PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 6 practice questions

AICPA Peer Review: Sharing Workpapers Without Consent

An authorized peer or practice review permits sharing confidential client information without consent, but only to the extent reasonably needed. Sort Harbor's file requests by review authority and disclosure scope.

The ruleA member may disclose confidential client information without client consent for an authorized peer or practice review. Limit disclosure to information reasonably necessary for the review and follow its confidentiality safeguards.

Try one first

Luca, CPA, is in public practice and does not have client-specific consent from Orion LLC to disclose Orion's information. Assume all requested materials below meet the AICPA definition of confidential client information (i.e., information obtained or prepared in the course of providing professional services), including analyses prepared by Luca, and assume no law independently requires disclosure unless the facts say otherwise. Which action may Luca take without violating the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule?
Hint

Identify the specific, enumerated no-consent exceptions in the confidentiality rule; ask whether each scenario matches an authorized exception (for example, an authorized peer review) or a legally enforceable compulsory process.

Sort it

Share for the review

The review is authorized, required safeguards apply, and the information is reasonably necessary.

Narrow the disclosure

The review is authorized, but the proposed disclosure includes information the review does not need.

Get client consent

The request is outside an authorized review, and no other disclosure exception applies.

ItemGoes to
Harbor has not consented to disclosure, and no law compels it. Its files contain confidential review-engagement and tax-return information. An authorized peer reviewer requests only selected review workpapers reasonably needed for the firm's review, with all required confidentiality safeguards.Share for the reviewThe authorized review and limited scope satisfy the peer-review exception.
Same facts, except Harbor's bank requests those workpapers to renew Harbor's loan.Get client consentA lender's business need does not create a peer-review exception.
Same facts, except the CPA proposes sending the entire file although the reviewer needs only selected workpapers.Narrow the disclosureAuthorization does not justify disclosing material beyond the review's reasonable needs.
Same facts, except Harbor expressly refuses permission for the authorized peer review.Share for the reviewThe refusal does not change the answer because this exception does not require client consent.
Same facts, except Harbor's newly engaged successor CPA requests selected prior-year workpapers.Get client consentBeing appointed successor does not make the CPA an authorized peer reviewer or authorize disclosure.
Same facts, except the reviewer needs selected tax-return workpapers for a qualifying tax-practice review.Share for the reviewTax files can qualify too when the review meets applicable tax confidentiality requirements and required safeguards.
Same facts, except the CPA proposes adding unrelated Harbor tax information to the requested review-engagement workpapers.Narrow the disclosureInformation about the same client is not automatically necessary for the review.
Same facts, except the reviewer reasonably needs the entire review-engagement file rather than selected workpapers.Share for the reviewAn entire file may qualify when reasonably necessary. The test is need, not a fixed document limit.
Same facts, except another CPA calls an informal, unauthorized inspection a peer review.Get client consentA peer-review label and a CPA license do not create an authorized review.
Same facts, except the bank requests only Harbor's nonpublic financial statements already issued to Harbor.Get client consentPrior delivery to Harbor does not authorize disclosure to its bank.
Same facts, except the authorized request comes through an approved professional practice-review program.Share for the reviewAn authorized practice review qualifies too. The program's different name does not remove the exception.

Key points

  • Remember: An authorized review opens access only to information the review reasonably needs.
  • Client refusal does not remove the authorized-review exception.
  • Previously issued, nonpublic statements remain confidential when a bank requests them.
  • Tax files qualify only when the review also meets applicable tax confidentiality requirements.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating any request from another CPA as an authorized peer review. Verify that the request is part of an authorized peer or practice-review program.
  • Sending the entire file when the reviewer needs only selected workpapers. Share only what the authorized review reasonably needs.
  • Assuming the client's refusal blocks an authorized review. Client consent is not required for disclosure within the authorized-review exception.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Rios, CPA, in public practice, prepares Harbor Inc.'s federal tax returns. Harbor has not given Rios any specific consent to disclose client information. During Year 2, Rios receives the following requests: (1) Harbor's bank asks Rios to email a copy of Harbor's filed federal return to support renewal of a credit line. (2) An AICPA-authorized peer reviewer requests selected Harbor tax engagement files as part of the firm's quality review. (3) Harbor's former controller, who no longer works for Harbor and is not authorized to act for it, asks for copies of prior-year returns because she originally assembled the tax data. (4) A private plaintiff's attorney sends a demand letter seeking Harbor's tax workpapers, but no subpoena or summons has been issued. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, which request(s), if any, may Rios satisfy without Harbor's specific consent?
Hint

Identify the narrow confidentiality exceptions that allow disclosure without client consent, and do not assume that a common business request or an informal legal demand is enough.

Question 3

A CPA firm prepared Rowan's Year 2 federal and state income tax returns and served as Rowan's paid tax return preparer. Assume Rowan gave no consent to disclose or use tax return information, and no court order or statute independently compels disclosure. The firm is subject to applicable professional confidentiality rules. Which action is the firm most likely permitted to take without Rowan's consent?
Hint

Identify whether the recipient fits within a narrowly defined nonconsensual exception under professional confidentiality rules and whether any limits on the disclosure are met.

Question 4

Harper, a CPA in public practice, prepared Atlas Co.'s tax returns and related advisory workpapers. Atlas has not given Harper specific consent to disclose any information. Assume no law independently requires disclosure unless stated. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, which of the following requests may Harper properly satisfy without Atlas's specific consent?
Hint

Decide whether the request fits a defined exception in the confidentiality rule (for example, a formal peer/quality review or a legal compulsion) rather than a routine business need or an informal government inquiry.

Question 5

Lane, an AICPA member in public practice, prepares tax returns and compiles financial statements for a privately held client. The financial statements were provided only to the client and were not publicly filed. The client has not given Lane any consent to disclose information, and no subpoena, summons, or other law or regulation requires disclosure. The client's bank asks Lane to confirm that the entity is Lane's client and to send the latest financial statements from Lane's files. In the same month, Lane's firm is undergoing an AICPA-authorized peer review, and the reviewer requests access to the engagement file. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Ask yourself which request is part of authorized professional oversight and which is merely a third-party business request.

Question 6

Jordan, a CPA in public practice, performs compilation and advisory services for Delta Co. Delta has given no oral or written consent to disclose its information. Jordan's firm participates in the AICPA peer review program. Assume no law, court order, subpoena, government regulation, client lawsuit, or ethics investigation requires disclosure. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, which action may Jordan take without first obtaining Delta's consent?
Hint

Which choice aligns with a specifically recognized AICPA exception that allows disclosure without client consent?

Drill all 93 Confidentiality questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a CPA give workpapers to a peer reviewer without client consent?

Yes, for an authorized peer or practice review with required confidentiality safeguards. Share only the information reasonably necessary for that review.

Can tax-return files be shared for a peer review without consent?

Yes, when the review qualifies under both professional and applicable tax confidentiality rules. Limit disclosure to the review's needs and use the required confidentiality protections.

Can a successor CPA get prior workpapers without client consent?

Not merely because the successor has been engaged. Without client consent or another applicable exception, the predecessor cannot release confidential workpapers.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Confidentiality

All Confidentiality practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.