REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 6 practice questions
AICPA Confidentiality: Authorized Board and Ethics Inquiries
An authorized board or ethics inquiry permits necessary disclosure without client consent, but not unrelated disclosure. Sort Lane's responses by the requester's authority and the information's relevance.
Try one first
Hint
Identify the choice that matches an express, narrowly defined exception in the professional confidentiality rule, a formal inquiry by a duly constituted investigative or disciplinary body.
Answer A. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule permits disclosure without client consent in narrowly defined circumstances, including responses to inquiries from a duly constituted investigative or disciplinary body (such as a state board of accountancy investigating a complaint). The stem describes a formal written inquiry tied to a complaint from such a body, which fits that exception. The other scenarios lack client consent or legally enforceable process and therefore do not meet the rule's exceptions.
Why not B: This is tempting because being listed as a reference might imply permission, but the confidentiality rule does not permit release of client reports or supporting schedules based solely on a client's listing; explicit client consent or another recognized exception is required.
Why not C: Although successor/predecessor coordination is common, a predecessor CPA generally may not release confidential workpapers without the client's authorization or another exception. The proper procedure is for the successor to obtain client-signed authorization or for the client to instruct the predecessor to transmit materials.
Why not D: An informal request from a government agent does not override the confidentiality rule. Absent client consent or a legally enforceable summons/subpoena or court order (or another applicable legal requirement), the CPA should not disclose confidential client information.
Sort it
The disclosure is reasonably necessary for a verified, authorized investigative or disciplinary inquiry.
The request lacks authorized investigative or disciplinary status, or the information falls outside the inquiry's scope.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Lane, CPA, reviewed Harbor Co.'s financial statements. Harbor expressly refuses disclosure consent. The state board, acting within its disciplinary authority, sends a letter requesting relevant review workpapers. Apply only the AICPA confidentiality rule; no other disclosure exception applies. May Lane provide the requested workpapers? | Oversight exceptionAn authorized disciplinary inquiry permits disclosure of reasonably necessary information, even when Harbor refuses consent. |
| Same facts, except the requester is Harbor's bank, which has no investigative or disciplinary authority. May Lane provide the workpapers? | Consent requiredA formal request from a private bank is not an authorized professional disciplinary inquiry. |
| Same facts, except the authorized disciplinary inquiry comes from the AICPA Ethics Division. May Lane provide the relevant workpapers? | Oversight exceptionThe AICPA Ethics Division's authorized disciplinary inquiry qualifies for the exception. |
| Same facts, except Lane proposes adding confidential documents unrelated to the board inquiry. May Lane disclose those extra documents? | Consent requiredAuthorization to answer the inquiry does not permit disclosure of unrelated confidential documents. |
| Same facts, except the request comes from Harbor's successor CPA rather than an authorized disciplinary body. May Lane provide the workpapers? | Consent requiredA successor CPA's request does not qualify as an authorized investigative or disciplinary inquiry. |
| Same facts, except the request is a board employee's personal question, not an authorized board inquiry. May Lane provide the workpapers? | Consent requiredA board employee's title does not turn a personal question into an authorized inquiry. |
| Same facts, except the state board requests relevant engagement emails rather than review workpapers. May Lane provide them? | Oversight exceptionDocument format does not control. Relevant confidential engagement emails may be disclosed for the authorized disciplinary inquiry. |
| Same facts, except the board's inquiry falls outside its investigative and disciplinary authority. May Lane disclose the workpapers under this exception? | Consent requiredA board's name alone is insufficient. The inquiry must fall within its investigative or disciplinary authority. |
| Same facts, except an authorized state CPA society ethics committee conducts the disciplinary inquiry. May Lane provide the relevant workpapers? | Oversight exceptionAn authorized state CPA society disciplinary inquiry qualifies, just as an authorized state board inquiry does. |
| Same facts, except the authorized board inquiry arrives by email instead of a letter. May Lane provide the relevant workpapers? | Oversight exceptionEmail rather than paper changes nothing. Verified authority and relevance, not delivery method, control the exception. |
Key points
- Remember: Check the requester's authority and the information's relevance, not whether the client agrees.
- A bank or successor CPA does not become a disciplinary body by sending a formal request.
- An inquiry's delivery method and the records' format do not determine whether the exception applies.
How the exam traps you
- Refusing an authorized board inquiry because Harbor expressly objects. Client refusal does not block this exception; disclose only what is reasonably necessary.
- Treating a formal bank request or a board employee's personal question as authorized oversight. Verify that the requester is acting through a duly constituted investigative or disciplinary body.
- Sending unrelated confidential files with the board response. The exception covers only information reasonably necessary for the authorized inquiry.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether each disclosure fits a recognized exception to confidentiality, and if it does, whether the disclosure should be limited to that purpose.
Answer D. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, a CPA generally may not disclose confidential client information without the client's specific consent. However, exceptions permit disclosure when reasonably necessary to defend against actual or threatened litigation or claims, and to participate in an authorized peer review. A bank's request to help with a loan renewal does not create a comparable exception, so client consent is still required for that disclosure.
Why not A: This is tempting if the candidate remembers the peer review exception but assumes litigation disclosures always require a court order. The AICPA rule allows disclosure reasonably necessary to defend against a client's claim or lawsuit, so a court order is not required for that limited purpose. The bank request is still not permitted without Cedar's consent.
Why not B: This choice reflects an overbroad view of the exceptions. The fact that a request relates to a prior professional relationship does not by itself authorize disclosure. The rule recognizes specific exceptions, and the bank's convenience request is not one of them.
Why not C: This distractor is attractive to someone who recalls the peer review exception but forgets the self-defense exception. Once Cedar sues Lopez, Lopez may disclose relevant client information as reasonably necessary to respond to that claim. The rule does not force the CPA to obtain the suing client's consent before defending against the lawsuit.
Question 3
Hint
Ask which requests fit a specific, recognized exception to the AICPA confidentiality rule rather than which requests merely seem professionally appropriate.
Answer B. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, a member generally may not disclose confidential client information without the client's consent. A recognized exception permits disclosure to respond to an inquiry or investigation by the AICPA Ethics Division (or a similar authorized disciplinary body). The lender is an outside third party and the CFO's request, without express client authorization, does not waive confidentiality. Likewise, the spouse is not counsel to Falcon and is therefore an outside third party, so discussing confidential client matters with the spouse would require Falcon's consent.
Why not A: Tempting because each request can appear professionally justified (the lender needs returns; the spouse is an attorney; the AICPA has an inquiry). It fails because professional purpose alone does not permit disclosure; only the Ethics Division inquiry fits a recognized exception here, while the lender and spouse are outside third parties requiring client consent.
Why not C: Tempting because an attorney may seem like a permissible recipient of legal or tax advice. It fails because the spouse is not counsel to Falcon, being an attorney personally does not make them authorized to receive Falcon's confidential information, so discussing Falcon's matters with the spouse still requires client consent; only the AICPA Ethics Division request is an exception.
Why not D: Tempting because the confidentiality rule generally prohibits disclosure without consent. It fails because it is overbroad: the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule recognizes a specific exception for disclosures in response to inquiries or investigations by the AICPA Ethics Division (or similar disciplinary bodies), so request 3 may be complied with without the client's consent.
Question 4
Hint
Separate voluntary third-party sharing from disclosures required under legal or regulatory authority, and consider who is actually authorized to consent for the client.
Answer D. Under the AICPA confidential client information rule, a CPA generally may not disclose client information without specific client consent. However, the rule does not relieve the CPA of the obligation to comply with applicable laws and government regulations, so a valid state board demand issued under statutory authority may be honored. The lender request is different: a business reason or client benefit is not enough, and the assumedly unauthorized treasurer cannot provide the needed client consent.
Why not A: Tempting because both requesters appear to have practical reasons, but a legitimate business purpose does not create an exception to confidentiality. The state board demand may be honored because it arises from legal/regulatory authority; the lender request requires proper client consent from an authorized representative.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate remembers only the general prohibition on disclosure. But the rule is not absolute: it permits compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, so a valid state board demand differs from a voluntary third-party request to a lender.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken idea that a disclosure that benefits the client is automatically permissible. It is not; absent proper client consent the lender is still a third party. Conversely, the confidentiality rule yields to applicable law and regulatory demands, so the board's written demand may be honored.
Question 5
Hint
Analyze the two disclosure requests separately. One is tied to the CPA's own defense in a filed legal claim; the other is just a third-party business request.
Answer C. A CPA's duty of confidentiality generally prohibits disclosure without client consent, but an accepted exception allows disclosure of client information to the extent reasonably necessary to defend against claims arising from the engagement. That permits providing relevant engagement files to defense counsel. By contrast, the bank is a third party requesting business information; absent client consent or another exception, the CPA should not discuss Ridge's projections with the bank.
Why not A: This is tempting because both requests relate to the client's information, but confidentiality doesn't disappear simply because the data originated from the client. The defense-related request fits the litigation-defense exception; the bank's request does not.
Why not B: This overstates the rule. A court order is not the only basis for permitted disclosure, information reasonably necessary to defend against a client's lawsuit may be disclosed without a court order.
Why not D: The lender's need for information does not substitute for the client's consent. The bank is a third party, so disclosing projections to it would breach confidentiality absent client consent or another exception. By contrast, disclosure to defend against the lawsuit is the appropriate exception here.
Question 6
Hint
Look for an exception that involves formal professional regulatory oversight rather than routine business needs or informal family involvement.
Answer A. The AICPA confidential client information rule prohibits disclosure without client consent but recognizes exceptions for certain professional oversight matters. A formal disciplinary inquiry by a state board of accountancy is a recognized exception, so Lee may produce relevant engagement documentation in that context under the AICPA rule as framed by the stem.
Why not B: This option appeals to practical continuity concerns, but absent client consent the AICPA confidentiality rule does not permit releasing engagement workpapers to a successor accountant; the stem rules out client authorization, so the disclosure is not allowed.
Why not C: This is tempting because the disclosure would benefit the client and is common in practice, but the confidentiality rule does not permit sharing client information with third parties for business convenience absent client consent or a listed exception; a lender's request is not an authorized exception under the given facts.
Why not D: Candidates may be tempted because the spouse appears involved in operations, but the facts do not establish that she is an authorized representative of the corporate client. Personal or family involvement alone does not create a confidentiality exception without client consent.
Common questions
Can a CPA give client workpapers to a state board without client consent?
Yes, when the disclosure is reasonably necessary to respond to an authorized investigative or disciplinary inquiry. The client's refusal does not block this exception.
Can a CPA disclose client information to the AICPA Ethics Division?
Yes, a CPA may provide information reasonably necessary to answer the AICPA Ethics Division's authorized disciplinary inquiry. Unrelated confidential information remains outside the exception.
Does a state board inquiry allow disclosure of the entire client file?
Not automatically. Provide only information reasonably necessary for the authorized inquiry, and do not add unrelated confidential documents.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Confidentiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.