PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 9 practice questions

Individual Estimated Tax Safe Harbor: 90% vs. 100% or 110%

Compare 90% of current-year tax with the applicable 100% or 110% of prior-year tax, then choose the lower amount. Below: a numbers table finds the target for a joint return and compares it with timely prepayments.

The ruleWith installment timing satisfied, the required annual payment is the lesser of 90% of current-year tax or 100% of prior-year tax, increased to 110% when prior-year AGI exceeds $150,000 for joint filers. The prior-year benchmark requires a 12-month return.

Try one first

Jordan and Lee, married filing jointly, had AGI of $170,000 on their Year 1 return, which reported total tax of $82,000. For Year 2, their total tax will be $98,000. During Year 2 they made four equal, timely estimated tax payments totaling $85,000. In addition, $4,000 of federal income tax was withheld from Lee's December Year 2 bonus. Assume no credits, no annualized income installment method election, and no waiver applies. For purposes of the individual estimated tax penalty under IRC §6654, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

First compare 90% of current‑year tax with the applicable prior‑year safe‑harbor (100% or 110% depending on prior‑year AGI); then treat wage withholding as ratably applied across the installment periods when checking whether each required installment was met.

Numbers to know

Prior-year return periodJordan and Lee file jointly. Their Year 1 return covered a full year, so the prior-year benchmark is available.12 months
Prior-year AGIUse Year 1 AGI to select the percentage applied to Year 1 tax.$170,000
Joint-filer threshold for 110%The threshold must be exceeded. Exactly $150,000 does not trigger 110% for joint filers.Over $150,000
Standard prior-year percentageApplies to joint filers whose prior-year AGI is $150,000 or less. It does not apply here.100%
Applicable prior-year percentageTheir $170,000 prior-year AGI exceeds the threshold. Apply this percentage to prior-year tax, not current-year tax.110%
Prior-year total taxTax shown on their Year 1 return.$82,000
Prior-year benchmark110% × $82,000 = $90,200.$90,200
Current-year total taxTotal Year 2 tax before subtracting prepayments.$98,000
Current-year percentageApply this percentage to Year 2 tax.90%
Current-year benchmark90% × $98,000 = $88,200.$88,200
Required annual paymentChoose the lesser of $88,200 and $90,200.$88,200
Qualifying prepaymentsThe $89,000 of prepayments satisfied installment timing requirements. No special exceptions apply.$89,000
Prepayments above the target$89,000 − $88,200 = $800. They meet the standard safe harbor, so no estimated tax underpayment penalty applies.$800
Remaining tax due$98,000 − $89,000 = $9,000. A balance due does not undo safe-harbor protection.$9,000

Key points

  • Remember: 110% raises only the prior-year benchmark; it never forces you to choose the higher benchmark.
  • Choose the target before comparing prepayments; missing one benchmark does not mean missing the safe harbor.
  • Safe-harbor protection prevents an estimated tax underpayment penalty; it does not erase the remaining $9,000 tax bill.

How the exam traps you

  • Choosing the $90,200 prior-year benchmark because prior-year AGI exceeds $150,000. Use the lower benchmark: $88,200, not $90,200. High AGI changes the prior-year percentage, not the lesser-of rule.
  • Treating $82,000 as the required annual payment. Wrong: min($88,200, $82,000) = $82,000. At $170,000 prior-year AGI, use 110%: min($88,200, $90,200) = $88,200.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Assume both taxpayers are unmarried, calendar-year individuals who each filed a 12-month federal return for Year 1. In Year 2, all tax payments consisted of withholding treated as paid ratably throughout the year and equal quarterly estimated tax payments made on each due date. Ignore interest and any waiver or exception other than the standard estimated tax safe harbors. Which conclusion is most accurate regarding protection from the Year 2 federal estimated tax underpayment penalty? Taxpayer A:
PeriodAgiYear 1 Total TaxYear 2 Total TaxYear 2 withholding and timely estimated payments
Year 1$120,000$18,000$26,000$19,000
Year 1$220,000$18,000$20,000$18,500
Hint

Apply the lesser-of safe harbor separately to each taxpayer. The high-AGI rule changes the prior-year benchmark, but it does not replace the 90%-of-current-year test.

Question 3

Casey, an individual taxpayer, had no federal income tax liability for Year 1 and was a U.S. citizen for all of Year 1. Casey expects substantial taxable income in Year 2 and wants to rely on the no-prior-year-tax-liability exception to the federal estimated tax underpayment penalty. Which additional condition must be met for that exception to apply?
Hint

Focus on the special exception for a taxpayer with zero prior-year tax liability, and separate it from the other estimated-tax safe harbors and exceptions.

Question 4

In December 20X5, Lee realizes that his federal income tax for the year will be much higher than expected because of consulting income earned fairly evenly throughout 20X5. He has a salaried job with one remaining paycheck in late December. His first three estimated tax payments were timely but too low. Lee can either (1) make a large fourth-quarter estimated tax payment now or (2) submit a revised Form W-4 so that the same additional amount is withheld from his final December paycheck. Assume no special waiver applies and Lee will not use the annualized income installment method. If Lee's goal is to minimize any 20X5 federal individual underpayment penalty, what is the best action?
Hint

Focus on how the IRS treats the timing of withholding versus the timing of estimated tax payments for underpayment-penalty purposes.

Question 5

For Year 1, Mason, an individual taxpayer, had a total federal income tax liability of $24,000. Through withholding, $18,000 was deemed paid by April 15, Year 2. Mason did not request an extension. On April 15, Year 2, Mason made an additional $2,000 payment but did not file the return. Mason filed the return and paid the remaining balance on June 10, Year 2. Assume Mason had no reasonable cause, the return was required to be filed on April 15, Year 2, and only the IRC failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties are considered. Ignore interest. What is the most supportable total penalty amount?
Hint

First identify the amount still unpaid on the original due date. Then count the months or parts of months late and remember how the two penalties interact when they apply at the same time.

Question 6

Diaz, a single taxpayer, had adjusted gross income of $170,000 in Year 1. Diaz's Year 1 federal income tax liability was $20,000, and the Year 1 return covered a full 12-month period. In Year 2, Diaz's total federal income tax liability is $32,000. Through withholding and timely estimated tax payments, Diaz prepaid $23,000 during Year 2. Assume those prepayments are treated as made evenly throughout the year, Diaz makes no annualized income installment election, and Diaz pays the remaining $9,000 with a timely filed Year 2 return. Which conclusion is best supported regarding Diaz's federal estimated tax underpayment penalty for Year 2?
Hint

Compare the current-year 90% test with the prior-year safe harbor, and pay attention to the higher-income percentage.

Question 7

Lane, a calendar-year single taxpayer, had 20X5 AGI of $190,000 and a 20X5 federal income tax liability of $16,000 on a properly filed return. For 20X6 Lane's total federal income tax liability is $20,000. Lane made no estimated tax payments during 20X6. Through November 30 only $1,000 had been withheld from wages, and an additional $16,600 was withheld from a December bonus, for total 20X6 withholding of $17,600. Assume Lane does not use the annualized income installment method and did not establish actual withholding dates. Which conclusion is most accurate regarding Lane's 20X6 estimated underpayment penalty?
Hint

Identify which prior-year safe-harbor percentage applies given Lane's prior-year AGI, and recall how wage withholding is allocated for estimated-tax purposes absent elections.

Question 8

Jordan and Riley, married filing jointly, filed a full 12-month Year 1 federal income tax return showing total tax of $40,000 and adjusted gross income of $180,000. For Year 2, they expect their total federal income tax to be $52,000. Assume no special exceptions apply, and assume amounts paid in through withholding and estimated tax payments are made in time and in a manner that satisfies the installment timing rules. What is the minimum amount they must pay in during Year 2 to satisfy the standard safe harbor and avoid an estimated tax underpayment penalty?
Hint

Compute both safe-harbor amounts before choosing. Then check whether the prior-year percentage is 100% or 110%.

Question 9

In Year 1, Rina, a single filer, had adjusted gross income of $220,000 and total tax of $18,000 on a timely filed federal return. For Year 2 she expects total tax of $30,000. During Year 2, $3,600 of federal income tax will be withheld from her wages, and she made three timely estimated tax payments of $4,050 each on the first three installment due dates. Assume Rina does not use the annualized income installment method and that withholding is treated as paid ratably during the year. If Rina makes an additional estimated tax payment on the January 15, Year 3 due date (treated as the fourth installment for Year 2), what minimum payment must she make by that date to avoid an underpayment penalty for Year 2?
Hint

First determine which safe-harbor applies using the prior-year AGI threshold, compare that amount to 90% of expected current-year tax, and then subtract withholding and the estimates already paid.

Drill all 134 Tax Compliance and Penalties questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Do I have to pay 110% if my prior-year AGI exceeds $150,000?

For joint filers, that AGI makes the prior-year benchmark 110% of prior-year tax. You may still use 90% of current-year tax if it is lower, as it is here.

Does the 110% safe harbor apply at exactly $150,000 of prior-year AGI?

Not for joint filers. The higher percentage applies only when prior-year AGI exceeds $150,000; at exactly $150,000, use 100% of prior-year tax.

Can I owe tax with my return and still avoid an estimated tax penalty?

Yes. Jordan and Lee still owe $9,000, but their $89,000 of timely prepayments exceeds the $88,200 required annual payment.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax Compliance and Penalties

All Tax Compliance and Penalties practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.