BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 6 practice questions
ASC 606 Right of Return: Refund Liability and Recovery Asset
At delivery, recognize revenue only for consideration you expect to keep, subject to the variable consideration constraint. Below: follow one sale from expected returns through the refund liability, recovery asset, and journal entries.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on how ASC 606 treats a reliable estimate of expected returns at the date of sale, not just when the cash was collected.
Answer C. Under ASC 606, expected returns reduce the transaction price when the estimate is reliable, so Apex recognizes revenue of $100,000 less expected refunds of $4,000 = $96,000 and records a $4,000 refund liability. Because some inventory is expected to be returned, Apex recognizes an asset for the right to recover returned goods measured at the expected cost of those returns (4% × $60,000 = $2,400). The anticipated cost of returns is removed from cost of goods sold, leaving COGS of $57,600.
Why not A: Deferring the entire amount overstates conservatism. ASC 606 does not require deferral of the whole transaction price for a return right; instead, recognize the portion of consideration expected to be retained and record a refund liability for the expected refunds.
Why not B: This ignores ASC 606's requirement to reflect expected returns at the date of sale when the estimate is reliable. Because Apex expects 4% returns with a reliable estimate, it must reduce revenue and record a refund liability and related recovery asset rather than recognizing full revenue with no liability.
Why not D: This mixes a correct revenue reduction with incomplete balance-sheet recognition. ASC 606 requires a refund liability for expected refunds and an asset for the right to recover returned inventory, and COGS should be adjusted for expected returns.
Step by step
- Set up the sale
Orion delivers 1,000 units at $80 each, collects cash, and transfers control; each unit costs $50 and has a 30-day return right. Orion expects 5% returns, meets the variable consideration constraint, and expects $200 total inspection and restocking costs with no decline in the returned goods' value.
- Calculate expected refunds
Expected returns are 1,000 × 5% = 50 units. The refund liability is 50 × $80 = $4,000.
- Recognize net revenue
Revenue is $80,000 collected minus $4,000 expected refunds = $76,000. Do not wait until the return period expires when the estimate meets the variable consideration constraint.
- Measure the recovery asset
The expected returned goods have a carrying amount of 50 × $50 = $2,500. Subtract $200 of expected recovery costs to recognize a $2,300 recovery asset.
- Calculate cost of sales
Remove the $2,300 recovery asset from the $50,000 cost of goods delivered, leaving $47,700 in cost of sales. This equals 950 units kept × $50, plus $200 of expected recovery costs.
- Record cash and revenue
Debit cash $80,000. Credit revenue $76,000 and refund liability $4,000.
- Record inventory and recovery
Debit cost of sales $47,700 and recovery asset $2,300. Credit inventory $50,000.
- Keep asset and liability separate
Present the $4,000 refund liability and $2,300 recovery asset separately. The obligation to refund cash is not reduced by the right to recover goods.
Key points
- Remember: Expected refunds use selling price; the recovery asset uses inventory cost less recovery costs and any decline in value.
- Collecting all the cash does not make all of it revenue.
- Cost of sales includes $47,500 for goods customers keep plus $200 of expected recovery costs.
- Present the refund liability separately from the recovery asset.
How the exam traps you
- Recognizing all $80,000 as revenue because delivery and cash collection occurred. Subtract $4,000 of expected refunds and recognize $76,000 of revenue.
- Using the $4,000 expected refund as the recovery asset. Use the returned goods' carrying amount, then subtract recovery costs: $2,500 minus $200 equals $2,300.
- Recording a $2,500 recovery asset without deducting inspection and restocking costs. Subtract the $200 expected recovery costs, reducing the asset to $2,300.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the issue of estimating variable consideration from the separate rule that limits when it can be included.
Answer B. The $60,000 bonus is variable consideration. Under ASC 606, an entity must apply the constraint on variable consideration and include such amounts only when it is probable that doing so will not result in a significant revenue reversal. Because permit delays have frequently eliminated the bonus in similar contracts and missing the deadline eliminates the entire bonus, Pine cannot conclude at inception that including the bonus is probable. Therefore, Pine should exclude the bonus from the transaction price at contract inception.
Why not A: This is tempting because the amount can be estimated and the contract defines the bonus, but ASC 606 requires more than estimability: the entity must also conclude it is probable that including the amount will not cause a significant reversal. The facts indicate too much reversal risk, so inclusion is not appropriate.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to choosing an estimation method for binary outcomes. However, selecting an estimation technique (like most likely amount) does not override the variable-consideration constraint. Pine still must conclude it is probable that including the bonus will not lead to a significant reversal before recognizing it.
Why not D: This overstates the uncertainty. The problem affects only the variable bonus, not the fixed $500,000 consideration (which is collectible and otherwise meets revenue recognition criteria). Pine should recognize the fixed portion and exclude the constrained bonus.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the extra condition that must be met for a bill-and-hold arrangement beyond invoicing, title passage, and customer request.
Answer D. Under ASC 606, a bill-and-hold sale may be recognized before delivery only if specific criteria are met, including that the goods are separately identified and are ready for physical transfer to the customer. Although Apex invoiced the hospital and the customer requested the hold, the scanner was not ready for transfer on December 20 because required final calibration and shipment preparation remained. Those activities were completed on January 10 and no other promised services remained, so control had transferred and revenue may be recognized on January 10, 20X6.
Why not A: This is tempting because invoicing, title passage, and a customer-requested hold are relevant indicators of a bill-and-hold arrangement. However, those facts alone are insufficient: one required condition is that the product be ready for physical transfer, which was not true on December 20.
Why not B: This distractor inappropriately applies a percentage-of-completion/manufacturing mindset. The contract describes delivery of a single good; revenue recognition depends on transfer of control of that good, not on how much of its manufacturing had been completed.
Why not C: This is plausible because physical possession is often evidence of control, but bill-and-hold arrangements are a specific circumstance in which control can transfer before physical delivery if the criteria (including readiness for physical transfer) are satisfied. Once the scanner was ready and no other services remained on January 10, recognition need not wait until the hospital took possession on January 31.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether control passed to the dealer or whether the dealer is simply holding the goods for sale to someone else.
Answer A. The facts describe a consignment arrangement: Maker retains title and separate identification of the goods, Dealer may return unsold goods, and Dealer remits proceeds less a commission only when an end-customer sale occurs. Because Maker retains control and the dealer is acting as consignee rather than the customer, revenue is not recognized until the goods are sold to the end customer.
Why not B: This confuses measurement/presentation (net of commission) with timing. Net presentation presumes a completed sale; the primary issue here is that no sale to a customer occurred and control remains with Maker, so no revenue should be recognized.
Why not C: This is tempting because delivery often signals transfer of control in a sale. Here, however, title retention, return rights, and the dealer's consignor-like role indicate control did not transfer at delivery, so revenue is not recognized then.
Why not D: This appeals to candidates thinking about performance over time, but Maker is not satisfying a time-based performance obligation, it is holding goods on consignment awaiting an end-customer sale. Time-based recognition does not apply when control has not transferred.
Question 5
Hint
Work in two steps: (1) Was there a valid ASC 606 contract at delivery (including probable collectibility)? (2) If amounts were recorded as a liability, did subsequent facts (forfeiture/termination) permit derecognition and recognition in income, and when?
Answer D. Because collectibility was not probable at inception, ASC 606 criteria for a contract were not met and the deposit was initially recorded as a liability (pre-contract consideration). When the parties terminated the arrangement on March 31 and Orion retained the nonrefundable deposit while being relieved of all performance obligations, the contract liability could be derecognized and recognizing the forfeited amount as revenue on the termination date is appropriate. Revenue could not be recognized on delivery (January 15) because the contract criteria, including probable collectibility, were not satisfied at that time.
Why not A: This is tempting because, if a valid contract existed, transfer of control would generally trigger revenue and subsequent nonpayment would be a credit loss. But here collectibility was not probable at inception, so no contract under ASC 606 existed at delivery and revenue could not be recorded then.
Why not B: This reflects the rule that pre-contract consideration is deferred as a liability. However, once the arrangement was terminated and the deposit was forfeited while Orion had no remaining obligations, the liability is extinguished and the amount may be recognized in income rather than held indefinitely as a liability.
Why not C: Although control transferred and the deposit was nonrefundable, ASC 606 requires a valid contract (including probable collectibility) before revenue recognition; because that criterion was not met at delivery, recognizing revenue on January 15 is not appropriate.
Question 6
Hint
Do not stop at the fact that the goods were delivered. Also consider how a reliable estimate of expected returns affects the amount of revenue recognized.
Answer A. Under ASC 606, when an entity can reasonably estimate expected returns, it recognizes revenue for the amount it expects to be entitled to keep. Pella expects 10 returns (10 × $300 = $3,000) out of 200 units (200 × $300 = $60,000), so recognized revenue = $60,000 − $3,000 = $57,000. The expected refund is recorded separately as a refund liability.
Why not B: Tempting because control transferred at delivery, but when returns can be reliably estimated revenue should be reduced for expected returns rather than recognized at the full gross sales amount.
Why not C: This represents the expected refund amount (10 × $300) and would be recorded as a refund liability, not as recognized revenue.
Why not D: Too conservative: if the entity can reliably estimate returns, ASC 606 permits recognition of revenue net of expected returns rather than waiting until the return period ends.
Common questions
What is the journal entry for a sale with a right of return?
Debit cash $80,000; credit revenue $76,000 and refund liability $4,000. Debit cost of sales $47,700 and recovery asset $2,300; credit inventory $50,000.
Why is cost of sales $47,700 instead of $47,500?
The recovery asset is reduced by $200 of expected recovery costs. Cost of sales therefore equals $47,500 for goods expected to be kept plus $200 of recovery costs.
Can the recovery asset be netted against the refund liability?
No. Present the $2,300 recovery asset separately from the $4,000 refund liability, not as a net $1,700 liability.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.
Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Revenue recognition
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.