PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 11 practice questions

AICPA Confidentiality: Valid Subpoena or Summons

Without client consent, a request alone does not permit disclosure; a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons permits required disclosure. Below, the request for client schedules changes legal form while the client's objection stays fixed.

The ruleWithout client consent or another applicable exception, do not disclose confidential client information. A validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons permits disclosure without consent, limited to what the legal process requires.

Try one first

A CPA has not received a client's specific consent to disclose confidential client information. Assume no other law or regulation independently requires disclosure unless stated. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, which of the following is the clearest situation in which the CPA may disclose the information without the client's specific consent?
Hint

Focus on the narrow situations in which the rule expressly allows disclosure without client consent, not on whether the disclosure would be useful or professionally convenient.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Mills, CPA, in public practice, provided non-tax consulting services to Dale Co. Dale expressly instructs Mills not to disclose its confidential cash flow schedules. Opposing counsel sends an informal request for those schedules. Only the AICPA confidentiality rule is at issue; no privilege, stricter law, or other disclosure requirement applies.

Answer: Do not disclose the schedules.

Dale has not consented, and counsel's informal request creates no legal compulsion. Providing a verbal summary would also disclose confidential client information.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The informal request is replaced by counsel's demand letter threatening to seek a subpoena.

Answer: Do not disclose the schedules.

A threat to seek a subpoena has no present legal force. The threatening language does not change the answer.

Change 2The informal request is replaced by a validly issued and enforceable court subpoena for the schedules.

Answer: Produce only the specified schedules, despite Dale's objection.

The subpoena creates a legal-compulsion exception. Dale's objection does not override it; confirm validity and scope before producing the schedules.

Change 3The informal request is replaced by a validly issued and enforceable IRS summons for the schedules.

Answer: Produce only the specified schedules, despite Dale's objection.

A valid, enforceable summons also permits required disclosure without consent. The summons controls, not Dale's objection.

Key points

  • Remember: A request or threat is not legal compulsion; a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons is.
  • Check the document's validity and scope before producing the requested schedules.
  • Dale's objection cannot block disclosure required by valid, enforceable legal process.
  • Produce the specified schedules, not the entire consulting file.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating counsel's demand or threatened subpoena as legal compulsion. Without consent or an applicable exception, keep the schedules confidential.
  • Letting Dale's objection override a valid, enforceable subpoena or summons. Comply with the legal process to the extent required.
  • Producing the entire consulting file once a subpoena arrives. Produce only the schedules specified in the legal process.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Mills, CPA, in public practice, provided non-tax consulting services to Dale Co. Dale expressly instructs Mills not to disclose its confidential cash flow schedules. Opposing counsel informally requests those schedules. Only the AICPA confidentiality rule is at issue; no privilege, stricter law, or other disclosure requirement applies. How should Mills respond?

Question 2

Same facts, except counsel sends a demand letter threatening to seek a subpoena for the schedules. How should Mills respond?

Question 3

Same facts, except Mills receives a validly issued and enforceable court subpoena requiring the cash flow schedules. How should Mills respond?

Question 4

Same facts, except Mills is served with a validly issued and enforceable IRS summons requiring the cash flow schedules. How should Mills respond?

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Grant, a CPA in public practice, provided tax and attest services for Orion Co. Orion has not given Grant specific consent to disclose confidential client information. During Year 2 Grant receives: (1) a validly issued and enforceable subpoena for specified engagement documents; (2) an inquiry from Orion's prospective successor CPA requesting information about disagreements with management; and (3) a request from Orion's lender for copies of Orion's tax returns to support a loan renewal. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, which disclosures may Grant make without Orion's consent?
Hint

Identify which requests, if any, fall within the confidentiality rule's named exceptions (for example, compliance with legal process) versus which require client authorization.

Question 3

Mills, CPA, provides tax and advisory services to Dale Co. Dale has not given Mills specific consent to disclose any of its information. Mills receives these requests for Dale's information: 1. Dale's commercial lender asks for Mills' tax workpapers and states it will keep them confidential. 2. A successor CPA engaged by Dale asks for prior-year schedules, but Dale has not communicated consent to Mills. 3. A court issues a validly issued and enforceable subpoena requiring production of specified Dale records. 4. Dale's 80% shareholder, acting in an individual capacity and not authorized by Dale to receive records, asks Mills to email the company's return details. Under the AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule, which request may Mills comply with without Dale's specific consent?
Hint

Ask which request is supported by a legal order (legal compulsion) rather than by third-party assurances, successor cooperation, or ownership claims.

Question 4

Barnes, CPA, performed a non-tax litigation consulting engagement for West Co. in Year 1. The engagement has ended, and West still disputes part of Barnes's fee. In Year 2, Barnes receives both of the following: (1) a written request from West's bank for copies of West's cash flow analysis because the bank is considering a loan renewal, and (2) a validly issued and enforceable subpoena from a court requesting specified engagement documents in litigation involving West. West has not given Barnes any consent to disclose information. Assume no statute imposes a stricter confidentiality rule than the AICPA Code. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate the two requests. Ask whether each one independently fits a recognized exception to the confidentiality rule.

Question 5

Pat, CPA, prepared Diaz's 20X5 federal income tax return for a fee. Pat is subject to both the AICPA confidentiality rule and the federal tax return preparer confidentiality rules. Diaz's spouse is not Pat's client and did not file a joint return with Diaz. Assume no client consent has been obtained unless a choice states otherwise, and any subpoena mentioned is valid and enforceable. Which statement is best supported?
Hint

Test each choice against both frameworks named in the stem, not just one. Ask which option has an explicit legal-process exception rather than relying on implied permission or business convenience.

Question 6

Rhee, a CPA in public practice, performed advisory services for Maple, Inc. Later, Maple hires a new CPA, who asks Rhee for prior-year engagement workpapers to help with the transition. Separately, in unrelated litigation involving Maple, a state court issues a validly issued and enforceable subpoena requiring Rhee to produce selected engagement documents. Maple does not consent to either disclosure. Assume the subpoenaed documents are not privileged. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, which response is best supported?
Hint

Ask whether each disclosure is merely helpful to another professional or instead is compelled by a recognized exception to confidentiality.

Question 7

Lee, a CPA in public practice, previously served Apex Co.; Apex later retained a new accountant. Apex has not given Lee specific consent to disclose confidential client information, and assume no state law modifies the AICPA confidentiality rule. Lee then receives these requests about Apex information: (1) Apex's successor CPA asks Lee for prior-year schedules and workpapers to help prepare the current year's return; (2) Apex's lender asks Lee to email a copy of Apex's tax return because the lender is renewing Apex's line of credit; (3) Lee receives a validly issued and enforceable subpoena requiring production of specified Apex records in litigation. Under the AICPA confidential client information rule, which response is best supported?
Hint

Ask which numbered request, if any, fits an AICPA-recognized exception to client confidentiality rather than whether the disclosure would be convenient or helpful.

Drill all 93 Confidentiality questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a CPA disclose client information after an attorney threatens a subpoena?

No. A demand letter or threat to seek a subpoena does not authorize disclosure without consent when no other exception applies.

Does a client's objection prevent disclosure under a valid subpoena?

No. Under the AICPA rule, a validly issued and enforceable subpoena permits disclosure without client consent. Produce only what it requires.

Can a CPA comply with an IRS summons without client consent?

Yes, if the summons is validly issued and enforceable. In Dale's non-tax consulting example, Mills may produce the specified schedules despite Dale's objection.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Confidentiality

All Confidentiality practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.