PracticeBARFree practice exam

BAR · Business Analysis · 9 practice questions

NPV vs IRR: Which Model Ranks Mutually Exclusive Projects?

For mutually exclusive projects, choose the higher positive NPV at the required return, even when the other project has a higher IRR. Below: compare dollar value and percentage return for one company's investment choice.

The ruleFor mutually exclusive projects with similar risk and no capital rationing, select the higher positive NPV at the required return. A higher IRR does not override a higher NPV.

Try one first

Mason Co. is evaluating a project with the following expected cash flows: Year 0 $(500,000), Year 1 $300,000, Year 2 $280,000, and Year 3 $(220,000) for required environmental cleanup. Assume Mason knows its required rate of return and is comparing valuation models for this single project. Which model's result is subject to a notable limiting condition because of this cash flow pattern?
Hint

Focus on which model is known to become unreliable when cash flows switch signs more than once.

Side by side

Net present value (NPV)Internal rate of return (IRR)
What it measuresDollar value added at the required return.Discount rate that makes NPV zero.
Company R's decisionChoose one same-risk, one-year project; no capital rationing.The same mutually exclusive choice.
Required returnDiscount the year-end inflow at 10%.Compare the calculated rate with 10%.
Project A cash flows$1,000 outflow now; $1,200 inflow in Year 1.$1,000 outflow now; $1,200 inflow in Year 1.
Project A result$1,200 / 1.10 - $1,000 = $90.91.$1,200 / $1,000 - 1 = 20%.
Project B cash flows$3,000 outflow now; $3,500 inflow in Year 1.$3,000 outflow now; $3,500 inflow in Year 1.
Project B result$3,500 / 1.10 - $3,000 = $181.82.$3,500 / $3,000 - 1 = 16.67%.
Ranking conflictB creates $90.91 more value.A earns the higher percentage on a smaller investment.
Final decisionChoose B. Both qualify individually, but B adds more value.Do not let A's higher IRR override B's higher NPV.

Key points

  • Remember: a higher percentage return can create fewer dollars of value.
  • Positive NPV makes a project acceptable individually, not necessarily the best choice.
  • Conventional cash flows do not prevent IRR and NPV from ranking projects differently.

How the exam traps you

  • Choose Project A because its 20% IRR is higher. Choose B because its NPV adds more dollar value.
  • Accept both projects because both NPVs are positive. Mutually exclusive means only one can be selected.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A company can fund only one of the following four machine investments. All four projects have similar risk, the same useful life, and no significant qualitative differences. Management's objective is to maximize shareholder value. An analyst prepared the following summary:
ProjectInitial InvestmentNPVIRRPayback (years)
Project A$100,000$8,00015%2.2
Project B$100,000$11,00013%2.6
Project C$100,000$5,00018%1.9
Project D$100,000$2,00012%2.0
Which project should the company select?
Hint

Focus on the decision rule that best aligns with maximizing value when only one acceptable project can be chosen.

Question 3

Rex Co. is evaluating two machine purchases that are mutually exclusive. Both machines have conventional cash flows, similar risk, and the same useful life. Rex's required rate of return is 10%. Machine A: Initial investment $200,000; net present value (NPV) $24,000; internal rate of return (IRR) 15% Machine B: Initial investment $120,000; NPV $18,000; IRR 18% Based only on these financial valuation measures, how should the two alternatives be classified?
Hint

Separate acceptance from ranking: first decide whether each project clears the hurdle rate, then decide which measure is usually preferred when only one of two acceptable projects can be chosen.

Question 4

Company Delta must choose one mutually exclusive investment. Project A is a conventional manufacturing expansion with stable, forecastable cash flows. Project B is a staged R&D program: an initial development outlay, with the option after two years to abandon or to invest additional capital to scale if early results are favorable. Project C is an acquisition with uncertain integration synergies. Management applied a standard DCF/NPV analysis (single expected cash‑flow paths discounted at project rates) to rank the alternatives. Which of the following best identifies an exception or limiting condition where reliance on a standard DCF/NPV model is least appropriate?
Hint

Ask whether future managerial decisions can materially change the project's payoff profile; if so, a single expected cash‑flow DCF may miss value from that flexibility.

Question 5

A firm with a 10% cost of capital must choose between two mutually exclusive projects. Project Red requires a $1,000,000 initial investment, has an IRR of 18%, and an NPV of $50,000 (discounted at 10%). Project Blue requires a $3,000,000 initial investment, has an IRR of 12%, and an NPV of $200,000 (discounted at 10%). All calculations are correct. To maximize shareholder value, which project should the firm accept?
Hint

Focus on which metric (percentage vs. dollars) directly measures the increase in shareholder wealth when projects are mutually exclusive and differ in scale.

Question 6

On January 1, 20X5, Lark Co. is evaluating two mutually exclusive equipment purchases. Qualitative factors are expected to be the same, and the company's required rate of return has already been used to compute the present values below. Project Atlas: Initial investment of $240,000; present value of expected net cash inflows of $264,000. Project Beacon: Initial investment of $100,000; present value of expected net cash inflows of $113,000. Using the net present value model, which project should Lark select?
Hint

Compute each project's net present value first, then focus on which measure controls when only one project can be chosen.

Question 7

Parker Co. is evaluating two mutually exclusive equipment projects. Each project requires a $500,000 initial investment, has conventional cash flows, and has similar risk. Parker is not capital constrained. At Parker's 10% required rate of return, Project A has a net present value of $42,000 and an internal rate of return of 14%, while Project B has a net present value of $55,000 and an internal rate of return of 13%. Which factor should govern Parker's decision?
Hint

Focus on which valuation model best measures value added when only one of two similar-risk projects can be accepted.

Question 8

Pine Co. must choose one of two mutually exclusive projects. Both projects require an immediate cash outflow and then generate only positive annual cash inflows for five years. At Pine's 10% required rate of return, Project A has an IRR of 18% and an NPV of $40,000, while Project B has an IRR of 15% and an NPV of $65,000. Assume Pine is not capital constrained and its goal is to maximize value. Which statement best reflects a limiting condition on using IRR in this decision?
Hint

Focus on what each model measures: one is a percentage return, and one is the dollar increase in value.

Question 9

Company Z evaluates two mutually exclusive capital projects, A and B. The firm's WACC is 10%. Management has determined that at most one project can be accepted this year (operational constraint), and the firm has $200,000 available now (enough to fund either project individually, but not both). The projects' values discounted at the WACC are: Project A, initial investment $100,000; present value of future cash inflows $118,000 (NPV = $18,000; profitability index = 1.18). Project B, initial investment $200,000; present value of future cash inflows $230,000 (NPV = $30,000; profitability index = 1.15). Given these facts, what is the most appropriate action?
Hint

First classify the constraint (mutually exclusive vs. budget-allocation). If only one project may be chosen and both fit the budget individually, rank by absolute NPV; use profitability index only when selecting multiple projects under a binding capital budget to maximize value per dollar.

Drill all 123 Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Should I use NPV or IRR for mutually exclusive projects?

Use NPV at the required return to maximize dollar value. Company R should choose B despite A's higher IRR.

Why can a higher IRR have a lower NPV?

IRR measures a percentage, not total dollars added. Here, A earns the higher percentage on a smaller investment, but B creates more value.

Can both mutually exclusive projects be acceptable?

Yes. Both projects have positive NPVs and are acceptable individually, but Company R can select only one.

Practice BAR like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models

All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.