AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
AU-C 725: Which Schedules Qualify for an In-Relation-To Opinion?
A schedule qualifies for an in-relation-to opinion only when every material part covered comes from and directly relates to the financial statement preparation records. Sort versions of one schedule by what the opinion can cover.
Try one first
Hint
For each schedule, decide whether its amounts are derived from and directly related to the accounting and other records used to prepare the financial statements.
Answer D. An in-relation-to opinion is appropriate for supplementary information presented outside the basic financial statements only when that information is derived from and directly related to the accounting and other records used to prepare the statements. Schedule A meets that criterion; Schedule B consists of operational KPIs not derived from those records and therefore would not qualify.
Why not A: Tempting because both schedules appear in the same report, but mere inclusion with the audited statements is insufficient. The in-relation-to opinion requires the information be derived from and directly related to the accounting records.
Why not B: Tempting if one confuses RSI and SI, but incorrect: the in-relation-to opinion is the reporting form for qualifying supplementary information (SI) presented outside the basic financial statements; RSI is handled under a different framework and does not make SI ineligible.
Why not C: Tempting because Schedule B is outside the financial statements, yet operational metrics that are not derived from the accounting records do not qualify as the type of supplementary information covered by an in-relation-to opinion.
Sort it
All material content comes from and directly relates to the financial statement preparation records and reconciles.
A separate eligible portion can be covered only if the ineligible portion is explicitly excluded from the opinion.
The requested whole-schedule opinion includes material content that fails the source test.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Omega Co. has an unmodified nonissuer audit opinion. Its accompanying product-line schedule shows historical revenue, expenses, and operating income derived from and directly related to the financial statement preparation records. All amounts reconcile. The schedule is outside the basic statements and is not required supplementary information. Assume other AU-C 725 conditions are met and required procedures cover the historical columns. Management requests coverage of the entire schedule. What qualifies? | Eligible as presentedThe entire schedule meets the source test, reconciles, and is supported by the required procedures. |
| Same facts, except material overhead is allocated using a formula created only for this schedule and absent from the financial statement preparation records. What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedThe material overhead allocations fail the source test, even though the schedule begins with recorded expenses. |
| Same facts as the projected-cost-savings version, except management requests an opinion covering only the historical columns and explicitly excluding the projection. What qualifies? | Eligible portion onlyThe presentation is unchanged. Only the requested coverage changes: the eligible historical columns are covered, and the separate projection is excluded. |
| Same facts, except operating income uses clearly disclosed loan-agreement definitions, with every adjustment traced to the same preparation records and reconciled. What qualifies? | Eligible as presentedDifferent definitions do not disqualify the schedule. Its amounts still come from and directly relate to the same records. |
| Same facts, except material customer-retention percentages from a separate operational system not used to prepare the financial statements are inseparably interwoven with the financial columns. What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedThe material operational measures fail the source test and cannot be separated into an excluded section. |
| Same facts as the version with interwoven customer-retention percentages from a separate operational system, except those percentages are now presented in a clearly separate section. What portion, if any, can qualify for an in-relation-to opinion? | Eligible portion onlyThe financial columns can qualify if the auditor performs the required procedures and explicitly excludes the separate operational section from the opinion. |
| Same facts, except material product-line amounts come from an unreconciled marketing report not used to prepare the financial statements, although grand totals still agree. What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedMatching grand totals does not establish that the material product-line amounts came from the financial statement preparation records. |
| Same facts, except the overhead-allocation version now uses the same allocation method and records used to prepare the financial statements. What qualifies? | Eligible as presentedThe changed source flips the answer. Allocations can qualify when they come from the same preparation records and reconcile. |
| Same facts as the overhead-allocation version, except management labels the schedule 'unaudited.' What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedThe label changes nothing. The material allocations still come from outside the records used to prepare the financial statements. |
| Same facts as the base schedule, except management adds a clearly separated column containing material projected cost savings and requests an opinion covering the entire schedule. What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedSeparation alone is insufficient. The requested whole-schedule opinion would still cover the projection, which fails the source test. |
| Same facts as the separated-operational-section version, except management removes the operational section. What qualifies? | Eligible as presentedRemoving the ineligible section leaves only historical financial information that meets the source test. |
| Same facts as the loan-definition version, except a material adjustment now uses projected savings absent from the financial statement preparation records. What qualifies? | Not eligible as presentedA lender-defined measure is not automatically eligible. The projected adjustment fails the source test. |
Key points
- Remember: A matching total does not rescue a material column built from a different source.
- Test only additional analysis outside the basic financial statements that is not required supplementary information.
- Disclosed lender definitions can qualify when the amounts still trace to the same records.
- Separate an ineligible section and explicitly exclude it before reporting on the eligible historical columns.
How the exam traps you
- Most columns come from the audited records, so the whole schedule qualifies. Check every material part included in the requested opinion.
- Calling the allocation schedule 'unaudited' makes it eligible. The label does not change where the material allocations came from.
- Any lender-defined measure is automatically ineligible. Check its source and reconciliation, not whether its definition matches GAAP.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the decisions: first determine whether the schedule as presented meets AU-C 725's definition of supplementary information (derived from and directly related to the accounting records), then determine whether the basis for the qualified opinion affects those items.
Answer C. AU-C 725 requires that supplementary information reported "in relation to" the financial statements be derived from and directly related to the accounting records used to prepare those statements. The Year 2 "synergy-adjusted" column is a management projection not derived from the audited records and therefore is not qualifying supplementary information; it must be removed or clearly segregated before issuing an in-relation-to opinion. Because the auditor performed the AU-C 725 procedures on the historical columns, the auditor may report on those columns; a qualified opinion on the basic financial statements does not automatically preclude an in-relation-to opinion on qualifying supplementary information that is unaffected by the qualification.
Why not A: Tempting because the financial statement qualification does not affect the historical columns, but incorrect because the schedule includes a management projection column that is not derived from the accounting records and therefore cannot be covered by an in-relation-to opinion without being removed or segregated.
Why not B: Tempting for candidates who overgeneralize that modifications must carry over, but incorrect because a qualified opinion on the financial statements does not automatically require a modified in-relation-to opinion where the basis for the qualification does not affect the supplementary information; the immediate issue here is the nonhistorical projection column.
Why not D: Tempting for those assuming any modification blocks all SI reporting, but incorrect because a qualified opinion does not categorically prohibit reporting on qualifying supplementary information; if the SI is unaffected and the AU-C 725 procedures are performed, the auditor may report on it after excluding or segregating nonqualifying items.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which item can be traced to the same underlying records used to prepare the audited financial statements, and which item depends on separate nonfinancial measures or management formulas.
Answer D. Supplementary information eligible for an in-relation-to opinion should be derived from and directly related to the underlying accounting and other records used to prepare the audited financial statements. The combining balance sheet meets that requirement because it reconciles to the audited consolidated amounts and was prepared from the same underlying records. The operating efficiency scorecard does not meet the requirement because it relies on nonfinancial measures and management weighting formulas that are not part of the accounting records used to prepare the financial statements.
Why not A: This is tempting because presentation outside the basic statements and clear labeling are relevant, but those facts alone do not make the information eligible for an in-relation-to opinion. The information must also be derived from and directly related to the accounting and other records used to prepare the financial statements, which the scorecard is not.
Why not B: This plays on confusion between supplementary information and required supplementary information (RSI). RSI is a distinct category with different procedures; the combining balance sheet is typical supplementary information that may support an in-relation-to opinion, while the scorecard is not RSI simply because it accompanies the statements.
Why not C: This distractor confuses the location of information with audit reporting eligibility. Supplementary information is often presented outside the basic financial statements, and an auditor may report on it in relation to the financial statements when the criteria (such as being derived from the accounting records) are met, as with the combining balance sheet here.
Question 4
Hint
Ask whether the auditor can derive the schedule's component amounts from, or directly relate them to, the accounting records used to prepare the financial statements.
Answer D. AU-C 725 requires procedures to support a conclusion that supplementary information is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements as a whole. That requires the auditor to be able to derive or directly relate the supplementary information to the accounting and other records used to prepare the audited financial statements. Agreement of totals alone is insufficient when component amounts originate from sources that cannot be reconciled to the accounting records.
Why not A: Tempting because matching totals suggest consistency with the financial statements. However, AU-C 725 demands more than matching totals: the auditor must be able to derive or directly link the supplementary information to the underlying records. When component amounts come from an unreconciled third-party report, totals alone do not provide sufficient appropriate evidence for an in-relation opinion.
Why not B: Tempting because written representations are part of audit evidence and may support management assertions. However, representations cannot substitute for the auditor's substantive procedures or the required direct linkage to accounting records. A management representation about the marketing report does not allow the auditor to form an in-relation conclusion if the amounts cannot be reconciled.
Why not C: Tempting because auditors often 'read' other information rather than perform detailed testing. However, this schedule is presented as supplementary information and the auditor was engaged to report on it, so AU-C 725 requires procedures to form an in-relation conclusion rather than merely reading for inconsistencies. Treating it as other information would not satisfy the auditor's responsibilities when component amounts cannot be reconciled.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the schedule can still qualify for an in-relation-to opinion even though it uses definitions that differ from GAAP.
Answer A. Supplementary information that accompanies audited financial statements can be reported on in relation to the financial statements as a whole even if it uses definitions different from GAAP, provided it is derived from the same accounting records, clearly describes the non-GAAP measures, and the auditor performs the procedures necessary to evaluate reconciliation and appropriateness. Under these facts, an in-relation-to opinion is appropriate.
Why not B: Tempting because lender-defined measures are non-GAAP, but the mere use of non-GAAP definitions does not preclude the schedule from qualifying as supplementary information if it is clearly described, derived from the same records, and the auditor has performed the necessary procedures.
Why not C: This confuses a separate special-purpose reporting framework with supplementary information that accompanies audited GAAP financial statements; the schedule here is supplementary and tied to the audited records, so it need not be treated as a separate special-purpose statement.
Why not D: Other information rules apply where the auditor is not engaged to report on the item. Here management asked the auditor to report and the auditor performed procedures specifically to support an in-relation-to opinion, so the auditor's role goes beyond merely reading for material inconsistency.
Question 6
Hint
Ask which schedule truly qualifies as supplementary information for an in-relation-to opinion, not merely which schedule accompanies the statements or ties to a total.
Answer D. Supplementary information eligible for an in-relation-to opinion must accompany the audited financial statements and be derived from and directly related to the accounting and other records used to prepare those statements. Schedule A meets that requirement because it is prepared from the same general ledger and allocation records. Schedule B does not qualify because it contains adjustments and estimates not recorded in, or used to prepare, the audited financial statements.
Why not A: Tempting because accompaniment and labeling are necessary, but not sufficient. Being labeled supplementary information does not qualify an item for an in-relation-to opinion if it is not derived from and directly related to the accounting and other records used to prepare the financial statements (which Schedule B is not).
Why not B: Mathematical reconciliation alone does not make information eligible for an in-relation-to opinion. The supplementary information must be derived from and directly related to the underlying accounting and other records used to prepare the audited financial statements; Schedule B contains adjustments not from those records.
Why not C: Incorrect: the auditor may express an in-relation-to opinion on qualifying supplementary information that accompanies the financial statements even though it is not part of the basic financial statements. Schedule A can be covered without being included in the basic statements.
Common questions
Does reconciling a schedule to audited totals satisfy AU-C 725?
No. Omega's marketing-report version still fails because material product-line amounts cannot be traced to the financial statement preparation records.
Can an in-relation-to opinion cover only certain columns?
Yes. Clearly separate the eligible historical columns and explicitly exclude the projection or operational section from the opinion.
Do lender-defined measures qualify under AU-C 725?
Different definitions do not automatically prevent in-relation-to reporting. Omega's lender-defined version can qualify when every adjustment comes from the same preparation records, reconciles, and is clearly described.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Supplementary Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.