AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
AU-C 725: Modify or Disclaim the SI Opinion
Agreement to audited totals does not prove that plant cost allocations are fairly stated. Follow Apex's reporting decision tree to distinguish a known allocation error from missing allocation evidence.
Try one first
Hint
Focus first on whether the schedule qualifies as supplementary information, then ask what extra work is needed when allocated amounts are included.
Answer B. The schedule qualifies as supplementary information because it is included with the audited financial statements, is derived from the same accounting records, and reconciles to audited amounts. When the auditor is engaged to report on supplementary information, he or she must perform additional procedures beyond merely reading for consistency, including evaluating the basis of preparation and, where allocations are used, whether the allocation method and presentation are reasonable so the schedule is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements as a whole.
Why not A: This is tempting because plant-level detail looks extensive, but additional disaggregation does not automatically create a separate set of financial statements. If the schedule is derived from the accounting records and directly relates to the audited statements, it can be supplementary information subject to the auditor's supplementary-information procedures.
Why not C: This distractor confuses supplementary information with other information that is only read for material inconsistencies. When the auditor is engaged to report on supplementary information, additional procedures (such as reconciling amounts and evaluating methods of preparation and allocation) are required.
Why not D: Allocations introduce judgment, but they do not automatically remove a schedule from the scope of supplementary information. The key issue is whether the schedule is derived from the accounting records and directly relates to the financial statements; if so, the auditor should evaluate the allocation method and the schedule's presentation.
Decide it in order
T1Assume Apex's plant repairs schedule qualifies for reporting under AU-C 725, the financial statements are unaffected, and all procedures that can be performed have been completed. Required work includes reconciliation, testing completeness and accuracy, evaluating allocation methods and disclosures, and obtaining written representations. The schedule's totals reconcile. If allocation evidence is unavailable, assume the possible effects are material and pervasive. Is there an uncorrected material allocation error?
T2Is the known material allocation error pervasive to the schedule?
YesExpress an adverse in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule and describe the misstatement. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.NoExpress a qualified in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule and describe the misstatement. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.T3Is sufficient appropriate evidence available to support the plant allocations?
YesExpress an unmodified in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.NoDisclaim an opinion on the supplementary schedule because the possible effects of missing allocation evidence are material and pervasive. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.
Key points
- Remember: Matching totals does not prove plant allocations are correct.
- Written representations do not replace evidence supporting plant allocations.
- For missing evidence, assess possible effects; for a known error, assess the actual misstatement.
How the exam traps you
- Treating a tie to audited totals as enough. Evaluate the plant allocation methods, disclosures, completeness, and accuracy.
- Using a disclaimer for a known material allocation error. Express a qualified or adverse SI opinion, depending on pervasiveness.
- Modifying the financial statement opinion for an SI-only error. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged when those statements are unaffected.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether the schedule qualifies for an AU-C 725 in-relation-to opinion at all; only then think about the type of opinion.
Answer C. AU-C 725 permits an in-relation-to opinion only for supplementary information that is derived from and directly related to the records used to prepare the financial statements. Here, roughly half the combined schedule consists of externally sourced market share estimates that are not derived from Lane's accounting records, so the combined schedule as presented does not qualify for an in-relation-to opinion. Because management requests one opinion on the undifferentiated schedule, the auditor should decline to issue an in-relation-to opinion on it.
Why not A: Tempting because the sales amounts were audited, but incorrect: the request is for an opinion on the combined schedule as presented. A material portion (market share data) is not derived from the underlying records, so the whole schedule does not meet AU-C 725 criteria.
Why not B: This seems plausible if you assume the schedule otherwise qualified as supplementary information. However, the proper classification issue is that the combined schedule does not meet the in-relation-to criteria at all, so a qualified in-relation-to opinion (which presumes the schedule is eligible supplementary information except for a limitation) is not appropriate.
Why not D: Although the sales amounts alone are supportable, the schedule is presented as an undifferentiated single schedule and the auditor was engaged to report on that schedule. The auditor should not carve out and opine on only part of a combined schedule unless management separates the unsupported data.
Question 3
Hint
First decide whether the entire schedule qualifies for an in-relation-to opinion, not just whether some of its numbers agree to the ledger.
Answer A. Under GAAS, an in-relation-to opinion may be issued only for supplementary information that is derived from and directly relates to the accounting and other records used to prepare the financial statements. Because the traffic counts are material to users' understanding and originate from a separate system (not the accounting records), the auditor should not express an in-relation-to opinion on the entire combined schedule unless the nonqualifying traffic-count information is removed or clearly separated.
Why not B: Tempting because the financial numbers tie to audited records, but incorrect: management requested an opinion on the entire schedule, and a material portion (traffic counts) is not derived from the accounting records. The auditor cannot cover the whole schedule with an in-relation-to opinion when material nonqualifying information is included.
Why not C: Attractive to those who conflate categories, but incorrect: required supplementary information (RSI) is a distinct category mandated by the financial reporting framework and is subject to limited procedures. This schedule is management-presented supplementary information, not RSI, so the RSI treatment is inappropriate.
Why not D: This answer reflects confusion with other-information responsibilities. It is incorrect because management specifically requested an in-relation-to opinion on the schedule; the appropriate GAAS response is to decline that opinion for the entire schedule unless the nonqualifying material is removed or separated, not merely to note that the schedule was read.
Question 4
Hint
Do not stop once the schedule ties in total to the audited financial statements. Ask what additional evidence is needed when management-created allocations affect the schedule.
Answer D. An in-relation-to opinion on supplementary information requires more than reconciling totals. The auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about how the supplementary information was prepared (including allocation methods) and whether it is complete and accurate in relation to the audited financial statements. Because the auditor did not test the overhead allocation method or the completeness of the included overhead, additional procedures are required before issuing an in-relation-to opinion.
Why not A: This choice is tempting because reconciliation and tracing are important procedures. However, when supplementary information is produced using management's methods (such as an allocation formula), the auditor must also obtain evidence that the method is appropriate and that the resulting information is complete and accurate; tying totals alone is not sufficient.
Why not B: While other-information responsibilities often require limited procedures, management specifically requested the auditor report on the accompanying supplementary information. If the auditor accepts, read-for-consistency procedures alone are insufficient for an in-relation-to opinion; the auditor must perform the additional procedures necessary to evaluate the preparation method and accuracy.
Why not C: This distractor preys on the subjectivity of allocations, but allocations do not automatically disqualify a schedule as supplementary information. The key issue is whether the auditor has performed sufficient procedures to support reporting on that supplementary information.
Question 5
Hint
Decide whether the misstatement affects the financial statements themselves or only the supplementary schedule, and recall the auditor's separate reporting responsibility under AU-C 725.
Answer D. AU-C 725 requires that when the auditor is engaged to report on supplementary information and that information is materially misstated and management refuses to revise it, the auditor should modify the auditor's report on the supplementary information. Because the basic financial statements themselves are fairly presented (they reflect the refinancing), the auditor's opinion on the financial statements remains unmodified while the report on the supplementary schedule is modified.
Why not A: This is tempting because users view supplementary information together with the statements, but the financial-statement opinion is based on whether the financial statements themselves are fairly presented. Here the misstatement is confined to the supplementary schedule, so the FS opinion need not be modified; AU-C 725 calls for modifying the supplementary-information report instead.
Why not B: Resignation or withdrawal is tempting as a strong response to management refusal, but it is not required here because the basic financial statements are fairly presented. The appropriate action is to modify the report on the supplementary information; withdrawal from the FS audit would only be necessary under more severe circumstances that prevent issuance of an opinion on the financial statements.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that supplementary information is separate from the basic statements, but the auditor was specifically engaged (AU-C 725) to report on that schedule. The auditor cannot simply ignore or omit reporting on it when it is materially misstated; an appropriate modification of the supplementary-information report is required.
Question 6
Hint
Ask first whether the schedule qualifies for an in-relation-to opinion at all, not whether management's allocation method seems reasonable.
Answer B. An in-relation-to opinion on supplementary information is appropriate only when the information is derived from and relates directly to the accounting and other records used to prepare the audited financial statements. Because the schedule relies on significant allocations created solely for the schedule and not used in preparing the financial statements, it does not qualify for an in-relation-to opinion.
Why not A: Tying in total to audited amounts is a necessary check but not sufficient. The schedule must be derived from the records used to prepare the financial statements; here, major allocations were created only for the schedule.
Why not C: Disclosure of the allocation method does not cure the fundamental problem. Explanatory wording cannot convert information that was not derived from the underlying accounting records into qualifying supplementary information.
Why not D: This overstates requirements. Non-GAAP-required schedules may accompany audited statements, but the issue here is whether the schedule qualifies as supplementary information that is derived from the records used to prepare the financial statements.
Common questions
Is reconciling supplementary information to audited totals enough under AU-C 725?
No. For Apex's schedule, the auditor also tests completeness and accuracy, evaluates allocation methods and disclosures, and obtains written representations.
When should an auditor modify the supplementary information opinion?
When Apex's schedule contains an uncorrected material allocation error, qualify the SI opinion if the error is not pervasive. Express an adverse SI opinion if it is pervasive.
When should an auditor disclaim an in-relation-to opinion?
Disclaim when missing evidence about Apex's plant allocations could have material and pervasive effects on the schedule. The opinion on unaffected financial statements stays unchanged.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Supplementary Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.