AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions
Using Management's Valuation Specialist as Audit Evidence
Before using management's valuation specialist's work, evaluate the specialist and the work itself. Below, sort the checks for Summit Co.'s complex investment valuations by what each check evaluates.
Try one first
Hint
If you intend to reduce substantive procedures based on controls, what evidence must you plan to obtain?
Answer C. If the auditor intends to rely on controls to reduce substantive testing, the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence that those controls operated effectively during the period. Merely noting that controls are well designed is insufficient; the plan should specify the timing and extent of tests of controls so substantive procedures are reduced only after evidence supports that reliance.
Why not A: Tempting because design adequacy may appear persuasive, but operating effectiveness (actual performance of controls) must be tested before relying on them to reduce substantive procedures.
Why not B: While a substantive-only approach is permissible, this choice contradicts the auditor's stated intention to rely on controls; cost considerations do not eliminate the obligation to obtain evidence of operating effectiveness if the auditor plans to reduce substantive procedures.
Why not D: Deferring prevents appropriate planning and timing of control tests; if the auditor plans to rely on controls to reduce substantive work, the audit plan should include when and how control testing will be performed so reliance is supported before substantive procedures are reduced.
Sort it
Does the specialist have the knowledge and expertise needed for Summit's investment valuations?
Can the specialist apply that expertise with the resources and time available for Summit's assignment?
Could bias, conflicts of interest, or relationships affect the specialist's judgment?
Do the report, methods, assumptions, and source data support using the valuation as audit evidence?
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| The specialist has extensive valuation experience, but only with investments unlike Summit's complex holdings. | CompetenceExperience must be relevant to the investments being valued, not merely extensive. |
| The valuation report was prepared solely for Summit management's use. | Appropriateness of the workThat restriction does not automatically exclude the report; evaluate whether its work supports the audit purpose. |
| The specialist's fee increases if Summit's investment valuation reaches management's target. | ObjectivityThe fee arrangement creates an incentive to favor a particular valuation. |
| The specialist understands the valuation model but lacks access to the tools needed to apply it. | CapabilitiesKnowledge alone does not establish the practical ability to complete this assignment. |
| The auditor compares the specialist's source data with Summit's investment records. | Appropriateness of the workThe auditor is evaluating the relevance, completeness, and accuracy of data supporting the valuation. |
| The auditor reviews the specialist's professional qualifications and experience with comparable investment valuations. | CompetenceQualifications and relevant experience help establish the specialist's expertise. |
| Management's valuation specialist is an outside firm with a significant financial relationship with Summit. | ObjectivityExternal status does not eliminate relationships that could affect judgment. |
| The specialist has suitable expertise but insufficient staff to complete Summit's valuation by the required date. | CapabilitiesStaffing and availability affect the ability to apply expertise to the assignment. |
| The specialist's report uses assumptions that lack support from available investment information. | Appropriateness of the workUnsupported assumptions require additional procedures before the valuation can support the audit conclusion. |
| The auditor considers whether the specialist understands the technical methods needed for Summit's complex investments. | CompetenceUnderstanding relevant valuation methods is a question of knowledge and expertise. |
| The specialist provides a statement of unbiasedness, but the auditor also investigates relationships with Summit. | ObjectivityA written statement does not replace evaluating relationships and potential bias. |
| The specialist has relevant expertise, but competing assignments leave inadequate time for Summit's valuation. | CapabilitiesCompeting demands can prevent a knowledgeable specialist from performing the assignment adequately. |
Key points
- Remember: An expert's credentials do not establish that the expert's valuation is appropriate audit evidence.
- Competence means expertise; capabilities means the ability to apply that expertise to this assignment.
- A report prepared solely for management is not automatically excluded from audit evidence.
- An outside firm still requires an objectivity evaluation.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting the valuation because management hired an outside firm. Evaluate the specialist and the work before using the valuation as audit evidence.
- Rejecting the report solely because it was prepared for management. Evaluate its appropriateness as audit evidence rather than automatically excluding it.
- Treating a written statement of unbiasedness as sufficient evaluation. Assess relationships and other threats to objectivity; a statement does not replace that assessment.
Question 2
Hint
Separate overall audit strategy decisions from procedures that directly test transactions or balances.
Answer B. Planning the engagement involves developing the overall audit strategy, decisions about staffing, supervision, timing, and the direction of audit work. Because Beacon changed its revenue system and expanded operations, assigning more experienced personnel and increasing supervision is an appropriate planning-level response to those risks. The other choices describe specific substantive or test-level procedures performed later to gather audit evidence, not planning decisions.
Why not A: Selecting and performing invoice vouching is a detailed substantive audit procedure for testing revenue transactions; it is executed after the planning phase establishes the audit strategy and staffing.
Why not C: Sending confirmations is a substantive test used during fieldwork to verify receivables. It is a procedure to obtain evidence, not a planning decision about how the engagement will be staffed or supervised.
Why not D: Reperforming a bank reconciliation is a specific test of a balance or control performed during audit execution; it does not represent an engagement-planning choice.
Question 3
Hint
Weigh seasonality, materiality by location, the recent system implementation, and prior misstatements when deciding whether interim counts or system data provide sufficient evidence versus attending year-end counts.
Answer C. Inventory is material and peaks at year-end, each warehouse holds a material portion, and there are heightened risks from a recently implemented perpetual system and prior-year count misstatements. To obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence in these circumstances, the engagement team should observe year-end physical counts at all material locations and perform cut-off testing and reconciliations to the perpetual records.
Why not A: Tempting because reliable perpetual records can reduce the need for observation, but the system was recently implemented and prior count misstatements raise questions about record reliability; physical observation of year-end counts remains necessary when inventory is material and control/record reliability is uncertain.
Why not B: Tempting because roll-forward from interim counts can be acceptable when controls and ongoing records are reliable and risk is low; however, seasonality (peak year-end balances), multiple locations that are each material, the new inventory system, and prior misstatements increase risk and make relying solely on interim counts without observing year-end counts insufficient.
Why not D: Tempting as a risk-based, resource-conscious approach, but the stem indicates each warehouse holds a material portion of total inventory and prior misstatements occurred at two warehouses; attending only the largest location would not adequately address the risk of material misstatement at the other material locations.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the auditor's responsibilities when others prepare specialized estimates, what must the auditor plan to do to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence?
Answer B. When management uses an external specialist, the auditor must plan to evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity and determine whether the specialist's work is appropriate and provides sufficient appropriate audit evidence. If concerns arise about the specialist's methods, assumptions, or conclusions, the auditor should perform additional procedures (for example, obtaining corroborative evidence or reviewing/reperforming aspects) to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates may assume an outside expert's report is automatically reliable; however, auditing standards require the auditor to evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity and the appropriateness of the specialist's work before accepting it as audit evidence.
Why not C: Tempting because documentation seems like a safeguard, but requiring a management-obtained written assertion from the specialist is not the auditor's standard planning step and does not replace the auditor's responsibility to evaluate and, if necessary, test the specialist's work.
Why not D: Tempting as an overly cautious response, but unnecessary and inefficient: auditors may rely on management's specialists if they appropriately evaluate the specialist and the work; refusing to consider the specialist's work and redoing all valuations in-house is not required.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what the auditor does before testing begins to set the direction, timing, and staffing of the engagement.
Answer B. Developing the overall audit strategy involves setting the scope, timing, and direction of the audit and determining the resources required. Identifying significant areas and deciding when work will be done and who will perform it are core planning decisions made before detailed risk assessment and substantive testing.
Why not A: This is tempting because walkthroughs are performed early and help shape the audit approach. However, a walkthrough is an evidence-gathering procedure used to obtain an understanding of the entity and its internal controls (risk assessment), not the higher-level task of setting the overall audit strategy.
Why not C: This distractor may seem plausible since receivable confirmations are common for significant balances. In fact, confirmations are substantive procedures to obtain audit evidence about account balances and are performed after planning, not part of developing the overall audit strategy.
Why not D: This is tempting if a candidate recalls that analytical procedures are used in audits. Final analytical procedures are completion-stage procedures performed near the end of the engagement to evaluate overall financial statement presentation, not part of planning the audit strategy.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what the auditor does to set the overall audit strategy and assign resources before gathering most audit evidence.
Answer B. Planning the engagement includes establishing the overall audit strategy, developing the audit plan, and deciding the nature and extent of resources needed for the audit. That includes identifying whether specialists or personnel with specific expertise should be assigned. The other choices are procedures more commonly performed later in the audit, especially as evidence is accumulated or the engagement is being completed.
Why not A: This is tempting because management representations are important required audit evidence. However, the written representation letter is ordinarily obtained near the end of the audit, not during initial planning. It supports conclusions after most audit work has been performed.
Why not C: This can seem related to planning because analytical procedures are also used in risk assessment early in the audit. The key word here is final analytical procedures, which are performed near completion to help evaluate the overall conclusion on the financial statements. That makes this a completion-stage procedure, not a planning activity.
Why not D: A weaker candidate may pick this because it is an important audit step and may require advance timing. Even so, attorney inquiry letters are substantive evidence-gathering procedures tied to identifying and evaluating contingencies, not part of classifying the engagement's planning activities. They are ordinarily performed after planning as fieldwork progresses.
Common questions
What must an auditor evaluate about management's valuation specialist?
Evaluate competence, capabilities, and objectivity. Also evaluate whether the specialist's work is appropriate audit evidence for the valuation.
Can an auditor use a valuation report prepared only for management?
Yes. Its intended use does not automatically disqualify it, but the auditor must evaluate the specialist and the appropriateness of the work.
What if management's specialist uses unsupported valuation assumptions?
Perform additional procedures to address the concern, such as obtaining corroborating evidence or reviewing relevant calculations. Do not accept the valuation solely because a specialist prepared it.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning an Engagement, worked step by step.
Audit Planning: Materiality & Scoping | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning an Engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.