REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 9 practice questions
S Corporation Basis Ordering: Distributions, Losses, and Debt
Increase stock basis for income, then subtract distributions, nondeductible expenses, and deductible losses in that order. Below: a worked example and a larger-distribution variation showing why stock and debt basis must stay separate.
Try one first
Hint
Work through stock basis in the required annual order: income items first, then distributions, then losses and deductions.
Answer C. Increase Lena's stock basis by income items first: $20,000 + $10,000 tax-exempt interest = $30,000. The $25,000 distribution then reduces basis to $5,000 (no dividend treatment because Oak has no accumulated E&P). The $12,000 ordinary loss is applied after distributions, so only $5,000 is deductible now and $7,000 is suspended.
Why not A: This reflects ignoring tax-exempt income when increasing basis. Tax-exempt municipal bond interest does increase S shareholder stock basis, so Lena's basis before the distribution is $30,000 and no gain is recognized on the $25,000 distribution; some loss is deductible.
Why not B: This treats the loss as occurring before the distribution and ignores the required ordering. Because income (including tax-exempt interest) increases basis first and distributions then reduce basis, there is sufficient basis to avoid gain and the loss is limited to the remaining basis.
Why not D: This properly avoids gain on the distribution but incorrectly applies the ordinary loss before the distribution. Because distributions reduce basis before losses and deductions, only $5,000 of the $12,000 loss is deductible currently and $7,000 is suspended.
Step by step
- Set up separate basis balances
Lena owns all of Oak, an S corporation with no accumulated E&P; her stock is a capital asset, and beginning basis is $18,000 in stock and $3,000 in a bona fide direct loan. Year 1 items are $2,000 tax-exempt interest, a $15,000 cash distribution, $1,000 nondeductible noncapital expense, and a $10,000 ordinary loss; assume normal ordering, no other adjustments, and only basis limits apply.
- Add income to stock basis
Tax-exempt interest increases stock basis: $18,000 + $2,000 = $20,000. Keep the $3,000 debt basis separate.
- Subtract the cash distribution
The $15,000 distribution reduces stock basis from $20,000 to $5,000 and creates no gain. It does not reduce debt basis.
- Subtract the nondeductible expense
The $1,000 nondeductible noncapital expense reduces stock basis from $5,000 to $4,000 before the loss is tested. Debt basis remains $3,000.
- Apply the loss limitation
Lena may deduct $7,000 of the $10,000 loss, using $4,000 of stock basis first and then $3,000 of debt basis. She suspends $3,000, and both ending basis balances are zero.
- Change only the distribution
Same facts, except the cash distribution is $21,000. Stock basis before the distribution remains $20,000, so Lena recognizes $1,000 of capital gain and stock basis becomes zero.
- Finish the variation separately
The $1,000 nondeductible expense now reduces debt basis from $3,000 to $2,000. Lena may deduct $2,000 of the ordinary loss and suspends $8,000; both ending basis balances are zero.
Key points
- Remember: Distributions use only stock basis; losses can use remaining stock basis and direct shareholder loan basis.
- Tax-exempt interest increases stock basis even though it is not taxable.
- Nondeductible expenses consume basis before losses and can reduce debt basis after stock basis reaches zero.
- Neither stock nor debt basis can fall below zero.
How the exam traps you
- Netting the ordinary loss against income before testing the distribution. Apply the distribution first. In the base example, no distribution gain arises and only $7,000 of loss is allowed.
- Pooling stock and debt basis to shelter the $21,000 distribution. Use stock basis alone: $1,000 gain arises. Pooling falsely gives no gain and only $1,000 of allowed loss.
- Ignoring tax-exempt interest because it is not taxable. Add the $2,000 interest first. Lena has $20,000 of stock basis before either distribution.
Question 2
Hint
Work the stock basis adjustments in order: income items first, then the cash distribution, then loss and deduction items.
Answer D. Reed's stock basis is increased by the S corporation's income items: $10,000 + $8,000 + $2,000 = $20,000. The $25,000 cash distribution then reduces basis to zero, and the $5,000 excess is treated as gain from the sale or exchange of the stock (capital gain because the stock is a capital asset). Separately stated deduction items such as charitable contributions are applied after distributions for basis purposes, so Reed has no remaining basis to deduct the $7,000 contribution in Year 1 (the contribution is suspended).
Why not A: This overstates the gain by applying the charitable deduction before the distribution (or otherwise misordering the adjustments). The correct ordering increases basis for income items, then reduces basis for distributions, yielding a $5,000 excess.
Why not B: This correctly computes the $5,000 excess distribution gain but incorrectly allows the charitable contribution to be deducted now. Because income items increased basis and the distribution exhausted that basis, the charitable contribution cannot be deducted in Year 1 and is suspended.
Why not C: This reflects the incorrect notion that distributions are tax-free simply because the corporation has no accumulated E&P; S corporation distributions are tax-free only to the extent of the shareholder's stock basis, and here the distribution exceeded adjusted basis.
Question 3
Hint
Do not net all S corporation items together. Apply the shareholder stock-basis adjustment order for the year step by step.
Answer C. Begin with Lark's $28,000 stock basis and add the $2,000 tax-exempt interest, increasing basis to $30,000. The $20,000 distribution is then applied (reducing basis to $10,000) and does not create gain because it did not exceed basis immediately before the distribution; the $1,000 nondeductible expense next reduces basis to $9,000. Therefore only $9,000 of the $14,000 ordinary loss is currently deductible (the remaining $5,000 is suspended).
Why not A: This result comes from incorrectly applying the loss before the distribution so that the distribution appears to exceed basis. The correct ordering applies the distribution (which did not exceed basis) before losses, so no gain is recognized and part of the loss is suspended.
Why not B: This ignores that nondeductible expenses reduce basis before applying losses. After the distribution Lark's $10,000 basis is further reduced by the $1,000 nondeductible expense, leaving only $9,000 available for the loss deduction.
Why not D: Although the loss limitation is computed correctly here, this choice incorrectly tests the distribution against basis after year-end reductions. The distribution is measured against basis immediately before the distribution reduction step (after income increases), so it does not trigger gain.
Question 4
Hint
Work the stock basis in the statutory order: positive basis adjustments first, then nondividend distributions, then loss items.
Answer D. Start with Kim's opening stock basis of $24,000 and increase it by the $6,000 of tax-exempt interest to get $30,000. The $20,000 nonliquidating distribution then reduces basis to $10,000, and the $15,000 loss can only be deducted to the extent of that remaining $10,000, suspending the $5,000 excess. Because the distribution did not exceed basis after the positive adjustment, no gain is recognized.
Why not A: This option overlooks that the distribution reduces basis before applying the loss limitation. After the distribution, only $10,000 of basis remains to absorb losses, so $5,000 of the loss must be suspended.
Why not B: This result assumes the loss is applied before the distribution or treats the distribution as exceeding basis; under S-corporation basis ordering, positive adjustments (tax-exempt income) are added first and distributions are applied before losses, so the distribution does not create gain here and the loss cannot be fully deducted.
Why not C: This choice ignores that tax-exempt income increases stock basis. Adding the $6,000 of tax-exempt interest raises basis to $30,000, which allows more of the loss to be deducted than this option permits.
Question 5
Hint
Compute stock basis immediately before the distribution, and do not ignore any income item that affects basis even if it is not taxable.
Answer C. Nora's stock basis is increased by her 20X5 pass-through income items, including the $4,000 of tax-exempt interest, so her basis immediately before the distribution is $25,000 ($15,000 + $6,000 + $4,000). Because Elm has no accumulated earnings and profits, the $28,000 cash distribution is nontaxable to the extent of basis and reduces basis to zero; the $3,000 excess ($28,000 - $25,000) is recognized as capital gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because S corporation distributions are tax-free to the extent of stock basis, but here the distribution ($28,000) exceeds Nora's adjusted basis ($25,000) so the excess is taxable gain.
Why not B: This distractor ignores that tax-exempt income also increases stock basis. Including the $4,000 of tax-exempt interest raises basis to $25,000, lowering the taxable excess to $3,000, not $7,000.
Why not D: This reflects the incorrect ordering rule. For S-corporation basis calculations, current-year income items (including tax-exempt income) increase basis before applying a distribution, so using only the opening $15,000 basis overstates the gain.
Question 6
Hint
Do not net the year's items all at once. For S corporation stock basis, think about the required order of annual basis adjustments.
Answer A. Jordan's beginning stock basis of $40,000 is increased by $10,000 of allocable income to $50,000. Because Maple has no accumulated C-corporation E&P, the $45,000 distribution is tax-free to the extent of basis and reduces basis to $5,000 (no gain recognized). Deductible losses are limited by post-distribution basis, so Jordan may deduct $5,000 of the $12,000 loss now and suspend the remaining $7,000.
Why not B: This answer arises from comparing the distribution to beginning basis only. However, current-year income items increase S-corporation stock basis before distributions are applied, so basis is $50,000 before the distribution and no gain is recognized.
Why not C: This mistakes the ordering of adjustments by allowing the full loss without first reducing basis for the distribution. After the $45,000 distribution, only $5,000 of basis remains to absorb losses, so $7,000 must be suspended.
Why not D: This combines two errors: measuring the distribution against beginning basis (leading to an erroneous $5,000 gain) and incorrectly permitting the full loss despite the basis reduction from the distribution.
Question 7
Hint
Do not net all of the year's items together. Apply the shareholder stock-basis adjustments in the required order.
Answer D. For S corporation stock basis, current-year income items increase basis first, distributions are applied next, and losses are applied last. Omar's basis increases from $12,000 to $22,000 after the $10,000 long-term gain, the $18,000 distribution reduces basis to $4,000 without triggering gain, and only $4,000 of the $8,000 ordinary loss is deductible in Year 1 (the remaining $4,000 is suspended).
Why not A: While no accumulated earnings and profits affects the tax characterization of a distribution, it does not allow a shareholder to deduct losses beyond remaining stock basis. The deductible loss is limited by basis after the distribution.
Why not B: This mistakes the ordering: losses do not reduce stock basis before distributions. Current-year income items increase basis first, then distributions are applied, and losses are tested against the remaining basis.
Why not C: This reflects the error of using beginning basis only. Separately stated current-year income items (like the $10,000 gain) increase basis before testing the distribution against basis.
Question 8
Hint
Work through stock basis in the required annual order: increases first, then nondividend distributions, then losses.
Answer B. Tax-exempt interest increases S corporation stock basis even though it is not taxable, so Nina's basis increases from $12,000 to $17,000 before applying the distribution. The $14,000 nonliquidating distribution is tax-free to the extent of basis, reducing basis to $3,000, so no gain is recognized. Losses are applied after distributions, so Nina may deduct only $3,000 of the $8,000 ordinary loss and must suspend the remaining $5,000.
Why not A: This is tempting if a candidate applies the cash distribution before adding income items. Under the annual S corporation basis ordering rules, basis is first increased by income (including tax-exempt interest) and only then reduced by distributions; because basis is $17,000 before the distribution, the $14,000 distribution does not trigger gain.
Why not C: This answer reflects treating tax-exempt interest as irrelevant for basis. That is incorrect: tax-exempt income increases shareholder stock basis. Once the $5,000 tax-exempt interest is added, the distribution is covered by basis and some loss becomes deductible.
Why not D: This avoids gain on the distribution correctly but ignores the loss limitation: after the $14,000 distribution Nina's remaining basis is $3,000, so only $3,000 of the $8,000 loss is currently deductible and $5,000 must be suspended.
Question 9
Hint
Track S corporation stock basis in the proper sequence for the year rather than netting everything at once.
Answer B. Increase stock basis by income items: $25,000 + $5,000 (tax-exempt interest) + $10,000 (LTCG) = $40,000. The $30,000 distribution reduces basis to $10,000 and, because there is no accumulated C corporation E&P, is not a dividend; no gain is recognized. The $12,000 ordinary loss is deductible only to the extent of the remaining $10,000 basis, so $10,000 is currently deductible and $2,000 is suspended.
Why not A: This treats the loss as if applied before the distribution. Under S corporation basis rules, income items increase basis, distributions reduce basis, and then losses reduce basis. Applying the loss first incorrectly creates a distribution-in-excess situation and an unjustified gain.
Why not C: This ignores the $5,000 tax-exempt interest increase to basis. Tax-exempt interest is not taxable but still increases S corporation stock basis, leaving $10,000 of basis after the distribution rather than $5,000.
Why not D: This result double-counts errors by both ignoring the tax-exempt interest basis increase and applying the loss before the distribution, which wrongly makes part of the distribution exceed basis and overstates deductible loss.
Common questions
What is the order of S corporation basis adjustments?
Under normal annual ordering, add income first, including tax-exempt income. Then subtract distributions, nondeductible noncapital expenses, and deductible losses and deductions.
Can S corporation debt basis make a distribution tax-free?
No. In the $21,000 distribution variation, Lena has only $20,000 of stock basis available, so she recognizes $1,000 of capital gain despite her separate debt basis.
How do nondeductible expenses affect suspended S corporation losses?
They consume basis before deductible losses are tested. In the base example, the $1,000 expense leaves $7,000 of combined basis for the $10,000 loss, so $3,000 is suspended.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions), worked step by step.
S Corporation Taxation & Distributions | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions)
- S Corporation Distributions With No E&P: Basis or Capital Gain?
- S Corporation Property Distributions: Gain Before Stock Basis
All S Corporations (elections and taxation and distributions) practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.