PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions

Unequal-Life Projects: EAA or Replacement Chain?

For unequal-life alternatives that provide ongoing service and can be replaced on the same terms, choose the higher equivalent annual annuity. Below: a worked EAA comparison checked with a common-life replacement chain.

The ruleFor mutually exclusive, unequal-life alternatives providing ongoing service with replacements on the same terms, compare equivalent annual annuities or common-life replacement-chain NPVs. Choose the higher value.

Try one first

A manufacturer must choose one of two mutually exclusive machines that perform the same function. The service will be needed continuously for the foreseeable future, and management expects that when a machine reaches the end of its useful life, it can be replaced with a comparable machine under similar economics. Both machines have similar risk, and the company's required return is 10%. The analyses below already incorporate all after-tax operating cash flows, terminal cash flows, and working capital effects. Machine A: Initial outlay $600,000; useful life 3 years; NPV at 10% = $74,000; IRR = 16.2% Machine B: Initial outlay $900,000; useful life 5 years; NPV at 10% = $96,000; IRR = 14.1% Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Do not stop at positive NPV versus higher IRR. Ask whether the projects have the same economic horizon and whether the service must be replaced over time.

Worked example

Cedar Co. must choose one machine for the same ongoing service. Identical replacements are available immediately on the same terms. At a 10% required return, Machine A has a 2-year life and $36,000 NPV; Machine B has a 4-year life and $54,000 NPV. Annuity factors are 1.7355 and 3.1699, respectively. The 2-year discount factor is 0.8264.

1Annualize Machine A’s NPV$36,000 ÷ 1.7355Approximately $20,743 per year
2Annualize Machine B’s NPV$54,000 ÷ 3.1699Approximately $17,035 per year
3Compare annualized value$20,743 − $17,035A provides approximately $3,708 more per year

Choose Machine A because its EAA is higher, even though Machine B has the higher single-cycle NPV.

Check: Over four years, A’s replacement-chain NPV is $36,000 + ($36,000 × 0.8264) ≈ $65,750, which exceeds B’s $54,000.

Key points

  • EAA converts each machine’s lifetime NPV into an equivalent yearly dollar benefit.
  • Use the required return and each machine’s own useful life to select its annuity factor.
  • A replacement chain discounts future replacement cycles back to today before adding their NPVs.

How the exam traps you

  • Choose B because its $54,000 single-cycle NPV exceeds A’s $36,000. Compare annualized values because the machines cover different service periods and will be replaced.
  • Swap factors: A = $36,000 ÷ 3.1699 ≈ $11,357; B = $54,000 ÷ 1.7355 ≈ $31,115. Choose B. Use each machine’s own life: A ≈ $20,743; B ≈ $17,035. Choose A.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Ravin Co. must choose one of two machines that provide the same level of output. Either machine can be replaced indefinitely at the same economics when its life ends. Ravin uses a 10% required rate of return and evaluates projects on an after-tax cash flow basis. No working capital effects exist, and no technology changes are expected.
Machine SMachine L
Initial outlay$200,000$300,000
Annual net cash inflow$76,000$80,000
Useful life4 years6 years
Salvage value$15,000 (end of Year 4)$30,000 (end of Year 6)
At 10%4 Years6 Years
PV annuity factor3.16994.3553
PV of $1 factor0.68300.5645
Which classification is most appropriate for these alternatives?
Hint

First decide whether raw NPV is the right comparison measure. Then ask what valuation model is appropriate when the alternatives are mutually exclusive, have different lives, and are assumed to be repeatable.

Question 3

A firm must choose one of two mutually exclusive capital projects. The firm's cost of capital is 10%. Project A requires a $100 initial outlay at time 0 and yields cash inflows of $70 at the end of Years 1 and 2. Project B requires a $200 initial outlay at time 0 and yields cash inflows of $60 at the end of Years 1-5. Management intends to select one project now and thereafter continually replace the chosen project with an identical project indefinitely (i.e., repeat the project whenever its life ends). Which project should management choose?
Hint

Convert each project's NPV into an equivalent annual annuity (EAA) when comparing projects with unequal lives that will be repeated; compare EAAs rather than raw NPVs in that scenario.

Question 4

Delta Co. must choose one of two mutually exclusive inspection systems that provide identical annual service capacity. Delta will need that capacity continuously for exactly 12 years, and whichever system is selected can be replaced immediately at the end of its service life on identical terms. Ignore taxes, salvage value, and working capital. At Delta's 9% required return, the standalone NPVs are: System S (4-year life) = $92,000; System L (6-year life) = $118,000. Relevant present value annuity factors at 9% are 3.2397 for 4 years and 4.4859 for 6 years. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Ask whether a one-cycle NPV is the right measurement basis when two mutually exclusive assets provide the same service but have different useful lives.

Question 5

Ridge Co. must acquire one of two automated packaging lines that perform the same function. Management has already calculated the following at Ridge's 10% required rate of return: - Line A: initial outlay $900,000; useful life 3 years; NPV $144,000; IRR 17%; profitability index 1.16 - Line B: initial outlay $1,300,000; useful life 5 years; NPV $179,000; IRR 14%; profitability index 1.14 Assume the production need will continue indefinitely, either line can be replaced at the same economics when its life ends, the cash flows are conventional, and Ridge is not capital constrained. Which is the correct treatment of these results?
Hint

Identify the fact that changes the usual NPV-first rule: the asset need does not end when the first machine wears out.

Question 6

River Co. must acquire one machine to perform the same production function for the next 6 years. The alternatives are mutually exclusive. If Machine X is selected, River will replace it immediately at the end of Year 3 with an identical Machine X having the same cost and cash-flow pattern. Assume no residual values, no working-capital effects, identical risk, and no capital rationing. River's required rate of return is 10%. Machine X: initial outlay $260,000 now; net cash inflows of $110,000 at each year-end for Years 1-3. Machine Y: initial outlay $420,000 now; net cash inflows of $100,000 at each year-end for Years 1-6. Present value factors: PV annuity factor, 10%, 3 years = 2.4869 PV annuity factor, 10%, 6 years = 4.3553 PV factor, 10%, 3 years = 0.7513 Which valuation approach and conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Ask whether the two alternatives can be compared on raw NPV alone, or whether their unequal lives must first be put on a common basis.

Drill all 123 Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do you calculate equivalent annual annuity from NPV?

Divide NPV by the present value annuity factor for the required return and the machine’s useful life. For Machine A, $36,000 ÷ 1.7355 gives approximately $20,743 per year.

Why not choose the unequal-life machine with the higher NPV?

Its NPV covers a different service period. Machine B has the higher single-cycle NPV, but Machine A creates more equivalent value per year under ongoing replacement.

Do EAA and replacement-chain analysis give the same ranking?

Yes, when both use the same discount rate and identical replacement economics over a common horizon. Repeating A over four years gives about $65,750 in present value, exceeding B’s $54,000.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models

All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.