BAR · Business Analysis · 9 practice questions
NPV vs IRR: Which Model Ranks Mutually Exclusive Projects?
For mutually exclusive projects, choose the higher positive NPV at the required return, even when the other project has a higher IRR. Below: compare dollar value and percentage return for one company's investment choice.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on which model is known to become unreliable when cash flows switch signs more than once.
Answer D. IRR has a known limitation when cash flows are nonconventional, meaning they change sign more than once. In this project, there is an initial outflow, later inflows, and then another outflow in Year 3, which can lead to multiple IRRs or an IRR that is not decision-useful. When the required rate of return is known, NPV is generally the more reliable measure in this situation.
Why not A: This is tempting because unusual cash flow timing can make candidates think the model itself breaks down. However, NPV can handle cash flows occurring in any pattern as long as the cash flows and discount rate are known. The later cleanup outflow is simply discounted like any other cash flow.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate overgeneralizes that valuation ratios only work with standard cash flow patterns. In fact, profitability index can still be computed from discounted cash flows even if a later outflow exists. The special limiting condition highlighted by this pattern is the multiple-IRR problem, not an inability to compute PI.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because the later outflow clearly matters economically. But a later cash outflow does not automatically prevent a payback calculation; payback still measures how long it takes to recover the initial investment. The real weakness is that payback may ignore important post-payback cash flows, not that it becomes impossible to compute.
Side by side
| Net present value (NPV) | Internal rate of return (IRR) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Dollar value added at the required return. | Discount rate that makes NPV zero. |
| Company R's decision | Choose one same-risk, one-year project; no capital rationing. | The same mutually exclusive choice. |
| Required return | Discount the year-end inflow at 10%. | Compare the calculated rate with 10%. |
| Project A cash flows | $1,000 outflow now; $1,200 inflow in Year 1. | $1,000 outflow now; $1,200 inflow in Year 1. |
| Project A result | $1,200 / 1.10 - $1,000 = $90.91. | $1,200 / $1,000 - 1 = 20%. |
| Project B cash flows | $3,000 outflow now; $3,500 inflow in Year 1. | $3,000 outflow now; $3,500 inflow in Year 1. |
| Project B result | $3,500 / 1.10 - $3,000 = $181.82. | $3,500 / $3,000 - 1 = 16.67%. |
| Ranking conflict | B creates $90.91 more value. | A earns the higher percentage on a smaller investment. |
| Final decision | Choose B. Both qualify individually, but B adds more value. | Do not let A's higher IRR override B's higher NPV. |
Key points
- Remember: a higher percentage return can create fewer dollars of value.
- Positive NPV makes a project acceptable individually, not necessarily the best choice.
- Conventional cash flows do not prevent IRR and NPV from ranking projects differently.
How the exam traps you
- Choose Project A because its 20% IRR is higher. Choose B because its NPV adds more dollar value.
- Accept both projects because both NPVs are positive. Mutually exclusive means only one can be selected.
Question 2
| Project | Initial Investment | NPV | IRR | Payback (years) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project A | $100,000 | $8,000 | 15% | 2.2 |
| Project B | $100,000 | $11,000 | 13% | 2.6 |
| Project C | $100,000 | $5,000 | 18% | 1.9 |
| Project D | $100,000 | $2,000 | 12% | 2.0 |
Hint
Focus on the decision rule that best aligns with maximizing value when only one acceptable project can be chosen.
Answer B. When projects are mutually exclusive and have the same risk and life, the goal of maximizing shareholder value calls for choosing the project with the largest net present value. Project B has the highest positive NPV ($11,000) and therefore adds the most value.
Why not A: Tempting because Project A's IRR (15%) exceeds Project B's (13%), but IRR is a percentage return, not the dollar value added. For mutually exclusive projects with identical lives and risk, choose the higher NPV, A's NPV ($8,000) is less than B's.
Why not C: IRR and payback can be useful secondary measures, but they don't measure absolute value added. Project C's IRR and payback are attractive, but its NPV ($5,000) is lower than Project B's, so it creates less shareholder value.
Why not D: An IRR above the hurdle means a project is acceptable on a stand-alone basis, but because the firm can fund only one project it should pick the acceptable project that adds the most value. Project D has the smallest positive NPV ($2,000).
Question 3
Hint
Separate acceptance from ranking: first decide whether each project clears the hurdle rate, then decide which measure is usually preferred when only one of two acceptable projects can be chosen.
Answer C. Both projects are acceptable on a stand-alone basis because each has a positive NPV and an IRR above the 10% required return. When projects are mutually exclusive and have similar risk and life, NPV is the preferred ranking criterion because it measures the dollar increase in firm value. Machine A, with an NPV of $24,000 versus Machine B's $18,000, is therefore the financially preferable choice if only one can be selected.
Why not A: This confuses accept/reject with ranking: a project is acceptable if it clears the required return. Both projects have positive NPVs and IRRs above 10%, so both are acceptable; the higher NPV only matters when choosing between mutually exclusive acceptable projects.
Why not B: This is tempting because Machine B has the higher IRR (18% vs 15%), but for mutually exclusive projects with similar lives and risk, NPV, not IRR, should determine which project adds more value. Machine A has the higher NPV, so it is preferred when only one can be chosen.
Why not D: This reflects two mistakes: treating the higher IRR as the sole ranking criterion and assuming only one project can be acceptable. Both machines exceed the 10% hurdle, so both are acceptable; IRR alone does not override a lower NPV when projects are mutually exclusive.
Question 4
Hint
Ask whether future managerial decisions can materially change the project's payoff profile; if so, a single expected cash‑flow DCF may miss value from that flexibility.
Answer B. A standard DCF/NPV discounts a single expected cash‑flow projection and therefore does not capture the value of managerial flexibility that creates contingent payoffs. Staged investments with abandon, delay, or expansion choices embed real options whose value arises from future decision rights and asymmetric upside; a static expected‑path DCF can understate that value. Real‑options valuation or scenario/option‑adjusted models are more appropriate in these cases.
Why not A: This is tempting because IRR appears to normalize returns, but IRR is not the superior ranking metric for value maximization. NPV (DCF) measures absolute value added and is preferred for comparing mutually exclusive projects of different scale; IRR can give misleading rankings when project sizes differ or cash flows are nonstandard.
Why not C: An uncertain discount rate complicates DCF implementation, but it is an implementation challenge rather than a fundamental theoretical limitation. Analysts can use project‑specific rates, scenario analysis, risk‑adjusted cash flows, or sensitivity analysis rather than abandoning DCF entirely.
Why not D: Heavy reliance on terminal value increases sensitivity and calls for careful scrutiny, scenario testing, or alternative terminal assumptions, but it does not make DCF intrinsically inapplicable. The correct remedy is to test and refine terminal assumptions (or use complementary methods), not to discard DCF for this reason alone.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on which metric (percentage vs. dollars) directly measures the increase in shareholder wealth when projects are mutually exclusive and differ in scale.
Answer B. When projects are mutually exclusive, choose the project with the higher NPV because NPV measures the absolute dollar increase in firm value. Although Red has a higher IRR (18% vs. 12%), Blue delivers a larger value addition ($200,000 vs. $50,000) at the firm's 10% cost of capital, so Blue should be accepted.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because IRR gives an intuitive percentage return. It is wrong here because IRR does not measure total value added; with mutually exclusive projects of different scale, the project with the larger NPV should be chosen.
Why not C: While both NPVs are positive, the projects are mutually exclusive so you cannot accept both. You should select the one that yields the greater increase in shareholder wealth, the higher NPV.
Why not D: IRR is a commonly used metric but can give misleading rankings for mutually exclusive projects with different scales or timing. NPV is the correct criterion for maximizing shareholder value in such cases.
Question 6
Hint
Compute each project's net present value first, then focus on which measure controls when only one project can be chosen.
Answer B. Net present value equals the present value of expected net cash inflows minus the initial investment. Project Atlas has an NPV of $24,000 ($264,000 - $240,000), while Project Beacon has an NPV of $13,000 ($113,000 - $100,000). When projects are mutually exclusive and qualitative factors are the same, the project with the higher positive NPV is preferred.
Why not A: This is tempting because Beacon does have the higher profitability index: 1.13 ($113,000 / $100,000) versus Atlas at 1.10 ($264,000 / $240,000). However, the question asks for the choice under the net present value model for mutually exclusive projects, and NPV favors the project that adds more total dollar value, which is Atlas.
Why not C: A candidate might incorrectly think mutual exclusivity creates an extra threshold beyond a positive NPV. It does not. Each project is already evaluated using the required return embedded in the present value amounts, and if both NPVs are positive, the higher NPV is selected.
Why not D: This distractor appeals to the common shortcut of preferring the lower-cost project. Under NPV, the deciding factor is which project produces the greater excess of discounted inflows over the initial outlay. Atlas produces the larger positive NPV.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on which valuation model best measures value added when only one of two similar-risk projects can be accepted.
Answer B. When choosing between mutually exclusive projects with similar risk and no capital rationing, NPV is the appropriate criterion because it measures the dollar increase in firm value using the company's required rate of return. NPV identifies which project adds the most value; therefore, even though Project A's IRR is higher, Project B should be chosen because its NPV ($55,000) is greater than Project A's ($42,000).
Why not A: IRR is a percentage return and can conflict with NPV; a higher IRR does not guarantee greater value when projects are mutually exclusive. Because the goal is to maximize dollar value added at the required return, IRR should not override NPV here.
Why not C: Discounted payback focuses on how quickly invested cash is recovered and can be a useful liquidity or risk screen, but it does not measure total value created over the project's life. It should not displace NPV for value-maximizing decisions.
Why not D: Average accounting return is based on book income and accounting measures rather than discounted cash flows and does not reflect the time value of money. It is not the preferred metric for capital budgeting when NPV is available.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on what each model measures: one is a percentage return, and one is the dollar increase in value.
Answer C. NPV measures the dollar increase in firm value and is the preferred decision rule when projects are mutually exclusive and the firm is not capital constrained. IRR reports a percentage return and can mislead when projects differ in scale or timing even with conventional cash flows. Because Project B has the higher NPV, it should be chosen.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often focus on the higher percentage return, but a higher IRR does not always mean greater value creation for mutually exclusive projects. NPV, not IRR, indicates which project adds more absolute value.
Why not B: While conventional cash flows avoid the multiple-IRR problem, that does not eliminate IRR's ranking issues for mutually exclusive projects with different scale or timing. NPV remains the correct tie-breaker when the measures conflict.
Why not D: This option arrives at the correct project but with incorrect reasoning. NPV does not directly encode payback-period concerns, and IRR can still be a useful metric. The key limitation here is IRR's potential to misrank mutually exclusive alternatives, not that NPV subsumes payback.
Question 9
Hint
First classify the constraint (mutually exclusive vs. budget-allocation). If only one project may be chosen and both fit the budget individually, rank by absolute NPV; use profitability index only when selecting multiple projects under a binding capital budget to maximize value per dollar.
Answer D. When management restricts the firm to choosing at most one of several individually fundable (nonreplicable) projects, the criterion that maximizes shareholder wealth is absolute NPV. Project B adds more value ($30,000) than Project A ($18,000), so B is preferred. Profitability index is used primarily to rank projects when allocating a fixed budget across multiple projects to maximize NPV per dollar, not to choose between mutually exclusive, individually fundable projects.
Why not A: This is tempting because profitability index measures value per dollar invested and is useful under binding capital rationing when selecting a combination of projects. It's incorrect here because management allows only one project and both projects are individually fundable, so the better rule is to choose the project with the larger absolute NPV.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to a common risk-avoidance intuition (lower cash outlay feels safer) but is incorrect absent additional risk information. The objective given is to maximize value under the stated constraint; lower upfront cost alone does not override Project B's higher NPV when both are individually fundable.
Why not C: Tempting as a general rule, but wrong because the stem imposes two constraints: management allows at most one project and available funds ($200,000) are insufficient to fund both projects together (combined initial cost $300,000). Those constraints make accepting both infeasible.
Common questions
Should I use NPV or IRR for mutually exclusive projects?
Use NPV at the required return to maximize dollar value. Company R should choose B despite A's higher IRR.
Why can a higher IRR have a lower NPV?
IRR measures a percentage, not total dollars added. Here, A earns the higher percentage on a smaller investment, but B creates more value.
Can both mutually exclusive projects be acceptable?
Yes. Both projects have positive NPVs and are acceptable individually, but Company R can select only one.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models
- How to Calculate NPV With an Annuity and Salvage Value
- Capital Rationing: Choose the Highest-NPV Project Bundle
- Unequal-Life Projects: EAA or Replacement Chain?
All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.