REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 6 practice questions
AICPA Peer Review: Sharing Workpapers Without Consent
An authorized peer or practice review permits sharing confidential client information without consent, but only to the extent reasonably needed. Sort Harbor's file requests by review authority and disclosure scope.
Try one first
Hint
Identify the specific, enumerated no-consent exceptions in the confidentiality rule; ask whether each scenario matches an authorized exception (for example, an authorized peer review) or a legally enforceable compulsory process.
Answer A. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule permits disclosure without client-specific consent in narrowly defined circumstances, one of which is an authorized peer review. Given the stem's assumption that the materials are confidential and that no legal compulsion exists, furnishing selected files to an external reviewer conducting an authorized peer review fits an accepted exception. The other choices do not invoke recognized no-consent exceptions.
Why not B: This is tempting because the analysis was prepared from client records, but the rule protects confidential client information regardless of whether the CPA prepared it. A lender's request or the potential client benefit does not by itself create a rule-recognized exception or substitute for client consent.
Why not C: Sale or transfer of a practice can permit limited disclosures only when appropriate safeguards exist (for example, a prospective purchaser bound to confidentiality and use limited to evaluating the purchase). Absent those safeguards here, disclosure would violate the confidentiality rule.
Why not D: An informal government inquiry does not override the confidentiality rule. Without client consent or legally enforceable compulsory process (such as a summons or subpoena), substantive disclosure is not permitted.
Sort it
The review is authorized, required safeguards apply, and the information is reasonably necessary.
The review is authorized, but the proposed disclosure includes information the review does not need.
The request is outside an authorized review, and no other disclosure exception applies.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Harbor has not consented to disclosure, and no law compels it. Its files contain confidential review-engagement and tax-return information. An authorized peer reviewer requests only selected review workpapers reasonably needed for the firm's review, with all required confidentiality safeguards. | Share for the reviewThe authorized review and limited scope satisfy the peer-review exception. |
| Same facts, except Harbor's bank requests those workpapers to renew Harbor's loan. | Get client consentA lender's business need does not create a peer-review exception. |
| Same facts, except the CPA proposes sending the entire file although the reviewer needs only selected workpapers. | Narrow the disclosureAuthorization does not justify disclosing material beyond the review's reasonable needs. |
| Same facts, except Harbor expressly refuses permission for the authorized peer review. | Share for the reviewThe refusal does not change the answer because this exception does not require client consent. |
| Same facts, except Harbor's newly engaged successor CPA requests selected prior-year workpapers. | Get client consentBeing appointed successor does not make the CPA an authorized peer reviewer or authorize disclosure. |
| Same facts, except the reviewer needs selected tax-return workpapers for a qualifying tax-practice review. | Share for the reviewTax files can qualify too when the review meets applicable tax confidentiality requirements and required safeguards. |
| Same facts, except the CPA proposes adding unrelated Harbor tax information to the requested review-engagement workpapers. | Narrow the disclosureInformation about the same client is not automatically necessary for the review. |
| Same facts, except the reviewer reasonably needs the entire review-engagement file rather than selected workpapers. | Share for the reviewAn entire file may qualify when reasonably necessary. The test is need, not a fixed document limit. |
| Same facts, except another CPA calls an informal, unauthorized inspection a peer review. | Get client consentA peer-review label and a CPA license do not create an authorized review. |
| Same facts, except the bank requests only Harbor's nonpublic financial statements already issued to Harbor. | Get client consentPrior delivery to Harbor does not authorize disclosure to its bank. |
| Same facts, except the authorized request comes through an approved professional practice-review program. | Share for the reviewAn authorized practice review qualifies too. The program's different name does not remove the exception. |
Key points
- Remember: An authorized review opens access only to information the review reasonably needs.
- Client refusal does not remove the authorized-review exception.
- Previously issued, nonpublic statements remain confidential when a bank requests them.
- Tax files qualify only when the review also meets applicable tax confidentiality requirements.
How the exam traps you
- Treating any request from another CPA as an authorized peer review. Verify that the request is part of an authorized peer or practice-review program.
- Sending the entire file when the reviewer needs only selected workpapers. Share only what the authorized review reasonably needs.
- Assuming the client's refusal blocks an authorized review. Client consent is not required for disclosure within the authorized-review exception.
Question 2
Hint
Identify the narrow confidentiality exceptions that allow disclosure without client consent, and do not assume that a common business request or an informal legal demand is enough.
Answer B. The AICPA confidentiality rule permits disclosure of client information without specific client consent only in limited circumstances. An authorized peer review is a recognized exception, so Rios may provide files to the AICPA-authorized reviewer. The bank request, the former controller, and a mere demand letter (without a subpoena or summons) are not exceptions on these facts.
Why not A: This is tempting because lenders commonly request tax returns and the return was filed with the government, but routine business requests are not a listed exception; client consent is required to disclose the return to the bank.
Why not C: This is tempting since the former controller worked with the tax data, but she no longer represents Harbor and is not authorized to act for the client, so disclosing confidential information to her requires current client consent.
Why not D: This is tempting because a lawyer's request sounds formal, but the confidentiality exception applies to complying with an enforceable subpoena or summons; a demand letter alone does not permit disclosure without client consent.
Question 3
Hint
Identify whether the recipient fits within a narrowly defined nonconsensual exception under professional confidentiality rules and whether any limits on the disclosure are met.
Answer D. Professional confidentiality guidance generally permits limited disclosures to independent peer or quality reviewers when the disclosure is confined to information reasonably necessary to perform the review and the reviewer is bound to protect the information (by professional standards or contractual obligation). That narrow oversight exception supports option B. The other options involve disclosures to taxing authorities, affiliates for marketing, or family members without authorization, which typically require client consent or legal compulsion.
Why not A: Tempting because it relates to enforcement, but preparer confidentiality does not authorize the firm to volunteer a client's return information to the IRS in the absence of client consent or an independent legal compulsion. The firm may advise the client about addressing noncompliance, but it should not unilaterally disclose return information to the IRS under the stated facts.
Why not B: Family involvement can make disclosure seem appropriate, but without a power of attorney or explicit client authorization the child is a third party; confidentiality rules generally bar disclosure to such parties absent consent or legal authority.
Why not C: This is tempting because affiliates may provide helpful services, but using tax return information for cross-selling or marketing is not a recognized nonconsensual exception to professional confidentiality; client consent is generally required.
Question 4
Hint
Decide whether the request fits a defined exception in the confidentiality rule (for example, a formal peer/quality review or a legal compulsion) rather than a routine business need or an informal government inquiry.
Answer A. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule permits disclosure of client information to a properly conducted peer (quality) review, provided appropriate confidentiality safeguards are followed. Because Atlas has not consented and no law compels disclosure, the other requests, by a lender, by an IRS agent without a summons, or by a successor accountant without client authorization, are not permitted under the rule.
Why not B: This distractor tempts by invoking a government authority, but an informal IRS request, absent a summons, subpoena, or other legal compulsion, does not override the client's confidentiality; disclosure would require the client's consent or proper legal process.
Why not C: This is tempting because lenders often need documentation to evaluate creditworthiness, but the confidentiality rule does not allow disclosure to unrelated third parties for business convenience without the client's consent or a legal compulsion.
Why not D: This seems plausible because successor accountants routinely request prior workpapers, but the AICPA rule requires the client's authorization before releasing engagement files to a successor unless another exception or legal requirement applies.
Question 5
Hint
Ask yourself which request is part of authorized professional oversight and which is merely a third-party business request.
Answer B. The AICPA confidentiality rule generally prohibits disclosing confidential client information without the client's specific consent. However, authorized peer review (practice monitoring) is an explicit exception that allows the member to provide access to engagement files. The bank's request to confirm the client relationship and to send nonpublic financial statements is not covered by that exception; absent client consent or legal compulsion (e.g., subpoena), such disclosure is prohibited.
Why not A: Tempting because both requests relate to prior services, but routine third-party requests do not override confidentiality. Peer review is an exception; a bank's request is not, so complying with the bank would violate the rule without consent or legal authority.
Why not C: This distractor exploits the idea that re-sending documents previously given to the client is harmless. The confidentiality rule still bars disclosing nonpublic client information to third parties without consent or legal authority, and it also misstates the peer review exception (peer review is an authorized exception).
Why not D: This is overly absolute. While the rule normally requires client consent, it includes specific exceptions (for example, authorized peer review or disclosures required by law), so declining both requests is too restrictive.
Question 6
Hint
Which choice aligns with a specifically recognized AICPA exception that allows disclosure without client consent?
Answer C. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule permits disclosure of confidential client information without client consent when necessary for an external peer review conducted under the peer review program's confidentiality protections. The stem states the firm participates in that program and excludes legal compulsion, so disclosure to the external peer reviewer is an authorized exception here; the other choices involve disclosures that require client consent.
Why not A: This option tempts because lenders commonly request documents for credit decisions, but the AICPA rule does not permit disclosure to a third-party lender for business purposes without the client's consent unless a recognized exception applies, none does in this scenario.
Why not B: This distractor is tempting because consulting with another CPA on technical matters is common; however, omitting the name is not enough if the facts would reasonably identify the client, such disclosure still requires client consent absent an exception like peer review.
Why not D: This seems plausible because vendors provide useful services for firms, but transferring client financial data to a vendor for a demonstration is not a listed exception under the confidentiality rule and therefore requires the client's consent.
Common questions
Can a CPA give workpapers to a peer reviewer without client consent?
Yes, for an authorized peer or practice review with required confidentiality safeguards. Share only the information reasonably necessary for that review.
Can tax-return files be shared for a peer review without consent?
Yes, when the review qualifies under both professional and applicable tax confidentiality rules. Limit disclosure to the review's needs and use the required confidentiality protections.
Can a successor CPA get prior workpapers without client consent?
Not merely because the successor has been engaged. Without client consent or another applicable exception, the predecessor cannot release confidential workpapers.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Confidentiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.