BAR · Business Analysis · 6 practice questions
How to Calculate NPV With an Annuity and Salvage Value
Discount equal annual inflows as an annuity and terminal cash flows as a separate lump sum, then subtract today's outlay. Below: a worked calculation including salvage value and working capital recovery.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the recurring annual inflows from the terminal salvage value, discount each appropriately, and then subtract the initial cost.
Answer C. NPV = present value of expected cash inflows minus the initial investment. The four annual inflows have PV = 60,000 × 3.312 = 198,720, and the salvage value's PV = 20,000 × 0.735 = 14,700, giving total PV of inflows = 213,420. NPV = 213,420 − 200,000 = 13,420.
Why not A: This arises if the candidate adds the undiscounted salvage ($20,000) to the PV of the annual inflows (198,720 + 20,000 = 218,720) and then subtracts cost (218,720 − 200,000 = 18,720). The salvage is received at Year 4 and must be discounted before adding.
Why not B: This results from discounting only the four annual inflows (60,000 × 3.312 = 198,720) and subtracting the cost (198,720 − 200,000 = (1,280)). It omits the discounted salvage proceeds, which must be included.
Why not D: This is the undiscounted net cash total: (4 × 60,000) + 20,000 − 200,000 = 60,000. NPV requires discounting future cash flows to present value, so using undiscounted totals overstates the investment's value.
Worked example
Cedar Co. considers a $150,000 machine requiring $10,000 of working capital today. It generates $50,000 at each year-end for four years. At Year 4's end, Cedar receives $20,000 salvage and fully recovers working capital. Ignore taxes. At the 10% required return, use 3.1699 for the four-year ordinary annuity and 0.6830 for the Year 4 single sum. Calculate NPV.
| 1 | Present value of annual inflows$50,000 × 3.1699 | $158,495 |
| 2 | Terminal cash flow$20,000 salvage + $10,000 working capital recovery | $30,000 |
| 3 | Present value of terminal cash flow$30,000 × 0.6830 | $20,490 |
| 4 | Total present value of inflows$158,495 + $20,490 | $178,985 |
| 5 | Initial outlay$150,000 machine + $10,000 working capital | $160,000 |
| 6 | Net present value$178,985 - $160,000 | $18,985 |
Accept the project: its positive $18,985 NPV indicates value creation at the 10% required return.
Check: Separate working capital from the machine: machine NPV is $158,495 + $13,660 - $150,000 = $22,155; subtract working capital's present-value cost of $10,000 - $6,830 = $3,170 to reach $18,985.
Key points
- Year-end annual inflows use an ordinary annuity factor.
- Salvage and working capital recovery occur once, so use the terminal year's single-sum factor.
- Include working capital in today's outlay even when it will be fully recovered.
- Use factors matching both the project's life and required return.
How the exam traps you
- Omitting salvage produces an NPV of $5,325. Include the $20,000 salvage proceeds at their $13,660 present value.
- Adding terminal cash without discounting produces an NPV of $28,495. Multiply the $30,000 terminal cash flow by 0.6830 before adding it.
- Reporting $178,985 confuses total present value with NPV. Subtract the $160,000 initial outlay to get $18,985.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on which cash flows are incremental to the decision now, and remember how financing costs are handled when using a discount rate.
Answer B. Only incremental, relevant cash flows belong in an NPV analysis. The consultant's study is a sunk cost already incurred and should be excluded. Financing cash flows such as interest are excluded when the discount rate already reflects the firm's cost of capital. The $40,000 working capital is a cash outflow at inception and its recovery at project end is a terminal cash inflow, so both are included.
Why not A: This option is tempting because the study, interest, and working capital are all real cash movements. However, the consultant's study is a sunk cost and irrelevant to the current decision, interest is a financing cash flow that should be excluded when using a discount rate reflecting cost of capital, and the working-capital recovery is a relevant terminal inflow that should be included.
Why not C: This choice correctly excludes the sunk cost but is wrong to include interest (which double-counts financing) and wrong to exclude the working-capital recovery. Recovery of working capital is a cash flow and must be included in the NPV terminal cash flows.
Why not D: While this option correctly excludes financing cash flows, it is incorrect to include the consultant's study because that cost is already incurred (a sunk cost) and is not affected by the current choice between machines.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on incremental project cash flows, not accounting expenses, sunk costs, or financing effects.
Answer B. Incremental working capital is a relevant project cash flow. The initial $25,000 increase is an outflow when the project begins, and the recovery (release) of that working capital at project termination is treated as a terminal cash inflow. Both the investment and the later recovery should be included in the DCF.
Why not A: Although the study relates to the project, it was already paid before the decision point and is therefore a sunk cost. Sunk costs are not incremental and should be excluded from DCF project cash flows.
Why not C: Depreciation is a noncash accounting expense and is not itself a cash outflow. With taxes ignored in this question, there is no depreciation tax shield to include. (If taxes were considered, the tax savings from depreciation would be included as a cash effect, not depreciation as a cash outflow.)
Why not D: Interest payments are financing costs; standard project-level DCF analysis excludes financing effects and focuses on operating/investment cash flows. The discount rate (cost of capital) reflects financing, so including interest separately would double-count financing effects.
Question 4
Hint
Compute each project's NPV at 10%, then compare total NPVs for all feasible project combinations under the $160,000 limit, maximize combined NPV rather than simply using the full budget or relying on profitability index ranking.
Answer C. Compute each project's NPV using the 4-year annuity PV factor at 10% (≈ 3.1699): A = 25,000 × 3.1699 − 60,000 ≈ 19,247; B = 40,000 × 3.1699 − 100,000 ≈ 26,795; C = 22,000 × 3.1699 − 50,000 ≈ 19,737. With no capital constraint accept all projects with positive NPVs. With a $160,000 budget evaluate feasible combinations: B + C has combined NPV ≈ 46,532, which is higher than A + B (≈ 46,041) and A + C (≈ 38,984), so accept B and C under the constraint.
Why not A: Tempting because A and C may have higher profitability indices, but ranking by PI for indivisible projects can lead to a suboptimal total NPV under a budget constraint. A + C leaves unused budget and yields a lower combined NPV than B + C.
Why not B: Tempting because Project B has the largest individual NPV, but this ignores that multiple independent projects can be accepted within the budget. B + C yields a higher combined NPV than B alone, so choosing B only leaves value on the table.
Why not D: Tempting because A + B fully uses the budget, but maximizing total NPV, not budget utilization, is the objective. B + C yields a slightly higher combined NPV than A + B, making B + C superior under the constraint.
Question 5
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Present value of an ordinary annuity of $1 for 5 periods at 8%: 3.993 | $1 |
| Present value of $1 for 5 periods at 8%: 0.681 | $1 |
Hint
Discount both the recurring annual inflows and the separate terminal salvage value, then compare the total present value to the initial cash outflow.
Answer D. PV of the annuity = $30,000 × 3.993 = $119,790. PV of the salvage = $10,000 × 0.681 = $6,810. Total PV of benefits = $126,600; NPV = $126,600 − $120,000 = $6,600.
Why not A: This is the total present value of expected benefits (119,790 + 6,810) but not the net amount; the initial investment must be subtracted to compute NPV.
Why not B: This results from discounting only the five annual inflows (119,790) and subtracting the cost (120,000), producing −$210. It ignores the discounted salvage value, which must be included.
Why not C: This comes from adding the undiscounted $10,000 salvage to the discounted annuity (129,790) and subtracting the cost, rather than discounting the salvage to $6,810 before summing.
Question 6
Hint
Under NPV, include all relevant incremental cash inflows and discount each based on when it is received.
Answer C. PV of the operating inflows = $35,000 × 2.487 = $87,045. PV of the salvage value = $8,000 × 0.751 = $6,008. Total present value of inflows = $93,053, so NPV = $93,053 − $90,000 = $3,053 (positive); therefore, accept the project.
Why not A: This uses nominal totals: 35,000×3 + 8,000 = 113,000, and 113,000 − 90,000 = 23,000. NPV requires discounting to present value; the discounted inflows total $93,053, not $113,000.
Why not B: A candidate might discount only the three annual operating inflows (35,000 × 2.487 = 87,045) and omit salvage, yielding 87,045 − 90,000 = (2,955). Salvage is an incremental cash inflow and must be discounted and included in the NPV.
Why not D: Salvage proceeds are a relevant future cash inflow from disposing of the asset and must be included in the NPV calculation at their present value; excluding salvage understates project value.
Common questions
How do you calculate NPV with an annuity and salvage value?
Multiply annual inflows by the annuity factor and salvage by the terminal single-sum factor. Add any discounted working capital recovery, then subtract the initial machine cost and working capital investment.
Is salvage value included in the annuity calculation?
No. The example's $20,000 salvage is received only at the end of Year 4, so multiply it by 0.6830, not 3.1699.
Does fully recovered working capital cancel out in NPV?
No. The $10,000 outflow occurs today, but its recovery has a present value of only $6,830. The timing reduces NPV by $3,170.
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models
- Capital Rationing: Choose the Highest-NPV Project Bundle
- Unequal-Life Projects: EAA or Replacement Chain?
- NPV vs IRR: Which Model Ranks Mutually Exclusive Projects?
All Investment alternatives using financial valuation decision models practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.