BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 7 practice questions
ASC 606: Allocate a Bundled Price Using Relative SSP
Allocate a bundled transaction price to distinct performance obligations in proportion to their standalone selling prices. Below: a worked allocation for equipment, installation, training, and support.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether the printer and installation are one performance obligation or two. Then determine how a bundled price is assigned when standalone selling prices are known.
Answer D. The printer and installation are distinct performance obligations because the printer is functional on delivery and the installation is separately available. Allocate the $110,000 transaction price to standalone selling prices: $100,000/(100,000+20,000) × $110,000 = $91,666.67 (rounded to $91,667) to the printer and $18,333 to installation. Control of the printer transfers on delivery in January, so Noll recognizes $91,667 in January and defers the installation portion until the service is performed in February.
Why not A: This is tempting because the product was delivered in January, but if installation is a separate performance obligation the portion of the transaction price allocable to installation cannot be recognized until that service is satisfied.
Why not B: Although $100,000 is the printer's standalone selling price, ASC 606 requires allocation of the actual transaction price to performance obligations based on relative standalone selling prices; when the contract price is a discount, the delivered item receives only its relative share of the total.
Why not C: An even split ignores the relative standalone selling prices. Allocation is based on relative standalone selling prices (or an appropriate estimate thereof), not simply the count of promised items.
Worked example
Vale sells equipment, routine installation, standard training, and one year of support for a fixed $144,000. All four are distinct performance obligations. Their standalone selling prices are $120,000, $20,000, $10,000, and $30,000, respectively. There is no variable consideration or basis to allocate the discount entirely to any specific obligation. Allocate the transaction price.
| 1 | Total standalone selling prices$120,000 + $20,000 + $10,000 + $30,000 | $180,000 |
| 2 | Equipment allocation$144,000 × ($120,000 ÷ $180,000) | $96,000 |
| 3 | Installation allocation$144,000 × ($20,000 ÷ $180,000) | $16,000 |
| 4 | Training allocation$144,000 × ($10,000 ÷ $180,000) | $8,000 |
| 5 | Support allocation$144,000 × ($30,000 ÷ $180,000) | $24,000 |
Vale allocates the $144,000 transaction price as follows: equipment $96,000; installation $16,000; training $8,000; support $24,000. Each allocation equals 80% of that obligation’s SSP, and the allocations total $144,000.
Check: Shortcut: the $36,000 bundle discount is 20% of total SSP, so reduce each SSP by 20% to get its allocation.
Key points
- SSP means standalone selling price, not the amount allocated from the bundled price.
- A proportionate bundle discount reduces every obligation’s SSP by the same percentage.
- The allocations must add back to the total transaction price.
How the exam traps you
- Assign $120,000 to equipment because that is its SSP. Apply its relative share to the $144,000 transaction price: equipment receives $96,000.
- Split the price equally, assigning $36,000 to each obligation. Weight each allocation by SSP, not by the number of obligations.
- Subtract the services’ full SSPs from $144,000, leaving $84,000 for equipment. Spread the discount proportionately rather than assigning the entire discount to equipment.
Question 2
Hint
Apply ASC 606's two-prong distinct-performance-obligation test: consider both 'capable of being distinct' and whether each promise is 'separately identifiable in the context of the contract.' Focus on which promises are highly interdependent or materially modify the software.
Answer D. ASC 606 requires promised goods or services to be both capable of being distinct and separately identifiable in the contract context. Here the license, required interface modifications, installation, and system testing are highly interdependent and materially affect whether the software will function as promised, so they are not separately identifiable and must be combined. The two-day standard end-user training is routine, can be provided by other vendors, and does not significantly modify or integrate the software, so it is a separate performance obligation.
Why not A: Tempting because the customer seeks one functioning imaging system and the implementation activities produce an integrated output. But ASC 606 focuses on whether contractual promises are separately identifiable; the standard two-day training does not significantly integrate with or modify the software and can be provided by other vendors, so it qualifies as a separate performance obligation and should not be combined with the integrated software deliverables.
Why not B: Tempting because licenses are often treated as distinct deliverables and a quick read may separate the license from implementation services. However, ASC 606 also requires promises to be separately identifiable in the contract context; the license cannot function for its intended purpose without the interface modifications and the installation/testing materially integrate with the license, so those items are not separately identifiable and must be combined. In addition, the training is a routine, standalone service that can be supplied by others and therefore should not be bundled with the integrated implementation activities.
Why not C: Tempting because a superficial application of the 'capable of being distinct' prong might treat each deliverable separately. ASC 606, however, requires both prongs: even if items could be sold separately, they must also be separately identifiable in the contract context; the license and the modification/implementation activities are highly interdependent (the software cannot be used for its intended purpose without the modifications), so those items should be combined. The training, by contrast, meets the separate-identifiability criteria and stands alone.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether each promised item is distinct, not on whether the contract has a single price.
Answer C. ASC 606 treats a promised good or service as a separate performance obligation if it is distinct, i.e., (1) capable of being distinct (the customer can benefit from it on its own) and (2) separately identifiable (it is not highly interrelated or integrated with other promised goods or services). Here the equipment can function on its own (capable of being distinct), and the routine installation does not significantly modify the equipment and could be provided by another vendor (separately identifiable). Therefore the equipment and the installation are two distinct performance obligations.
Why not A: This is tempting because both promises are in the same contract, but ASC 606 requires an assessment of distinctness. Inclusion in one contract alone does not make separate promises one obligation, the facts here support separate obligations.
Why not B: This distractor plays on the common mistake of tying separate obligations to separate stated prices. Distinctness depends on the nature of the promised goods or services, not whether the contract lists separate prices; the transaction price can be allocated even when only one price is stated.
Why not D: Some tasks performed to fulfill a contract are not separate promises, but here installation is an explicit promised service to the customer and meets the distinctness criteria given the facts, so it is a performance obligation rather than merely a fulfillment activity.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether each warranty is an assurance-type warranty or a service-type warranty. Then allocate the contract price only among the actual performance obligations.
Answer A. The mandatory one-year warranty is an assurance-type warranty and is not a separate performance obligation; expected costs for it are accrued as a warranty liability. The optional two-year maintenance-type warranty is a service-type warranty sold separately and therefore is a separate performance obligation; its portion of the transaction price must be deferred. Allocate the $11,700 transaction price on a relative standalone selling price basis (equipment $12,000/$13,500 = $10,400; optional warranty $1,500/$13,500 = $1,300). Thus, Apex recognizes $10,400 of revenue at delivery and records a $1,300 contract liability for the optional warranty.
Why not B: This is appealing because warranty costs are often accrued, but it ignores that the optional maintenance-type warranty is a separate service sold separately; the portion of consideration attributable to that service must be deferred rather than recognized immediately.
Why not C: This correctly treats the optional warranty as a separate performance obligation but incorrectly allocates the discount. Absent evidence that the discount applies entirely to one obligation, the transaction price must be allocated proportionately to the standalone selling prices.
Why not D: Although the allocation amounts are correct, the classification is wrong: amounts received for a future service obligation should be recorded as a contract liability (deferred revenue), whereas a 'warranty liability' normally refers to expected costs for an assurance-type warranty.
Question 5
Hint
First identify the actual performance obligations, then decide whether the activation fee is its own obligation or just part of total consideration.
Answer A. The $120 activation fee is not a separate performance obligation because the setup activities do not transfer a distinct good or service, so include it in the total transaction price of $1,080 ($120 + $960). Allocate the $1,080 to the distinct performance obligations (router and 12-month service) using relative standalone selling prices of $240 and $960: router receives 20% ($216) and service receives 80% ($864). Recognize the router portion at contract inception and the $864 service portion over the 12 months (i.e., $72 per month).
Why not B: This treats the activation fee as a separately earned revenue at inception and leaves the router at its standalone selling price. Under ASC 606 the activation fee must be included in the contract's transaction price if it does not represent a separate performance obligation, and the total consideration is allocated across identified performance obligations, you cannot recognize the $120 separately and still recognize the router at full standalone price.
Why not C: This option correctly sees that the activation fee is not earned entirely upfront, but it incorrectly keeps the router at its full standalone selling price while treating the activation fee separately. Once the activation fee is included in the transaction price, the consideration must be allocated to the performance obligations by relative standalone selling price, so the router receives only $216, not $240.
Why not D: This focuses only on the activation fee and ignores that the router is explicitly stated to be distinct and is transferred at inception. Because the router is a separate performance obligation, a portion of the transaction price must be recognized at the time control of the router transfers.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the license and the support are separate performance obligations, then determine whether each is recognized at a point in time or over time.
Answer A. Alder has two distinct performance obligations: the functional software license and the one year of post-contract support. Allocate $100,000 to the license and $20,000 to support because the standalone selling prices sum to the contract price. The license is recognized at the point in time of delivery (Jan 1); support is recognized over time, three months of support equals $20,000 × 3/12 = $5,000, so total recognized by March 31 is $100,000 + $5,000 = $105,000.
Why not B: This assumes the entire contract is completed at delivery. It's wrong because the one year of support is a separate performance obligation that must be recognized over time rather than immediately.
Why not C: This correctly identifies the license revenue recognized at delivery but ignores that three months of the support obligation have already been satisfied and a portion of the $20,000 for support should be recognized by March 31.
Why not D: This reflects spreading the entire contract price evenly over 12 months ($120,000 ÷ 12 × 3 = $30,000). It's incorrect because the functional license transfers control at delivery and should be recognized at that point, while only the support is recognized over the service period.
Question 7
Hint
First decide which promised goods or services are separate performance obligations. Then allocate the bundled price using relative standalone selling prices before deciding what has transferred by year-end.
Answer A. Identify the distinct performance obligations: scanner, installation, and training. The assurance-type warranty is not a separate performance obligation. Allocate the $120,000 transaction price by relative standalone selling prices (scanner share = 110/128), so scanner revenue = 120,000 × (110/128) = $103,125. Control of the scanner transferred on December 20, so Nova recognizes $103,125 by December 31.
Why not B: $0 is tempting if a candidate treats the scanner and installation as a single combined obligation not satisfied until installation. But the installation is distinct (customer could use another provider and installation doesn't significantly modify the scanner), so scanner revenue should not be fully deferred.
Why not C: $110,000 is the scanner's standalone selling price, but the contract price must be allocated across all distinct obligations. The scanner's recognized amount is the allocated portion of the bundled price, not its standalone price when a bundle discount exists.
Why not D: $112,500 would result from allocating and recognizing both the scanner and installation before year-end (120,000 × ((110+10)/128)). Installation has not yet been performed by December 31, so its allocated amount must remain deferred.
Common questions
What is the relative standalone selling price allocation formula?
Allocation = transaction price × individual SSP ÷ total SSP. Vale’s equipment allocation is $144,000 × $120,000 ÷ $180,000 = $96,000.
Do you split a bundled price equally among performance obligations?
No. Use relative SSP weights. Vale’s equipment has two-thirds of total SSP, so it receives two-thirds of the transaction price.
How is a bundle discount allocated under ASC 606?
In this example, allocate the discount proportionately because no basis exists to assign it to specific obligations. The $144,000 bundle price is 80% of total SSP, so each allocation is 80% of its SSP.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.
Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Revenue recognition
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.