AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 7 practice questions
When to Revise the Overall Audit Strategy and Audit Plan
Revise the overall audit strategy and audit plan when new information changes audit risks or the planned response. Below: follow a new inventory ERP system from the planning trigger to documented revisions.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether audit planning is fixed once it starts, or whether new risk-relevant information can trigger revisions during the engagement.
Answer B. Audit planning is an iterative process and should be updated when significant new information affecting risk arises. A new sales channel that accounts for roughly 30% of revenue and uses a new IT system likely changes the assessed risks of material misstatement and requires revising the overall strategy and planned procedures (including considerations of controls and substantive testing). The auditor should update the plan promptly rather than waiting for evidence of an actual misstatement.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may think changes are only needed after an error is found. However, planning responds to changes in the auditor's understanding of the entity and risk, not only to confirmed misstatements; significant new operations should prompt earlier revision of planned procedures.
Why not C: This reflects the incorrect belief that planning is a one-time activity. In reality, auditors continually revise the plan as new risk-relevant information becomes available and should not delay adjustments simply because year-end has not yet occurred.
Why not D: This distractor confuses management's judgments with the auditor's responsibility. The auditor independently determines whether new information affects the risk assessment and planned audit procedures; revisions are not contingent on management labeling an issue as a control deficiency.
Step by step
- Identify the planning trigger
Lark's auditor planned interim inventory work using last year's approach, which found no significant issues. Before fieldwork, the auditor learns that Lark converted all inventory records to a new ERP system; inventory is a significant balance.
- Reassess the affected risks
Consider how the conversion affects inventory records, relevant controls, and available audit evidence. Prior-year results do not establish that the new system's controls are effective.
- Revise the overall strategy
Reconsider staffing, supervision, timing, and the need for IT expertise. Decide whether the original interim approach remains appropriate in light of the system change.
- Update the detailed audit plan
Plan procedures to understand the new system and address risks in converted inventory records. Revise the nature, timing, and extent of relevant control testing and substantive inventory procedures.
- Document significant revisions
Document significant changes to the strategy and plan and the reasons for them. Link the ERP conversion to the revised resources, timing, and inventory procedures.
- Keep planning during fieldwork
Make the initial revisions now, rather than waiting for testing to reveal an error. If fieldwork provides new information affecting the inventory audit response, update the strategy and plan again as necessary.
Key points
- Remember: changed risk triggers a planning update; an actual misstatement is not required.
- A clean prior-year audit does not establish that a new ERP system's controls are effective.
- Strategy addresses resources and direction; the detailed plan specifies the procedures that carry out that strategy.
How the exam traps you
- Wait until testing finds an inventory misstatement. Respond when the ERP change becomes known, before performing affected procedures.
- Reuse last year's approach because inventory testing found no problems. Reassess current-year risks because the system supporting inventory records has changed.
- Change only inventory test counts and leave the strategy untouched. Reconsider IT expertise, supervision, and timing as well as detailed inventory procedures.
Question 2
Hint
In audit planning, start with what changed since last year and how those changes could alter risk and audit strategy.
Answer A. Significant changes in the client's operations and information system can directly affect the risks of material misstatement and the overall audit strategy. A third-party warehouse and a new ERP may change relevant controls, available audit evidence, and where procedures must be performed. The auditor should update the risk assessment during planning so the nature, timing, and extent of procedures are properly tailored to current-year circumstances.
Why not B: This is tempting because recurring engagements often use prior-year programs as a starting point. However, material changes in operations and systems mean the auditor must reassess risks and revise the plan before deciding what prior procedures, if any, can be reused.
Why not C: A written representation letter is required but is typically obtained near the completion of fieldwork, not before interim procedures. It is not the primary planning issue when significant operational and system changes affect risk assessment.
Why not D: Report wording depends on current-year evidence and conclusions. Relying on prior-year results to set report wording would be inappropriate without completing current-year procedures and reassessing risks caused by the new warehouse arrangement and ERP.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on events that increase the risk of material misstatement specifically around the period end (cutoff, occurrence, valuation) so interim evidence may no longer be sufficient.
Answer C. The promotional campaign and extended returns materially increase cutoff, occurrence, and valuation risks for revenue and accounts receivable around year‑end. Interim procedures planned before the campaign would not provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the increased year‑end activity, so AU‑C guidance indicates the auditor should revise the nature, timing, and extent of procedures and perform appropriate procedures at or near year‑end.
Why not A: A future IT implementation scheduled well after year‑end that does not affect current‑year processing generally does not require postponing interim substantive tests; the auditor should evaluate IT control implications but need not move the timing of substantive procedures solely because of a later system change.
Why not B: A management change can affect controls and risk assessments, but a planned retirement occurring six months after year‑end, without indications of errors, fraud, or control deficiencies, does not by itself require moving interim substantive procedures to year‑end. The auditor should consider whether the change affects assessed risks and whether additional procedures are needed.
Why not D: Losing a customer that represents about 3% of revenue is unlikely by itself to create a material year‑end risk that invalidates interim testing. Absent evidence that the loss affects valuation or collectibility of receivables or indicates broader risk, the auditor would not normally need to move interim procedures to year‑end.
Question 4
Hint
Ask which facts change the audit's scope, timing, and resource deployment versus which facts would actually change the contractual terms of the engagement.
Answer A. Under AU-C 300, the overall audit strategy sets the scope, timing, and direction of the engagement and guides development of the more detailed audit plan. A new foreign component, a new service organization, and a materially earlier reporting deadline all affect audit scope, timing, and resource deployment, so the strategy should be revised first and the audit plan then conformed to it. Because the facts rule out a misunderstanding about engagement terms, this is a planning-strategy issue rather than a terms-of-engagement issue.
Why not B: This is tempting because recurring audits often leverage prior-year knowledge and may require less fresh planning than an initial audit. However, significant changes in the client's operations and reporting timetable can change the engagement's scope, timing, and staffing, which are matters for the overall audit strategy, not just account-level procedures.
Why not C: This distractor is appealing because major business changes sometimes do require revisiting engagement terms. But the stem expressly states there is no misunderstanding about the audit objective, management's responsibilities, or the reporting framework, so a revised engagement letter is not automatically required; the primary issue is how the audit should be planned and staffed.
Why not D: Candidates may choose this because risk assessment procedures do inform planning, and planning is iterative. Still, the overall audit strategy is established early to direct those very procedures, including timing and resource allocation; the auditor should not postpone strategic planning decisions until after detailed work has begun.
Question 5
Hint
Ask whether the new facts affect only a few procedures or whether they also change the audit’s scope, timing, direction, and needed supervision.
Answer A. These are significant current-year changes that affect the audit's scope, timing, and direction. Under GAAS, planning is iterative and new information that changes risk assessments requires revising both the overall audit strategy and the detailed plan. A redesigned revenue system, a new controller, and covenant pressure reduce reliance on prior-year control experience and warrant greater year-end substantive testing and closer supervision.
Why not B: Tempting because prior-year control effectiveness can sometimes support an interim-focused approach in recurring audits. Wrong here because a material revenue-system redesign late in the year and a controller replacement mean prior-year controls may no longer operate effectively; without current-year testing, carrying forward the same overall strategy is inappropriate.
Why not C: Tempting because revenue is the most obviously affected area. Wrong because the developments also affect timing, staffing, supervision, and overall direction of the audit, elements of the audit strategy, not just the procedure list for a single account.
Why not D: Tempting because covenant pressure increases fraud risk and analytical procedures are appropriate at completion. Wrong because covenant-related incentives and the system/personnel changes should be considered during planning and may require earlier, more substantive work and increased supervision rather than only a completion-stage analytic.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what auditors do when a known, material change in the client's operations affects where audit evidence will need to be obtained.
Answer B. Planning is an ongoing process; material changes in the client's operations (like new warehouses holding material inventory) should be reflected in the overall audit strategy and audit plan. The auditor should address risks, staffing, timing, and extent of procedures for the new locations during planning rather than waiting to react later.
Why not A: Tempting because prior-year work is a helpful starting point, but material operational changes require the auditor to update planning now; relying unchanged on last year's plan risks missing location-specific risks.
Why not C: Delaying decisions until fieldwork ignores known, risk-relevant facts available during planning; the auditor should design appropriate procedures for the new locations in the audit plan.
Why not D: Management representations do not substitute for sufficient appropriate audit evidence and cannot justify reducing planned audit procedures over material inventory at new locations.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on whether audit planning is static or whether it should change when important client circumstances change.
Answer C. Planning is an ongoing, iterative process; significant client changes require revising the overall audit strategy and the audit plan. A new revenue system and new foreign sales offices can affect risk assessment, staffing and supervision, and the nature, timing, and extent of procedures, so the auditor should update the plan and assign personnel with appropriate experience.
Why not A: Planning is not a one-time activity completed before fieldwork; it continues throughout the engagement. Waiting until after substantive testing would prevent designing appropriate responses to newly identified risks in a timely manner.
Why not B: This is tempting because recurring engagements often begin with prior-year documentation, but important changes (new systems, foreign operations) create new risks and may require different procedures and staffing. The auditor must tailor current-year planning to the changed circumstances.
Why not D: Focusing only on disclosures misses broader implications: system implementations and new foreign locations can affect internal controls, risk assessment, required procedures, and staffing. These changes commonly require updates to the audit strategy and plan beyond the disclosure checklist.
Common questions
When does AU-C 300 require revising the audit strategy and plan?
Revise them as necessary when new information affects risks or the audit response. In this example, the significant inventory system change triggers reconsideration before fieldwork, without waiting for a misstatement.
Does a new ERP system affect the overall audit strategy?
Yes. An ERP change affecting significant inventory can change resource needs, supervision, and timing, not just individual inventory procedures.
What audit planning changes must be documented?
Document significant changes to the overall audit strategy and audit plan, including the reasons. Here, explain how the ERP conversion changed the planned inventory audit response.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning an Engagement, worked step by step.
Audit Planning: Materiality & Scoping | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning an Engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.