PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions

AU-C 725: Modify or Disclaim the SI Opinion

Agreement to audited totals does not prove that plant cost allocations are fairly stated. Follow Apex's reporting decision tree to distinguish a known allocation error from missing allocation evidence.

The ruleA reconciled schedule still requires support for its allocations. An uncorrected material misstatement requires a modified supplementary information opinion; insufficient evidence with material and pervasive possible effects requires a disclaimer, without changing an unaffected financial statement opinion.

Try one first

Apex Co.'s 20X5 basic financial statements were audited, and the auditor issued an unmodified opinion. In the same auditor-submitted document, management includes a schedule showing repairs and maintenance expense by plant. The schedule was prepared from the accounting records used to prepare the financial statements, reconciles to the audited total repairs and maintenance expense, and allocates central maintenance department costs to individual plants using labor hours. The auditor is engaged to report on this schedule as supplementary information. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus first on whether the schedule qualifies as supplementary information, then ask what extra work is needed when allocated amounts are included.

Decide it in order

  1. T1Assume Apex's plant repairs schedule qualifies for reporting under AU-C 725, the financial statements are unaffected, and all procedures that can be performed have been completed. Required work includes reconciliation, testing completeness and accuracy, evaluating allocation methods and disclosures, and obtaining written representations. The schedule's totals reconcile. If allocation evidence is unavailable, assume the possible effects are material and pervasive. Is there an uncorrected material allocation error?

  2. T2Is the known material allocation error pervasive to the schedule?

    YesExpress an adverse in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule and describe the misstatement. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.
    NoExpress a qualified in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule and describe the misstatement. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.
  3. T3Is sufficient appropriate evidence available to support the plant allocations?

    YesExpress an unmodified in-relation-to opinion on the supplementary schedule. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.
    NoDisclaim an opinion on the supplementary schedule because the possible effects of missing allocation evidence are material and pervasive. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged.

Key points

  • Remember: Matching totals does not prove plant allocations are correct.
  • Written representations do not replace evidence supporting plant allocations.
  • For missing evidence, assess possible effects; for a known error, assess the actual misstatement.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating a tie to audited totals as enough. Evaluate the plant allocation methods, disclosures, completeness, and accuracy.
  • Using a disclaimer for a known material allocation error. Express a qualified or adverse SI opinion, depending on pervasiveness.
  • Modifying the financial statement opinion for an SI-only error. Leave the financial statement opinion unchanged when those statements are unaffected.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Lane Co. engaged its auditor to report under AU-C 725 on a schedule included after the audited financial statements. The schedule is presented as one combined schedule titled "Regional Sales and Market Position." It shows audited net sales by region and estimated market share percentages by region. The market share percentages are based on external industry studies and are not derived from Lane's underlying accounting or other records used to prepare the financial statements. The market share data occupies about half of the schedule, and management does not separate or label that data from the sales amounts. The auditor issued an unmodified opinion on the financial statements. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether the schedule qualifies for an AU-C 725 in-relation-to opinion at all; only then think about the type of opinion.

Question 3

An auditor issued an unmodified opinion on a nonissuer's Year 2 GAAP financial statements. In the same document, management presents a "Supplementary Schedule of Branch Performance" showing each branch's revenues, expenses, and operating margin, along with branch traffic counts. The financial amounts were derived from the accounting records used to prepare the financial statements. The traffic counts were generated from a separate marketing system and are not derived from the accounting and other records used to prepare the financial statements. The traffic counts are material to users' understanding of the schedule, and management asks the auditor to state that the entire schedule is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements as a whole. Under GAAS, what is the auditor's most appropriate response?
Hint

First decide whether the entire schedule qualifies for an in-relation-to opinion, not just whether some of its numbers agree to the ledger.

Question 4

Brant Co.'s auditor completed the audit of Brant's 20X5 financial statements and plans to issue an unmodified opinion. Management asks the auditor to also report on an accompanying schedule of selling, general, and administrative expense by business unit. Direct expenses on the schedule were taken from the general ledger. Shared corporate overhead was allocated among business units using management's formula developed for the schedule. The auditor agreed the schedule's total SG&A to the audited financial statements and traced the direct expenses to the accounting records, but did not test the overhead allocation formula or whether all relevant overhead was included in the schedule. Assuming the schedule otherwise qualifies as supplementary information and no other reporting issues exist, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Do not stop once the schedule ties in total to the audited financial statements. Ask what additional evidence is needed when management-created allocations affect the schedule.

Question 5

North Co.'s Year 2 basic financial statements were audited and the auditor plans to issue an unmodified opinion. The auditor was also engaged under AU-C 725 to report on an accompanying schedule of debt maturities presented as supplementary information in relation to the financial statements. During the AU-C 725 procedures, the auditor determines that the schedule is materially misstated because a year-end refinancing was omitted. The basic financial statements properly reflect the refinancing, and management refuses to revise only the supplementary schedule. Which reporting response is most appropriate?
Hint

Decide whether the misstatement affects the financial statements themselves or only the supplementary schedule, and recall the auditor's separate reporting responsibility under AU-C 725.

Question 6

After completing the audit of Beta Co.'s 20X5 financial statements, for which the auditor expects to issue an unmodified opinion, management asks the auditor to report on an accompanying schedule titled "Contribution Margin by Product Line." The schedule agrees in total to audited revenue and expense amounts, but it allocates headquarters costs to product lines using percentages developed solely for this schedule. Those allocations were not used in preparing the audited financial statements. No separate audit engagement on the schedule has been requested. Which conclusion is most appropriate regarding the auditor's report on this schedule?
Hint

Ask first whether the schedule qualifies for an in-relation-to opinion at all, not whether management's allocation method seems reasonable.

Drill all 61 Supplementary Information questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Is reconciling supplementary information to audited totals enough under AU-C 725?

No. For Apex's schedule, the auditor also tests completeness and accuracy, evaluates allocation methods and disclosures, and obtains written representations.

When should an auditor modify the supplementary information opinion?

When Apex's schedule contains an uncorrected material allocation error, qualify the SI opinion if the error is not pervasive. Express an adverse SI opinion if it is pervasive.

When should an auditor disclaim an in-relation-to opinion?

Disclaim when missing evidence about Apex's plant allocations could have material and pervasive effects on the schedule. The opinion on unaffected financial statements stays unchanged.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Supplementary Information

All Supplementary Information practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.