REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 6 practice questions
Can't Pay Taxes by April 15? File or Extend on Time
File on time even if you cannot pay in full; an extension postpones filing, not payment. Below, compare responses to a completed return with only enough cash to pay part of the tax.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the filing deadline from the payment deadline, and think about which action usually limits the most serious avoidable penalty exposure.
Answer D. File the return on time to avoid the generally larger failure-to-file penalty and preserve compliance. Paying as much as possible by the due date reduces the unpaid balance on which interest and the failure-to-pay penalty accrue. If Jordan cannot pay in full, timely filing plus contacting the IRS to arrange a payment plan (for example, an installment agreement or other payment options) is typically the most penalty-minimizing approach.
Why not A: This incorrectly conflates filing and paying: filing late can trigger a heavier penalty than paying late, so delaying filing until payment is available typically increases total penalties and is not the best compliance move.
Why not B: Tempting because extensions feel like extra time, but an automatic extension generally extends only the time to file, not the time to pay; interest and failure-to-pay penalties begin accruing from the original due date.
Why not C: Tempting if a taxpayer waits for a notice, but penalties and interest accrue from the tax due date regardless of whether the IRS has issued a bill; paying nothing by the due date increases total charges compared with paying what you can on time.
What should you do?
The situation
Mia has completed her federal income tax return. The return and $9,000 balance are due April 15. She can pay $4,000 by that date but cannot pay in full. Assume no fraud or special deadline relief. Which response best limits penalties and interest?
File by April 15, pay $4,000, and arrange payment of the remaining $5,000.
Best Timely filing avoids failure-to-file penalties. Paying $4,000 reduces the balance accruing late-payment penalties and interest to $5,000.
Request a valid extension, pay $4,000 by April 15, and file by the extended deadline.
Acceptable Valid, but unnecessary because the return is complete. The extension changes filing time, not the $5,000 payment obligation.
Pay $4,000 now, but wait to file until the remaining $5,000 is available.
Wrong Partial payment reduces the unpaid balance but does not postpone filing. Waiting can trigger the harsher failure-to-file penalty.
Request an extension and postpone all payment until the extended deadline.
Wrong An extension does not extend payment time. Leaving $9,000 unpaid increases exposure compared with paying the available $4,000.
File by April 15, but wait for an IRS bill before paying.
Wrong A bill does not start the clock. Late-payment penalties and interest generally accrue from the original payment deadline.
Key points
- Remember: Filing and paying are separate obligations; not having the cash is no reason to miss the filing deadline.
- Paying $4,000 leaves $5,000 exposed to interest and late-payment penalties, rather than the full $9,000.
- A valid extension postpones filing, not payment. Filing after the extended deadline generally starts failure-to-file penalties from that deadline.
How the exam traps you
- Waiting to file until the entire tax balance is available. File on time even without full payment. Delay can add the larger failure-to-file penalty.
- Treating a filing extension as extra time to pay. Pay the available $4,000 by April 15 even if requesting an extension.
- Treating an IRS bill as the payment deadline. Pay available cash by April 15. Interest and late-payment penalties generally start before any bill arrives.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the taxpayer relied on a professional for a legal tax conclusion or simply relied on the professional to meet a deadline.
Answer D. Reasonable cause may exist when a taxpayer, after fully disclosing all relevant facts to a tax professional, reasonably relies on the professional's advice on a substantive tax-law question (for example, whether a return is legally required). That type of reliance is different from merely delegating the ministerial task of filing. Prompt correction after learning of the error and the absence of fraud support good faith but do not by themselves control whether the original failure was reasonable.
Why not A: Lack of bad intent is relevant to whether the failure was willful, but absence of intent alone does not satisfy the reasonable-cause standard, actual, reasonable reliance on substantive professional advice after full disclosure is the governing factor here.
Why not B: Tempting because hiring a qualified preparer matters in penalty cases, but simply retaining a CPA or expecting the preparer to meet the deadline does not by itself establish reasonable cause, the duty to file is generally nondelegable absent substantive reliance on legal advice after full disclosure.
Why not C: Prompt correction supports good faith and may mitigate penalties, but it does not determine whether the initial failure to file was reasonable; the key issue is the nature of the taxpayer's reliance before the due date.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the tax law treats the filing deadline and the payment deadline the same way.
Answer A. Timely filing the return or obtaining a valid extension avoids the late-filing penalty, which can be more severe than the late-payment penalty. Paying as much as possible by the original due date reduces late-payment penalties and interest because an extension to file does not extend the time to pay.
Why not B: This distractor reflects the common mistake of treating an extension as extra time to pay. A valid extension generally extends only the time to file the return, not the time to pay; Dana should still pay as much as she reasonably can by the original due date.
Why not C: This is tempting because many taxpayers assume they should not file until they can pay in full. However, inability to pay does not extend the filing deadline, and waiting can create avoidable late-filing penalties.
Why not D: Doing nothing until the IRS sends a notice delays both filing and payment, increasing penalties and interest. The better approach is to file or extend on time and then address the unpaid balance.
Question 4
Hint
Think separately about stopping additional penalty accrual (what to file/pay now) and the administrative scope of first-time abatement (which penalties it typically covers and how prior penalties are treated).
Answer A. Filing immediately stops additional failure-to-file penalty accrual; paying the balance or promptly arranging payment addresses continuing failure-to-pay exposure. First-time abatement is an administrative, one-time relief that can apply to failure-to-file and failure-to-pay penalties when the taxpayer meets the qualifying penalty-history criteria. A prior assessed estimated tax penalty does not automatically bar an FTA request, but underpayment/estimated-tax penalties generally require separate analysis. Given these facts, the most effective sequence is to file, pay or arrange payment, then seek FTA after assessment.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates overstate IRS timing requirements for payment. Wrong because delaying filing allows failure-to-file penalties to continue accruing; filing now and paying or promptly arranging payment is the stronger sequence and FTA does not generally require payment in full before filing to later request relief.
Why not C: Attractive because it recognizes FTA for FTF/FTP and the clean history, but wrong because underpayment/estimated-tax penalties are not routinely abated under the same FTA administrative policy and typically require separate consideration or a different relief route.
Why not D: Tempting because reasonable-cause relief is available and some assume prior penalties categorically bar FTA. Wrong because an assessed estimated tax penalty does not automatically render a taxpayer ineligible for FTA, and ordinary moving-related disorganization is often a weaker reasonable-cause showing; the more effective immediate step is to file and address payment, then pursue FTA or reasonable-cause relief as appropriate.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the filing deadline from the payment deadline, and think about which step reduces each penalty.
Answer C. A timely extension extends only the time to file, not the time to pay. Paying the available $2,500 by the original due date reduces the unpaid balance that accrues interest and failure-to-pay penalties, and a filed extension prevents the failure-to-file penalty provided the completed return is submitted by the extended due date.
Why not A: This correctly identifies the need for an extension to avoid the failure-to-file penalty but incorrectly assumes the extension delays payment. Tax is still due by the original due date, so making no payment when $2,500 is available increases failure-to-pay exposure and interest.
Why not B: Although the missing K-1 is a real information gap, it does not automatically excuse missing the filing deadline. Waiting without requesting an extension exposes the taxpayer to the failure-to-file penalty.
Why not D: Partial payment reduces the amount subject to late-payment penalties but does not substitute for a filed return or a valid extension. Without a timely extension the taxpayer risks failure-to-file penalties if the return is filed after the original due date.
Question 6
Hint
Think separately about the due date for filing the return and the due date for paying the tax.
Answer A. Filing on time avoids the failure-to-file penalty, which is generally more severe than the failure-to-pay penalty. Paying as much as possible by the due date reduces the unpaid balance subject to penalties and interest. The taxpayer can then work with the IRS (for example, by requesting a payment plan) to address the remaining balance.
Why not B: This is tempting because many confuse an extension to file with an extension to pay. It is wrong because an extension to file does not extend the time to pay; delaying payment increases late-payment penalties and interest.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that filing and paying must happen together. It is wrong because failing to file on time can trigger the failure-to-file penalty, which is typically larger than the failure-to-pay penalty.
Why not D: Although timely filing is correct, making no payment when some payment is possible unnecessarily leaves a larger unpaid balance that accrues penalties and interest before any IRS billing or collection actions.
Common questions
Should I file my tax return if I cannot pay?
Yes. Mia should file on time, pay the available $4,000, and arrange payment of the remaining $5,000.
Does a tax extension give me more time to pay?
No. A valid extension moves the filing deadline, but any tax Mia leaves unpaid remains due April 15.
When do late-filing penalties start if I have an extension?
If Mia files after the extended deadline, failure-to-file penalties generally run from that deadline, not April 15. The extension does not postpone interest or late-payment penalties.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax Compliance and Penalties
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.