PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 9 practice questions

ASC 606: Cumulative Catch-Up for Contract Modifications

Non-distinct additions to a partially satisfied over-time performance obligation require a cumulative catch-up adjustment. Below, follow BuildCo's integrated renovation modification through a cost-to-cost decision tree.

The ruleNon-distinct additions to a single, partially satisfied over-time performance obligation require cumulative catch-up. Update the transaction price and measure of progress, then recognize the difference between revised cumulative revenue and revenue already recognized.

Try one first

On January 2, 20X5, BuildCo entered into a $5,000,000 fixed-price contract to renovate Customer's headquarters. BuildCo concluded the arrangement contains a single performance obligation satisfied over time because Customer controls the asset as it is improved; BuildCo measures progress using the cost-to-cost (input) method. By September 30, 20X5, before any modification, BuildCo had incurred $1,600,000 of costs, expected total costs of $4,000,000, and had recognized $2,000,000 of revenue. On October 1, 20X5, the parties approved and enforceably added upgraded HVAC work and a lobby redesign for an additional $800,000. BuildCo estimates the modification will add $1,000,000 of costs. The added work is not priced at standalone selling price and is not distinct from the original promised service; it must be integrated with the partially completed renovation. Ignore financing, claims, and variable consideration. What is the best-supported accounting conclusion about the contract modification as of October 1, 20X5?
Hint

First apply the ASC 606 modification test: are the added goods or services distinct and is the change priced at a standalone selling price? If not, use the cumulative catch-up, recompute percent complete using revised total expected costs under the cost-to-cost method before comparing to previously recognized cumulative revenue.

Decide it in order

  1. T1BuildCo has a single renovation performance obligation satisfied over time. Approved HVAC and lobby additions must be integrated with the partially completed renovation. Are the additions distinct in the context of the contract?

    YesThis non-distinct-work catch-up path does not apply. Evaluate the modification under the other ASC 606 modification guidance.
  2. T2Has BuildCo already partially satisfied the single over-time performance obligation?

    NoUpdate the existing obligation's transaction price and progress estimates. With no performance yet transferred, there is no previously recognized revenue to adjust.
  3. T3BuildCo incurred $1,600,000 and recognized $2,000,000. Revised price = $5,000,000 + $800,000 = $5,800,000. Revised expected costs = $4,000,000 + $1,000,000 = $5,000,000. Cost-to-cost progress = 32%; revised cumulative revenue = $1,856,000. Is that below revenue already recognized?

    YesRecord a downward cumulative catch-up: $1,856,000 − $2,000,000 = −$144,000. Reduce current-period revenue by $144,000.
    NoSubtract previously recognized revenue from revised cumulative revenue. Record an upward catch-up if positive; record no adjustment if zero.

Key points

  • Remember: Integrated added work means recomputing revenue to date, not just recognizing the added contract price.
  • Update both the transaction price and total expected costs under cost-to-cost.
  • A higher contract price can still produce a revenue reduction when revised progress falls.

How the exam traps you

  • Treat the approved HVAC and lobby additions as a separate contract. The work is not distinct because BuildCo must integrate it into the existing renovation.
  • Keep the original 40% progress after increasing the contract price. Use revised expected costs: $1,600,000 ÷ $5,000,000 = 32%.
  • Report $1,856,000 as the current-period adjustment. Subtract $2,000,000 already recognized. The adjustment is a $144,000 revenue reduction.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Blue Co. enters into a contract to deliver 100 identical units of product to a customer at $500 per unit. Each unit is a distinct good, and control transfers at shipment. Blue has already shipped 40 units and recognized $20,000 of revenue. The customer then requests 20 additional units, and Blue agrees to add those units for $8,400 total. At the modification date, Blue's current standalone selling price is $450 per unit. Assume there is no variable consideration, no significant financing component, and no return right. How should Blue account for the contract modification for units shipped after the modification date?
Hint

Work the modification in two steps: first decide whether it is a separate contract, then determine whether any remaining goods are distinct from those already transferred.

Question 3

On January 1, Year 1, Seller enters into a contract to provide 100 identical maintenance visits for a fixed price of $200,000. The visits qualify as a series and are accounted for as a single performance obligation satisfied over time as each visit is performed. By the date of a contract modification, Seller has completed 40 visits and has recognized $80,000 of revenue. At that date, the parties modify the contract to add 30 additional maintenance visits for an additional $48,000. The added visits are distinct, and the 60 remaining original visits plus the 30 added visits are all distinct from the visits already transferred. At the modification date, the standalone selling price of each remaining or added visit is $1,800, and the $48,000 increase does not reflect the standalone selling price of the added visits or any appropriate adjustment for the circumstances of the contract. Which of the following best describes how Seller should account for the modification and the revenue to recognize for visits performed after the modification?
Hint

First decide whether the modification is a separate contract. Then determine whether the remaining services are distinct from those already transferred before computing any revised per-visit revenue.

Question 4

On January 2, Year 1, Apex entered into a contract to deliver 100 identical networking devices to a customer at $200 each. Control of each device transfers at delivery, and each device is distinct. By April 30, Apex had delivered 40 devices. On May 1, the parties approved a modification adding 30 more identical devices. Because market prices had fallen, Apex's standalone selling price on May 1 for each device was $190, and the modification priced the 30 additional devices at $190 each. The original price and terms for the remaining 60 devices were unchanged. Assuming collectibility remains probable and no other contract terms changed, how should Apex account for the modification under ASC 606?
Hint

Ask two questions in order: Are the added goods distinct, and is the added price based on standalone selling price at the modification date rather than the original contract price?

Question 5

Omega Systems enters into a contract in 20X5 to design, build, and install a highly customized bottling line for $12 million. The contract is recognized over time because the asset has no alternative use to Omega and Omega has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Omega concluded the promised design, equipment, software, and installation are a single performance obligation because it provides a significant integration service. In 20X6, before the line is complete, the parties approve a change order adding specialized inspection modules for $2 million. The modules will be built into the same line, require rework of some completed design work, and significantly modify the overall system. The $2 million equals Omega's standalone selling price for the added modules. Which accounting treatment is most appropriate for the approved modification?
Hint

First determine whether the added modules are distinct in the context of the existing promise, standalone selling price alone does not decide the outcome.

Question 6

On January 2, Year 1, MedSupply Co. contracted to sell 100 identical infusion pumps to a hospital for $5,000 each, with control passing on delivery. By June 30, Year 1, MedSupply had delivered 40 pumps and recognized revenue for those deliveries. On July 1, Year 1, the parties modified the contract to add 20 pumps priced at $4,600 each (their standalone selling price on July 1) and to reduce the price of each of the remaining 60 original pumps to $4,700. The modification did not affect the 40 pumps already delivered. Under ASC 606, which accounting treatment is most appropriate for the modification?
Hint

Apply the ASC 606 contract-modification sequence: first consider whether the added goods can be treated separately; if not, determine whether the remaining promised goods are distinct from those already transferred.

Question 7

On January 1, 20X5, Orion Co. entered into a 20-month contract to provide monthly cybersecurity monitoring services to a customer for total consideration of $100,000. Each monthly service is distinct, but Orion accounts for the arrangement as a single series performance obligation satisfied over time. After 8 months of service had been provided, the parties modified the contract to add 10 additional monthly service periods to be provided after the original 20-month term ends. On the modification date, Orion's list price for a 10-month block sold to a new customer is $55,000. Orion routinely charges existing customers $42,000 for the same 10-month extension when no new setup or sales effort is required, and the customer agreed to pay $42,000. Under ASC 606, which accounting treatment for the contract modification is most appropriate?
Hint

First determine whether the added months are distinct from the remaining promised services; if they are distinct, then assess whether the agreed price for the extension represents the standalone selling price in the relevant circumstances.

Question 8

Apex enters into a $1,200,000 fixed-price contract in Year 1 to build and install a customized production line for a customer. The contract contains a single performance obligation satisfied over time because the asset has no alternative use to Apex and Apex has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Apex uses a cost-to-cost input method. The contract includes a specialized module that Apex purchases from a third party for $300,000 and will install near the end of the project. The module is not distinct within the contract; the customer obtains control of the module when it is delivered to the customer's site; the module's cost is significant relative to total expected contract costs; Apex is not involved in designing or manufacturing the module; and Apex expects no margin on it. These facts meet the conditions commonly described in ASC 606 for the 'uninstalled materials' treatment (recognize at cost when control transfers). By December 31, Year 1, Apex has delivered the module to the customer's site and has incurred $150,000 of other contract costs. Apex expects $450,000 of additional other contract costs to complete the project. Ignoring any financing or variable consideration issues, what is the most supportable amount of revenue Apex should recognize through December 31, Year 1?
Hint

Decide whether the third-party module should be recognized separately when control transfers; if so, remove it from the cost-to-cost base, compute progress on the remaining performance, and then add any separately recognized amount.

Question 9

In 20X5, Metro Co. enters into a contract to deliver 100 identical industrial sensors to a customer for $100 each. Each sensor is distinct, and control transfers at a point in time when each sensor is shipped. After 40 sensors have been shipped, the parties approve a contract modification that adds 20 more sensors for $85 each. On the modification date, Metro's stand-alone selling price for a sensor is $90. The prices for the remaining 60 original sensors are not changed, and no other terms are modified. Assume collectibility is probable and there is no variable consideration, significant financing component, or right of return. Under ASC 606, what is the best action for Metro?
Hint

For a contract modification involving added goods, first decide whether the added goods are distinct, and then ask whether the added price reflects their stand-alone selling price.

Drill all 126 Revenue recognition questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

When does an ASC 606 contract modification require cumulative catch-up?

When added work is not distinct and becomes part of a single, partially satisfied over-time performance obligation. BuildCo's integrated HVAC and lobby work meets that test.

How do you calculate cumulative catch-up using cost-to-cost?

Divide costs incurred by revised total expected costs, then multiply by the revised transaction price. Subtract revenue already recognized to find the adjustment.

Can a contract price increase cause a downward revenue adjustment?

Yes. BuildCo's revised progress is 32%, producing $1,856,000 of cumulative revenue despite the price increase. That is $144,000 below revenue already recognized.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.

Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Revenue recognition

All Revenue recognition practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.