PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 6 practice questions

ASC 606 Right of Return: Refund Liability and Recovery Asset

At delivery, recognize revenue only for consideration you expect to keep, subject to the variable consideration constraint. Below: follow one sale from expected returns through the refund liability, recovery asset, and journal entries.

The ruleRecognize revenue net of expected refunds, subject to the variable consideration constraint. Record a refund liability and a separate recovery asset at former carrying amount less expected recovery costs and any decline in value.

Try one first

On December 28, Year 1, Apex Co. sold goods for $100,000 cash. Customers have a 30-day right to return the goods for a full refund. Based on a large volume of similar transactions, Apex expects 4% of the goods sold to be returned, and this estimate is reliable. The cost of the goods delivered was $60,000. Assume collection is probable and all other ASC 606 criteria are met. What is the correct treatment on December 28, Year 1?
Hint

Focus on how ASC 606 treats a reliable estimate of expected returns at the date of sale, not just when the cash was collected.

Step by step

  1. Set up the sale

    Orion delivers 1,000 units at $80 each, collects cash, and transfers control; each unit costs $50 and has a 30-day return right. Orion expects 5% returns, meets the variable consideration constraint, and expects $200 total inspection and restocking costs with no decline in the returned goods' value.

  2. Calculate expected refunds

    Expected returns are 1,000 × 5% = 50 units. The refund liability is 50 × $80 = $4,000.

  3. Recognize net revenue

    Revenue is $80,000 collected minus $4,000 expected refunds = $76,000. Do not wait until the return period expires when the estimate meets the variable consideration constraint.

  4. Measure the recovery asset

    The expected returned goods have a carrying amount of 50 × $50 = $2,500. Subtract $200 of expected recovery costs to recognize a $2,300 recovery asset.

  5. Calculate cost of sales

    Remove the $2,300 recovery asset from the $50,000 cost of goods delivered, leaving $47,700 in cost of sales. This equals 950 units kept × $50, plus $200 of expected recovery costs.

  6. Record cash and revenue

    Debit cash $80,000. Credit revenue $76,000 and refund liability $4,000.

  7. Record inventory and recovery

    Debit cost of sales $47,700 and recovery asset $2,300. Credit inventory $50,000.

  8. Keep asset and liability separate

    Present the $4,000 refund liability and $2,300 recovery asset separately. The obligation to refund cash is not reduced by the right to recover goods.

Key points

  • Remember: Expected refunds use selling price; the recovery asset uses inventory cost less recovery costs and any decline in value.
  • Collecting all the cash does not make all of it revenue.
  • Cost of sales includes $47,500 for goods customers keep plus $200 of expected recovery costs.
  • Present the refund liability separately from the recovery asset.

How the exam traps you

  • Recognizing all $80,000 as revenue because delivery and cash collection occurred. Subtract $4,000 of expected refunds and recognize $76,000 of revenue.
  • Using the $4,000 expected refund as the recovery asset. Use the returned goods' carrying amount, then subtract recovery costs: $2,500 minus $200 equals $2,300.
  • Recording a $2,500 recovery asset without deducting inspection and restocking costs. Subtract the $200 expected recovery costs, reducing the asset to $2,300.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Pine Co. signs a contract to install equipment for a fixed price of $500,000 plus a $60,000 bonus if installation is completed by June 30, Year 1. Pine can estimate the possible bonus outcomes, but timely completion depends heavily on permits the customer must obtain. On similar jobs, those permits have often been delayed, and missing the deadline would eliminate the entire bonus. Assume the fixed price is otherwise collectible and no other revenue recognition issues are present. Under ASC 606, how should Pine treat the bonus at contract inception?
Hint

Separate the issue of estimating variable consideration from the separate rule that limits when it can be included.

Question 3

On December 20, 20X5, Apex Medical sold a CT scanner to a hospital. At the hospital's request, Apex agreed to hold the scanner until January 31, 20X6 because the hospital's imaging room would not be available until then. On December 20, Apex invoiced the hospital under normal credit terms, the scanner was separately identified as the hospital's unit, and Apex could not redirect it to another customer. The contract states that title and risk of loss pass on invoicing. However, as of December 20, Apex still had to complete contract-required final calibration and secure-shipment preparation before the scanner would be ready for immediate delivery. Apex finished those activities on January 10, 20X6. No further customer acceptance, installation, or other promised services remained after that date. When should Apex recognize revenue for the scanner?
Hint

Focus on the extra condition that must be met for a bill-and-hold arrangement beyond invoicing, title passage, and customer request.

Question 4

On December 28, 20X5, Maker Co. delivered goods to Dealer under an arrangement with these terms: Maker retains title until Dealer sells the goods to an end customer, Dealer may return unsold goods without penalty, the goods are separately identified as Maker's inventory, and Dealer will remit the sales price to Maker less a stated commission when a customer purchase occurs. No end-customer sale occurred by December 31, 20X5. Assuming no other performance obligations are involved, what is the effect on Maker's 20X5 revenue recognition?
Hint

Focus on whether control passed to the dealer or whether the dealer is simply holding the goods for sale to someone else.

Question 5

On January 2, 20X5, Orion Manufacturing agreed to transfer specialized equipment to a customer for $600,000, payable in 180 days. The customer paid a nonrefundable $120,000 deposit at signing. Because of the customer's severe liquidity problems, Orion concluded at the arrangement's inception that collectibility of the consideration was not probable, so the arrangement did not qualify as a contract under ASC 606. Orion nevertheless delivered the equipment on January 15, 20X5, and had no further performance obligations after delivery. On March 31, 20X5, the parties formally terminated the arrangement; the customer was released from the unpaid balance, Orion retained the $120,000 deposit (which remained nonrefundable), and Orion had no further obligations. Which accounting treatment is most appropriate as of March 31, 20X5?
Hint

Work in two steps: (1) Was there a valid ASC 606 contract at delivery (including probable collectibility)? (2) If amounts were recorded as a liability, did subsequent facts (forfeiture/termination) permit derecognition and recognition in income, and when?

Question 6

On December 15, Year 1, Pella Co. sold 200 identical products for $300 each and delivered them to customers that day. Customers have a 30-day right to return the products for a full refund. Based on extensive experience with similar transactions, Pella expects 10 products to be returned and concludes the estimate is reliable. Ignore sales taxes and the asset for recovery of returned inventory. How much revenue should Pella recognize on December 15, Year 1?
Hint

Do not stop at the fact that the goods were delivered. Also consider how a reliable estimate of expected returns affects the amount of revenue recognized.

Drill all 126 Revenue recognition questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the journal entry for a sale with a right of return?

Debit cash $80,000; credit revenue $76,000 and refund liability $4,000. Debit cost of sales $47,700 and recovery asset $2,300; credit inventory $50,000.

Why is cost of sales $47,700 instead of $47,500?

The recovery asset is reduced by $200 of expected recovery costs. Cost of sales therefore equals $47,500 for goods expected to be kept plus $200 of recovery costs.

Can the recovery asset be netted against the refund liability?

No. Present the $2,300 recovery asset separately from the $4,000 refund liability, not as a net $1,700 liability.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.

Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Revenue recognition

All Revenue recognition practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.