PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 10 practice questions

Qualified Financial Statements: What Happens to the SI Opinion?

A qualified financial statement opinion carries into the SI opinion when the same GAAP departure materially affects the SI. Below, compare the same plant-asset schedule as its coverage or agreement with records changes.

The ruleWhen financial statements are qualified, qualify the SI in-relation-to opinion if the same GAAP departure materially affects the SI. Otherwise, an unmodified SI opinion may be appropriate after required procedures, with reference to the qualified financial statement opinion.

Try one first

An auditor audited West Co.'s Year 2 GAAP financial statements and issued a qualified opinion because West used an accounting method for a class of equipment that departs from GAAP. The matter is material to the financial statements but not pervasive. West also presents, for additional analysis, an accompanying schedule of plant assets by location as supplementary information. The schedule is clearly differentiated from the basic financial statements, is derived from the underlying accounting records, and the same GAAP departure materially affects amounts in the schedule. Assume the auditor performed the additional procedures required to report on supplementary information and obtained sufficient appropriate evidence for all other amounts. Which reporting conclusion is most appropriate for the supplementary schedule?
Hint

Start with the opinion on the basic financial statements, then ask whether that same matter materially affects the supplementary schedule and whether any type of modification is carried over.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

West Co. has North and South plants. Its financial statements are qualified for a non-GAAP equipment method used only at North. The departure materially, but not pervasively, affects the statements and its supplementary plant-asset schedule covering both plants and all asset classes. The schedule derives from the financial statement records. The auditor performed the required AU-C 725 procedures to report on the schedule.

Answer: Express a qualified in-relation-to opinion, except for the effects of the same GAAP departure.

The equipment departure materially affects both the financial statements and the supplementary schedule. The SI opinion therefore reflects the same qualification.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The schedule covers only the South plant.

Answer: Express an unmodified in-relation-to opinion and refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.

The non-GAAP method applies only at North. Removing North from the schedule removes the qualifying matter's effect on the SI.

Change 2The schedule covers only land at both plants.

Answer: Express an unmodified in-relation-to opinion and refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.

The departure concerns equipment, not land. Including North does not require qualification when the schedule excludes the affected asset class.

Change 3The auditor confirms that every scheduled amount agrees exactly with the underlying accounting records.

Answer: Still express a qualified in-relation-to opinion for the same GAAP departure.

Exact agreement does not change the answer. The records contain the departure, which still materially affects the schedule.

Key points

  • Remember: Follow the qualifying matter into the schedule, not the financial statement opinion label.
  • Required AU-C 725 procedures support the opinion; they do not correct a GAAP departure.
  • An unmodified SI opinion still refers to the qualified financial statement opinion.

How the exam traps you

  • Automatically copying the financial statement qualification. Check whether the same matter materially affects the schedule.
  • Treating agreement with accounting records as proof the schedule is fairly stated. Records can contain the same material GAAP departure.
  • Refusing any SI opinion because the financial statements are qualified. A qualification does not by itself prevent an in-relation-to opinion.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

West Co. has North and South plants. Its financial statements are qualified for a non-GAAP equipment method used only at North. The departure materially, but not pervasively, affects the statements and its supplementary plant-asset schedule covering both plants and all asset classes. The schedule derives from financial statement records. Required AU-C 725 reporting procedures are complete. Which SI opinion is appropriate?

Question 2

Same facts, except the schedule covers only the South plant. Which SI opinion is appropriate?

Question 3

Same facts, except the schedule covers only land at both plants. Which SI opinion is appropriate?

Question 4

Same facts, except the auditor confirms that every scheduled amount agrees exactly with the underlying accounting records. Which SI opinion is appropriate?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Lane, CPA, audited Apex Co.'s 20X5 financial statements and will issue a qualified opinion because management omitted a material lease liability and related right-of-use asset. Apex engaged Lane to report on an accompanying supplementary schedule showing quarterly advertising expense. Lane performed the procedures required by AU-C 725 for supplementary information and concluded the lease omission does not affect that schedule. What is the most appropriate action regarding the supplementary schedule?
Hint

First decide whether a qualified opinion on the financial statements automatically prevents an in‑relation‑to report; then consider whether the lease omission affects the advertising schedule.

Question 3

Harbor, CPA, audited North Coast Co.'s 20X5 financial statements. Harbor expects to issue a qualified opinion because inventory at one location could not be observed and alternative procedures did not fully resolve the ending inventory quantities. North Coast also presents, alongside the audited financial statements, a schedule of net sales by geographic region. Assume this schedule is supplementary information, not required supplementary information. The schedule is derived from the same accounting records used to prepare the financial statements, directly relates to the audited revenue amounts, and Harbor has performed the procedures ordinarily required to report on supplementary information. The inventory scope limitation does not affect the regional net sales schedule. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Do not stop at the word qualified. Ask whether the modification always blocks reporting on supplementary information and whether the modified matter affects this particular schedule.

Question 4

Rex & Co. audited Alder Corp.'s 20X5 financial statements in accordance with GAAS and issued a qualified opinion because a material GAAP departure affected the reported carrying amount of certain long-term obligations. After the audit, Alder asks Rex to issue a separate report on a supplementary schedule of long-term debt. Assume (1) the schedule is derived from and directly relates to the underlying accounting records used to prepare the audited financial statements, (2) Rex can perform the AU-C 725 procedures, and (3) the same GAAP departure that caused the qualified opinion on the financial statements materially affects the schedule. Which reporting conclusion is best supported under AU-C 725?
Hint

Consider AU-C 725's treatment of how the type of financial-statement opinion affects an in-relation-to report, which opinion types effectively bar an in-relation-to report versus which allow reporting after the AU-C 725 procedures with any necessary, corresponding modification.

Question 5

In connection with its audit of Hall Co.'s Year 2 financial statements, Hall included in the same document a schedule showing detailed long-term debt maturities by year. The schedule is presented as supplementary information, is not required supplementary information, and is not part of the basic financial statements. Hall engaged the auditor to report on the schedule under the auditing guidance for supplementary information. The auditor issued a qualified opinion on the financial statements because inventory was materially overstated; that matter does not affect the debt schedule. After performing the required procedures on the schedule, the auditor concluded the schedule is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate the issues: first identify the information as supplementary information rather than RSI or other information, then ask whether the reason for the qualified financial statement opinion carries over to that schedule.

Question 6

An auditor audited Falcon Co.'s Year 2 financial statements in accordance with GAAS and issued a qualified opinion solely because management omitted a required note disclosure about a probable litigation loss. Falcon also presents, outside the basic financial statements, a schedule of selling expenses by region. Assume the schedule is clearly identified as supplementary information, is derived from and relates directly to the accounting records used to prepare the financial statements, and is not affected by the omitted litigation disclosure. The auditor performed the procedures required to report on the supplementary information. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on two questions: what type of information this schedule is, and whether the matter causing the qualified opinion changes that schedule.

Drill all 61 Supplementary Information questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a qualified financial statement opinion automatically qualify the supplementary information opinion?

No. In West's case, the SI opinion is qualified only when the equipment departure materially affects the schedule. A schedule excluding the affected equipment can receive an unmodified in-relation-to opinion after the required procedures.

Can supplementary information agree with the records and still need a qualified opinion?

Yes. West's records can contain the same material GAAP departure as its financial statements. Agreement with those records does not remove the departure from the schedule.

Must an unmodified SI report refer to the qualified financial statement opinion?

Yes. When West's schedule excludes the affected equipment, the SI opinion can be unmodified, but the SI report should still refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Supplementary Information

All Supplementary Information practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.