AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 7 practice questions
AU-C 725 Supplementary Information Opinion and Placement
An AU-C 725 opinion covers supplementary information in relation to the financial statements as a whole, not on a standalone basis. Follow Delta's schedule to see the appropriate conclusion and where it may be reported.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on how auditors report on supplementary information that accompanies audited financial statements: it is tied back to the financial statements as a whole.
Answer A. When supplementary information accompanies audited financial statements, the auditor may report on whether that information is fairly stated 'in relation to' the financial statements as a whole. That conclusion can be included in an other-matter paragraph in the auditor's report or issued in a separate report. The auditor does not give a standalone GAAP opinion on the schedule as if it were a basic financial statement.
Why not B: This is tempting because the auditor is giving an opinion-like conclusion, but supplementary information accompanying audited financial statements is reported on in relation to the financial statements as a whole. The auditor should not treat the schedule as a separate basic financial statement and issue an independent GAAP opinion on it.
Why not C: Although supplementary information is not part of the basic financial statements, the auditor was engaged to report on it and has sufficient evidence to form a conclusion. Ignoring the schedule would be inappropriate when the auditor is required to or has agreed to report on that information.
Why not D: Negative-assurance language (e.g., 'nothing came to our attention') is typical of review or limited-assurance engagements. Under an audit engagement, the auditor's reporting on supplementary information is framed as whether it is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements, not as a limited negative-assurance statement.
Step by step
- Identify Delta's schedule
Delta's audited financial statements have an unmodified opinion, and an accompanying schedule shows gross profit by product line for additional analysis. The schedule is supplementary information, not a basic financial statement or required supplementary information.
- Confirm the reporting basis
The auditor is engaged to report on Delta's schedule, which is derived from and directly relates to the records used to prepare the audited financial statements. Management accepts responsibility for the schedule.
- Complete the required procedures
Perform the required supplementary-information procedures, including reconciling Delta's schedule to the audited financial statements or underlying records. Obtain management's written representations about the schedule.
- Use the in-relation-to wording
After completing the required procedures and finding no material misstatements, conclude that Delta's schedule is “fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole.” The schedule remains outside the basic financial statements.
- Choose the report location
Include the conclusion in an other-matter paragraph of the auditor's report or issue a separate report. Either format links Delta's schedule to the financial statements as a whole, rather than expressing a standalone GAAP opinion.
Key points
- Remember: A separate report changes where the opinion appears, not what the opinion covers.
- An unmodified financial statement opinion does not automatically cover Delta's supplementary schedule.
- Look for “in relation to” in the answer, not merely familiar GAAP opinion wording.
How the exam traps you
- Giving Delta's schedule the same standalone GAAP opinion as the basic financial statements. Use the in-relation-to conclusion because the schedule remains supplementary information.
- Treating an other-matter paragraph as a description that cannot contain an opinion. Include the in-relation-to opinion there, or issue a separate report with the same conclusion.
Question 2
Hint
Remember that the date of a report reflects completion of the procedures for that specific report; focus on which procedures determine the separate supplementary-information report date.
Answer D. A separate report on supplementary information should be dated no earlier than the date the auditor completes the procedures required for that supplementary information (AU-C 725). The auditor completed those procedures on May 3, Year 2, so May 3 is the earliest appropriate date for the separate report. Dating the separate report earlier would misstate the extent of work performed; the question's assumption that no revision of the previously issued financial statements is required means the original March 12 opinion need not be changed.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because the supplementary information covers the same reporting period as the audited financial statements. It is incorrect because the date of a separate supplementary-information report must reflect completion of the procedures performed on that information, not the date of the original audit report.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to candidates who think disclosure can justify an earlier date. It is wrong because a disclosure that no procedures were performed after a prior date does not permit dating the separate report earlier than the date on which the required procedures for that report were actually completed.
Why not C: This is tempting because candidates may conflate a later report date with a need to extend all audit responsibilities to that date. It is incorrect here because the separate report date is driven by completion of the procedures on the supplementary information; extending subsequent-event procedures for the previously issued financial statements is not required solely because the auditor issues a separate supplementary-information report dated later.
Question 3
Hint
First classify the schedule correctly. Ask whether it is part of the basic financial statements, required supplementary information, or supplementary information that accompanies the audited statements.
Answer A. Because the schedule is supplementary information derived from the same underlying records and accompanying the audited statements, the auditor can perform procedures on it and issue a report stating whether it is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole. This is a narrower 'in relation to' conclusion rather than a separate opinion as if the schedule were a basic financial statement.
Why not B: Tempting because full opinions apply to basic financial statements, but supplementary information can be reported on using the narrower 'in relation to' wording without elevating it to basic financial statement status.
Why not C: Incorrect: supplementary information is not part of the basic statements, but the auditor can be engaged to perform procedures on it and report findings; it is not automatically outside the auditor's reporting responsibilities.
Why not D: This confuses supplementary information with required supplementary information (RSI). RSI has its own limited-procedures framework; a supplementary schedule like this is addressed by the 'in relation to' conclusion when procedures are performed.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on two things: the earliest report date the auditor can use and what users must have access to when supplementary information is reported on separately.
Answer B. A separate report on supplementary information may be issued after the report on the basic financial statements, but its date cannot be earlier than the date the auditor has obtained sufficient appropriate evidence on the supplementary information. Here, that date is March 14. In addition, the audited financial statements and the auditor's report on those statements must accompany the supplementary information or be otherwise readily available to the users.
Why not A: Tempting because the supplementary information relates to the already-audited financial statements, but the auditor cannot date the separate report earlier than when the auditor completed procedures and obtained representations on the supplementary information (March 14). The report cannot be backdated to March 5.
Why not C: Incorrect because the critical date for the auditor's report is when the auditor has completed the required procedures and obtained representations (March 14), not when management finalized the schedule. Also, when reporting separately the audited financial statements and auditor's report must accompany the schedule or be readily available.
Why not D: This reflects a common confusion. AU-C guidance permits the auditor to report on supplementary information either within the auditor's report on the financial statements or in a separate report issued later, provided the reporting conditions (procedures completed, date not earlier than completion, and audited financial statements available) are met.
Question 5
Hint
Think about all conditions for an in-relation-to opinion, not just whether the schedule can be traced to the audited records.
Answer D. For supplementary information reported in relation to the financial statements as a whole, the auditor may only issue an in-relation-to report when several conditions are met, including that the audited financial statements and the auditor's report accompany the supplementary information or are readily available to users. Because those documents will not accompany the schedule and will not be made readily available to the lender, the auditor should not issue the in-relation-to report.
Why not A: Those are necessary conditions but not sufficient. A further condition is that the audited financial statements and the auditor's report accompany the supplementary information or be readily available to users.
Why not B: A management representation is commonly obtained, but it does not substitute for the requirement that the audited financial statements and the auditor's report be available to users; availability is a separate condition for issuing an in-relation-to report.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes. GAAS permits an in-relation-to report on supplementary information when the required conditions are met. The issue here is not that the schedule is supplementary information but that the audited financial statements and auditor's report will not be available to the lender.
Question 6
Hint
First decide what kind of information the schedule is. Then match that classification to the kind of assurance the auditor may provide when specifically engaged to report on it.
Answer A. This schedule is supplementary information (not required supplementary information). Because it is derived from the same underlying records, reconciles to audited totals, and the auditor was engaged and performed the required procedures, the auditor may issue an "in relation to" opinion that the schedule is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole. That is the appropriate form of assurance under the supplementary-information reporting model.
Why not B: This is tempting because the schedule is outside the basic financial statements, but being outside the basic statements does not by itself preclude the auditor from reporting on it. When the auditor is specifically engaged to report on qualifying supplementary information and performs the required procedures, an in-relation-to opinion is permissible rather than an automatic disclaimer.
Why not C: This distractor confuses supplementary information with required supplementary information (RSI). RSI is subject to limited procedures; by contrast, supplementary information that the auditor is engaged to report on is addressed by the in-relation-to reporting model (e.g., AU-C 725), not the RSI limited-procedures approach.
Why not D: Although the schedule ties to audited amounts, the appropriate conclusion for this type of supplementary information is an in-relation-to opinion relative to the financial statements as a whole, not a separate, standalone opinion that treats the schedule as an independent set of financial statements prepared under the framework.
Question 7
Hint
Decide whether the schedule is part of the basic financial statements for reporting purposes and what AU-C 725 requires the auditor to say when management refuses to differentiate potentially misleading supplementary information.
Answer C. Under AU-C 725, when supplementary information accompanies audited financial statements and could be mistaken for audited information, the auditor should clarify its status. If management refuses to differentiate the supplementary information, the auditor should state in the auditor's report that the information was not subjected to the audit procedures applied to the basic financial statements and that no opinion is expressed on it, thereby preserving the unmodified opinion on the basic financial statements while preventing user misinterpretation.
Why not A: This is tempting because the auditor was not engaged to report on the supplementary information and it lies outside the basic financial statements. It is incorrect because the schedule appears in the same format as audited items and could mislead users; AU-C 725 requires the auditor to clarify the schedule's status in the report when management refuses to differentiate it.
Why not B: This choice appeals as a compromise, providing limited procedures and negative assurance, because it seems to protect users. It is wrong because the auditor was not engaged to report on the supplementary information and cannot unilaterally provide negative assurance; the appropriate response when management refuses differentiation is to state that no opinion is expressed on the schedule.
Why not D: This distractor is attractive because management's refusal resembles a scope issue. It fails because the matter concerns supplementary information outside the basic financial statements and does not prevent obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence for the basic financial statements; therefore, a qualified opinion on the basic financial statements is not required solely for this issue.
Common questions
What is the AU-C 725 opinion wording?
State that the supplementary information is “fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole.” This is not a standalone GAAP opinion on Delta's schedule.
Where does the auditor report on supplementary information?
Include Delta's in-relation-to opinion in an other-matter paragraph of the auditor's report or issue a separate report. The conclusion is the same in either location.
Does a separate supplementary information report give a standalone opinion?
No. A separate report on Delta's schedule still relates the schedule to the audited financial statements as a whole; it does not treat the schedule as a basic financial statement.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Supplementary Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.