PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 7 practice questions

ASC 606: Allocate a Bundled Price Using Relative SSP

Allocate a bundled transaction price to distinct performance obligations in proportion to their standalone selling prices. Below: a worked allocation for equipment, installation, training, and support.

The ruleAllocate the transaction price to each distinct performance obligation using its standalone selling price divided by total standalone selling prices. Here, the bundle discount is allocated proportionately to all obligations.

Try one first

On January 2, Year 1, Noll Co. enters into a contract to sell a commercial printer and standard installation services for a single bundled price of $110,000. The printer is delivered on January 15, Year 1, and installation is completed on February 10, Year 1. Noll regularly sells the printer separately for $100,000 and the installation service separately for $20,000. The printer is functional when delivered, and the installation is routine and can be performed by other service providers. Assume collectibility is probable and there is no variable consideration, significant financing component, right of return, or customer acceptance clause. How much revenue should Noll recognize in January Year 1 from this contract?
Hint

First decide whether the printer and installation are one performance obligation or two. Then determine how a bundled price is assigned when standalone selling prices are known.

Worked example

Vale sells equipment, routine installation, standard training, and one year of support for a fixed $144,000. All four are distinct performance obligations. Their standalone selling prices are $120,000, $20,000, $10,000, and $30,000, respectively. There is no variable consideration or basis to allocate the discount entirely to any specific obligation. Allocate the transaction price.

1Total standalone selling prices$120,000 + $20,000 + $10,000 + $30,000$180,000
2Equipment allocation$144,000 × ($120,000 ÷ $180,000)$96,000
3Installation allocation$144,000 × ($20,000 ÷ $180,000)$16,000
4Training allocation$144,000 × ($10,000 ÷ $180,000)$8,000
5Support allocation$144,000 × ($30,000 ÷ $180,000)$24,000

Vale allocates the $144,000 transaction price as follows: equipment $96,000; installation $16,000; training $8,000; support $24,000. Each allocation equals 80% of that obligation’s SSP, and the allocations total $144,000.

Check: Shortcut: the $36,000 bundle discount is 20% of total SSP, so reduce each SSP by 20% to get its allocation.

Key points

  • SSP means standalone selling price, not the amount allocated from the bundled price.
  • A proportionate bundle discount reduces every obligation’s SSP by the same percentage.
  • The allocations must add back to the total transaction price.

How the exam traps you

  • Assign $120,000 to equipment because that is its SSP. Apply its relative share to the $144,000 transaction price: equipment receives $96,000.
  • Split the price equally, assigning $36,000 to each obligation. Weight each allocation by SSP, not by the number of obligations.
  • Subtract the services’ full SSPs from $144,000, leaving $84,000 for equipment. Spread the discount proportionately rather than assigning the entire discount to equipment.

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

MedSoft enters into a single contract with City Hospital to provide: (1) a perpetual license to MedSoft's existing, functional on-premise imaging software, (2) modifications to certain software modules so the software interfaces with the hospital's legacy equipment and patient-records system, (3) installation and system testing, and (4) two days of standard end-user training after go-live. City Hospital cannot use the software for its intended purpose without the interface modifications. MedSoft is responsible for delivering a fully functioning integrated system, and the modification and testing activities significantly affect whether the licensed software will operate as promised in the hospital's environment. The training uses a standard curriculum and can be provided by other vendors. Assume no post-contract support, updates, renewal options, or other promises are included. How should MedSoft classify the promised goods and services into performance obligations at contract inception?
Hint

Apply ASC 606's two-prong distinct-performance-obligation test: consider both 'capable of being distinct' and whether each promise is 'separately identifiable in the context of the contract.' Focus on which promises are highly interdependent or materially modify the software.

Question 3

Delta Co. enters into a contract to sell a standard piece of equipment and to provide routine installation for a single contract price. The equipment can function on its own after delivery, other vendors regularly perform similar installation, and the installation does not significantly modify or customize the equipment. Assume the contract includes no other promised goods or services. Under ASC 606, how should Delta classify the promises in this contract?
Hint

Focus on whether each promised item is distinct, not on whether the contract has a single price.

Question 4

On January 2, 20X5, Apex sells industrial equipment and, in the same contract, an optional two-year maintenance-type warranty for total consideration of $11,700, payable at signing. The equipment is delivered on January 2, 20X5. Apex regularly sells the equipment alone for $12,000 and sells the optional two-year warranty separately for $1,500. The equipment also includes a mandatory one-year warranty that only assures the equipment complies with agreed-upon specifications at delivery; that mandatory warranty is not sold separately and does not provide any additional service beyond assurance. Assume no financing component, no variable consideration, and no other performance obligations. What is the effect on Apex's accounting on January 2, 20X5?
Hint

First decide whether each warranty is an assurance-type warranty or a service-type warranty. Then allocate the contract price only among the actual performance obligations.

Question 5

On January 1, Year 1, CableCo enters into a noncancelable 12-month contract with a customer. The customer pays a nonrefundable $120 activation fee at signing and agrees to pay $80 per month for internet service for 12 months. CableCo also provides a Wi-Fi router to the customer at contract inception. The router is distinct from the internet service and is regularly sold separately for $240. The monthly internet service is distinct and is regularly sold separately for $80 per month. The activation activities consist only of administrative and network setup tasks and do not transfer a distinct good or service to the customer. Assume collectibility is probable and there is no significant financing component. Under ASC 606, how should CableCo recognize revenue from this contract?
Hint

First identify the actual performance obligations, then decide whether the activation fee is its own obligation or just part of total consideration.

Question 6

On January 1, 20X5, Alder Co. enters into a contract to provide a customer with (1) a perpetual license to functional tax software and (2) one year of post-contract customer support consisting of help-desk access and unspecified minor updates. The software is functional when delivered, and the updates are not required to keep the software usable. The customer can benefit from the license on its own. Alder delivers the software on January 1 and begins support immediately. The contract price is $120,000. Standalone selling prices are $100,000 for the license and $20,000 for the support. Assume no variable consideration and no significant financing component. As of March 31, 20X5, what is the correct amount of revenue Alder should recognize under ASC 606?
Hint

First decide whether the license and the support are separate performance obligations, then determine whether each is recognized at a point in time or over time.

Question 7

On December 1, Nova Corp. enters into a contract to provide a standard diagnostic scanner, routine installation, two days of on-site training, and a one-year assurance-type warranty for a single price of $120,000. Nova regularly sells these items separately for the following standalone selling prices: scanner $110,000, installation $10,000, and training $8,000. The warranty only assures that the scanner complies with agreed-upon specifications and is not sold separately. The scanner is delivered on December 20, and legal title and physical possession transfer to the customer on that date. The customer could hire another qualified provider to perform the installation, and Nova's installation does not significantly modify or customize the scanner. Installation is scheduled for January 5 of the following year, and training is scheduled for January 15 of the following year. How much revenue should Nova recognize for the year ended December 31?
Hint

First decide which promised goods or services are separate performance obligations. Then allocate the bundled price using relative standalone selling prices before deciding what has transferred by year-end.

Drill all 126 Revenue recognition questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the relative standalone selling price allocation formula?

Allocation = transaction price × individual SSP ÷ total SSP. Vale’s equipment allocation is $144,000 × $120,000 ÷ $180,000 = $96,000.

Do you split a bundled price equally among performance obligations?

No. Use relative SSP weights. Vale’s equipment has two-thirds of total SSP, so it receives two-thirds of the transaction price.

How is a bundle discount allocated under ASC 606?

In this example, allocate the discount proportionately because no basis exists to assign it to specific obligations. The $144,000 bundle price is 80% of total SSP, so each allocation is 80% of its SSP.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.

Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Revenue recognition

All Revenue recognition practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.