BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Unequal-Life Projects: EAA or Replacement Chain?
For unequal-life alternatives that provide ongoing service and can be replaced on the same terms, choose the higher equivalent annual annuity. Below: a worked EAA comparison checked with a common-life replacement chain.
Try one first
Hint
Do not stop at positive NPV versus higher IRR. Ask whether the projects have the same economic horizon and whether the service must be replaced over time.
Answer C. Because the service is provided continuously and the machines have unequal lives, compare their equivalent annual annuity (EAA) rather than raw NPV. Using PVIFA(10%,3) ≈ 2.487 gives A's annualized value ≈ $74,000 / 2.487 ≈ $29,800; using PVIFA(10%,5) ≈ 3.791 gives B's annualized value ≈ $96,000 / 3.791 ≈ $25,300. Thus Machine A provides the greater annual economic benefit and should be chosen.
Why not A: Tempting because NPV is the preferred rule for mutually exclusive projects, but that rule assumes comparable project horizons. With unequal lives and continuous replacement, annualizing the NPVs (EAA) is the correct ranking method.
Why not B: This reflects the independent-project acceptance rule; it ignores that the projects are mutually exclusive and have different useful lives. Both pass the hurdle but one yields a higher annualized benefit and should be preferred.
Why not D: Scale and IRR/NVP tradeoffs can matter, but here the decisive issue is unequal lives in a repeating-replacement context; annualized NPV (EAA) is the appropriate comparator, and it favors Machine A despite B's larger scale.
Worked example
Cedar Co. must choose one machine for the same ongoing service. Identical replacements are available immediately on the same terms. At a 10% required return, Machine A has a 2-year life and $36,000 NPV; Machine B has a 4-year life and $54,000 NPV. Annuity factors are 1.7355 and 3.1699, respectively. The 2-year discount factor is 0.8264.
| 1 | Annualize Machine A’s NPV$36,000 ÷ 1.7355 | Approximately $20,743 per year |
| 2 | Annualize Machine B’s NPV$54,000 ÷ 3.1699 | Approximately $17,035 per year |
| 3 | Compare annualized value$20,743 − $17,035 | A provides approximately $3,708 more per year |
Choose Machine A because its EAA is higher, even though Machine B has the higher single-cycle NPV.
Check: Over four years, A’s replacement-chain NPV is $36,000 + ($36,000 × 0.8264) ≈ $65,750, which exceeds B’s $54,000.
Key points
- EAA converts each machine’s lifetime NPV into an equivalent yearly dollar benefit.
- Use the required return and each machine’s own useful life to select its annuity factor.
- A replacement chain discounts future replacement cycles back to today before adding their NPVs.
How the exam traps you
- Choose B because its $54,000 single-cycle NPV exceeds A’s $36,000. Compare annualized values because the machines cover different service periods and will be replaced.
- Swap factors: A = $36,000 ÷ 3.1699 ≈ $11,357; B = $54,000 ÷ 1.7355 ≈ $31,115. Choose B. Use each machine’s own life: A ≈ $20,743; B ≈ $17,035. Choose A.
Question 2
| Machine S | Machine L | |
|---|---|---|
| Initial outlay | $200,000 | $300,000 |
| Annual net cash inflow | $76,000 | $80,000 |
| Useful life | 4 years | 6 years |
| Salvage value | $15,000 (end of Year 4) | $30,000 (end of Year 6) |
| At 10% | 4 Years | 6 Years |
|---|---|---|
| PV annuity factor | 3.1699 | 4.3553 |
| PV of $1 factor | 0.6830 | 0.5645 |
Hint
First decide whether raw NPV is the right comparison measure. Then ask what valuation model is appropriate when the alternatives are mutually exclusive, have different lives, and are assumed to be repeatable.
Answer A. Compute NPVs then convert to equivalent annual annuities because the assets are mutually exclusive with unequal repeatable lives. Machine S: PV inflows ≈ $251,157 (76,000 × 3.1699 + 15,000 × 0.6830) → NPV ≈ $51,157. Machine L: PV inflows ≈ $365,359 (80,000 × 4.3553 + 30,000 × 0.5645) → NPV ≈ $65,359. Annualizing gives EAA_S ≈ $51,157 ÷ 3.1699 ≈ $16,100 and EAA_L ≈ $65,359 ÷ 4.3553 ≈ $15,000, so Machine S is preferable.
Why not B: This is tempting because raw NPV is the standard rule for mutually exclusive projects of equal comparison basis. However, when alternatives have different useful lives and can be replaced indefinitely, raw NPV over different horizons is not an apples-to-apples comparison; annualizing (EAA) or using a common repeated-horizon approach is required.
Why not C: That reasoning applies to independent projects where each is judged only against the hurdle rate. Here Ravin must choose one machine (mutually exclusive alternatives), so the assets must be ranked against each other rather than simply accepted because both beat the required rate.
Why not D: IRR is not required and can be misleading for ranking projects with different lives; the stem provides sufficient information to compute NPVs and convert them to equivalent annual annuities, which yields a defensible ranking without using IRR.
Question 3
Hint
Convert each project's NPV into an equivalent annual annuity (EAA) when comparing projects with unequal lives that will be repeated; compare EAAs rather than raw NPVs in that scenario.
Answer B. Compute NPVs at 10%: NPV_A = -100 + 70/1.1 + 70/1.1^2 ≈ $21.49; NPV_B = -200 + 60·[1 - (1.1)^-5]/0.10 ≈ $27.45. Convert each NPV to an equivalent annual annuity: EAA_A = NPV_A·[0.10/(1 - 1.1^-2)] ≈ $12.38; EAA_B = NPV_B·[0.10/(1 - 1.1^-5)] ≈ $7.24. Because the firm repeats projects indefinitely and A's EAA is higher, choose Project A.
Why not A: This is tempting because Project B's raw NPV (≈ $27.45) exceeds Project A's (≈ $21.49). However, with unequal lives that will be repeated indefinitely, compare EAAs rather than raw NPVs; Project A's EAA is higher.
Why not C: This distractor relies on undiscounted totals (B: $300 vs A: $140). Ignoring the time value of money and unequal lives is incorrect for investment choice; discounted measures or EAA are appropriate.
Why not D: This option introduces an additional constraint (deferral) not given in the stem. The firm must choose one mutually exclusive project now, and under the indefinite-replacement assumption the correct economic comparison is by EAA.
Question 4
Hint
Ask whether a one-cycle NPV is the right measurement basis when two mutually exclusive assets provide the same service but have different useful lives.
Answer B. When mutually exclusive assets have unequal lives but provide the same ongoing service and can be replaced on identical terms, compare equivalent annual values (EAV). System S EAV = $92,000 / 3.2397 ≈ $28,400 per year; System L EAV = $118,000 / 4.4859 ≈ $26,300 per year. Therefore System S yields the higher annual value and should be selected.
Why not A: This is tempting because NPV is the standard decision rule, but standalone NPVs are not directly comparable when project lives differ and the firm needs continuous service. In that case you must annualize NPVs (or use a replacement-chain approach) before comparing.
Why not C: Even though both systems fit evenly into 12 years, that fact alone does not make the longer life superior. The firm needs the best value per year (or the larger repeated-cycle PV over the horizon), and annualizing the NPVs shows System S is better.
Why not D: Accepting all positive-NPV projects applies only to independent projects. These systems are mutually exclusive, so Delta must choose the one that creates greater value for the continuous service need; that choice is System S when measured on an annualized basis.
Question 5
Hint
Identify the fact that changes the usual NPV-first rule: the asset need does not end when the first machine wears out.
Answer C. When the service need is ongoing and projects have unequal lives, raw NPV or IRR comparisons can mislead because they ignore differing time spans. Normalize the choices to a common-life basis, typically by converting NPVs to equivalent annual annuities (EAA) or using a replacement-chain analysis, then select the alternative with the higher annualized benefit. Doing so will identify the better long-run choice even when the raw NPVs or IRRs conflict.
Why not A: NPV is generally the primary decision rule for mutually exclusive projects, which makes this tempting. The error is the word "always": with unequal lives and an ongoing replacement need, you must first normalize the projects to a common life or annualize the benefits before relying on raw NPVs.
Why not B: A higher IRR is attractive, but IRR can mis-rank mutually exclusive projects, especially when project sizes and lives differ. IRR is not the preferred tie-breaker here; life-normalization (EAA or replacement-chain) is required.
Why not D: Profitability index is useful when capital is constrained and you must rank projects by return per dollar invested. The stem states Ridge is not capital constrained, and unequal lives still require a common-life or annualized comparison, PI does not address the life-length issue.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether the two alternatives can be compared on raw NPV alone, or whether their unequal lives must first be put on a common basis.
Answer D. Because the machines are mutually exclusive, provide the same service, and Machine X can be repeated on identical terms, River should not compare raw NPVs over unequal lives. Machine X's 3-year NPV is about $13,559 [$110,000 × 2.4869 - $260,000], which converts to a 6-year replacement-chain NPV of about $23,748 [$13,559 + ($13,559 × 0.7513)]. Machine Y's 6-year NPV is about $15,530 [$100,000 × 4.3553 - $420,000]. Therefore, the proper normalized comparison favors Machine X.
Why not A: This is tempting because Machine Y's stand-alone NPV over its own life ($15,530) is slightly higher than Machine X's single-cycle NPV ($13,559). However, comparing raw NPVs is flawed when lives differ and one asset can be repeated; the lives must be normalized via EAA or replacement-chain analysis.
Why not B: Profitability index can be useful when capital is rationed or projects are divisible, but here there is no capital rationing and the alternatives are mutually exclusive with unequal lives. PI does not address the life-normalization issue as directly as EAA or a replacement-chain NPV.
Why not C: This recognizes the need for a 6-year horizon but is incorrect because it fails to discount the second 3-year cycle back to time 0. Simply doubling the first-cycle NPV overstates Machine X's present value.
Common questions
How do you calculate equivalent annual annuity from NPV?
Divide NPV by the present value annuity factor for the required return and the machine’s useful life. For Machine A, $36,000 ÷ 1.7355 gives approximately $20,743 per year.
Why not choose the unequal-life machine with the higher NPV?
Its NPV covers a different service period. Machine B has the higher single-cycle NPV, but Machine A creates more equivalent value per year under ongoing replacement.
Do EAA and replacement-chain analysis give the same ranking?
Yes, when both use the same discount rate and identical replacement economics over a common horizon. Repeating A over four years gives about $65,750 in present value, exceeding B’s $54,000.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models
- How to Calculate NPV With an Annuity and Salvage Value
- Capital Rationing: Choose the Highest-NPV Project Bundle
- NPV vs IRR: Which Model Ranks Mutually Exclusive Projects?
All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.