AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 10 practice questions
Assessed Risk, Detection Risk, and Audit Procedures
Higher assessed risk of material misstatement requires lower planned detection risk and more persuasive audit evidence. Below: one scenario with changed facts showing when to expand procedures, reduce their extent, or keep evidence requirements unchanged.
Try one first
Hint
Think about whether the auditor's procedural choices should respond to assessed risk at the assertion level or primarily to a monetary threshold.
Answer B. Standards require that the nature, timing, and extent of further procedures be responsive to the assessed risks of material misstatement at the assertion level. That assessed risk combines inherent and control risk and drives decisions about substantive procedures, tests of controls, timing, and sample sizes. Materiality and individual risk components inform planning but do not by themselves determine the specific audit responses.
Why not A: Materiality tempts because it sets thresholds for what is important and influences tolerable misstatement, sample sizes, and the evaluation of errors. However, materiality addresses magnitude, not the likelihood of misstatement at particular assertions; procedures must respond to assessed assertion-level risk rather than only to a monetary threshold.
Why not C: Control effectiveness is tempting because strong controls may allow the auditor to rely more on controls and reduce substantive testing. But control effectiveness is only one component (affecting control risk); the auditor must consider both inherent and control risk together, the combined assessed risk at the assertion level governs the audit response.
Why not D: Inherent risk is tempting because it reflects susceptibility to misstatement absent controls and helps shape the audit approach. However, relying on inherent risk alone ignores control risk and the combined assessed risk that should direct the nature, timing, and extent of procedures.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
BrightWidgets has material revenue. Assessed risk of material misstatement for revenue occurrence is moderate. The auditor plans moderate detection risk, interim tests of details, and year-end follow-up. Acceptable audit risk is unchanged. The reporting deadline allows enough time for the planned work.
Answer: Retain moderate planned detection risk and the planned mix of interim testing and year-end follow-up.
The procedures match the moderate assessed risk. Neither a higher-risk response nor a reduction in testing is supported by the facts.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Assessed risk for revenue occurrence increases from moderate to high.
Answer: Lower planned detection risk. Obtain more persuasive evidence through expanded tests of details, larger samples, and more year-end work.
Higher assessed risk requires a lower chance that audit procedures fail to detect a material misstatement.
Change 2Assessed risk for revenue occurrence decreases from moderate to low.
Answer: Higher planned detection risk may be acceptable. Less extensive substantive testing and more interim work may be appropriate.
Lower assessed risk permits higher planned detection risk, but does not eliminate substantive procedures or evidence for the remaining period.
Change 3The reporting deadline moves earlier; assessed risk remains moderate.
Answer: Keep the evidence requirements for moderate risk. Adjust staffing or scheduling rather than cut required testing.
This tempting fact does not change assessed risk. A deadline cannot justify accepting insufficient audit evidence.
Key points
- Remember: assessed risk and planned detection risk move in opposite directions when acceptable audit risk stays fixed.
- Nature means the procedures used; timing means when; extent means how much testing.
- Lower assessed risk can support interim testing, but evidence must still cover the remaining period.
- A shorter reporting deadline changes staffing needs, not the evidence needed to address assessed risk.
How the exam traps you
- Increasing planned detection risk when assessed risk rises. Lower planned detection risk and obtain more persuasive evidence.
- Lowering materiality while keeping procedures unchanged despite higher assessed risk. Design procedures that directly respond to the increased assertion-level risk.
- Cutting testing because the reporting deadline moves earlier. Adjust resources or scheduling without weakening required audit evidence.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. The planned response matches the moderate assessed risk.
Why not B: No increased assessed risk supports this expansion.
Why not C: No decreased assessed risk supports this reduction.
Why not D: Materiality does not replace an assertion-level risk response.
Question 2
Answer C. Correct. More persuasive evidence reduces planned detection risk.
Why not A: The original plan does not respond to the increased risk.
Why not B: Higher assessed risk requires lower, not higher, planned detection risk.
Why not D: Changing materiality alone does not adequately address the increased assertion-level risk.
Question 3
Answer B. Correct. Lower assessed risk can support higher detection risk and less extensive work.
Why not A: Lower risk does not eliminate substantive procedures for material revenue.
Why not C: This reverses the relationship between assessed risk and planned detection risk.
Why not D: Planned detection risk can change when assessed risk changes.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. Scheduling pressure does not reduce assessed risk or required evidence.
Why not A: A deadline does not justify higher detection risk.
Why not B: Interim results alone do not provide evidence for the remaining period.
Why not C: Lower materiality does not justify cutting required procedures.
Question 2
Hint
Under AU-C 240, consider how a significant fraud risk should change the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures, can newly implemented controls or internal audit work substitute for substantive evidence at period end?
Answer C. When a significant fraud risk is identified (particularly for revenue), AU-C 240 requires changing the nature, timing, and extent of procedures. The auditor should emphasize substantive procedures at or near period end, increase sample sizes and cutoff testing, include unpredictable procedures, and use more experienced personnel. Newly implemented and untested controls, and unverified internal audit work, are not a sufficient basis to reduce substantive evidence for a significant fraud risk.
Why not A: Tempting because effective controls can reduce substantive testing, but the controls here were implemented only two months before year‑end and are untested. With a significant fraud risk, the auditor should obtain substantive evidence at or near period end rather than primarily relying on newly implemented controls.
Why not B: Analytical procedures and journal‑entry testing can help detect anomalies, but they do not substitute for detailed transaction- and cutoff-testing at or near period end when there is a significant fraud risk in revenue recognition.
Why not D: Delegating to internal audit is inappropriate here: internal audit has been reorganized and has not tested the new system, so its competence and work are unproven. Even competent internal audit work does not eliminate the need for substantive procedures when fraud risk is significant.
Question 3
Hint
Apply AR = IR × CR × DR and ask which component is driven by how the auditor designs and executes tests (nature, timing, extent).
Answer A. Poor planning affects how audit procedures are designed; omitting preliminary analytics, not identifying related parties/significant accounts, and using an inappropriately high preliminary materiality can result in procedures that are not properly targeted in nature, timing, or extent. That increases detection risk, the risk the auditor's procedures will fail to detect material misstatements. Inherent and control risks reflect the client's characteristics and controls and do not change simply because the auditor planned poorly, and an opinion is modified only if sufficient appropriate evidence cannot be obtained or material misstatements remain uncorrected.
Why not B: Tempting because poor planning makes it more likely the auditor will miss issues, so it feels like the client's risk rose. It is wrong because inherent risk describes the client's susceptibility to misstatement (e.g., complexity, estimates) and is not caused by the auditor's planning choices; the auditor's failure to detect issues is captured by detection risk.
Why not C: This distractor is plausible, if controls are not identified or tested during planning an auditor might conservatively increase substantive work. It fails because control risk is a function of the client's control effectiveness, not the quality of the auditor's planning; the immediate and most direct consequence of not designing appropriate procedures is higher detection risk, though control risk might be reassessed later if evidence about weak controls emerges.
Why not D: Tempting because planning failures are serious and could jeopardize an audit. It is wrong because an audit opinion is based on the sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence and the presence of material misstatements; planning deficiencies alone do not automatically require a modified opinion if they are corrected or do not lead to insufficient evidence or uncorrected material misstatements.
Question 4
Hint
Consider what auditing standards require when a material account has significant valuation risk and controls are unreliable, focus on the type and persuasiveness of evidence, staffing, and supervision.
Answer A. When controls are weak and cannot be relied on, the auditor must plan substantive procedures that are responsive to the assessed risk. For complex valuation estimates this means obtaining more persuasive evidence (for example, larger or targeted tests of cost components), using specialists if necessary, and assigning experienced staff with increased supervision to the high-risk area.
Why not B: Tempting because effective controls can legitimately reduce substantive testing, but the stem indicates the auditor concluded controls cannot be relied on. Devoting planning effort primarily to tests of controls is unlikely to be effective here; when controls are weak, emphasis should be on substantive procedures tailored to the valuation risk.
Why not C: Tempting because analytical procedures are efficient and can identify anomalies, but for a significant valuation risk involving complex cost allocations, overall analytics are generally insufficient. Detailed, targeted substantive testing is required to obtain persuasive evidence about valuation estimates.
Why not D: Tempting because severe control weaknesses may justify conditioning or declining an engagement, but that is a more extreme step. At the planning stage the auditor should first plan and perform responsive substantive procedures and attempt alternative procedures; conditioning or declining is appropriate only if those efforts cannot provide sufficient appropriate evidence or management refuses needed cooperation.
Question 5
Hint
Consider how increases in assessed risk should change the nature, timing, and extent of evidence-gathering, and whether specialist expertise or year-end procedures are needed.
Answer C. When assessed risk increases because of a new IT platform and complex revenue judgments, the auditor must obtain more persuasive evidence by changing the nature, timing, and extent of procedures. This typically means more tests of details, procedures nearer to year end, and involvement of specialists or experienced staff. Controls implemented with the new system should not be relied on until their operating effectiveness has been tested.
Why not A: Tempting because early reliance on controls and interim testing can be efficient. It fails here because the controls relate to a newly implemented third-party platform and are unproven; relying on them and concentrating testing at interim increases the risk of missing year-end recognition, cut-off, and complex estimation issues.
Why not B: Tempting because lowering materiality and increasing sample sizes can increase detection, but this is not the primary or sufficient response. The auditor should change the nature, timing, and extent of procedures to obtain more persuasive evidence given the new systems and complex estimates, not simply keep the same procedures at a smaller threshold.
Why not D: Tempting because analytics are efficient for identifying anomalies. It fails here because analytical procedures are generally less persuasive for complex transactions, variable consideration, and new IT processing; analytics alone are unlikely to reduce detection risk to an acceptable level without targeted tests of details.
Question 6
Hint
Which assessment reflects both how likely a specific assertion is to be misstated and whether entity controls are likely to prevent or detect that misstatement?
Answer C. The auditor's assessed risk of material misstatement at the assertion level (inherent risk combined with control risk) should primarily govern the nature, timing, and extent of procedures because it reflects how susceptible a specific assertion is to material misstatement and whether controls are likely to prevent or detect such misstatements. The facts given (new ERP, complex estimates and manual adjustments for inventory, customer concentration in receivables, and management turnover) raise assertion-level risk for those accounts, so the auditor must plan more persuasive and targeted substantive procedures and consider timing and additional controls testing as appropriate.
Why not A: Why tempting: Materiality is central to planning because it sets tolerable misstatement levels and influences sample sizes and evaluation of findings. Why wrong: Materiality affects the magnitude of misstatements considered significant but does not by itself determine the types, timing, or extent of procedures needed to respond to assertion-level risks.
Why not B: Why tempting: Control effectiveness is a major planning consideration, strong controls can reduce some substantive testing, so candidates may focus on this. Why wrong: Control effectiveness (control risk) is only one component of the assessed risk of material misstatement; the auditor must consider inherent risk and other assertion-level factors together before deciding the appropriate response.
Why not D: Why tempting: Practical constraints clearly influence when and how procedures are scheduled and which staff perform them, so they feel relevant to planning. Why wrong: Practical constraints may affect logistics (timing, staffing) but cannot replace professional judgment about the nature and extent of procedures required to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence for assessed risks.
Common questions
How does assessed risk affect planned detection risk?
With acceptable audit risk unchanged, higher assessed risk requires lower planned detection risk. The auditor obtains more persuasive evidence to reduce the chance that procedures miss a material misstatement.
Does lower assessed risk allow interim audit testing?
Lower assessed risk may support more interim testing and less extensive substantive procedures. The auditor must still obtain evidence covering the remaining period.
Can an earlier reporting deadline justify fewer audit procedures?
No. The deadline does not reduce assessed risk or the evidence required. The auditor may need more staff or a different schedule.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning an Engagement, worked step by step.
Audit Planning: Materiality & Scoping | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning an Engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.