TCP · Tax Compliance and Planning for Individuals and Personal Financial Planning · 6 practice questions
When Are Suspended Passive Losses Deductible After a Sale?
A fully taxable sale of an entire passive activity to an unrelated buyer releases its suspended passive losses. Below: follow Rowan's losses through the sale year, then see how selling only half changes the deduction.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the specific event that releases suspended passive losses, and note that the facts say no basis or at-risk limitation remains.
Answer C. When a taxpayer disposes of the entire interest in a passive activity in a taxable transaction with an unrelated party, suspended passive activity losses are released in the year of the disposition. Because the facts state that basis and at-risk limitations are not an issue, the suspended losses become deductible in Year 3. Once released by the qualifying disposition, those losses are not confined to offsetting only passive income and may reduce other types of income to the extent allowed.
Why not A: This is tempting because passive losses are normally limited to passive income, but a complete taxable disposition of the entire passive activity to an unrelated party releases suspended passive losses and they are deductible in full in the year of disposition.
Why not B: Some students may think the losses can only offset gain on the sale, but the release of suspended PALs on a qualifying disposition is not limited to the amount of gain; remaining suspended losses are deductible in the year of the disposition (subject to other non-PAL limitations).
Why not D: This distractor confuses reporting timing with the tax event. The triggering event is the Year 3 taxable sale of the partnership interest, not when a final K-1 is received.
The timeline
- Year 1Rowan incurs a $40,000 loss from a passive partnership activity.
Rowan has sufficient basis and amount at risk throughout. There is no passive income in Years 1 or 2. The full $40,000 is suspended solely under the passive activity rules. Assume no other loss limitations apply.
- Year 2The activity breaks even, and Rowan keeps the entire interest.
With no passive income and no disposition, Rowan deducts $0. The $40,000 remains suspended under the passive activity rules.
- Year 3: saleRowan sells the entire interest in a fully taxable transaction to an unrelated buyer.
The sale produces no recognized gain or loss. Rowan has no other passive income, and the activity has no Year 3 operating income or loss. All three disposition requirements are met.
- Year 3: tax returnRowan deducts the full $40,000 of suspended passive losses.
The qualifying sale releases the losses in Year 3. They may offset other income. Limiting the deduction to the $0 sale gain would incorrectly deny the entire deduction.
- Year 3: partial-sale comparisonChange only the portion sold: Rowan sells half rather than all of the interest.
Keep the same fully taxable transaction, unrelated buyer, no sale gain or loss, and no other passive income. The partial sale does not trigger full release: the deduction is $0 and $40,000 remains suspended. Treating any transfer as a full release would incorrectly allow $40,000.
Key points
- Remember: a qualifying sale releases suspended passive losses even when the sale produces no gain.
- Check all three requirements: entire activity, fully taxable transaction, and unrelated buyer.
- Deduct released losses in the sale year, not the following year.
How the exam traps you
- Allowing no deduction because Rowan has no passive income. The qualifying sale releases $40,000 that may offset other income.
- Limiting the deduction to sale gain, producing a $0 deduction. The sale has no gain, but the qualifying disposition still releases the full $40,000.
- Treating the half-interest sale as a full release and deducting $40,000. A partial sale does not trigger full release. With no gain or other passive income, the deduction is $0.
Question 2
| Item | Year 1 | Year 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Cash contribution by Avery | $30,000 | $10,000 |
| Avery personally liable for recourse bank debt | $20,000 | , |
| Activity ordinary income (loss) | ($90,000) | $20,000 |
| Passive income from other sources | $0 | $15,000 |
No distributions occur in either year.
At the end of Year 2, how much of Avery’s Year 1 loss remains suspended under the at-risk rules and under the passive activity rules, respectively?Hint
Track the Year 1 loss in two separate buckets, then apply the Year 2 facts in the correct order: at-risk first, passive second.
Answer D. Year 1 at-risk amount = $30,000 contribution + $20,000 recourse debt = $50,000, so $50,000 of the $90,000 loss was allowable for at-risk purposes and $40,000 was suspended under the at-risk rules. The $50,000 allowed by the at-risk test was still passive and was suspended at year-end because Avery had no passive income in Year 1. In Year 2, the $10,000 contribution plus $20,000 of activity income increases the amount at risk by $30,000, releasing $30,000 of the prior at-risk suspension (leaving $10,000 at-risk suspended). The $30,000 released joins the $50,000 previously suspended as passive losses, creating $80,000 of passive losses available in Year 2; passive income in Year 2 totals $20,000 (same activity) + $15,000 (unrelated) = $35,000, which is absorbed, leaving $80,000 - $35,000 = $45,000 suspended as passive losses.
Why not A: This reflects the common mistake of considering only the $10,000 new contribution when adjusting the at-risk amount and ignoring the $20,000 of activity income that also increases at-risk. It also fails to aggregate the prior passive suspension with any at-risk release before offsetting Year 2 passive income.
Why not B: This correctly computes the remaining at-risk carryforward but understates the passive suspension by failing to add the at-risk-released amount to the prior passive pool. The $50,000 that was passive-suspended from Year 1 plus any at-risk release in Year 2 form the passive-loss pool that is limited by Year 2 passive income.
Why not C: This overstates the at-risk release, the $10,000 contribution plus $20,000 income increases at-risk by $30,000, leaving $10,000 still suspended under at-risk. It also misapplies passive sequencing: the activity's $20,000 income and the $15,000 unrelated passive income reduce the passive carryforward by $35,000, not increase it.
Question 3
Hint
Apply the limitations in order, then ask what event actually turns a suspended passive loss into a currently deductible loss.
Answer D. Both the at-risk and passive-activity limitations can suspend losses. In Year 1 the entire $40,000 loss is suspended: $25,000 by the at-risk limitation (amount exceeding the $15,000 at risk) and the remaining $15,000 is prevented from current deduction by the passive-activity rules because Dana had no passive income. Dana's Year 2 $30,000 contribution restores the at-risk capacity for the $25,000 amount, but without passive income or a qualifying disposition of the entire interest the suspended passive losses are not deductible in Year 2.
Why not A: Tempting because the Year 2 contribution does cure the at-risk shortfall for the $25,000, but clearing the at-risk barrier does not, by itself, overcome the passive-activity limitation; without passive income or a qualifying disposition the loss remains suspended.
Why not B: This stops after the at-risk analysis. Even amounts that were within the at-risk limit can be suspended by the passive-activity rules when the taxpayer has no passive income; those suspended passive losses remain blocked until passive income or a disposition occurs.
Why not C: Although basis and at-risk capacity are important, they are separate from the passive-activity limitation; increasing at-risk does not convert suspended passive losses into current deductions absent passive income or a disposition of the entire interest.
Question 4
Hint
Work the loss through the limitation rules in order, and ask whether clearing the first limitation automatically clears the second.
Answer C. Apply the limits in order. The at‑risk limit reduced the Year 1 loss so only $10,000 was within Rowan's at‑risk amount while $30,000 was disallowed under the at‑risk rules; however, amounts that are within the at‑risk limit are still subject to the passive activity loss rules and were suspended because Rowan had no passive income. The $30,000 disallowed by at‑risk in Year 1 became allowable after the Year 2 contribution but remained a suspended passive loss; on the Year 3 complete taxable disposition to an unrelated party, suspended passive losses from the activity are deductible, so the entire $40,000 is deducted in Year 3.
Why not A: Tempting because the Year 2 contribution does restore at‑risk capacity, which allows the previously at‑risk‑disallowed $30,000 to be recognized for tax purposes; but even amounts that are allowable under the at‑risk test remain subject to the passive loss rules and cannot be deducted without passive income or a disposition.
Why not B: This treats the $10,000 that was within the at‑risk amount in Year 1 as currently deductible, but that $10,000 is still a passive loss and was suspended because Rowan had no passive income until the Year 3 disposition.
Why not D: This correctly notes that the at‑risk restriction is cleared by the Year 2 cash contribution, but restoring at‑risk capacity does not by itself make passive losses deductible when the taxpayer has no passive income; the suspension only lifts on a qualifying disposition.
Question 5
Hint
Work the limitations in order: first determine how much prior loss is released by Year 2 increases in amount at risk (include both contributions and allocable income), then apply Year 2 passive income to total passive losses.
Answer A. Apply the at-risk limitation first. The Year 2 increase in amount at risk equals the $6,000 cash contribution plus the $10,000 allocated income = $16,000, which releases $16,000 of the $18,000 previously suspended under the at-risk rules, leaving $2,000 still suspended under the at-risk rules. The $16,000 released is available as passive loss and combines with the prior $12,000 passive-suspended loss for $28,000 of passive losses; with only $10,000 of Year 2 passive income, $10,000 is used and $18,000 remains suspended under the passive activity rules.
Why not B: This reflects the error of assuming the entire $18,000 at-risk-suspended loss is released, so a candidate would combine $18,000 + $12,000 = $30,000 passive losses and subtract $10,000 passive income to get $20,000 passive suspended and $0 at-risk. That is incorrect because the at-risk increase is only $6,000 + $10,000 = $16,000, so $2,000 remains suspended under the at-risk rules.
Why not C: This matches the mistake of counting only the $10,000 allocated income (and not the $6,000 contribution) as increasing amount at risk: release = $10,000, leaving $8,000 at-risk suspended; passive losses = $12,000 + $10,000 = $22,000, and after $10,000 passive income $12,000 would remain suspended under passive rules. That is wrong because both the cash contribution and the allocated income increase the amount at risk, so the correct release is $16,000.
Why not D: This reflects the error of counting only the $6,000 cash contribution (and not the $10,000 income) as increasing amount at risk: release = $6,000, leaving $12,000 at-risk suspended; passive losses = $12,000 + $6,000 = $18,000, and after $10,000 passive income $8,000 would remain suspended under passive rules. That is incorrect because allocated income also increases amount at risk, so the release is $16,000.
Question 6
Hint
Follow the ordering of limitations (basis → at-risk → passive). Ask whether increasing the at-risk amount eliminates the passive suspension when there is still no passive income or disposition.
Answer D. Apply the limitations in order: basis, then at-risk, then passive activity. Year 1: basis is sufficient; at-risk limits deductible loss to $30,000 (so $20,000 is at-risk-suspended), and the $30,000 that passed the at-risk test is suspended under the passive-activity rules because Lee had no passive income. The Year 2 $10,000 contribution increases Lee's amount at risk and releases $10,000 of the at-risk suspension, but with no passive income or disposition that $10,000 remains nondeductible under the passive-activity rules, so no loss is deductible in Year 2.
Why not A: Tempting because increasing the amount at risk does release part of the at-risk suspension; however, any amount allowed by the at-risk rules is still subject to the passive-activity limitation. With no passive income or disposition the released $10,000 remains disallowed under the PAL rules.
Why not B: Tempting because $30,000 did pass the at-risk test in Year 1, but this ignores the passive-activity limitation. Amounts that pass the at-risk test can still be suspended under the passive rules when the taxpayer has no passive income or disposition.
Why not C: Tempting because a fully taxable disposition can release passive-suspended losses, but this overstates the position for at-risk suspensions. At-risk suspensions can be released by later increases in amount at risk; here such a release occurs but is blocked by the passive-activity limitation.
Common questions
What year can I deduct suspended passive losses after selling an activity?
Deduct them in the year of a fully taxable disposition of the entire activity to an unrelated party. Rowan's qualifying Year 3 sale releases the $40,000 in Year 3.
Can suspended passive losses exceed the gain on sale?
Yes. A qualifying disposition releases suspended passive losses even if the sale produces no recognized gain or loss. Rowan can deduct $40,000 despite having no sale gain.
Does selling part of a passive activity release suspended losses?
A partial sale does not trigger full release. In Rowan's half-interest comparison, no sale gain or other passive income exists, so the deduction is $0 and $40,000 remains suspended.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications), worked step by step.
At-Risk and Passive Activity Losses | CPA TCP Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Compliance for passive activity and at-risk loss limitations (excluding tax credit implications)
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.