TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 7 practice questions
Rental Real Estate $25,000 Allowance MAGI Phaseout
The $25,000 rental real estate special allowance falls by $1 for every $2 of MAGI above $100,000. Below: a worked calculation showing how the phaseout limits an active participant's current rental loss deduction.
Try one first
Hint
Apply the limitations in the correct order, and do not forget the modified AGI phaseout of the rental real estate special allowance.
Answer C. Apply the at-risk rules first (section 465): only $45,000 of the $60,000 loss is permitted now and $15,000 is suspended under the at‑risk limitation. Then apply the passive activity rules with the active‑participation special allowance (up to $25,000), which is reduced by 50% of modified AGI over $100,000: 50% × ($130,000 − $100,000) = $15,000, leaving a $10,000 current deduction. The remaining $35,000 of the allowable $45,000 is suspended under the passive activity rules as a passive loss carryforward.
Why not A: This choice incorrectly treats active participation as if it entirely removes the passive activity limitation. Active participation only permits the special allowance (subject to the MAGI phaseout); it does not override the passive activity rules, so some of the at‑risk‑allowed loss remains suspended.
Why not B: This is tempting because of the $25,000 active‑participation allowance, but that allowance phases out by 50% of modified AGI over $100,000. With $130,000 MAGI the allowance is reduced by $15,000 to $10,000, so $25,000 is not fully available.
Why not D: This ignores that the at‑risk rules allow $45,000 of the loss and that Jordan qualifies for a reduced active‑participation special allowance (a $10,000 deduction after the MAGI phaseout). Not all rental losses are automatically fully suspended.
Worked example
Morgan, a single taxpayer, owns 100% of a rental property and actively participates but is not a real estate professional. The rental produces a $54,000 loss. MAGI for the special allowance, computed without the rental loss, is $124,000. Morgan has sufficient basis and amount at risk to absorb the entire $54,000 loss. There is no other passive income, prior suspended loss, or disposition.
| 1 | MAGI above the phaseout threshold$124,000 − $100,000 | $24,000 |
| 2 | Allowance reduction50% × $24,000 | $12,000 |
| 3 | Available allowance and current deduction$25,000 − $12,000 | $13,000 |
| 4 | Suspended passive activity loss$54,000 − $13,000 | $41,000 |
Morgan deducts $13,000 currently and carries forward $41,000 as a suspended passive activity loss.
Check: Within the phaseout range, halve the distance to $150,000: ($150,000 − $124,000) ÷ 2 = $13,000.
Key points
- Use MAGI for the special allowance, computed without the rental loss.
- Active participation permits the special allowance; it does not make this rental activity nonpassive.
- Each $2 of MAGI above $100,000 removes $1 of the allowance.
How the exam traps you
- Deducting the full $25,000 because Morgan actively participates. Apply the MAGI phaseout. Morgan's allowance is only $13,000.
- Subtracting the entire $24,000 MAGI excess, leaving a $1,000 allowance. Subtract only 50% of the excess: $12,000.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| invested | $6,000 |
| bank debt for which Dana is personally liable | $4,000 |
| qualified nonrecourse financing from an unrelated commercial lender secured by the rental real estate (qualified nonrecourse financing generally means nonrecourse acquisition financing from an unrelated lender) | $4,000 |
| nonrecourse note payable to the seller of the property (seller nonrecourse financing generally does not qualify as qualified nonrecourse financing for at-risk purposes) | $10,000 |
Hint
Compute Dana's at-risk amount first, including only cash, personally liable debt, and qualified nonrecourse financing from unrelated lenders (seller nonrecourse financing generally does not count). Then compute passive-activity availability: passive income plus the phased $25,000 special allowance; the allowed current deduction is the lesser of the two results.
Answer D. Apply the at-risk rules before the passive activity limits. Dana is at risk for $6,000 cash + $4,000 personally liable bank debt + $4,000 qualified nonrecourse financing from an unrelated lender (the $10,000 seller nonrecourse note does not qualify for at-risk treatment), so the at-risk amount is $14,000. Under the passive activity rules the available current loss would be passive income ($7,000) plus the phased $25,000 special allowance: 25,000 - 0.5*(132,000 - 100,000) = 25,000 - 16,000 = 9,000, so 7,000 + 9,000 = 16,000. The deductible loss is the lesser of the at-risk amount and the passive-activity allowance, so $14,000 is currently deductible.
Why not A: Tempting because $9,000 is the phased-down $25,000 special allowance at Dana's MAGI, but incorrect because it ignores Dana's separate $7,000 of passive income that also offsets losses and does not account for the at-risk calculation.
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate recalls the $25,000 active-participation allowance but forgets the MAGI phaseout and the at-risk limitation; it is wrong because the $25,000 is phased down at Dana's MAGI and the at-risk amount is only $14,000.
Why not C: Tempting because it equals passive income plus the phased special allowance, but incorrect because the at-risk limitation (applied before the passive-activity limitation) caps the deductible loss at $14,000.
Question 3
Hint
Compute Riley's at‑risk cap first (include the qualified nonrecourse financing as stated), then compute the rental real estate special allowance after the MAGI phaseout; which numeric limit is smaller?
Answer B. Apply the at‑risk rules first: Riley's at‑risk amount equals $20,000 + 25% of $140,000 = $55,000, limiting the $70,000 loss to $55,000. Because Riley actively (but not materially) participates and has MAGI of $130,000, the $25,000 special allowance is reduced by 50% × ($130,000 − $100,000) = $15,000, leaving a $10,000 allowance. That $10,000 special allowance is smaller than the $55,000 at‑risk cap, so the phaseout-adjusted special allowance governs the deductible amount this year.
Why not A: Tempting because the at‑risk limit is applied before passive-activity considerations and it does reduce the loss to $55,000; however, the rental real estate special allowance (after MAGI phaseout) is smaller ($10,000) and therefore is the binding current‑year limit.
Why not C: This confuses material participation with active participation. Although rentals are passive absent material participation, a taxpayer who actively (but not materially) participates may still qualify for the special $25,000 allowance (subject to the MAGI phaseout), so lack of material participation does not by itself eliminate the current deduction here.
Why not D: Recourse status often matters for at‑risk computations, but qualified nonrecourse financing for real property can count toward a partner's at‑risk amount when the statutory criteria are met (the stem directs you to assume those requirements are satisfied), so the recourse/nonrecourse label does not block the deduction in these facts.
Question 4
Hint
Apply the limitations in sequence: first determine how much loss survives the at-risk rules, then apply the passive activity limitation, including any phased-down rental real estate special allowance.
Answer D. First apply the at‑risk limitation: Alpha's $40,000 loss is limited to $18,000 by the at‑risk rules. That produces $38,000 of passive losses (Alpha $18,000 + Beta $20,000) and $6,000 of passive income from Gamma. The rental real estate special allowance is phased out at higher AGI and at $130,000 is reduced to $10,000 [$25,000 − 50% × ($130,000 − $100,000)]. The deductible amount is therefore the $6,000 passive income plus the $10,000 allowable rental allowance = $16,000; the remaining $22,000 of passive loss is suspended and carried forward.
Why not A: This allows both Alpha and Beta losses to be fully deductible after the at‑risk reduction, ignoring the passive activity loss rules and the rental allowance phaseout. It fails to account for the $6,000 passive income limit and the phased special allowance.
Why not B: This treats the $6,000 passive income and the full $20,000 rental loss as currently deductible (6,000 + 20,000 = 26,000). It ignores the phaseout of the $25,000 rental real estate allowance, at $130,000 AGI that allowance is only $10,000.
Why not C: This assumes Alpha is limited to $18,000 and Beta's allowance is $10,000, then treats both amounts as fully deductible (18,000 + 10,000 = 28,000). That is incorrect because Alpha is a nonrental passive loss after the at‑risk limit and can be deducted only to the extent of passive income (only $6,000 here).
Question 5
Hint
Apply the limitations in sequence, and remember that active participation in a rental activity creates only a limited exception to the passive loss rules.
Answer D. Apply the at-risk limitation first: Nolan is only $32,000 at risk, so $8,000 of the $40,000 loss is suspended under the at-risk rules. Next apply the passive activity rules and the special $25,000 allowance for active participation (phased out 50% for MAGI over $100,000). With MAGI of $130,000 the allowance is $25,000 - 0.5*(30,000) = $10,000, so $10,000 is currently deductible and the remaining $22,000 of the at-risk-allowed loss is suspended under the passive activity rules.
Why not A: This choice gets the $10,000 phased allowance right but skips the ordering rule. Only $32,000 of the $40,000 survives the at-risk limitation and can be tested under the passive rules, so the passive suspension is $22,000 (not $30,000).
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate applies the at-risk limit but then treats active participation as making the rental loss fully deductible against nonpassive income. Because Nolan is not a real estate professional, the rental loss remains passive and only the $25,000 special allowance (subject to MAGI phaseout) can offset nonpassive income.
Why not C: Attractive because it recognizes the $25,000 special allowance and the $8,000 at-risk suspension, but it ignores the MAGI phaseout. At $130,000 MAGI the $25,000 allowance is reduced by 50% of $30,000 (the amount over $100,000), leaving only $10,000 deductible.
Question 6
Hint
Run the loss through the limitation regimes in the proper order, and do not forget that the rental real estate special allowance is reduced rather than eliminated at this AGI level.
Answer D. Apply the at-risk limitation first: because Lane's amount at risk is $18,000, $12,000 of the $30,000 loss is disallowed under the at-risk rules. Next apply the passive activity loss rules: the remaining $18,000 can offset $4,000 of passive income plus a $10,000 reduced rental real estate special allowance (the $25,000 allowance is reduced by 50% of the $30,000 excess over $100,000, i.e., $15,000), yielding a $14,000 current deduction and a $4,000 passive loss carryforward.
Why not A: This is tempting if the candidate correctly applies the at-risk limit but then stops there. It is wrong because the passive activity rules still apply after the at-risk test; Lane can only use $4,000 of passive income plus a reduced $10,000 special allowance, so $4,000 must remain suspended as a passive loss.
Why not B: This is tempting if the candidate mistakenly believes the special allowance disappears once modified AGI exceeds $100,000. In fact the allowance phases out between $100,000 and $150,000, so at $130,000 Lane still has a $10,000 special allowance in addition to the $4,000 of passive income.
Why not C: This choice applies the phased-down special allowance but ignores the $4,000 of passive income that also offsets passive loss and it also neglects that $12,000 is suspended under the at-risk rules before applying the passive activity limitation.
Question 7
Hint
Apply the limits in order: first determine how much loss is allowed under the at-risk rules, then consider whether any passive loss can be used currently under the rental real estate special allowance.
Answer A. Apply limits in order. Lara's at-risk amount for Year 1 is $18,000 + $6,000 = $24,000, so at-risk rules would allow up to $24,000 of the loss. As an active participant in rental real estate she is eligible for the $25,000 special allowance, but it is phased out by 50% of modified AGI over $100,000: reduction = 0.5 × ($130,000 − $100,000) = $15,000, so the allowance is $25,000 − $15,000 = $10,000. The deductible amount is the lesser of the at-risk-allowed amount and the phased special allowance, i.e., $10,000.
Why not B: Tempting because rental losses are generally passive, but Lara actively participates and therefore may qualify for the rental real estate special allowance. Her AGI reduces that allowance but does not eliminate it, so the deduction is not zero.
Why not C: This reflects the correct at-risk computation (beginning $18,000 + $6,000 contribution = $24,000) but ignores the passive activity special allowance and its AGI phaseout. The phased special allowance ($10,000) is smaller than $24,000 and governs the current deduction.
Why not D: This uses the full $25,000 special allowance without accounting for the AGI phaseout. At $130,000 modified AGI the allowance is reduced by $15,000 to $10,000; additionally, Lara's at-risk amount is only $24,000, so $25,000 cannot be supported.
Common questions
How do I calculate the rental loss allowance at $124,000 MAGI?
Subtract half the MAGI excess over $100,000 from $25,000: $25,000 − 50% × $24,000 = $13,000.
Can I subtract the rental loss before calculating the MAGI phaseout?
No. Use MAGI computed for the special allowance without the rental loss. Morgan uses $124,000, not $70,000.
What happens to the rental loss above the phased-out allowance?
With no passive income and sufficient basis and amount at risk, the excess is suspended under the passive activity rules. Morgan carries forward $41,000.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications), worked step by step.
At-Risk and Passive Activity Losses | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications)
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.