PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 6 practice questions

HSA Eligibility When Medicare Part A Is Retroactive

HSA contribution eligibility ends the month Medicare coverage becomes effective, including retroactive months. Below: follow an October Medicare application back to its April effective date and identify the eligible months.

The ruleHSA contribution eligibility is determined monthly. Medicare Part A coverage disqualifies an individual beginning with its effective month, even when that effective date precedes the application by up to six months.

Try one first

Jordan, age 52, is covered by a qualifying self-only high-deductible health plan for all of Year 1 and is not claimed as another taxpayer's dependent. Assume the annual HSA contribution limit is not otherwise an issue. Which additional fact would prevent Jordan from being eligible to contribute to an HSA for the months that fact applies?
Hint

Focus on what types of additional coverage are specifically disqualifying for HSA eligibility, rather than what creates taxable distributions.

The timeline

  1. January 1Jordan begins the year HSA-eligible.

    Jordan is 67, has qualifying self-only HDHP coverage all year, and has no disqualifying coverage before Medicare. Jordan has never enrolled in Medicare or started Social Security benefits.

  2. April 1Medicare Part A becomes effective retroactively.

    The October application later establishes this date. Assume the maximum six-month retroactivity applies. April is the first ineligible month; March is the last eligible month.

  3. October 10Jordan applies for Medicare Part A and Part B.

    The application date does not control HSA eligibility. Part A reaches back to April 1, eliminating eligibility for April through December.

  4. December 31Determine the annual HSA contribution limit using three eligible months.

    Use 3/12 of the annual self-only limit and 3/12 of the age-55 catch-up. Contributions made before the application do not change this limit.

Key points

  • Remember: Count eligible months using Medicare’s effective date, not its application date.
  • Keeping qualifying HDHP coverage all year does not preserve eligibility during Medicare-covered months.
  • Depositing the contribution before applying for Medicare does not protect contributions attributable to retroactively covered months.

How the exam traps you

  • Count January through September because Jordan applies in October. Part A starts April 1, so only January through March qualify.
  • Include April because it is six months before the application. April 1 is the coverage start date. April itself is ineligible.
  • Disallow contributions for the entire year because Jordan enrolls in Medicare. Eligibility is monthly. January through March remain eligible.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Taylor, age 38, is covered by a qualifying high-deductible health plan for all of Year 1 and has no other disqualifying health coverage. Taylor wants an individually owned account that can receive tax-favored contributions, keep unused balances from year to year, allow investment growth, and provide tax-free distributions when used for qualified medical expenses. Assuming contribution limits are not an issue, which account best fits this description?
Hint

Focus on which account is both individually owned and specifically designed for qualified medical expenses, not just any tax-advantaged savings account.

Question 3

Assume Morgan otherwise satisfies all HSA requirements unless the facts below make Morgan ineligible. Morgan, age 56, is not enrolled in Medicare, cannot be claimed as another taxpayer's dependent, and had self-only HDHP coverage from January 1 through March 31 of Year 1 and family HDHP coverage from April 1 through December 31 of Year 1. Morgan's spouse had a limited-purpose FSA from January 1 through September 30. On October 1, the spouse began a new job and elected a general-purpose health FSA for the rest of Year 1; under that plan's terms, Morgan's unreimbursed medical expenses were eligible for reimbursement beginning October 1. No HSA testing-period issue applies, and no FSA reimbursements were actually made for Morgan. Which conclusion is most appropriate regarding Morgan's maximum Year 1 HSA contribution?
Hint

Separate the analysis into two steps: first decide which months Morgan is an 'eligible individual' for HSA purposes, then determine whether that same month-count applies to both the regular limit and the catch-up amount.

Question 4

On October 15, Year 1, Nolan, age 66, asks his CPA about making a Year 1 HSA contribution. Nolan has had self-only HDHP coverage for all of Year 1, has no other disqualifying coverage, is not enrolled in any part of Medicare, and has made no HSA contribution yet. He plans to apply for Social Security retirement benefits in November Year 1. Assume that, as a result, Medicare Part A would begin retroactively on May 1, Year 1. Which response is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on the effective date of Medicare Part A, not just when Nolan files for benefits. HSA eligibility is tested month by month.

Question 5

In 20X6, Nina, age 57, and Omar, age 63, are married and file jointly. They are covered for all 12 months under Nina's employer-sponsored family high-deductible health plan. The employer offers no general-purpose health FSA or HRA; the only additional coverage is a limited-purpose dental and vision FSA. Omar enrolled in Medicare Part A effective January 1, 20X6, and remained enrolled all year. Neither spouse is eligible to be claimed as another taxpayer's dependent. They want to maximize permitted HSA funding for 20X6. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Test HSA eligibility separately for each spouse first, then determine which coverage level applies to the spouse who remains eligible.

Question 6

Taylor, age 54, was an eligible individual for HSA purposes in Year 1 during months when not covered by Medicare. Taylor had self-only HDHP coverage from January 1 through April 30 and family HDHP coverage from May 1 through November 30. Taylor enrolled in Medicare effective December 1, Year 1, and had no other disqualifying coverage at any time before then. Taylor's employer contributed $1,800 to Taylor's HSA during Year 1. Assume the Year 1 HSA contribution limits for this question are $4,320 for self-only coverage and $8,640 for family coverage, and ignore catch-up contributions. What is the most supportable maximum above-the-line deduction Taylor may claim for personal HSA contributions for Year 1?
Hint

Compute the HSA limit one month at a time, then ask how employer contributions affect the amount the taxpayer can still deduct personally.

Drill all 137 Financial planning for individuals questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How does retroactive Medicare Part A affect HSA contributions?

It removes HSA eligibility for the retroactively covered months. Jordan’s October application produces an April 1 effective date, leaving only January through March eligible.

Can I keep contributing to an HSA if I still have an HDHP after Medicare starts?

HDHP coverage alone is not enough. Jordan keeps self-only HDHP coverage all year, but Medicare makes April through December ineligible.

Does making an HSA contribution before applying for Medicare avoid retroactivity?

No. The deposit date does not determine the eligible months. Jordan must base the annual limit on January through March even if the money was deposited before applying.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Financial planning for individuals

All Financial planning for individuals practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.