Why not C: Tempting because it yields the smallest residual risk, but it's incorrect: the in‑house mitigation costs $120,000, which exceeds the project's $100,000 mitigation budget. Per the policy, a mitigation that exceeds the approved budget would require escalation rather than unilateral implementation by the BA; additionally, it is not the least‑cost feasible mitigation available.
Why not D: Tempting because escalation is required when the least‑cost feasible mitigation is above budget, but it's incorrect here: a cheaper feasible mitigation exists (the $20,000 expedite) that is within budget and reduces residual expected loss below the threshold, so escalation is unnecessary.
Question 6
Hint
Calculate the residual EAL under current controls and compare it to the board's $75,000 appetite; also check whether insurance is immediately available without first implementing other controls.
Answer C. Under current controls residual EAL = 12% × $800,000 = $96,000, which exceeds the board's $75,000 annual appetite. The available cyber insurance that would cap net loss requires air-gapped backups and an IR plan, so insurance is not immediately obtainable. Implementing the backups and IR plan reduces residual EAL to 3% × $100,000 = $3,000, bringing the risk within the board's appetite and enabling insurance later, so that is the best immediate action.
Why not A: Tempting because it emphasizes cost and acknowledges controls have helped, but it is wrong: the computed residual EAL under current controls (12% × $800,000 = $96,000) still exceeds the board's explicit annual appetite of $75,000, so simply accepting the risk would violate governance.
Why not B: Transfer looks attractive because a $50,000 per-incident cap would meet the $75,000 appetite, but this option is wrong: the insurer's policy is conditional on air-gapped backups and a formal IR plan already being in place, so insurance cannot be obtained now without first implementing those controls.
Why not D: Monitoring avoids immediate expense but is the wrong immediate choice here: deferring leaves the company with a residual EAL of about $96,000, which exceeds the board's stated $75,000 appetite and fails to meet the governance requirement.
Question 7
Hint
Compare each option's net annual cost (including residual losses and implementation/premium costs) and consider whether stopping the business activity is a realistic solution.
Answer C. Purchasing the insurance results in an approximate annual outlay of $130,000 (premium plus average retention), which is less than the current expected loss of $250,000 and much less than the combined cost of controls plus residual loss (≈ $270,000). Insurance also preserves the online channel, so transferring the risk is the most cost-effective option that maintains operations.
Why not A: Doing nothing leaves the company with an expected annual loss of $250,000. While it avoids upfront costs, acceptance is more expensive than the insurance option ($130,000) and therefore not the most cost-effective choice.
Why not B: Avoidance would remove the exposure but at the cost of eliminating the online channel and likely forfeiting revenue. Since a lower-cost option (insurance) preserves operations, avoidance is not the most appropriate response here.
Why not D: Controls reduce expected loss to $50,000 but cost $220,000 annually, for a total annual outlay of about $270,000. That is higher than both doing nothing ($250,000) and purchasing insurance (~$130,000), so mitigation via these controls is not the most cost-effective choice.
Question 8
Hint
For each proposed control, compute the expected annual loss reduction divided by the control's annual cost, then compare those ratios to determine which is largest.
Answer B. Compute expected-loss reduction per dollar for each control: supply-chain diversification reduces $600,000 for $200,000 → 600,000/200,000 = 3.0; cybersecurity reduces $900,000 for $400,000 → 900,000/400,000 = 2.25; credit insurance reduces $96,000 for $75,000 → 96,000/75,000 ≈ 1.28. Because management's objective is to maximize expected-loss reduction per dollar spent, the supplier diversification (ratio = 3.0) is the best-supported choice.
Why not A: This option yields the largest absolute expected-loss reduction ($900,000) and is attractive, but on a per-dollar basis it gives 900,000/400,000 = 2.25, which is less cost-effective than the supplier diversification (3.0), so it does not meet the stated objective as well as option A.
Why not C: Although the premium is relatively low and the reduction is measurable, the ratio is 96,000/75,000 ≈ 1.28, which is substantially lower than the ratios for options A and B, so it does not maximize expected-loss reduction per dollar.
Why not D: Accepting risk or reserving funds does not itself reduce expected annual loss; therefore it cannot outperform a control that delivers a positive expected-loss reduction per dollar, and it fails to meet the stated objective.
Common questions
How do you calculate total expected annual risk cost?
Multiply residual event probability by the loss retained per event, then add annual response cost. Cedar's controls cost 4% × $600,000 + $20,000 = $44,000 annually.
How does insurance affect expected annual loss?
Use the loss the company retains after coverage, without changing the event probability. Cedar retains $60,000 per breach, so expected retained loss is 10% × $60,000 = $6,000 before the premium.
Why reject the risk response with the lowest expected cost?
The cheapest response may violate the stated risk appetite. Cedar's controls cost less than insurance but leave $24,000 of expected annual loss, above the $10,000 limit.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Risk management
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.