PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 9 practice questions

When Do Tax Penalties Start After a Filing Extension?

A valid Form 4868 extends the time to file, not the time to pay. Follow one taxpayer from April 15 through late filing and payment to see when each penalty starts and stops.

The ruleA valid Form 4868 extends filing, not payment. In this scenario, failure-to-pay begins April 16 on the $8,000 unpaid balance; failure-to-file begins October 16 because the return remains unfiled after October 15.

Try one first

Jordan, a calendar-year individual, timely filed a valid automatic extension for Year 1, extending the filing due date from April 15, Year 2, to October 15, Year 2. Jordan paid none of the Year 1 tax by April 15, Year 2. Jordan filed the return on November 10, Year 2, and the return showed $12,000 of unpaid tax. Assume no reasonable cause, no fraud, no installment agreement, no notice-and-demand rate increase, no interest, and ignore any minimum late-filing penalty. Which is the correct treatment of the federal penalties under IRC Section 6651?
Hint

Separate the due date for filing from the due date for paying, then consider what happens in a month when both penalties apply.

The timeline

  1. April 15, Year 2Jordan files a valid Form 4868 and pays $12,000.

    Jordan's Year 1 tax is $20,000, leaving $8,000 unpaid. Payment is due today; filing is extended to October 15. Assume no reasonable cause or other penalty relief.

  2. April 16, Year 2Failure-to-pay begins on the unpaid $8,000.

    The original payment deadline has passed. Form 4868 does not postpone it.

  3. October 15, Year 2The extended filing deadline arrives.

    Jordan can still file on time today. Failure-to-pay is already running because the $8,000 remains unpaid.

  4. October 16, Year 2Failure-to-file begins because Jordan has not filed.

    The extended filing deadline has passed. Jordan now faces both penalties.

  5. October 20, Year 2Jordan files the return but does not pay the balance.

    Filing ends the failure-to-file period. Failure-to-pay continues because the $8,000 remains unpaid.

  6. December 3, Year 2Jordan pays the remaining $8,000.

    Payment ends the failure-to-pay period. Filing the return on October 20 did not end it.

Key points

  • Remember: An extension moves the filing deadline, but the payment deadline stays put.
  • Unpaid tax after April 15 does not trigger failure-to-file while the valid filing extension remains in effect.
  • Filing the return does not stop failure-to-pay while the balance remains unpaid.

How the exam traps you

  • Starting both penalties after October 15 because Jordan obtained an extension. Only filing moves to October 15. Failure-to-pay begins April 16.
  • Starting both penalties April 16 because Jordan still owes tax. The valid extension delays failure-to-file until October 16.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Lopez timely submitted a valid automatic six-month extension for her individual federal income tax return for Year 1. She did not pay her full Year 1 tax by the original due date, but she filed the completed return and paid the remaining balance on the extended due date. Assume no fraud and no other filing defects. For determining whether the federal failure-to-file penalty applies, which factor is most important?
Hint

Keep separate the rule for extra time to file from the rule for time to pay.

Question 3

Jordan properly obtained an automatic extension of time to file an individual federal income tax return for Year 1. Jordan expected to owe tax with the return but made no payment by the original April due date. Jordan then filed the return and paid the full balance due before the extended filing deadline. Assume the return was otherwise accurate and there was no reasonable cause relief. What is the primary federal tax compliance issue?
Hint

Separate the deadline to file the return from the deadline to pay the tax.

Question 4

Assume no fraud, no reasonable cause, and no payments made before the original due date. For Year 1, both Adams and Brown owe $8,000 of federal individual income tax due on April 15. - Adams timely filed a valid automatic extension to October 15, made no payment with the extension, and filed the return and paid the full $8,000 on October 20. - Brown did not request an extension and filed the return and paid the full $8,000 on June 20. Ignoring interest, which statement is most accurate about their combined failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties?
Hint

Track the filing deadline and the payment deadline separately, and remember that any part of a month counts as a month for these penalties.

Question 5

For Year 1, assume both taxpayers are calendar-year individuals. Each had unpaid income tax as of the original April due date, neither has reasonable cause or disaster relief, and any requested extensions were properly obtained. Reed timely filed a valid automatic extension, then filed the return and paid the remaining tax 20 days after the extended October due date. Shaw did not request an extension and filed and paid the remaining tax 20 days after the original April due date. For each taxpayer, when do the federal failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties begin to apply?
Hint

Treat the time-to-file and time-to-pay as separate deadlines, the automatic extension affects only the filing deadline.

Question 6

An individual taxpayer owed $10,000 of tax shown on the Year 1 return. No extension was filed. The taxpayer filed the return and paid the full $10,000 exactly three months after the original due date. Assume there was no reasonable cause, and ignore interest. What total federal late-filing and late-payment penalty will generally apply?
Hint

Focus on what happens to the monthly failure-to-file rate when the failure-to-pay penalty applies during the same months.

Question 7

Jordan, a calendar-year individual taxpayer, expects to owe federal income tax for Year 1. By April 15, Year 2, Jordan's records are incomplete, so Jordan timely submits Form 4868 requesting an automatic extension to file. Assume no special relief applies. Which response is still required by April 15?
Hint

Separate the deadline to file the return from the deadline to pay the tax.

Question 8

Taylor timely submitted a valid automatic 6-month extension for a Year 1 individual federal income tax return. By the original April due date, Taylor paid 70% of the ultimately reported Year 1 tax liability. Taylor filed a complete, nonfraudulent return before the extended due date, but the remaining balance was still unpaid as of the original April due date. Assume no reasonable-cause relief or other special exception applies. What is the best conclusion?
Hint

Separate the due date for filing the return from the due date for paying the tax.

Question 9

Morgan timely filed an individual federal income tax return for Year 1 on the original due date. The return was complete and accurate and showed $4,000 still due. Morgan paid only $1,000 with the return and paid the remaining $3,000 two months later. Assume no fraud, no reasonable-cause relief, and no estimated tax issue is being tested. Based on these facts, what is the primary federal penalty issue?
Hint

Separate the conduct in the facts: Was the problem filing late, paying late, or reporting inaccurately?

Drill all 134 Tax Compliance and Penalties questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does Form 4868 give me more time to pay my taxes?

No. Jordan's payment deadline stays April 15, so failure-to-pay begins April 16 on the unpaid $8,000.

When does failure-to-file start if I have an extension?

Jordan's valid extension moves the filing deadline to October 15. Failure-to-file begins October 16 because the return is still unfiled.

Does filing my return stop the late-payment penalty?

No. Jordan files on October 20, which ends the failure-to-file period. Failure-to-pay continues until the $8,000 is paid on December 3.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax Compliance and Penalties

All Tax Compliance and Penalties practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.