TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 6 practice questions
Taxable-Equivalent Yield: Municipal vs. Corporate Bonds
Compare tax-exempt municipal bonds with taxable bonds using after-tax yields, not stated yields. Below, Mia’s bond comparison shows how both calculation methods identify the higher after-tax return.
Try one first
Hint
When one investment is tax-exempt and the other is taxable, do not compare their stated yields directly.
Answer C. For personal financial planning, compare a tax-exempt yield to a taxable yield using the taxable-equivalent yield: TEY = tax-exempt yield / (1 − tax rate). Here TEY = 4.2% / (1 − 0.35) ≈ 6.46%. Because 6.46% > 6.0%, the municipal bond provides the better after-tax return under the stated assumptions.
Why not A: This is tempting because it compares the stated yields directly, but it ignores tax differences. The corporate bond's interest is taxable, while the municipal bond's interest is federally tax-exempt, so you must use after-tax or taxable-equivalent yields for a fair comparison.
Why not B: This reflects the common mistake of taxing tax-exempt income. The municipal bond interest is exempt from federal tax, so you should not reduce its yield; instead, gross it up to a taxable-equivalent basis for comparison.
Why not D: Multiplying by 35% calculates the tax amount, not the after-tax return. The correct after-tax yield on the corporate bond is 6.0% × (1 − 0.35) = 3.9%, which is still below the municipal bond's taxable-equivalent yield (≈6.46%).
Side by side
| Municipal bond | Taxable corporate bond | |
|---|---|---|
| Mia’s investment setting | Taxable account; comparable risk and maturity. | Same account; comparable risk and maturity. |
| Tax assumptions | No state income taxes or AMT effect. | No state income taxes or AMT effect. |
| Stated annual yield | 4.2% | 6.0% |
| Federal interest treatment | Exempt from federal income tax. | Taxable at Mia’s 35% marginal rate. |
| Share of interest retained | 100% | 1 − 35% = 65% |
| After-tax yield | 4.2%, unchanged. | 6.0% × 65% = 3.9%. |
| Yield on a taxable-equivalent basis | 4.2% ÷ 65% ≈ 6.46%. | 6.0%, already a taxable yield. |
| Which bond wins? | Municipal: 4.2% after tax exceeds 3.9%. | Corporate loses despite its higher stated yield. |
Key points
- Remember: Put both yields on the same tax basis before choosing a bond.
- Use the marginal rate because it determines the tax on additional interest income.
- Taxable-equivalent yield is a comparison rate, not the yield the municipal bond actually pays.
How the exam traps you
- Choosing the corporate bond because 6.0% exceeds 4.2%. Compare its 3.9% after-tax yield with the municipal bond’s 4.2%.
- Multiplying the exempt municipal yield by 65%. Keep its after-tax yield at 4.2%; divide by 65% only to find taxable-equivalent yield.
- Treating 6.0% × 35% = 2.1% as the corporate bond’s after-tax yield. That is the tax cost. Subtract it from 6.0% to get 3.9%.
Question 2
Hint
Think about how capital losses net with capital gains within a tax year and how the wash‑sale rule treats quick repurchases of 'substantially identical' securities.
Answer A. Realized capital losses in the same tax year offset capital gains dollar‑for‑dollar, so selling the $20,000 of losing positions before the distribution will fully offset the $20,000 long‑term gain. Replacing the holdings with similar but not substantially identical securities preserves market exposure while avoiding the wash‑sale rule (disallows losses if you repurchase substantially identical securities within 30 days).
Why not B: Tempting because it preserves exact holdings, but incorrect: repurchasing the same (or substantially identical) securities within 30 days triggers the wash‑sale rule and disallows the current deduction (the disallowed loss is added to the basis of the repurchased shares).
Why not C: Misleadingly appeals to the $3,000 limit against ordinary income, but incorrect here because capital losses first offset capital gains in the same year without regard to the $3,000 cap; selling only $3,000 would forgo the opportunity to offset the $20,000 distribution in Year 1.
Why not D: Incorrect because unrealized losses do not affect taxable income, losses must be realized (by selling) in the tax year to offset capital gain distributions; leaving positions unrealized will not reduce Year 1 tax on the distribution.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which investment tends to create more current taxable income in a regular brokerage account.
Answer D. Taxable bond funds generate interest that is typically taxed at ordinary income rates in a brokerage account, which reduces after-tax returns. A traditional IRA shelters that ordinary income until withdrawal, while broad-market stock index funds are generally more tax-efficient in taxable accounts because they often produce qualified dividends and long-term capital gains and have lower turnover. Therefore holding the bond fund in the IRA and the stock index fund in the taxable account usually improves after-tax results.
Why not A: Keeping the IRA unused may preserve flexibility, but it also forgoes the opportunity to shelter currently taxable, ordinary-income-producing assets. Absent a specific reason to avoid using the IRA, placing the bond fund in the IRA is usually the better tax-efficient choice.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates sometimes assume the highest-growth asset should go in tax-advantaged accounts. However, the key consideration is tax treatment: bond income is taxed at ordinary rates in a taxable account, so leaving the bond fund in the taxable account exposes that income to current taxation and typically lowers after-tax returns relative to sheltering it in an IRA.
Why not C: Although the overall asset allocation stays the same, asset location can materially affect after-tax returns. Because bond interest and equity returns are taxed differently in taxable accounts, splitting assets evenly can leave tax-inefficient income exposed and reduce after-tax performance compared with placing bonds in the tax-deferred account.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on what happens when the same stock is repurchased shortly before or after a sale at a loss.
Answer A. A wash sale occurs when substantially identical stock or securities are repurchased within 30 days before or after a loss sale. Because Jordan repurchased the same stock 10 days later in a taxable account, the $4,000 loss is not currently deductible. Instead, the disallowed loss is added to the basis of the replacement shares, preserving the loss until a later taxable disposition.
Why not B: This is tempting because capital losses in taxable accounts are generally deductible, but the wash sale rules disallow a loss if substantially identical stock is bought within the 30-day window around the sale.
Why not C: Some candidates recall permanent loss treatment when replacement shares are purchased in retirement accounts; that permanent loss scenario doesn't apply here because the replacement shares were bought in a taxable account, so the loss is deferred by being added to the replacement basis.
Why not D: This confuses the wash sale timing rule with a year-end timing issue; the disallowance is based on the 30-day window and the loss remains added to basis until a later taxable sale, not automatically reinstated at year-end.
Question 5
Hint
Compare which investment suffers the most from current annual taxation in a taxable account versus one that already has favorable tax treatment.
Answer D. Interest from taxable corporate bond funds is taxed currently as ordinary income when held in a taxable account, creating annual tax drag. Placing that fund in a traditional IRA defers taxation until withdrawal, reducing current taxable income and usually making it the better asset-location choice. Investments that already receive favorable tax treatment or naturally defer tax are often better kept in taxable accounts.
Why not A: This is tempting because growth assets align with long-term retirement savings. Still, a stock that generates little current income is tax-efficient in a taxable account because tax is typically deferred until sale and long-term gains may qualify for lower rates; it therefore is usually a weaker candidate for placing in a traditional IRA than a taxable bond fund.
Why not B: This is tempting because municipal interest is generally federally tax-exempt in a taxable account. Putting municipal bonds inside a traditional IRA typically wastes that benefit, since withdrawals from a traditional IRA are taxed at ordinary rates.
Why not C: This is tempting because retirement accounts are common default holdings. However, a low-turnover index fund is already tax-efficient in a taxable account (deferring gains and often qualifying for favorable long-term capital gains rates), so it is usually less urgent to shelter it in a traditional IRA than a high-current-income bond fund.
Question 6
Hint
Do not stop at the words tax-exempt or taxable. Ask which measure reflects what the investor actually keeps.
Answer C. Compare after-tax returns when choosing between taxable and tax-exempt bonds. The taxable bond's after-tax yield is 5.8% × (1 − 0.37) = 3.654%, which is less than the 4.2% municipal yield. Because risk, maturity, and liquidity are comparable, the after-tax yield using the marginal tax rate should drive the recommendation.
Why not A: Tempting because 5.8% > 4.2%, but pretax yield ignores taxes. The relevant comparison for the investor is what they keep after taxes, not the stated coupon alone.
Why not B: Average tax rate is a familiar concept, but the tax on additional interest income is determined by the marginal tax rate. Use the marginal rate when comparing incremental investment returns.
Why not D: Federal tax-exempt status is important but not decisive by itself; a taxable bond can still be preferable if its after-tax yield exceeds the municipal bond's yield.
Common questions
How do you calculate taxable-equivalent yield for a municipal bond?
Divide the tax-exempt yield by one minus the marginal tax rate. For Mia, 4.2% ÷ 65% is about 6.46%, which exceeds the corporate bond’s 6.0% yield.
Do you use the marginal or average tax rate for taxable-equivalent yield?
Use the marginal rate because the comparison concerns additional interest income. Mia uses her 35% marginal rate, not her average rate.
Is a 4.2% municipal bond better than a 6% corporate bond?
For Mia at a 35% marginal rate, yes: the corporate bond yields only 3.9% after federal tax. This comparison assumes comparable risk and maturity, no state taxes, and no AMT effect.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Financial planning for individuals
- How Much Should You Convert to a Roth IRA?
- First RMD Due Date at Age 73
- HSA Eligibility When Medicare Part A Is Retroactive
- 529 Distributions: Calculate Taxable Earnings
- Term vs Whole Life: Matching Coverage to a Temporary Need
- 2026 SALT Deduction: Apply the MAGI-Adjusted Cap
- 2025 Kiddie Tax Calculation: Form 8615 Example
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.