BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 8 practice questions
ASC 606: No Alternative Use and Enforceable Right to Payment
For customized assets, no alternative use alone does not establish over-time revenue recognition. Below: follow a machine contract through the three over-time criteria before considering delivery.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the specific ASC 606 test for customized goods when the customer does not control the asset as it is produced.
Answer A. ASC 606 permits recognizing revenue over time when an entity is creating an asset that has no alternative use to the seller and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. The facts explicitly state both conditions are met here. Legal title and possession transferring on delivery are point-in-time indicators, but they do not override an applicable over-time criterion.
Why not B: Customization can suggest over-time recognition to candidates, but under ASC 606 the no-alternative-use pathway also requires an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Without that right the no-alternative-use condition alone is insufficient for over-time recognition.
Why not C: Title and physical possession are common indicators of point-in-time control, but they apply only if no over-time criterion is met. Because this contract meets the no-alternative-use and enforceable-right-to-payment test, revenue is recognized over time despite title transferring on delivery.
Why not D: Prepayment affects cash flow and contract liabilities but does not by itself change whether performance satisfies an ASC 606 over-time criterion. The key issue is the presence of the no-alternative-use plus enforceable-right-to-payment conditions, which point to over-time recognition here.
Decide it in order
T1Nilo builds one custom machine at its factory. The customer neither consumes benefits during production nor controls work in process. Nilo cannot redirect the machine without significant economic loss. Enforceable cancellation terms pay costs plus reasonable profit for work to date. Nilo bills monthly; title passes at delivery. Does the customer simultaneously receive and consume benefits as Nilo performs?
YesRecognize revenue over time. Simultaneous receipt and consumption satisfies an over-time criterion.NoGo to T2T2Does the customer control the machine as Nilo creates it? For Nilo's stated facts, no.
YesRecognize revenue over time. Customer control of the asset as created satisfies an over-time criterion.NoGo to T3T3Does the machine have no alternative use to Nilo? Yes: redirecting it would cause significant economic loss.
YesGo to T4NoRecognize revenue at a point in time when control transfers. None of the over-time criteria is met.T4If the customer cancels for reasons other than Nilo's nonperformance, is payment for work to date, including reasonable profit, enforceable? For Nilo, yes.
YesRecognize revenue over time as Nilo performs. No alternative use plus enforceable payment satisfies the third criterion, despite monthly billing and title at delivery.NoRecognize revenue at a point in time when control transfers. No alternative use alone is insufficient; a costs-only cancellation entitlement fails this payment test.
Key points
- Remember: customization needs payment protection, not just a machine that cannot be sold to someone else.
- For Nilo, costs plus reasonable profit satisfy the payment test; costs alone would fail it.
- Monthly billings and title at delivery do not override a satisfied over-time criterion.
How the exam traps you
- Choosing over time solely because the machine has no alternative use. After ruling out the first two criteria, confirm enforceable payment for work to date, including reasonable profit.
- Treating reimbursement of costs alone as sufficient payment protection. The payment right must compensate completed performance, including reasonable profit.
- Letting monthly billings or title at delivery decide recognition. Test the over-time criteria first; neither billing nor title alone determines the answer.
Question 2
Hint
Evaluate each contract separately against the ASC 606 over-time criteria. Progress payments and title terms are indicators, but they do not replace the actual recognition tests.
Answer C. Contract 1 meets ASC 606's over-time criterion for an asset with no alternative use to the seller combined with an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date (the customer must pay costs plus a reasonable profit if it cancels). Contract 2 does not meet that criterion because the generators have alternative use to Atlas and Atlas has no right to payment for unbilled work. Receipt of deposits or milestone billings by itself does not require over-time recognition.
Why not A: This is tempting because long production and progress billings look like over-time situations, but ASC 606 requires one of the specific over-time criteria to be met. Contract 2 fails the no-alternative-use/enforceable-right test because Atlas can redirect the unfinished generators and has no right to payment for unbilled work.
Why not B: Deposits and milestone billings indicate cash collection progress but do not, by themselves, demonstrate transfer of control or the ASC 606 over-time criteria. Contract 2 has alternative-use facts and no contractual right to payment for unbilled work, so it does not qualify for over-time recognition.
Why not D: Title transfer on delivery can be a point-in-time indicator, but it is not dispositive when an ASC 606 over-time criterion is met. Contract 1 qualifies for over-time recognition under the no-alternative-use plus enforceable-right-to-payment criterion despite title-transfer language.
Question 3
Hint
If one over-time criterion is already ruled out and another is already met, focus on the remaining condition under ASC 606.
Answer D. Because the asset has no alternative use to Ridge, ASC 606 permits over-time recognition only if the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. The fact in option A, entitlement to payment for work done to date (including a reasonable profit margin) if the contract is terminated for reasons other than Ridge's failure to perform, satisfies that requirement and allows revenue recognition over time. The other options do not create the required enforceable right.
Why not A: The expected contract length or completion within a reporting period does not determine whether revenue is recognized over time; ASC 606 requires that one of the over-time criteria (such as an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date) be met.
Why not B: This is tempting because cash receipts often distract candidates, but a deposit affects contract liabilities and cash flows and does not by itself establish an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date or that control transfers over time.
Why not C: Title passing at delivery is an indicator used in point-in-time assessments of control; it does not create the enforceable right-to-payment required under the no-alternative-use pathway for over-time recognition.
Question 4
Hint
Identify which of ASC 606's three over-time criteria the facts explicitly satisfy before focusing on title, billing, or collectibility.
Answer A. ASC 606 allows revenue recognition over time if any one of its over-time criteria is met. The facts meet the no-alternative-use plus enforceable-right-to-payment criterion: the asset cannot be redirected without significant rework, and the contract/legal framework entitles Apex to recover costs plus a reasonable profit if the customer terminates. Therefore Apex may recognize revenue over time despite title and possession transferring at completion.
Why not B: This is attractive because title and possession are classic indicators of control at delivery. It fails here because ASC 606 permits over-time recognition if an over-time criterion is met; the no-alternative-use/enforceable-right facts support over-time recognition despite those end-of-contract control indicators.
Why not C: This distractor tempts because collectibility and payment timing are important to revenue recognition and monthly billings often align with progress invoicing. However, under ASC 606 collectibility is a threshold for applying the standard, and payment terms alone do not satisfy any of the over-time recognition criteria.
Why not D: This references a legitimate over-time test and therefore is plausible. It is incorrect on these facts because PharmaCo does not control or receive the benefits of the work in process while Apex manufactures the specialized asset, so the simultaneous-receipt test is not met.
Question 5
Hint
Apply ASC 606's over-time tests: does the customer control the asset as created, or (if no alternative use exists) does the contract give the seller an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date? Focus on whether the cancellation remedy entitles the seller to consideration that reflects value (including profit) of completed work.
Answer B. ASC 606 allows over-time recognition if the customer controls the asset as it is created or if the asset has no alternative use to the seller and the seller has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Here, Utility does not control the work in process, and the contract's cancellation-for-convenience remedy limits Fabricator to recovery of costs (no profit). A right to recover costs only generally does not meet ASC 606's enforceable-right requirement because it does not provide entitlement to consideration that reflects the value of completed performance. Therefore, the over-time criteria are not met and revenue should be recognized at the point of delivery and acceptance.
Why not A: This is tempting because customer-specific customization and a nonrefundable deposit suggest customer commitment, but ASC 606 requires customer control of the asset as created for over-time recognition; a deposit alone does not establish that Utility controls the work in process when the facts state it does not.
Why not C: Progress billings are a payment mechanism but do not by themselves create the ASC 606 'enforceable right' to payment for completed performance; because the contract limits cancellation recovery to costs (no profit), the contract does not provide the typical enforceable-right entitlement required for over-time recognition.
Why not D: Title and possession transferring at delivery are indicators of point-in-time transfer, but stating that as the sole reason is incomplete. The correct conclusion is point-in-time recognition because none of the ASC 606 over-time criteria are satisfied in this fact pattern.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on ASC 606's criteria for recognizing revenue over time and identify which facts speak to 'no alternative use' and an 'enforceable right to payment.'
Answer B. Under ASC 606 a performance obligation may be satisfied over time if, among other criteria, the asset being created has no alternative use to the seller and the seller has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Here the machine cannot be readily redirected to another customer (no alternative use) and the contract requires reimbursement plus reasonable profit on cancellation (an enforceable right). Thus the primary issue is whether those over-time criteria are met; if they are, revenue may be recognized during production.
Why not A: This is tempting because indicators of control such as title transfer often point to point-in-time recognition. However, ASC 606's over-time test is based on specific criteria (including no alternative use and an enforceable right to payment); title transfer is only one indicator of control and is not the primary determinant when the over-time criteria are met.
Why not C: An upfront deposit affects cash flows and the presentation of contract liabilities but does not determine whether a performance obligation is satisfied over time. The scenario already states collectibility is probable; the core question is whether the facts satisfy ASC 606's over-time criteria.
Why not D: Capitalizing costs to obtain or fulfill a contract is an ASC 606 accounting consideration, but it relates to expense recognition and asset presentation. It does not resolve whether the performance obligation is satisfied over time versus at a point in time.
Question 7
Hint
For customized goods, do not stop after identifying no alternative use. Check whether the seller is entitled to payment for performance completed to date.
Answer B. ASC 606 permits over-time recognition when (among other criteria) the entity's performance does not create an asset with an alternative use to the entity and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Both contracts describe customized equipment with no alternative use, but only Contract B provides an enforceable right to payment that includes a reasonable profit margin for work performed to date. Contract A offers only cost reimbursement, which generally does not satisfy the 'enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date' requirement. Therefore, only Contract B should be recognized over time.
Why not A: Tempting if the student focuses solely on the customized nature of the asset. However, no alternative use alone is not sufficient, the contract must also provide an enforceable right to payment for performance to date, which Contract A lacks because it provides only cost reimbursement and no profit.
Why not C: Reflects the common mistake of assuming all highly customized production is over time. ASC 606 requires both no alternative use and an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date; Contract A fails the latter requirement.
Why not D: Attractive to candidates who default to point-in-time recognition because control transfers on delivery, but the stem excludes the other over-time criteria and specifies legally enforceable termination terms, Contract B meets the third criterion and therefore should be over time.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on the specific ASC 606 criterion for customized assets. Ask whether both required conditions for one over-time trigger are present.
Answer D. ASC 606 permits recognizing revenue over time when the entity is creating an asset that has no alternative use to the entity and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. Both conditions are explicitly met here, so Orion should recognize revenue over time rather than waiting until delivery.
Why not A: An upfront nonrefundable payment is not required for over-time recognition under this criterion. The key requirements are no alternative use and an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date.
Why not B: Many candidates default to delivery as the revenue date, but delivery is not required when an over-time recognition criterion is met. The facts support over-time recognition before delivery.
Why not C: Incurring a majority of expected costs does not itself trigger point-in-time recognition under ASC 606. Cost percentages may be used to measure progress once over-time recognition applies, but they are not the triggering criterion.
Common questions
Does no alternative use automatically mean revenue is recognized over time?
No. When the customer neither consumes benefits during performance nor controls work in process, the seller also needs an enforceable right to payment for completed performance, including reasonable profit.
Does a right to recover costs qualify as an enforceable right to payment under ASC 606?
Costs alone do not satisfy the payment test in this machine contract. Changing Nilo's cancellation entitlement from costs plus reasonable profit to costs only would change recognition to a point in time.
Can revenue be recognized over time if title transfers at delivery?
Yes. Nilo meets the no-alternative-use and enforceable-payment criterion, so title passing at delivery does not delay revenue recognition.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.
Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Revenue recognition
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.