REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 9 practice questions
S Corporation Distributions With No E&P: Basis or Capital Gain?
With no accumulated earnings and profits, an S corporation’s nonliquidating cash distribution is tax-free up to adjusted stock basis; the excess is capital gain. Below: a worked calculation that adds current-year income, including tax-exempt interest, before testing the distribution.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on two facts: the corporation has no accumulated earnings and profits, and the shareholder's stock basis before the distribution is limited.
Answer B. For an S corporation with no accumulated earnings and profits, distributions are tax-free to the extent of the shareholder's stock basis and any excess is treated as capital gain. Here, $12,000 of the $20,000 distribution reduces the shareholder's basis to zero, and the $8,000 excess is recognized as capital gain.
Why not A: This reflects overgeneralizing the C corporation dividend rule. Because Maple is an S corporation with no accumulated E&P, the distribution is not treated as a dividend; instead, it is applied against stock basis first.
Why not C: While S corporation distributions can be tax-free, that is only true up to the shareholder's stock basis. Any excess over basis is taxable (typically as capital gain).
Why not D: This confuses the character of excess distributions. The excess over stock basis from an S corporation distribution (with no accumulated E&P) is capital gain, not ordinary income.
Worked example
Cedar is an S corporation with no accumulated E&P. Its sole shareholder, Alex, holds the stock as a capital asset and begins Year 1 with $12,000 of stock basis. Alex’s allocated income is $6,000 of ordinary business income and $2,000 of tax-exempt interest. Cedar makes a $26,000 nonliquidating cash distribution at year-end. There are no loans or other basis adjustments.
| 1 | Increase stock basis for income$12,000 + $6,000 + $2,000 | $20,000 |
| 2 | Determine the tax-free portionLesser of $26,000 cash or $20,000 stock basis | $20,000 |
| 3 | Calculate capital gain$26,000 − $20,000 | $6,000 |
| 4 | Reduce stock basis$20,000 − $20,000 tax-free portion | $0 |
Alex treats $20,000 as a tax-free return of basis and recognizes $6,000 of capital gain. Ending stock basis is zero.
Check: Cash exceeds beginning basis by $14,000; the $8,000 income-related basis increase shelters $8,000 of that excess, leaving $6,000 of capital gain.
Key points
- Ordinary business income is taxable separately from any gain on the distribution.
- Tax-exempt interest increases stock basis without becoming taxable income.
- No accumulated E&P means this distribution has no dividend portion.
How the exam traps you
- Using beginning basis produces $14,000 of capital gain. Add both income items first. Adjusted stock basis is $20,000, not $12,000.
- Ignoring tax-exempt interest produces $8,000 of capital gain. The $2,000 of tax-exempt interest increases basis and reduces distribution gain to $6,000.
- Reporting the entire $26,000 as dividend income. With no accumulated E&P, recover stock basis first and classify only the excess as capital gain.
Question 2
Hint
Adjust the shareholder's stock basis for current-year pass-through items before deciding whether the cash distribution creates gain.
Answer B. Parker's basis is increased by the $6,000 of pass-through ordinary income to $16,000 before testing distributions. The $12,000 cash distribution is tax-free to the extent of basis, so it reduces basis to $4,000 and produces no gain. Therefore, Parker recognizes no taxable gain on the Year 1 distribution.
Why not A: This attracts candidates who compare the distribution only to the beginning basis of $10,000 and ignore current-year income. Because the $6,000 of S-corporation income increases basis to $16,000 before the distribution, the $12,000 does not exceed basis and does not trigger gain.
Why not C: This reflects the incorrect idea that pass-through income is taxed again when distributed. In fact, S-corporation income is passed through and increases shareholder basis, which helps absorb later distributions rather than creating additional taxable gain.
Why not D: This assumes all cash distributions from an S corporation are fully taxable. In a no-E&P fact pattern, distributions are tax-free to the extent of the shareholder's adjusted stock basis, with gain only for any amount in excess of basis.
Question 3
Hint
First update the shareholder's stock basis for current-year S corporation income, then compare the cash distribution to that adjusted basis.
Answer C. A shareholder's stock basis in an S corporation is increased by passed-through income before determining the effect of a nondividend cash distribution. Mia's basis becomes $25,000 ($18,000 beginning basis + $7,000 ordinary income). Because Oak has no accumulated earnings and profits, the $22,000 cash distribution is tax-free to the extent of basis, so Mia recognizes no gain and ends with $3,000 of stock basis.
Why not A: This mixes up S corporation distribution rules with C corporation dividend rules. Because Oak has no accumulated earnings and profits from prior C years, the distribution is not a dividend here; instead it is generally a tax-free basis reduction to the extent of Mia's adjusted stock basis.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates sometimes compare the distribution only to beginning basis. That shortcut ignores the required basis increase for the shareholder's share of current-year S corporation income. After adding the $7,000 income, Mia's adjusted basis is $25,000, so the $22,000 distribution does not exceed basis.
Why not D: This distractor targets the error of double-counting S corporation taxation. S corporation income is taxed to the shareholder when earned; later cash distributions are not taxed again except to the extent they exceed stock (and debt) basis or are treated as dividends if E&P exists.
Question 4
Hint
For S corporation distributions, determine the shareholder's adjusted stock basis after current-year income items before deciding whether the cash distribution is taxable.
Answer C. Diaz's stock basis is increased by the $8,000 pass-through ordinary income, bringing basis from $12,000 to $20,000 (12,000 + 8,000 = 20,000). The $17,000 cash distribution then reduces basis to $3,000 (20,000 − 17,000). Because the distribution does not exceed adjusted stock basis and Maple has no accumulated C-corp E&P, Diaz recognizes no gain and no dividend income.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the idea that corporate distributions can be dividends, but dividend treatment for an S corporation generally requires accumulated earnings and profits from C corporation years. The facts state there are none, so the distribution is applied against stock basis before any dividend treatment.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate compares the distribution only to Diaz's beginning basis of $12,000. That misses the required basis increase for the $8,000 of Year 1 ordinary income before testing the distribution; after the increase basis is $20,000, so the $17,000 distribution does not create gain.
Why not D: This correctly concludes there is no taxable gain but miscomputes the ending basis. After adding the $8,000 income, basis is $20,000; a $17,000 distribution leaves $3,000, not zero.
Question 5
Hint
First decide whether dividend treatment is even possible, then compare the cash distribution with the shareholder's stock basis.
Answer C. Because Lake has no accumulated earnings and profits from C corporation years, nonliquidating S corporation distributions are tax-free only up to the shareholder's stock basis. Nina uses $18,000 of basis to absorb the tax-free portion, reducing her basis to zero. The $7,000 excess over basis is recognized as gain (generally capital gain).
Why not A: This lures candidates who overgeneralize that S-corporation distributions are always tax-free. The distribution is tax-free only to the extent of stock basis; any excess over basis is taxable.
Why not B: This distractor relies on confusing corporate dividends with S-corporation distributions. Dividend treatment requires accumulated E&P from prior C years (none here), and the tax-free portion does reduce stock basis rather than leaving it unchanged.
Why not D: This choice is incorrect because the entire distribution is not ordinary income. Only the amount exceeding basis is taxable, and that excess is treated as gain, not ordinary income by default.
Question 6
Hint
Before testing whether a cash distribution is taxable, adjust the shareholder's stock basis for current-year pass-through income.
Answer C. P first increases stock basis by the $5,000 of pass-through ordinary income, bringing basis from $10,000 to $15,000. A nonliquidating distribution from an S corporation with no accumulated earnings and profits is tax-free to the extent of the shareholder's adjusted stock basis. Because the $18,000 distribution exceeds P's $15,000 basis by $3,000, that $3,000 is recognized as gain.
Why not A: Tempting because S-corp distributions can be tax-free, but they are only tax-free up to the shareholder's adjusted stock basis. Here the distribution exceeds adjusted basis after the income increase, so gain is recognized on the $3,000 excess.
Why not B: This reflects misreading the $5,000 of pass-through income as the taxable portion of the distribution. In fact, that $5,000 increases basis before testing the distribution, so it reduces rather than creates taxable gain.
Why not D: This arises from comparing the $18,000 distribution only to the beginning $10,000 basis and ignoring the $5,000 basis increase. Because basis is $15,000 when the distribution is tested, the excess is $3,000, not $8,000.
Question 7
Hint
For S corporation distributions, start by adjusting stock basis for current-year pass-through income before deciding whether the cash distribution is tax-free or taxable.
Answer C. Lee's stock basis is increased by the $12,000 of pass-through ordinary income from $20,000 to $32,000. Because Oak has no accumulated earnings and profits, the $25,000 cash distribution is a nontaxable return of capital to the extent of Lee's stock basis and reduces basis. The distribution ($25,000) is less than the adjusted basis ($32,000), so Lee recognizes no gain and ends the year with a $7,000 stock basis.
Why not A: This reflects the common incorrect belief that corporate cash distributions are always dividends. For an S corporation with no accumulated E&P, distributions are not dividends but instead reduce the shareholder's stock basis.
Why not B: This error comes from comparing the distribution to the beginning basis ($20,000) instead of the adjusted basis after current-year income. Basis is first increased by the $12,000 of pass-through income (to $32,000), so the $25,000 distribution does not produce a gain.
Why not D: This confuses the taxability of S corporation income with taxation of distributions. Lee reports the $12,000 as taxable pass-through income, but the distribution itself is not ordinary income when it falls within the shareholder's stock basis.
Question 8
Hint
Compute the shareholder's adjusted stock basis for Year 1 before deciding how much of the cash distribution, if any, exceeds basis.
Answer A. Because Finch has no accumulated E&P and was never a C corporation, distributions are tax-free to the extent of the shareholder's stock basis and any excess is capital gain. Lark's $10,000 beginning basis is increased by the $8,000 of ordinary business income to $18,000. The $25,000 distribution reduces basis to zero and the $7,000 excess is treated as capital gain.
Why not B: This is tempting because S corporation distributions are often nontaxable, but they are tax-free only up to the shareholder's adjusted basis; here the distribution exceeds Lark's adjusted basis after the income increase, so some gain must be recognized.
Why not C: This reflects the mistake of comparing the distribution only to the beginning basis ($10,000) and ignoring current-year pass-through income; the correct basis to use is $10,000 + $8,000 = $18,000, leaving only $7,000 of excess.
Why not D: This treats the entire distribution as taxable; incorrect because part of the distribution is absorbed by Lark's adjusted stock basis, so only the amount exceeding basis is capital gain.
Question 9
Hint
First determine Olive's adjusted stock basis immediately before the distribution, then decide how an S corporation cash distribution is treated when it exceeds that basis.
Answer B. Olive's stock basis is increased by her share of the S corporation's income items (including tax-exempt municipal interest): 25,000 + 10,000 + 5,000 = 40,000. A distribution from an S corporation is tax-free to the extent of the shareholder's adjusted stock basis, which reduces basis to zero; the remaining $5,000 is treated as gain from the sale or exchange of the stock and, since the stock is a capital asset for Olive, is capital gain.
Why not A: This option omits the $5,000 of tax-exempt municipal interest when increasing basis. Tax-exempt income allocated from an S corporation still increases shareholder stock basis, so the correct adjusted basis is $40,000, not $35,000.
Why not C: When an S corporation has no accumulated earnings and profits from C corporation years (as stated), amounts in excess of adjusted stock basis are not dividends but are recognized as gain from the sale or exchange of the stock.
Why not D: S corporation distributions are tax-free only to the extent of the shareholder's adjusted stock basis. Once Olive's adjusted basis ($40,000) is exhausted, the $5,000 excess must be recognized as gain.
Common questions
Is an S corporation distribution a dividend if there is no accumulated E&P?
No. In this example, $20,000 is a tax-free return of stock basis, and the remaining $6,000 is capital gain.
Does tax-exempt interest increase S corporation stock basis?
Yes. The $2,000 of tax-exempt interest increases basis before the distribution, even though the interest itself is not taxable.
How do I calculate capital gain on an S corporation cash distribution?
Subtract adjusted stock basis from the cash distribution, but not below zero. Here, $26,000 minus $20,000 produces $6,000 of capital gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions), worked step by step.
S Corporation Taxation & Distributions | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions)
- S Corporation Basis Ordering: Distributions, Losses, and Debt
- S Corporation Property Distributions: Gain Before Stock Basis
All S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.