TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 9 practice questions
Nonrental Passive Losses: At-Risk Before Passive Activity Rules
After basis, apply the at-risk limit before the passive activity loss limit. Below: follow a nonrental partnership loss from its full amount to the current deduction and separate suspended amounts.
Try one first
Hint
Apply the loss limits in sequence, and keep track of which dollars are suspended under which rule.
Answer B. Apply the limitations in order: basis (already sufficient) then at-risk, then passive activity loss rules. The at-risk limit allows only $18,000 of the $30,000 loss to pass the at-risk test, so $12,000 is suspended under the at-risk rules. The $18,000 that survives the at-risk test is a passive loss and must be suspended because Reed has no passive income in Year 1. Therefore no part of the $30,000 is deductible in Year 1.
Why not A: This mistakes treating the at-risk outcome as automatically deductible. Even though $18,000 survives the at-risk test, that amount is still a passive loss and cannot be deducted without passive income; the $12,000 excess is suspended under the at-risk rules, not the passive-activity rules.
Why not C: This reflects the memory that passive losses are generally suspended, but it ignores the required ordering of limits. The at-risk rules suspend $12,000 first; only the $18,000 that survives at-risk reaches the passive-activity step and is suspended under the passive rules.
Why not D: This mixes a correct at-risk amount with two errors: the $18,000 is still a passive loss and is suspended without passive income, and the $12,000 suspended under the at-risk rules is not permanently disallowed, it can be allowed in later years if Reed's at-risk amount increases or upon disposition.
Step by step
- Read the facts
In Year 1, Lee, a passive investor in a retail partnership, has a $50,000 loss, $30,000 contributed cash, $20,000 allocated nonrecourse debt, and $20,000 of other passive income. Basis is sufficient; assume no personal liability, other amounts at risk, prior suspended losses, dispositions, or other relevant limits.
- Clear the basis limit
Apply the basis limitation first. Because Lee has sufficient basis, the full $50,000 loss reaches the at-risk test.
- Determine the amount at risk
Before applying the loss, Lee is at risk for the $30,000 cash contribution. The $20,000 nonrecourse retail business debt does not increase that amount.
- Cap the loss under Sec. 465
Only $30,000 of the $50,000 loss survives the at-risk limit. Suspend the $20,000 excess under the at-risk rules; it never reaches passive netting this year.
- Apply Sec. 469 next
Compare the surviving $30,000 passive loss with Lee's $20,000 of other passive income. Deduct $20,000 currently and suspend the remaining $10,000 under the passive activity loss rules.
- Keep the carryforwards separate
Record $20,000 as an at-risk carryforward and $10,000 as a passive activity loss carryforward. The $20,000 deduction plus those separate carryforwards accounts for the full $50,000 loss.
Key points
- Remember: passing the at-risk test lets a loss reach the passive test; it does not make the loss deductible.
- Sufficient partnership basis does not establish an equal amount at risk.
- Income from another passive activity can absorb the loss that survives the at-risk limit.
How the exam traps you
- Deducting $30,000 because that amount passes the at-risk test. Apply the passive limit next. Lee has only $20,000 of passive income.
- Classifying the entire $30,000 unused loss as passive-suspended. Separate $20,000 stopped by at-risk from $10,000 stopped by the passive rules.
- Including the $20,000 nonrecourse business debt in Lee's amount at risk. The retail partnership debt supports basis but does not increase Lee's amount at risk.
Question 2
Hint
Work through the limitations in the required order, and separate the portion stopped by the at-risk rules from the portion that reaches the passive activity rules.
Answer C. Loss limitations are applied in order: basis first (here sufficient), then at-risk, then passive activity. Only $20,000 of the $50,000 loss passes the at-risk limitation (so $30,000 is suspended under the at-risk rules). Of that $20,000 allowed by the at-risk rules, only $12,000 can be used currently because passive losses are deductible only to the extent of passive income, leaving $8,000 suspended under the passive activity rules.
Why not A: This treats the entire shortfall after deducting $12,000 as a passive suspension, but ignores the at-risk limitation: only $20,000 of the $50,000 loss is allowed under at-risk rules, so $30,000 is an at-risk suspension, not a passive suspension.
Why not B: This assumes the at-risk limit is applied but then misapplies the passive activity limitation: the $30,000 is suspended by the at-risk rules (it never reaches the passive-activity stage), and only $12,000 of the $20,000 that survives the at-risk limit can be deducted against Morgan's $12,000 passive income.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes that passive losses are entirely nondeductible. Morgan has $12,000 of net passive income from other activities, so $12,000 of the loss that survives the at-risk limitation is currently deductible.
Question 3
Hint
Compute Dana's at‑risk amount first (use only qualified lender nonrecourse in this fact pattern; exclude the seller‑financed note), then apply the active‑participation $25,000 special allowance reduced for MAGI above $100,000.
Answer C. Apply the at‑risk rules first. Dana's at‑risk amount is $20,000 (cash) + $15,000 (recourse bank debt) + $25,000 (qualified nonrecourse financing) = $60,000; the $30,000 seller-financed nonrecourse note does not increase at‑risk for this fact pattern. The $70,000 loss is therefore limited to $60,000 by the at‑risk rules, suspending $10,000 under Sec. 465. Of the $60,000 remaining, the active‑participation special allowance is $25,000 reduced by 50% of MAGI over $100,000 (50% of $20,000 = $10,000), so $15,000 is currently deductible and $45,000 is suspended as a passive loss.
Why not A: This counts the qualified nonrecourse financing toward at‑risk (correct) but fails to apply the MAGI phaseout of the $25,000 active‑participation allowance: with MAGI of $120,000 the $25,000 allowance is reduced by $10,000, leaving only $15,000 allowable now.
Why not B: Tempting because it applies the phased-down $25,000 active‑participation allowance but treats the seller‑financed nonrecourse note as increasing Dana's at‑risk amount so that no at‑risk suspension occurs; incorrect because, under the facts given, seller‑financed nonrecourse is not treated as qualified nonrecourse financing for at‑risk purposes, so $10,000 must be suspended under Sec. 465.
Why not D: This reflects mistakenly treating the rental as fully deductible once the at‑risk ceiling is applied (for example, as if Dana materially participated or were a real estate professional). Dana is not a real estate professional; active participation yields only the limited special allowance (subject to phaseout), so passive‑activity limits still suspend $45,000 after at‑risk adjustments.
Question 4
Hint
Apply the loss limitations in order, and keep track of which portion is blocked by each rule.
Answer C. Apply the at-risk rules first and then the passive activity loss rules. Hall's at-risk amount equals his $40,000 cash contribution, so $15,000 of the $55,000 allocated loss is disallowed by the at-risk rules and suspended (carried forward) until he increases his at-risk amount or disposes of the interest. The remaining $40,000 passes the at-risk test but is a passive loss; because Hall has no passive income or special allowance, that $40,000 is suspended under the passive activity loss rules and is not deductible in Year 1.
Why not A: This choice overlooks ordering: the at-risk rules apply before the passive activity loss rules. Only $40,000 reaches the passive loss stage; the $15,000 excess is separately limited by the at-risk rules.
Why not B: This is tempting because many candidates stop after identifying the at-risk amount. However, passing the at-risk test does not make the loss currently deductible if the activity is passive. With no passive income, the $40,000 that passes the at-risk test is still suspended under the passive activity loss rules.
Why not D: This mixes two errors. The $40,000 is not currently deductible because Hall has no passive income, and amounts limited by the at-risk rules are suspended and carried forward rather than permanently disallowed.
Question 5
Hint
Determine the amount Rowan is economically at risk for before looking at whether passive income can absorb the loss.
Answer A. The at-risk limitation is applied before the passive activity loss limitation. Rowan is at risk only for the $40,000 cash investment because Rowan is not personally liable for partnership debt and did not pledge other property. After limiting the loss to $40,000 under the at-risk rules, Rowan can deduct that entire $40,000 because Rowan has $50,000 of passive income from another activity.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often jump straight to the passive income number. But the at-risk rules must be applied first, and Rowan is only at risk for $40,000. Because the deductible loss is capped at $40,000 before the passive limitation is considered, Rowan cannot deduct $50,000.
Why not C: This choice reflects a common mistake of treating passive income as the only relevant limitation. Rowan has only $50,000 of passive income, not $70,000, and more importantly Rowan is at risk for only $40,000. The loss must be reduced to the at-risk amount before passive loss rules are applied.
Why not D: This distractor overstates the passive activity rules. Passive losses generally may offset passive income in the current year; a full disposition is relevant when suspended passive losses remain. Here, Rowan has passive income available, so the allowable loss after the at-risk limitation is currently deductible.
Question 6
Hint
Apply the two limitations in order: first determine how much loss is allowed by the amount at risk, then compare that result with available passive income.
Answer C. The at-risk rules are applied before the passive activity loss rules. Taylor's $45,000 loss is first limited to the $30,000 amount at risk. Because Taylor does not materially participate, the activity is passive, so the currently deductible loss is then limited to available passive income of $18,000. Therefore, Taylor may deduct $18,000 in Year 1.
Why not A: This is tempting because passive losses generally cannot offset nonpassive income. However, Taylor has $18,000 of passive income from another passive activity, so some of the loss can be deducted after applying the at-risk limit.
Why not B: This reflects applying only the at-risk limitation. Taylor is limited to $30,000 at risk, but because Taylor's involvement is passive the deductible amount is further limited to available passive income of $18,000.
Why not D: This ignores both limiting regimes. Taylor cannot deduct more than the amount at risk, and any at-risk-allowed loss is then subject to the passive activity loss rules since Taylor does not materially participate.
Question 7
Hint
Work through the loss limits in sequence rather than trying to net everything at once.
Answer C. Apply the limits in sequence. The at-risk rules cap the deductible loss at Jordan's $30,000 at-risk amount. Then the passive activity loss rules limit current deductibility to available passive income, which is $10,000. Thus Jordan may currently deduct $10,000; the remaining loss is suspended and carried forward subject to the rules.
Why not A: This ignores the statutory limits and assumes the full economic loss is deductible. Jordan is limited by at-risk rules and then by passive activity loss rules, so the full $50,000 is not currently deductible.
Why not B: This reflects only the at-risk ceiling. Even though $30,000 is the most Jordan could deduct under the at-risk rules, passive activity loss rules further limit current deductibility to the $10,000 of passive income.
Why not D: This likely comes from an incorrect netting or subtraction error. The correct procedure is sequential: first apply the at-risk limit ($30,000), then apply the passive activity limit (deductible only to the $10,000 passive income), not an arbitrary split leaving $20,000 current.
Question 8
Hint
Determine the maximum loss allowed by the at‑risk rules first, then limit current deduction by passive income, note which amounts become suspended under each rule.
Answer A. Apply the at‑risk rules first: Lee's amount at risk is $40,000, so only $40,000 of the $55,000 loss can be considered; the $15,000 excess (55−40) is suspended under the at‑risk rules. Next apply the passive activity loss rules: current passive losses are deductible only to the extent of passive income ($30,000), so $30,000 is deductible this year. The remaining $10,000 of the at‑risk‑allowed amount is suspended under the passive activity rules.
Why not B: Tempting because $40,000 is Lee's amount at risk (the maximum loss that can be considered). However, after the at‑risk limit is applied, the passive activity rules further limit the current deduction to passive income of $30,000, so only $30,000 is deductible this year.
Why not C: Tempting because it equals the partnership's reported loss, but it ignores the sequential limits: Lee is first limited to $40,000 by the at‑risk rules and then to $30,000 by the passive activity rules, so $55,000 is not deductible.
Why not D: Tempting because $15,000 equals the portion of the loss that exceeds Lee's at‑risk amount (55,000−40,000). But that $15,000 is the part suspended under the at‑risk rules, not the deductible amount; the deductible amount this year is limited to $30,000.
Question 9
Hint
Apply the limitations in order, and do not assume that the same suspended amount belongs under only one set of rules.
Answer A. Apply the limitations in sequence. Nina's outside tax basis ($60,000) exceeds her amount at risk ($25,000), so the at-risk rules limit the $40,000 loss to $25,000. Because Oak is a passive activity and Nina has only $10,000 of passive income elsewhere, she may currently deduct $10,000; $15,000 of the $25,000 is suspended under the passive activity loss rules. The other $15,000 (the portion exceeding her amount at risk) is suspended under the at-risk rules and can be used only if her at-risk amount increases or on a qualifying disposition.
Why not B: This stops after the at-risk calculation and ignores the passive activity loss rules. Even after the at-risk limit reduces the loss to $25,000, only passive losses up to Nina's $10,000 of passive income may be deducted currently.
Why not C: This gets the immediate deduction right but treats all remaining loss as passive-suspended. It ignores the fact that $15,000 of the original $40,000 is disallowed by the at-risk rules and is separately suspended until Nina's at-risk amount increases.
Why not D: This overstates the passive restriction: passive losses cannot offset nonpassive income, but they can offset passive income from other activities. Because Nina has $10,000 of passive income elsewhere, she may deduct $10,000 after applying the at-risk limitation.
Common questions
Do at-risk rules apply before passive activity loss rules?
Yes. Apply basis first, then at-risk, then passive activity rules. Lee's $50,000 loss falls to $30,000 under at-risk, then to a $20,000 current deduction under the passive rules.
How do I split at-risk and passive suspended losses?
Assign each portion to the rule that stops it first. Lee suspends $20,000 under at-risk and $10,000 under the passive rules, rather than combining them into one carryforward.
Does nonrecourse partnership debt increase the amount at risk?
Not for Lee's retail partnership debt. The $20,000 debt allocation supports tax basis, but Lee is at risk only for the $30,000 cash contribution.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications), worked step by step.
At-Risk and Passive Activity Losses | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications)
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.