PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 8 practice questions

ASC 606: No Alternative Use and Enforceable Right to Payment

For customized assets, no alternative use alone does not establish over-time revenue recognition. Below: follow a machine contract through the three over-time criteria before considering delivery.

The ruleIf neither simultaneous receipt and consumption nor customer control during production applies, recognize over time only when no alternative use is paired with enforceable payment for work to date, including reasonable profit. Otherwise, recognize at a point in time.

Try one first

On January 2, Year 1, Nilo Co. enters into a contract to manufacture highly customized equipment for a customer for $900,000. The equipment is designed specifically for the customer and has no alternative use to Nilo. The contract states that if the customer cancels for reasons other than Nilo's failure to perform, Nilo is entitled to payment for costs incurred plus a reasonable profit margin on work performed to date. Legal title and physical possession transfer only upon delivery, and the customer does not control the work in process as it is produced. Assume collectibility is probable and the contract contains a single performance obligation. Under ASC 606, when should Nilo recognize revenue?
Hint

Focus on the specific ASC 606 test for customized goods when the customer does not control the asset as it is produced.

Decide it in order

  1. T1Nilo builds one custom machine at its factory. The customer neither consumes benefits during production nor controls work in process. Nilo cannot redirect the machine without significant economic loss. Enforceable cancellation terms pay costs plus reasonable profit for work to date. Nilo bills monthly; title passes at delivery. Does the customer simultaneously receive and consume benefits as Nilo performs?

    YesRecognize revenue over time. Simultaneous receipt and consumption satisfies an over-time criterion.
  2. T2Does the customer control the machine as Nilo creates it? For Nilo's stated facts, no.

    YesRecognize revenue over time. Customer control of the asset as created satisfies an over-time criterion.
  3. T3Does the machine have no alternative use to Nilo? Yes: redirecting it would cause significant economic loss.

    NoRecognize revenue at a point in time when control transfers. None of the over-time criteria is met.
  4. T4If the customer cancels for reasons other than Nilo's nonperformance, is payment for work to date, including reasonable profit, enforceable? For Nilo, yes.

    YesRecognize revenue over time as Nilo performs. No alternative use plus enforceable payment satisfies the third criterion, despite monthly billing and title at delivery.
    NoRecognize revenue at a point in time when control transfers. No alternative use alone is insufficient; a costs-only cancellation entitlement fails this payment test.

Key points

  • Remember: customization needs payment protection, not just a machine that cannot be sold to someone else.
  • For Nilo, costs plus reasonable profit satisfy the payment test; costs alone would fail it.
  • Monthly billings and title at delivery do not override a satisfied over-time criterion.

How the exam traps you

  • Choosing over time solely because the machine has no alternative use. After ruling out the first two criteria, confirm enforceable payment for work to date, including reasonable profit.
  • Treating reimbursement of costs alone as sufficient payment protection. The payment right must compensate completed performance, including reasonable profit.
  • Letting monthly billings or title at delivery decide recognition. Test the over-time criteria first; neither billing nor title alone determines the answer.

7 more, each from a different angle

0 of 7 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Atlas Manufacturing entered into two separate customer contracts in Year 1. Assume collectibility is probable, each contract contains a single performance obligation, and neither customer controls the work in process as it is created. Contract 1: Atlas will build a highly customized packaging line in its own facility. Because of the customer-specific design, the asset has no alternative use to Atlas. If the customer cancels for convenience, the contract requires the customer to pay Atlas for costs incurred to date plus a reasonable profit margin on work completed to date. Contract 2: Atlas will build standard generators from its normal product line. Atlas receives a 40% deposit and periodic milestone billings during production, but Atlas can readily redirect unfinished generators to other customers. If the customer cancels, Atlas has no right to payment for work not yet billed. Under ASC 606, which statement is most appropriate?
Hint

Evaluate each contract separately against the ASC 606 over-time criteria. Progress payments and title terms are indicators, but they do not replace the actual recognition tests.

Question 3

Ridge Co. enters into a contract in 20X5 to manufacture a highly customized machine for a customer. Once production begins, the machine has no alternative use to Ridge. Assume the customer does not control the machine as it is created and does not simultaneously receive and consume the benefits of Ridge's performance. Under ASC 606, which additional fact would allow Ridge to recognize revenue over time rather than at a point in time?
Hint

If one over-time criterion is already ruled out and another is already met, focus on the remaining condition under ASC 606.

Question 4

Apex Co. contracts to build a highly customized production line for PharmaCo. Title and physical possession transfer only after installation and final acceptance. PharmaCo does not control the work in process while Apex manufactures the equipment at Apex's factory. Apex bills monthly based on progress, and collectibility is probable. The equipment is so specialized that Apex could not redirect it to another customer without significant rework and economic loss. Under the contract and applicable law, if PharmaCo terminates for convenience Apex may recover costs plus a reasonable profit on work performed to date. Assume ASC 606 applies and there is no significant financing component. Under ASC 606, which issue is primary in deciding whether Apex may recognize revenue over time rather than only at final delivery?
Hint

Identify which of ASC 606's three over-time criteria the facts explicitly satisfy before focusing on title, billing, or collectibility.

Question 5

On January 2, 20X5, Fabricator Co. enters into a fixed-price contract to build a highly customized industrial unit for Utility Co. The unit will be built at Fabricator's plant and delivered in 14 months. The arrangement contains a single performance obligation, collectibility is probable, there is no variable consideration, and Utility does not control the work in process during production. The unit cannot be redirected to another customer without significant economic loss because of Utility-specific design features and contractual restrictions. Utility pays a 20% nonrefundable deposit at signing and monthly progress billings thereafter. If Utility cancels for convenience, Fabricator is entitled to reimbursement of costs incurred to date but not to any profit margin on work performed to date. Legal title and physical possession transfer only upon delivery and acceptance. Under ASC 606, what is the best conclusion about when Fabricator should recognize revenue for this contract?
Hint

Apply ASC 606's over-time tests: does the customer control the asset as created, or (if no alternative use exists) does the contract give the seller an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date? Focus on whether the cancellation remedy entitles the seller to consideration that reflects value (including profit) of completed work.

Question 6

Rex Co. enters into a noncancelable contract in Year 1 to design, build, and install a highly customized production machine for a customer. The machine is being built to the customer's unique specifications and cannot be readily redirected to another customer without significant economic loss. The contract provides that if the customer cancels for reasons other than Rex's nonperformance, Rex is entitled to reimbursement of costs incurred plus a reasonable profit. Assume the contract is approved, collectibility is probable, and the design/build/install package is a single performance obligation. To determine whether Rex should recognize revenue during production rather than waiting until installation is complete, what is the primary revenue recognition issue?
Hint

Focus on ASC 606's criteria for recognizing revenue over time and identify which facts speak to 'no alternative use' and an 'enforceable right to payment.'

Question 7

Omega Co. enters into two separate contracts in Year 1 to manufacture equipment for different customers. For both contracts, the equipment is being built to the customer's unique specifications and cannot be redirected to another customer without significant rework. Also assume the customer does not control the equipment as it is created, the customer does not simultaneously receive and consume benefits as Omega performs, and the stated termination provisions are legally enforceable. Contract A: If the customer cancels for convenience, Omega is entitled to reimbursement of costs incurred to date, but no profit margin. Contract B: If the customer cancels for convenience, Omega is entitled to reimbursement of costs incurred to date plus a reasonable profit margin on work performed to date. Under ASC 606, which contract(s) should Omega account for as satisfied over time?
Hint

For customized goods, do not stop after identifying no alternative use. Check whether the seller is entitled to payment for performance completed to date.

Question 8

In Year 1, Orion Co. enters into a valid contract to build a highly customized piece of manufacturing equipment for a customer. The equipment is being made to the customer's unique specifications and Orion could not readily redirect the partly completed asset to another customer without significant economic loss. The contract also gives Orion an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date, including a reasonable profit margin, if the customer cancels for convenience. Assume no other over-time criterion is relevant. Under ASC 606, when should Orion recognize revenue for this contract?
Hint

Focus on the specific ASC 606 criterion for customized assets. Ask whether both required conditions for one over-time trigger are present.

Drill all 126 Revenue recognition questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does no alternative use automatically mean revenue is recognized over time?

No. When the customer neither consumes benefits during performance nor controls work in process, the seller also needs an enforceable right to payment for completed performance, including reasonable profit.

Does a right to recover costs qualify as an enforceable right to payment under ASC 606?

Costs alone do not satisfy the payment test in this machine contract. Changing Nilo's cancellation entitlement from costs plus reasonable profit to costs only would change recognition to a point in time.

Can revenue be recognized over time if title transfers at delivery?

Yes. Nilo meets the no-alternative-use and enforceable-payment criterion, so title passing at delivery does not delay revenue recognition.

Watch it solved

A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Revenue recognition, worked step by step.

Multiple Performance Obligations & Contract Assets | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Revenue recognition

All Revenue recognition practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.