AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 10 practice questions
Qualified Financial Statements: What Happens to the SI Opinion?
A qualified financial statement opinion carries into the SI opinion when the same GAAP departure materially affects the SI. Below, compare the same plant-asset schedule as its coverage or agreement with records changes.
Try one first
Hint
Start with the opinion on the basic financial statements, then ask whether that same matter materially affects the supplementary schedule and whether any type of modification is carried over.
Answer B. Because the auditor's qualified opinion on the basic financial statements results from a GAAP departure that also materially affects the supplementary schedule, the auditor should modify the in‑relation‑to opinion on the schedule to reflect that same qualification. The matter is material but not pervasive, so a qualified in‑relation‑to opinion (stating the schedule is fairly stated except for the effects of the GAAP departure) is appropriate.
Why not A: Although the auditor performed the required procedures on the supplementary information, the same GAAP departure that caused the qualified opinion on the financial statements materially affects the schedule; issuing an unmodified in‑relation‑to opinion would fail to disclose that known material departure.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes the rule: adverse opinions or disclaimers on the basic financial statements may prevent an in‑relation‑to opinion on supplementary information, but a qualified opinion does not automatically preclude reporting. Instead, the auditor should modify the in‑relation‑to opinion if the same matter affects the supplementary information.
Why not D: An adverse opinion is appropriate when a GAAP departure is both material and pervasive. The stem states the departure is material but not pervasive, which calls for a qualified, rather than an adverse, conclusion.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
West Co. has North and South plants. Its financial statements are qualified for a non-GAAP equipment method used only at North. The departure materially, but not pervasively, affects the statements and its supplementary plant-asset schedule covering both plants and all asset classes. The schedule derives from the financial statement records. The auditor performed the required AU-C 725 procedures to report on the schedule.
Answer: Express a qualified in-relation-to opinion, except for the effects of the same GAAP departure.
The equipment departure materially affects both the financial statements and the supplementary schedule. The SI opinion therefore reflects the same qualification.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The schedule covers only the South plant.
Answer: Express an unmodified in-relation-to opinion and refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.
The non-GAAP method applies only at North. Removing North from the schedule removes the qualifying matter's effect on the SI.
Change 2The schedule covers only land at both plants.
Answer: Express an unmodified in-relation-to opinion and refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.
The departure concerns equipment, not land. Including North does not require qualification when the schedule excludes the affected asset class.
Change 3The auditor confirms that every scheduled amount agrees exactly with the underlying accounting records.
Answer: Still express a qualified in-relation-to opinion for the same GAAP departure.
Exact agreement does not change the answer. The records contain the departure, which still materially affects the schedule.
Key points
- Remember: Follow the qualifying matter into the schedule, not the financial statement opinion label.
- Required AU-C 725 procedures support the opinion; they do not correct a GAAP departure.
- An unmodified SI opinion still refers to the qualified financial statement opinion.
How the exam traps you
- Automatically copying the financial statement qualification. Check whether the same matter materially affects the schedule.
- Treating agreement with accounting records as proof the schedule is fairly stated. Records can contain the same material GAAP departure.
- Refusing any SI opinion because the financial statements are qualified. A qualification does not by itself prevent an in-relation-to opinion.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. The same GAAP departure materially affects the schedule.
Why not B: Incorrect. Referring to the financial statement opinion does not replace the necessary SI qualification.
Why not C: Incorrect. A qualified financial statement opinion does not by itself prevent SI reporting.
Why not D: Incorrect. The schedule is materially affected, and omitting the financial statement opinion reference is inappropriate.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. South's schedule is unaffected, but the report still refers to the financial statement qualification.
Why not A: Incorrect. The departure applies only at North, which this schedule excludes.
Why not C: Incorrect. The financial statement qualification does not prevent an opinion on this unaffected schedule.
Why not D: Incorrect. The opinion can be unmodified, but the report should reference the qualified financial statement opinion.
Question 3
Answer B. Correct. The land schedule is unaffected, and the report refers to the qualified financial statement opinion.
Why not A: Incorrect. Including North does not matter when the schedule excludes the affected equipment.
Why not C: Incorrect. A financial statement qualification does not automatically prevent SI reporting.
Why not D: Incorrect. An unaffected schedule does not eliminate the reference to the qualified financial statement opinion.
Question 4
Answer A. Correct. Agreement with records does not remove the material GAAP departure affecting the schedule.
Why not B: Incorrect. Record agreement does not justify an unmodified opinion on materially affected SI.
Why not C: Incorrect. The qualification permits a correspondingly qualified in-relation-to opinion.
Why not D: Incorrect. The material departure still requires qualification, regardless of exact agreement with the records.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether a qualified opinion on the financial statements automatically prevents an in‑relation‑to report; then consider whether the lease omission affects the advertising schedule.
Answer C. Under AU-C 725, a modification of the auditor's opinion on the financial statements does not automatically prevent issuing an in‑relation‑to report on supplementary information. Because Lane was engaged to report on the schedule, performed the required supplementary‑information procedures, and concluded the lease omission does not affect the schedule, Lane should issue an in‑relation‑to report stating the schedule is fairly presented in relation to the financial statements as a whole and refer to the qualified opinion on the financial statements.
Why not A: Tempting because some candidates assume any modification to the financial‑statement opinion bars related reporting. It fails because AU-C 725 permits an in‑relation‑to report when the auditor was engaged, performed required procedures, and concluded the supplementary information is not materially affected by the matter causing the financial‑statement modification.
Why not B: Tempting because one might think the modification automatically extends to related schedules. It fails because a qualification on the supplementary schedule is required only if the auditor's procedures show the schedule itself is materially misstated or affected by the underlying issue; here Lane concluded the schedule was not affected.
Why not D: Tempting because auditors sometimes only 'read' other information for inconsistencies. It fails here because the client specifically engaged Lane to report on the schedule, so the supplementary‑information reporting framework (AU-C 725) applies rather than the limited 'other information' read-and-consider approach.
Question 3
Hint
Do not stop at the word qualified. Ask whether the modification always blocks reporting on supplementary information and whether the modified matter affects this particular schedule.
Answer D. An auditor may express an in‑relation‑to opinion on supplementary information even if the auditor's opinion on the financial statements is qualified, provided the modification does not affect the supplementary information. Here, the schedule is derived from the same records, directly relates to audited revenue, and was subjected to the required procedures, so an in‑relation‑to opinion is appropriate. The supplementary-information report should, however, refer to the auditor's qualified opinion on the financial statements so users have the full context.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates sometimes overgeneralize that a modified opinion blocks other reporting. It is wrong because only adverse opinions and disclaimers automatically preclude certain reporting; a qualified opinion does not automatically prevent an in‑relation‑to opinion where the cause of the qualification does not affect the supplementary information.
Why not B: This choice confuses supplementary-information procedures with a separate stand‑alone audit. When the supplementary information is derived from the same records and the auditor has performed the required procedures, a separate audit is not required and a disclaimer is unnecessary.
Why not C: This distractor correctly recognizes that the unaffected schedule may receive an in‑relation‑to opinion, but it is incorrect because the auditor's report on the supplementary information should still refer to the auditor's report on the financial statements (including the qualified opinion) to provide proper context for users.
Question 4
Hint
Consider AU-C 725's treatment of how the type of financial-statement opinion affects an in-relation-to report, which opinion types effectively bar an in-relation-to report versus which allow reporting after the AU-C 725 procedures with any necessary, corresponding modification.
Answer B. AU-C 725 permits issuance of an in-relation-to report on supplementary information when the required AU-C 725 procedures are completed. A qualified opinion on the financial statements does not automatically preclude reporting on supplementary information; if the AU-C 725 procedures are performed and the schedule is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements except for the same GAAP departure, the auditor may issue a correspondingly qualified in-relation-to opinion. AU-C 725 indicates that only an adverse opinion or a disclaimer on the financial statements precludes issuance of an in-relation-to opinion.
Why not A: This is tempting because an unmodified in-relation-to opinion is possible when AU-C 725 procedures show no material effect, but the stem explicitly states the same GAAP departure materially affects the schedule; therefore an unmodified opinion would ignore that material departure and be inappropriate.
Why not C: This overgeneralizes AU-C 725. A modified (qualified) opinion on the financial statements does not automatically bar an in-relation-to report; only an adverse opinion or a disclaimer precludes issuance of an in-relation-to opinion when the AU-C 725 procedures can be performed.
Why not D: This confuses a GAAP departure with an inability to perform required procedures. A disclaimer is appropriate when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence or cannot perform required procedures, not merely because the supplementary schedule is affected by a GAAP departure; if AU-C 725 procedures can be completed, a qualified in-relation-to opinion is appropriate.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the issues: first identify the information as supplementary information rather than RSI or other information, then ask whether the reason for the qualified financial statement opinion carries over to that schedule.
Answer C. When the auditor is engaged to report on supplementary information and the required procedures have been performed, the auditor may report that the information is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the financial statements as a whole. A qualified opinion on the basic financial statements does not automatically preclude issuing such an in-relation-to report if the cause of the qualification does not affect the supplementary information. Here, the inventory overstatement does not affect the debt schedule, so an in-relation-to opinion is supportable.
Why not A: Although procedures were performed on the schedule, the auditor's report on supplementary information is expressed 'in relation to the financial statements as a whole' rather than as a standalone GAAP opinion on the schedule itself.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes: a disclaimer on supplementary information is required only when the qualification or limitation affects the supplementary information or prevents the auditor from performing required procedures. A financial-statement qualification unrelated to the schedule does not automatically force a disclaimer.
Why not D: Incorrect: supplementary information that the auditor was engaged to report on remains within the auditor's reporting responsibilities even when the financial-statement opinion is modified, provided the issue leading to the modification does not affect the supplementary information.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on two questions: what type of information this schedule is, and whether the matter causing the qualified opinion changes that schedule.
Answer A. A qualified opinion on the financial statements does not automatically preclude an in-relation-to opinion on supplementary information. If the matter causing the qualification does not affect the supplementary information and the auditor has performed the required procedures on that information, the auditor may report that the supplementary information is fairly stated in relation to the financial statements. The supplementary-information report should appropriately refer to the qualified opinion on the financial statements.
Why not B: This choice overgeneralizes. A disclaimer or adverse on the financial statements can prevent an in-relation-to opinion in some cases, but a mere qualified opinion does not automatically bar an in-relation-to opinion when the qualification does not affect the supplementary information.
Why not C: This distractor assumes reporting on supplementary information must always mirror the financial-statement opinion. Instead, the key is whether the matter giving rise to the financial-statement qualification affects the supplementary information; if it does not, the supplementary-information opinion need not be qualified for that reason.
Why not D: This option incorrectly requires that the omitted disclosure be repeated in the supplementary schedule. The test is whether the omission affects the supplementary information; if the schedule is unaffected, adding the litigation disclosure to the schedule is not required to permit an in-relation-to opinion.
Common questions
Does a qualified financial statement opinion automatically qualify the supplementary information opinion?
No. In West's case, the SI opinion is qualified only when the equipment departure materially affects the schedule. A schedule excluding the affected equipment can receive an unmodified in-relation-to opinion after the required procedures.
Can supplementary information agree with the records and still need a qualified opinion?
Yes. West's records can contain the same material GAAP departure as its financial statements. Agreement with those records does not remove the departure from the schedule.
Must an unmodified SI report refer to the qualified financial statement opinion?
Yes. When West's schedule excludes the affected equipment, the SI opinion can be unmodified, but the SI report should still refer to the qualified financial statement opinion.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Supplementary Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.