TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 6 practice questions
How Much Should You Convert to a Roth IRA?
Convert pretax IRA dollars when their marginal tax rate now is lower than the expected rate at withdrawal. Below: compare recommendations for filling a lower bracket without converting extra dollars at a higher rate.
Try one first
Hint
Compare today’s combined marginal tax rate (federal + state) to the marginal rate expected at distribution; if the expected future rate is lower, deferring tax (Traditional) typically minimizes lifetime tax.
Answer D. Compare marginal rates: current combined marginal rate = 24% + 6% = 30%, expected retirement marginal rate = 22% (federal only). Because the rate at distribution is lower than the current rate, deferring tax via Traditional contributions minimizes lifetime federal-plus-state tax under the stated assumptions. For example, sheltering $1,000 pre-tax today avoids $300 of tax now but would incur $220 of tax when withdrawn later, a net $80 tax advantage versus paying $300 today on a Roth contribution.
Why not A: This is tempting because Roth withdrawals are tax-free and retiring in a no-tax state avoids state tax later. It fails here because Roth contributions are taxed today at Alex's combined 30% marginal rate; with a lower expected retirement federal rate (22%), paying tax later on Traditional distributions yields lower lifetime tax under the given assumptions.
Why not B: Hedging is a reasonable real-world strategy under uncertainty, which makes this option tempting. It is incorrect for this question because the facts give a clear expectation (lower future federal rate and no state tax in retirement); splitting sacrifices the concrete tax savings that full Traditional funding would provide under those assumptions.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the value of tax-free compounding. However, compounding applies to the after-tax amount in both accounts and does not change the marginal-rate comparison that drives lifetime-tax minimization, since the current combined rate (30%) exceeds the expected future rate (22%), Traditional contributions are preferable here.
What should you do?
The situation
Dana has $80,000 of taxable income before conversion, a $200,000 entirely pretax traditional IRA, and $30,000 outside the IRA for taxes. She expects a 28% marginal retirement rate. For this exercise only, conversion dollars face 22% up to $90,000 of total taxable income and 32% above it. Ignore state taxes, surtaxes, and phaseouts. What conversion minimizes lifetime federal income tax?
Convert $10,000 and pay the $2,200 tax from outside cash.
Best The first $10,000 costs 22% now versus 28% later. Additional dollars cost 32% now.
Convert nothing because the conversion could reach the 32% bracket.
Wrong A $10,000 conversion stays within the 22% bracket and avoids the expected 28% tax later.
Convert $30,000 because Dana has $30,000 available outside the IRA.
Wrong This converts $20,000 at 32%, higher than the expected 28% retirement rate.
Convert the entire $200,000 to eliminate future tax on qualified Roth withdrawals.
Wrong Most conversion dollars would cost 32% now, exceeding the expected 28% rate at withdrawal.
Key points
- Remember: convert the cheaper dollars, not necessarily the whole IRA.
- Bracket room is $90,000 minus $80,000, so $10,000 can be converted at 22%.
- Paying the $2,200 conversion tax from outside cash keeps the full $10,000 invested in the Roth.
- The $30,000 cash balance helps pay taxes; it does not determine the conversion amount.
How the exam traps you
- Convert the entire IRA because future qualified Roth withdrawals are tax-free. Additional conversion dollars cost 32% now versus an expected 28% later.
- Skip conversion because some dollars would fall in the 32% bracket. Separate the first $10,000, taxed at 22%, from additional dollars taxed at 32%.
- Convert $30,000 because that matches available outside cash. Size the conversion by marginal rates, not the cash available to pay tax.
Question 2
Hint
Match the tax benefit to the expected tax bracket: is it better to get the tax break now or later?
Answer C. A Roth IRA is the preferred choice when the taxpayer expects to be in a higher tax bracket in retirement: you pay tax now at the current (lower) rate and qualified distributions are tax-free later. Ava gives up an immediate deduction but locks in tax-free retirement income under her stated expectation. The stem already assumes she will receive qualified distributions, so Roth treatment best matches her goal.
Why not A: Taxable brokerage accounts offer flexibility and favorable long-term capital gain rates on gains, but realized gains and dividends are still taxable; withdrawals are not tax-free. Because Ava's goal is tax-free qualified retirement income given a higher expected future tax rate, a Roth IRA is superior.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often overvalue the immediate deduction. However, a deductible traditional IRA is generally more attractive when you expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement (so you defer tax until later at a lower rate). Ava expects a higher rate in retirement, so the immediate deduction is not the better match.
Why not D: This distractor reflects a common misunderstanding: nondeductible (after-tax) contributions create basis that can be withdrawn tax-free, but the earnings in the traditional IRA are taxable on distribution. That leaves the nondeductible traditional IRA less favorable than a Roth for Ava's objective of tax-free retirement withdrawals.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the factor that usually determines whether paying tax today makes sense compared with paying tax in the future.
Answer A. The key economic question for a Roth conversion is whether paying income tax now results in a lower lifetime tax cost than paying tax later on withdrawals. That depends primarily on Dana's current marginal tax rate versus the marginal rate she expects in retirement. Given she can pay the tax from outside funds and expects a long holding period, the tax-rate comparison is the main driver of whether the conversion is advantageous.
Why not B: This is tempting because age 59 1/2 is a common distribution threshold, but it does not make a Roth conversion itself disallowed or the primary financial issue. (There is a separate 5-year/early-withdrawal penalty nuance for converted amounts taken out early, but because Dana plans to leave the funds invested, that nuance is not the main conversion decision.)
Why not C: Paying the tax from non-IRA funds is generally preferable to having the custodian withhold from the conversion, but withholding is an execution detail rather than the central planning tradeoff. The primary question remains whether paying tax now (at today's rate) is preferable to paying tax later.
Why not D: This distractor confuses contributions with conversions. Annual contribution limits restrict new Roth or traditional contributions, not conversions of existing traditional IRA balances, so the contribution limit is not the primary issue here.
Question 4
Hint
Ask which actions raise MAGI and which rules use MAGI versus account type; remember conversions of pre‑tax IRAs are taxed in the conversion year and Roth IRAs owned by the original owner generally avoid RMDs.
Answer A. A Roth conversion of pre‑tax traditional IRA funds is included in taxable income in the year of conversion, which increases AGI/MAGI and ordinary income tax for that year. That higher MAGI can push the taxpayers over NIIT thresholds, causing the 3.8% surtax to apply to any net investment income (conversion dollars themselves are generally not treated as net investment income). Because SSA uses MAGI from prior tax returns (a two‑year lookback) to determine IRMAA, the Year 1 MAGI increase can raise Medicare Part B/D surcharges in later years; Roth IRAs owned by the original owner are not subject to RMDs, reducing future required taxable withdrawals.
Why not B: This is tempting because Roth contributions are after‑tax and do not increase taxable income, but conversions of pre‑tax IRA funds are taxable in the year converted and therefore increase current taxable income, they do not act like new after‑tax contributions.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea of being 'double taxed,' but NIIT applies to net investment income, not broadly to all income increases; conversions raise MAGI and can trigger NIIT on net investment income, yet conversion dollars are generally not treated as net investment income themselves.
Why not D: This is tempting because IRMAA uses prior tax-year MAGI, but that timing only delays the impact, higher MAGI in Year 1 can be used to set IRMAA surcharges in later years (typically two years later), so the conversion can increase Medicare premiums even though the increase is not immediate.
Question 5
Hint
Remember that the 0% long-term capital gains band is determined by total taxable income (ordinary income + conversions + capital gains); compute the 'headroom' below the $40,000 threshold.
Answer A. Total taxable income that determines the 0% capital gains band includes ordinary income, conversions, and capital gains. With $19,000 ordinary income and $14,000 LTCG, headroom under the $40,000 threshold is $40,000 − ($19,000 + $14,000) = $7,000. Converting up to $7,000 keeps all $14,000 of LTCG within the 0% bracket; any larger conversion would push some gains above the threshold.
Why not B: This reflects the error of subtracting only ordinary income from the $40,000 threshold ($40,000 − $19,000 = $21,000) and ignoring that the $14,000 of LTCG is also part of taxable income. Converting $21,000 would make taxable income $54,000 and subject part of the gains to higher capital gains rates.
Why not C: This is an overly conservative choice. It ignores that there is positive headroom ($7,000) in Year 1 that allows a tax-efficient conversion without causing any of the LTCG to be taxed above 0%. Foregoing conversion misses that opportunity.
Why not D: Some may assume symmetry between gains and conversions, but converting $14,000 would add to ordinary taxable income, raising total taxable income to $47,000 and pushing part of the $14,000 of LTCG above the 0% threshold.
Question 6
Hint
Focus first on the client's stated priority: current-year tax reduction, not just long-term tax-free growth.
Answer B. A fully deductible traditional IRA contribution best matches Jordan's stated objective because it provides a current-year federal income tax deduction. That is generally most attractive when the taxpayer expects to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement, since the deduction is taken at a higher current rate and the future distributions are expected to be taxed at a lower rate. Under the facts given, Jordan is eligible for the deduction, so this is the best planning response.
Why not A: This is tempting because Roth IRAs are a popular retirement-planning choice and tax-free qualified withdrawals sound attractive. However, a Roth IRA contribution does not provide a current-year deduction, so it does not meet Jordan's main goal of reducing current-year federal income taxes. Roth treatment is generally more appealing when a taxpayer expects the same or a higher tax rate in retirement.
Why not C: This can seem reasonable because tax-deferred growth is still a retirement benefit. But a nondeductible traditional IRA does not give Jordan the current-year tax reduction that the question specifically prioritizes. If Jordan is eligible for a fully deductible traditional IRA contribution, the nondeductible contribution is not the best response.
Why not D: This distractor appeals to a common shortcut that lower capital gains rates automatically make taxable investing the best choice. But a regular brokerage account does not provide the immediate deduction available from a deductible traditional IRA. It also does not align as well with the stated retirement-planning objective under the facts provided.
Common questions
How much should I convert to a Roth IRA to fill a tax bracket?
Subtract taxable income before conversion from the chosen bracket ceiling. In this exercise, $90,000 minus $80,000 leaves $10,000 taxed at 22%, below the expected 28% retirement rate.
Should I convert my entire traditional IRA to a Roth at once?
Not under these facts. Only $10,000 is taxed at 22%; converting more means paying 32% now instead of the expected 28% at withdrawal.
Should I pay Roth conversion taxes with money outside the IRA?
Dana can pay the $2,200 tax from outside cash, preserving the full $10,000 in the Roth. Available cash supports the conversion but does not justify converting dollars at an unfavorable rate.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Financial planning for individuals
- First RMD Due Date at Age 73
- HSA Eligibility When Medicare Part A Is Retroactive
- 529 Distributions: Calculate Taxable Earnings
- Term vs Whole Life: Matching Coverage to a Temporary Need
- Taxable-Equivalent Yield: Municipal vs. Corporate Bonds
- 2026 SALT Deduction: Apply the MAGI-Adjusted Cap
- 2025 Kiddie Tax Calculation: Form 8615 Example
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.