PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 7 practice questions

Rental Real Estate $25,000 Allowance MAGI Phaseout

The $25,000 rental real estate special allowance falls by $1 for every $2 of MAGI above $100,000. Below: a worked calculation showing how the phaseout limits an active participant's current rental loss deduction.

The ruleFor a single taxpayer eligible for the active-participation rental real estate special allowance, the maximum allowance is $25,000, reduced by 50% of MAGI above $100,000 and eliminated at $150,000.

Try one first

Jordan, a single taxpayer, owns 100% of a residential rental property directly. Jordan is not a real estate professional but does actively participate in the rental activity. At the start of Year 1, Jordan's amount at risk in the activity is $45,000, consisting of cash invested and qualified nonrecourse financing secured by the property. The activity generates a $60,000 loss in Year 1. Jordan's modified AGI for the passive loss rules, determined before the rental loss, is $130,000. Jordan has no other passive activities, no passive income, no prior suspended losses, and no disposition of the property in Year 1. What is the effect on Jordan's Year 1 deduction and suspended losses?
Hint

Apply the limitations in the correct order, and do not forget the modified AGI phaseout of the rental real estate special allowance.

Worked example

Morgan, a single taxpayer, owns 100% of a rental property and actively participates but is not a real estate professional. The rental produces a $54,000 loss. MAGI for the special allowance, computed without the rental loss, is $124,000. Morgan has sufficient basis and amount at risk to absorb the entire $54,000 loss. There is no other passive income, prior suspended loss, or disposition.

1MAGI above the phaseout threshold$124,000 − $100,000$24,000
2Allowance reduction50% × $24,000$12,000
3Available allowance and current deduction$25,000 − $12,000$13,000
4Suspended passive activity loss$54,000 − $13,000$41,000

Morgan deducts $13,000 currently and carries forward $41,000 as a suspended passive activity loss.

Check: Within the phaseout range, halve the distance to $150,000: ($150,000 − $124,000) ÷ 2 = $13,000.

Key points

  • Use MAGI for the special allowance, computed without the rental loss.
  • Active participation permits the special allowance; it does not make this rental activity nonpassive.
  • Each $2 of MAGI above $100,000 removes $1 of the allowance.

How the exam traps you

  • Deducting the full $25,000 because Morgan actively participates. Apply the MAGI phaseout. Morgan's allowance is only $13,000.
  • Subtracting the entire $24,000 MAGI excess, leaving a $1,000 allowance. Subtract only 50% of the excess: $12,000.

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Dana, a single taxpayer, actively participates in one rental real estate activity but is not a real estate professional. Dana has no prior-year suspended losses, no other rental activities, and $7,000 of passive income from an unrelated passive investment. Dana's modified AGI, determined without regard to any rental real estate loss, is $132,000. In Year 1, the rental activity generated a $46,000 loss. At the end of Year 1, Dana's relevant investment and financing in the rental activity is as follows:
ItemAmount
invested$6,000
bank debt for which Dana is personally liable$4,000
qualified nonrecourse financing from an unrelated commercial lender secured by the rental real estate (qualified nonrecourse financing generally means nonrecourse acquisition financing from an unrelated lender)$4,000
nonrecourse note payable to the seller of the property (seller nonrecourse financing generally does not qualify as qualified nonrecourse financing for at-risk purposes)$10,000
Assume all basis limitations are satisfied, the debt is otherwise bona fide, and no other limitations or elections apply. What is the most supportable amount of Dana's Year 1 rental loss deduction currently allowed?
Hint

Compute Dana's at-risk amount first, including only cash, personally liable debt, and qualified nonrecourse financing from unrelated lenders (seller nonrecourse financing generally does not count). Then compute passive-activity availability: passive income plus the phased $25,000 special allowance; the allowed current deduction is the lesser of the two results.

Question 3

Riley, a single taxpayer, owns a 25% interest in an LLC taxed as a partnership whose only activity is renting an apartment building. Riley actively participates (but does not materially participate) by approving tenant selection, rental terms, and major repair decisions. In Year 1, Riley contributed $20,000 cash. The LLC obtained $140,000 of qualified nonrecourse financing from an unrelated bank, secured only by the building, and Riley is allocated 25% of that debt. Riley's share of the Year 1 loss is $70,000. Before considering this loss, Riley's modified AGI is $130,000, Riley has no other passive income, and Riley has sufficient outside basis. Assume all requirements for qualified nonrecourse financing and for active participation are satisfied. Which factor ultimately governs the amount of Riley's Year 1 currently deductible loss from this activity?
Hint

Compute Riley's at‑risk cap first (include the qualified nonrecourse financing as stated), then compute the rental real estate special allowance after the MAGI phaseout; which numeric limit is smaller?

Question 4

In 20X5, Lee, a single taxpayer, did not materially participate in any trade or business activity and does not qualify as a real estate professional. Assume Lee has sufficient tax basis in each activity, no suspended losses from prior years, no dispositions, and no grouping elections. Lee's 20X5 items are as follows: - Alpha LP, an equipment-leasing limited partnership: current-year loss of $40,000; Lee's amount at risk immediately before applying the 20X5 loss is $18,000. - Beta rental property: current-year loss of $20,000; Lee actively participated in management decisions throughout the year, and Lee's amount at risk is sufficient. - Gamma LLC: passive income of $6,000. - Lee's modified AGI for purposes of the rental real estate special allowance, determined before any passive activity income or loss, is $130,000. What is the most supportable amount of loss Lee may deduct on the 20X5 individual return from these activities?
Hint

Apply the limitations in sequence: first determine how much loss survives the at-risk rules, then apply the passive activity limitation, including any phased-down rental real estate special allowance.

Question 5

In Year 1, Nolan, a single taxpayer, owns 100% of a residential rental activity. Nolan actively participates in management decisions but is not a real estate professional. The activity generated a $40,000 loss for Year 1. Nolan has no passive income from any other activity and no suspended losses from prior years. Nolan's modified AGI, computed without the rental loss, is $130,000. Before considering the Year 1 loss, Nolan is $32,000 at risk in the activity at year-end. Assuming no other limitations apply, which result is most appropriate for Nolan's Year 1 return?
Hint

Apply the limitations in sequence, and remember that active participation in a rental activity creates only a limited exception to the passive loss rules.

Question 6

In Year 1, Lane, a single taxpayer, owns 100% of a rental condominium activity. Lane actively participates in the rental activity but does not materially participate and is not a real estate professional. Lane's modified AGI for purposes of the rental real estate special allowance is $130,000 before considering any loss from the condo. The condo generates a $30,000 loss in Year 1. Lane's amount at risk in the condo activity immediately before applying the Year 1 loss is $18,000. Lane also has $4,000 of passive income from a separate limited partnership investment. Assume no grouping election, no suspended losses from prior years, and no other passive items. Which of the following is the best supported conclusion about Lane's Year 1 deduction and suspensions related to the condo loss?
Hint

Run the loss through the limitation regimes in the proper order, and do not forget that the rental real estate special allowance is reduced rather than eliminated at this AGI level.

Question 7

In Year 1, Lara, a single calendar-year taxpayer, owns 100% of a residential rental activity. She actively participates in management decisions but is not a real estate professional. Her modified AGI for purposes of the rental real estate special allowance, determined before considering the rental loss, is $130,000. Lara's at-risk amount in the activity at the start of Year 1 was $18,000, and she contributed an additional $6,000 cash during Year 1. The activity generated a $40,000 loss in Year 1. Lara has no other passive income or passive losses, and assume basis is not limiting. What is the most supportable amount of the Year 1 rental loss that Lara may deduct on her Year 1 return?
Hint

Apply the limits in order: first determine how much loss is allowed under the at-risk rules, then consider whether any passive loss can be used currently under the rental real estate special allowance.

Drill all 173 Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications) questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do I calculate the rental loss allowance at $124,000 MAGI?

Subtract half the MAGI excess over $100,000 from $25,000: $25,000 − 50% × $24,000 = $13,000.

Can I subtract the rental loss before calculating the MAGI phaseout?

No. Use MAGI computed for the special allowance without the rental loss. Morgan uses $124,000, not $70,000.

What happens to the rental loss above the phased-out allowance?

With no passive income and sufficient basis and amount at risk, the excess is suspended under the passive activity rules. Morgan carries forward $41,000.

Watch it solved

A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications), worked step by step.

At-Risk and Passive Activity Losses | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications)

All Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications) practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.