BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
Capital Rationing: Choose the Highest-NPV Project Bundle
Under a hard budget, choose the feasible combination of whole projects with the highest total NPV. Below: a step-by-step example showing why profitability index and IRR rankings can select the wrong projects.
Try one first
| Project | Initial Investment | NPV | PI | IRR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project A | $450,000 | $100,000 | 1.22 | 14% |
| Project B | $400,000 | $94,000 | 1.24 | 15% |
| Project C | $300,000 | $69,000 | 1.23 | 16% |
Hint
List all project combinations that fit within $750,000, compute each bundle's total NPV, and choose the highest.
Answer C. With indivisible projects under a fixed capital budget, evaluate feasible bundles and choose the one with the highest total NPV. A + C uses the full $750,000 (450,000 + 300,000) and yields total NPV $169,000 (100,000 + 69,000), which exceeds B + C's $163,000 (94,000 + 69,000) and any single project. Therefore A and C maximize shareholder value within the budget.
Why not A: This distractor tempts candidates who mechanically follow profitability index rankings because B and C have the two highest PIs and are mutually feasible. It fails because PI ranking can mislead for indivisible projects; B + C yields total NPV $163,000, which is less than A + C's $169,000, so B + C is not value-maximizing.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to those who over-weight IRR (Project C's IRR is highest). It is incorrect because IRR is a percentage measure and ignores project scale, accepting only C yields $69,000 NPV, far below feasible bundles such as A + C ($169,000).
Why not D: This choice tempts candidates who stop at the best single project (A's NPV = $100,000). It fails because A alone yields $100,000, whereas combining A with C is feasible and yields $169,000, so accepting A alone does not maximize total NPV under the budget.
Step by step
- Lock down the constraints
North Co. has a $750,000 capital budget for three independent, indivisible projects of similar risk. Accept only whole projects, and do not exceed the budget.
- Read the project data
A costs $450,000, with NPV $100,000, PI 1.22, and IRR 14%; B costs $400,000, with NPV $94,000, PI 1.24, and IRR 15%. C costs $300,000, with NPV $69,000, PI 1.23, and IRR 16%; all NPVs were computed at the appropriate required return.
- Remove over-budget combinations
A plus B costs $850,000, so reject that combination. All three cost $1,150,000, so reject that combination too.
- List every feasible choice
The feasible choices are none, A, B, C, A plus C, and B plus C. Their total NPVs are $0, $100,000, $94,000, $69,000, $169,000, and $163,000, respectively.
- Choose the highest total NPV
A plus C costs $750,000 and produces $169,000 of total NPV, exceeding B plus C by $6,000. Choose A and C because they maximize feasible NPV, not because they spend the full budget.
- Check the ranking shortcuts
PI ranking points to B and C, but that pair produces only $163,000 of NPV. C's highest IRR does not justify choosing it alone, and A's highest standalone NPV does not justify stopping at A.
Key points
- Remember: Compare bundles by total dollar value, not individual projects by percentage return.
- An NPV computed at the required return already accounts for that return.
- A positive NPV makes a project attractive, but does not guarantee selection under a budget.
- Using the full budget is not the objective; maximizing feasible total NPV is.
How the exam traps you
- Pick B and C because they have the two highest profitability indexes. Their $163,000 combined NPV is below A and C's $169,000.
- Pick C alone because its 16% IRR is highest. C alone adds $69,000, not the $169,000 available from A and C.
- Pick A and B because their combined NPV is highest among the pairs. Their $850,000 outlay exceeds the $750,000 cap.
Question 2
Hint
First identify relevant initial outlays and ignore sunk costs. Then compute each project's NPV and compare only combinations that fit within the Year 1 funding cap.
Answer D. Include only relevant initial outlays and ignore sunk costs (the $20,000 study is sunk). Initial outlays: Alpha = $500,000 + $100,000 = $600,000; Beta = $450,000 + $50,000 = $500,000; Gamma = $300,000 + $100,000 = $400,000. NPVs using the given present values are Alpha = ($690,000 + $70,000) - $600,000 = $160,000; Beta = $640,000 - $500,000 = $140,000; Gamma = ($430,000 + $45,000) - $400,000 = $75,000; Beta and Gamma together cost $900,000 and yield total NPV $215,000, which is higher than any other feasible choice.
Why not A: Tempting because Alpha has the largest individual NPV, but with an indivisible-project constraint and a binding budget you must compare feasible combinations; Alpha alone ($600,000, NPV $160,000) is inferior to the combined feasible pair Beta + Gamma (total NPV $215,000).
Why not B: Tempting if one stops after finding a good standalone project, but Beta alone ($500,000, NPV $140,000) leaves room within the $900,000 cap to accept Gamma as well, increasing total value to $215,000; the objective is maximize total NPV under the funding limit.
Why not C: Tempting if a candidate improperly nets expected working-capital recoveries against the initial funding need or ignores the feasibility study timing; Alpha + Gamma require $600,000 + $400,000 = $1,000,000 up front which exceeds the $900,000 Year 1 budget, so that combination is infeasible.
Question 3
Hint
First decide which metric should govern the portfolio choice under a fixed budget when projects cannot be split, then compare total value across feasible combinations.
Answer D. When projects are independent but capital is rationed and projects are indivisible, the company should choose the feasible portfolio that maximizes total NPV. Project A plus Project D costs exactly $1,000,000 and yields total NPV of $175,000. That exceeds other feasible combinations such as A + B + C ($170,000), B + D ($170,000), and A + C ($135,000).
Why not A: This is tempting because the combination fully uses the budget and all three projects have positive NPVs. However, exact budget usage and taking more projects do not control the decision if another feasible combination creates more value. A + B + C produces $170,000 of total NPV, which is still less than A + D at $175,000.
Why not B: This is a realistic mistake because profitability index is often used to rank projects under capital rationing. But with indivisible projects, a greedy PI ranking can fail to identify the best overall portfolio. A + C yields $135,000 of total NPV, while A + D yields $175,000 even though D's PI is slightly lower than C's.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to candidates who default to the largest single-project NPV when PI and IRR point in different directions. But the projects are independent, not mutually exclusive, so the company is allowed to combine projects within the budget. Choosing D alone gives only $135,000 of NPV, which is less than the feasible A + D combination.
Question 4
Hint
Do not rank projects only by IRR or profitability index. First determine the decision rule that best matches shareholder-value maximization under a fixed budget and indivisible projects, then compare only feasible portfolios.
Answer D. With a fixed (hard) budget and indivisible projects, the firm should choose the feasible combination that maximizes total NPV. A + D uses the entire $1,300,000 and yields total NPV = $72,000 + $153,000 = $225,000, which is greater than all other feasible combinations (for example, B + C = $202,000; A + B = $184,000; A + C = $162,000; D alone = $153,000). Therefore accepting Projects A and D maximizes firm value.
Why not A: Project D has the largest standalone NPV, so stopping there is understandable. The error is failing to evaluate feasible combinations; D alone gives $153,000, but combining D with A uses the full budget and yields a higher total NPV of $225,000.
Why not B: This choice is tempting because B and C both have high profitability indexes and together fit the budget. However, when projects are indivisible and the budget is fixed, the objective is total NPV; B + C yields total NPV of $112,000 + $90,000 = $202,000, which is less than A + D's $225,000.
Why not C: Picking A and C may appeal to candidates focusing on the highest individual PIs or IRRs. But A + C uses only $900,000 and produces total NPV of $72,000 + $90,000 = $162,000, which is well below the $225,000 achievable with A + D.
Question 5
Hint
List every feasible project combination that fits the $400,000 limit and compare their total NPVs, do not rely solely on IRR or a greedy profitability-index ranking.
Answer A. With a fixed $400,000 budget the firm should choose the combination that maximizes total NPV. Feasible combinations yield: A+C = $60,000 + $35,000 = $95,000; B+C = $50,000 + $35,000 = $85,000; any single project is lower. Therefore accept Projects A and C for the highest total NPV.
Why not B: Tempting since A has the largest single-project NPV, but selecting A alone leaves unused budget that could be invested in C to raise total NPV to $95,000. The firm should use remaining budget if doing so increases total NPV.
Why not C: Tempting because Project B has the highest IRR, and an IRR- or PI-driven greedy choice would pair B with C. It's wrong because B+C's combined NPV ($85,000) is still less than A+C's $95,000 given the $400,000 budget, maximizing total NPV is the objective.
Why not D: Appealing because B has the highest IRR and a positive NPV, yet choosing B alone yields a lower total NPV than feasible combinations that better utilize the budget (for example, A+C yields $95,000). Maximizing NPV, not IRR alone, is correct under a capital constraint.
Question 6
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Atlas | initial investment $700,000; NPV $126,000; IRR 17.2%; profitability index 1.18 |
| Beacon | initial investment $600,000; NPV $108,000; IRR 18.0%; profitability index 1.18 |
| Crest | initial investment $400,000; NPV $84,000; IRR 16.4%; profitability index 1.21 |
Hint
First identify every feasible project set under the $1,000,000 cap. Then apply the value-maximization criterion to the feasible set, not just to the individual project with the strongest single metric.
Answer B. Under hard capital rationing with indivisible, independent projects, the firm should choose the feasible combination that maximizes total NPV. Beacon plus Crest uses the full $1,000,000 budget and yields combined NPV of $108,000 + $84,000 = $192,000, which exceeds Atlas alone at $126,000, Beacon alone at $108,000, or Crest alone at $84,000. IRR and profitability index are informative, but they do not override total value creation when selecting among feasible project sets.
Why not A: This is tempting because NPV is generally the primary capital-budgeting criterion. However, with a binding budget you must compare feasible project combinations; Atlas has the highest single-project NPV, but the Beacon-and-Crest combination creates more total value within the same capital limit.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to candidates who default to percentage return when projects differ in size. IRR measures return efficiency rather than absolute dollar value; Beacon alone leaves part of the budget unused, whereas the feasible Beacon-and-Crest bundle yields higher total NPV.
Why not D: Profitability index ranks value per dollar invested and can guide allocation, but with indivisible projects it can mis-rank the best overall package. Crest has the highest PI, yet Crest alone generates much less total NPV than the feasible Beacon-and-Crest combination.
Common questions
How do you choose projects under capital rationing?
List the combinations that fit the budget, then compare their total NPVs. Here, A and C produce the highest feasible total NPV: $169,000.
Why can profitability index give the wrong capital rationing answer?
PI measures value relative to investment, not total dollar value. With whole projects, the higher-PI pair B and C creates less total NPV than A and C.
Should you choose the project with the highest IRR?
Not when the objective is the highest total NPV under a hard budget. C has the highest IRR, but accepting A with C creates more value than C alone.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models
- How to Calculate NPV With an Annuity and Salvage Value
- Unequal-Life Projects: EAA or Replacement Chain?
- NPV vs IRR: Which Model Ranks Mutually Exclusive Projects?
All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.