REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 10 practice questions
S Corporation Property Distributions: Gain Before Stock Basis
An S corporation's gain on distributed appreciated property increases shareholder stock basis before the distribution is tested. Below, change one fact at a time to see how that order controls additional shareholder gain.
Try one first
Hint
Work in sequence: first determine the corporation-level effect of distributing appreciated property, then update the shareholder's stock basis before testing whether the distribution itself creates gain.
Answer C. When an S corporation distributes appreciated property, the corporation recognizes gain as if it sold the property at its fair market value; here Slate recognizes $50,000 - $20,000 = $30,000 of gain. That $30,000 flows through to Reed and increases his stock basis from $30,000 to $60,000. Reed then takes a $50,000 basis in the distributed land and reduces his stock basis by $50,000, leaving $10,000; the distribution itself therefore produces no additional shareholder-level gain.
Why not A: This reflects two common mistakes: that an S corporation never recognizes gain on distribution of appreciated property and that the shareholder always takes the corporation's carryover basis. In fact, Slate recognizes the $30,000 gain which flows through to Reed, and the shareholder's basis in distributed property is its FMV, not Slate's adjusted basis.
Why not B: This is tempting because the land's $50,000 FMV exceeds Reed's original $30,000 stock basis by $20,000. However, the corporate-level $30,000 gain increases Reed's stock basis to $60,000 before the distribution; the $50,000 distribution therefore does not exceed his adjusted basis and does not generate an additional shareholder-level gain.
Why not D: This choice correctly identifies the corporate-level pass-through gain but then incorrectly applies a carryover basis rule to the distributed property. The shareholder takes a $50,000 (FMV) basis in the land, and the stock basis is reduced by $50,000, not by the corporation's $20,000 adjusted basis.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Reed owns all of Slate, an S corporation with no accumulated E&P. Reed begins Year 1 with $30,000 stock basis. Slate's only Year 1 transaction is a nonliquidating distribution of land to Reed. The land has a $20,000 adjusted tax basis and $50,000 FMV, with no liabilities. Assume no special taxes apply.
Answer: Slate recognizes $30,000 of gain, which passes through to Reed. Reed recognizes no additional distribution gain and ends with $10,000 stock basis.
Slate's gain is $50,000 minus $20,000, or $30,000. Reed first increases stock basis to $60,000. The $50,000 distribution then reduces stock basis to $10,000 without creating additional gain.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Reed's beginning stock basis is $10,000 instead of $30,000.
Answer: Slate recognizes $30,000 of gain. Reed recognizes $10,000 of additional capital gain and ends with zero stock basis.
The $30,000 pass-through raises stock basis to $40,000. The $50,000 distribution exceeds that basis by $10,000.
Change 2The land's adjusted tax basis is $40,000 instead of $20,000.
Answer: Slate recognizes $10,000 of gain. Reed recognizes $10,000 of additional capital gain and ends with zero stock basis.
Less appreciation means a smaller basis increase: $30,000 + $10,000 = $40,000. The $50,000 distribution exceeds that basis by $10,000.
Change 3The land's adjusted tax basis is $10,000 instead of $20,000.
Answer: Slate recognizes $40,000 of gain. Reed recognizes no additional distribution gain and ends with $20,000 stock basis.
More appreciation creates a larger basis increase: $30,000 + $40,000 = $70,000. Subtracting the $50,000 distribution leaves $20,000.
Key points
- Remember: Add the corporate gain to stock basis before subtracting the property's FMV.
- Corporate gain equals the property's FMV minus its adjusted tax basis.
- Only the distribution amount exceeding adjusted stock basis creates additional shareholder capital gain.
- Ending stock basis cannot fall below zero.
How the exam traps you
- Comparing the distribution with beginning stock basis. Increase stock basis by the pass-through gain before testing the distribution.
- Reducing stock basis by the land's tax basis. Use the land's FMV as the distribution amount.
- Treating corporate gain and additional distribution gain as the same amount. Calculate corporate gain first, then separately test for an excess distribution.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer C. Correct. Stock basis becomes $60,000 before the $50,000 distribution, leaving $10,000.
Why not A: Incorrect. Distributing appreciated land triggers corporate gain, which increases Reed's stock basis.
Why not B: Incorrect. This tests the distribution against beginning basis without adding the pass-through gain.
Why not D: Incorrect. This subtracts the land's $20,000 tax basis rather than its $50,000 FMV.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. Adjusted stock basis is $40,000, so the $50,000 distribution creates $10,000 additional gain.
Why not A: Incorrect. Reed now starts with only $10,000 basis, not $30,000.
Why not C: Incorrect. Slate must recognize the land's $30,000 appreciation and pass it through.
Why not D: Incorrect. This ignores the $30,000 basis increase when calculating additional distribution gain.
Question 3
Answer D. Correct. Corporate gain raises stock basis to $40,000, leaving a $10,000 excess distribution.
Why not A: Incorrect. The higher land tax basis reduces corporate gain to $10,000.
Why not B: Incorrect. The $10,000 pass-through increases stock basis before the distribution is tested.
Why not C: Incorrect. Stock basis cannot absorb the full distribution; the $10,000 excess creates capital gain.
Question 4
Answer A. Correct. The $40,000 gain raises stock basis to $70,000; the distribution leaves $20,000.
Why not B: Incorrect. This compares FMV with beginning stock basis and ignores the pass-through increase.
Why not C: Incorrect. This retains the base scenario's gain despite the lower land tax basis.
Why not D: Incorrect. This reduces stock basis by the land's tax basis instead of its FMV.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the corporation's gain-recognition rule from the shareholder's later sale or stock-basis consequences.
Answer D. Under the general corporate distribution rule (IRC §311), a corporation recognizes gain on a nonliquidating distribution of appreciated property as if the property had been sold at its fair market value on the distribution date. Here the land has a built-in gain of $30,000 (FMV $70,000 minus basis $40,000), so Maple recognizes that $30,000 gain in Year 2 when it distributes the land. That recognized gain is reported by the S corporation and flows through to the shareholder, generally increasing the shareholder's taxable income and stock basis.
Why not A: This distractor mixes distribution-ordering and dividend-character issues (where E&P matters) with the separate rule that a corporation recognizes gain on distributing appreciated property. Recognition of the corporation's gain on distribution does not depend on having prior C corporation E&P.
Why not B: Tempting because students often think the shareholder's sale is the taxable event, but the corporation itself recognizes gain on distributing appreciated property at the time of distribution, not only when the shareholder later sells.
Why not C: This distractor confuses shareholder-level basis rules with corporate-level gain recognition. The shareholder's stock basis affects the shareholder's tax consequences, but it does not prevent the S corporation from recognizing gain when it distributes appreciated property.
Question 3
Hint
Treat the appreciated-property distribution as creating two separate tax effects: one at the S corporation level and one at the shareholder distribution level.
Answer B. Pine recognizes a $20,000 gain on the distribution (FMV $30,000 less basis $10,000), and that gain passes through to Holt, increasing Holt's stock basis from $5,000 to $25,000. The distribution is measured at the land's $30,000 FMV and reduces Holt's basis to zero. The $5,000 excess of the distribution over Holt's basis is the gain Holt recognizes on the nonliquidating distribution.
Why not A: Tempting because many S-corp distributions are tax-free to the extent of stock basis, but here the $20,000 pass-through gain raises basis only to $25,000, which is still less than the $30,000 distribution, leaving taxable excess.
Why not C: This is the gain recognized by Pine on the appreciated-property distribution, but that corporate-level gain passes through and increases Holt's basis rather than being the shareholder-level gain on the distribution itself.
Why not D: This result would follow from subtracting Holt's beginning basis ($5,000) from the distribution FMV ($30,000) while ignoring the $20,000 basis increase from the pass-through gain; under S-corp rules the basis increase is applied before testing distributions.
Question 4
Hint
Analyze the corporation and the shareholder separately, and remember the ordering of stock-basis adjustments for an S corporation distribution.
Answer A. An S corporation recognizes gain on a nonliquidating distribution of appreciated property as if it sold the property at fair market value. Oak recognizes $40,000 of gain ($70,000 FMV − $30,000 basis), and that pass-through gain increases Lane's stock basis from $50,000 to $90,000 before the distribution is applied. The $70,000 distribution then reduces Lane's stock basis to $20,000, so Lane recognizes no shareholder-level gain, and Lane's basis in the land is its $70,000 FMV.
Why not B: This is tempting because the distribution amount exceeds Lane's pre-distribution stock basis, but it ignores that Oak recognizes corporate-level gain on distributing appreciated property and that the recognized gain is passed through and increases Lane's stock basis before the distribution is applied.
Why not C: This correctly identifies the corporate-level gain but errs on the shareholder side: the pass-through gain increases Lane's basis to $90,000 before the distribution, so the $70,000 distribution does not exceed basis and does not create shareholder-level gain.
Why not D: This distractor confuses dividend treatment with the separate rule that an S corporation recognizes gain on distributing appreciated property; it also incorrectly applies a carryover basis to the shareholder. In this situation Oak recognizes gain and the shareholder's basis in the distributed property is its FMV.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the corporation's tax consequence from the shareholder's distribution consequence, then apply the stock-basis ordering carefully.
Answer A. When an S corporation distributes appreciated property in a nonliquidating distribution, the corporation recognizes gain as if it sold the property for fair market value. Pine recognizes a $19,000 long-term capital gain ($28,000 FMV − $9,000 basis), which passes through to Diaz and increases his stock basis. Diaz's basis becomes $45,000 ($20,000 + $6,000 ordinary income + $19,000 LTCG) and is then reduced by the $28,000 FMV of the property distributed, leaving $17,000; because the distribution does not exceed his adjusted basis, he recognizes no shareholder-level gain.
Why not B: This treats the distribution as taxable at the shareholder level without recognizing that the S corporation must recognize the built-in gain on the appreciated property. That corporate gain passes through to the shareholder and increases stock basis before applying the distribution reduction, so there is no $2,000 shareholder distribution gain and the basis does not drop to zero.
Why not C: This reflects the mistake of reducing stock basis by the corporation's adjusted basis in the land ($9,000) instead of by the fair market value of the distributed property. For a noncash distribution, the shareholder's basis is reduced by the value of the distribution (FMV here), not by the corporation's basis in the asset.
Why not D: This result arises from an ordering error: treating the distribution as occurring before the corporation's recognized gain increases the shareholder's basis. The correct ordering treats the S corporation's gain as a pass-through item that increases stock basis before reducing basis for the distribution.
Question 6
Hint
First determine any corporate gain on the distributed property and adjust AAA and the shareholder's basis for that gain; then apply the S‑corporation distribution‑ordering rules.
Answer D. Oak recognizes a $3,000 gain on the distributed land (FMV $10,000 − basis $7,000). That gain flows through, increasing AAA to $8,000 ($5,000 + $3,000) and increasing the shareholder's basis to $7,000 ($4,000 + $3,000) before applying distribution ordering. The $14,000 distribution is applied first to AAA: $7,000 reduces basis to zero and $1,000 of the AAA is capital gain; the remaining $6,000 is a dividend from accumulated C‑year E&P.
Why not A: Tempting because the corporation has accumulated C‑year E&P and one might (incorrectly) treat the entire distribution as a dividend. It fails because S‑corporation distributions are applied to AAA (including current recognized gain) before any remaining amounts are treated as dividends to the extent of accumulated E&P; only $6,000, not the full $14,000, is a dividend here.
Why not B: Tempting because it uses the beginning AAA of $5,000 (ignoring the $3,000 corporate gain) and then treats the remaining $9,000 as a dividend. It fails because the corporation recognizes the $3,000 gain, which raises AAA to $8,000 and the shareholder's basis to $7,000; with that correction the dividend portion is only $6,000, not $9,000.
Why not C: Tempting because it correctly treats $6,000 as the dividend portion and recognizes AAA = $8,000, then assumes the shareholder's basis is $8,000 so the entire $8,000 AAA is absorbed tax‑free. It fails because the pass‑through gain increases basis only to $7,000, so $1,000 of the AAA is distributed in excess of basis and is capital gain.
Common questions
Does an S corporation recognize gain when it distributes appreciated property?
Yes. Slate recognizes gain equal to the land's FMV minus its adjusted tax basis. That gain passes through to Reed and increases his stock basis.
Does property distribution gain increase S corporation stock basis first?
Yes. In the base scenario, Reed's $30,000 stock basis increases by the $30,000 pass-through gain before the $50,000 distribution is tested.
When does an S corporation property distribution create additional shareholder gain?
With no accumulated E&P, additional capital gain arises when the property's FMV exceeds stock basis after the pass-through increase. If Reed starts with $10,000 basis, the distribution creates $10,000 of additional gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions), worked step by step.
S Corporation Taxation & Distributions | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions)
- S Corporation Distributions With No E&P: Basis or Capital Gain?
- S Corporation Basis Ordering: Distributions, Losses, and Debt
All S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.