REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 11 practice questions
AICPA Confidentiality: Valid Subpoena or Summons
Without client consent, a request alone does not permit disclosure; a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons permits required disclosure. Below, the request for client schedules changes legal form while the client's objection stays fixed.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the narrow situations in which the rule expressly allows disclosure without client consent, not on whether the disclosure would be useful or professionally convenient.
Answer C. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule generally prohibits disclosure of client information without the client's specific consent, but includes narrow exceptions required by law. One clear exception is disclosure to comply with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or court order, which permits producing requested client information without the client's consent. Other situations (requests from lenders, successor CPAs, or informal consultations) normally require client consent or a separate legal/regulatory basis for disclosure.
Why not A: This is tempting because lenders commonly request tax returns to assess creditworthiness, but a third party's business need does not create an exception to the confidentiality rule. Without the client's specific consent (or a legal requirement), the CPA should not disclose tax return details to the lender.
Why not B: This distractor plays on normal predecessor-successor communications, but providing a client's workpapers or identifiable client information typically requires the client's consent. A successor CPA's request alone does not override confidentiality absent client permission or a legal exception.
Why not D: Although professional consultation is common, sharing identifiable client information with an outside CPA without consent is a disclosure of confidential information. Unless identifying details are removed or the client consents, such informal discussions are not permitted by the rule.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Mills, CPA, in public practice, provided non-tax consulting services to Dale Co. Dale expressly instructs Mills not to disclose its confidential cash flow schedules. Opposing counsel sends an informal request for those schedules. Only the AICPA confidentiality rule is at issue; no privilege, stricter law, or other disclosure requirement applies.
Answer: Do not disclose the schedules.
Dale has not consented, and counsel's informal request creates no legal compulsion. Providing a verbal summary would also disclose confidential client information.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The informal request is replaced by counsel's demand letter threatening to seek a subpoena.
Answer: Do not disclose the schedules.
A threat to seek a subpoena has no present legal force. The threatening language does not change the answer.
Change 2The informal request is replaced by a validly issued and enforceable court subpoena for the schedules.
Answer: Produce only the specified schedules, despite Dale's objection.
The subpoena creates a legal-compulsion exception. Dale's objection does not override it; confirm validity and scope before producing the schedules.
Change 3The informal request is replaced by a validly issued and enforceable IRS summons for the schedules.
Answer: Produce only the specified schedules, despite Dale's objection.
A valid, enforceable summons also permits required disclosure without consent. The summons controls, not Dale's objection.
Key points
- Remember: A request or threat is not legal compulsion; a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons is.
- Check the document's validity and scope before producing the requested schedules.
- Dale's objection cannot block disclosure required by valid, enforceable legal process.
- Produce the specified schedules, not the entire consulting file.
How the exam traps you
- Treating counsel's demand or threatened subpoena as legal compulsion. Without consent or an applicable exception, keep the schedules confidential.
- Letting Dale's objection override a valid, enforceable subpoena or summons. Comply with the legal process to the extent required.
- Producing the entire consulting file once a subpoena arrives. Produce only the schedules specified in the legal process.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer C. Correct. Dale withheld consent, and no disclosure exception applies.
Why not A: An attorney's informal request does not create legal compulsion.
Why not B: An informal request authorizes neither the schedules nor the full file.
Why not D: A verbal summary still discloses confidential client information.
Question 2
Answer D. Correct. The threat changes the pressure, not Mills's authority to disclose.
Why not A: A threatened subpoena is not a validly issued and enforceable subpoena.
Why not B: A demand letter does not authorize disclosure of any part of the file.
Why not C: Confidentiality covers information, not just physical documents.
Question 3
Answer A. Correct. Valid, enforceable legal process permits the required disclosure without consent.
Why not B: Dale's objection does not override the valid, enforceable subpoena.
Why not C: The exception covers only what the subpoena requires, not the entire file.
Why not D: A verbal summary does not satisfy a subpoena requiring production of the schedules.
Question 4
Answer B. Correct. The summons permits required disclosure without Dale's consent.
Why not A: Client objection does not defeat the valid, enforceable summons.
Why not C: The summons authorizes required disclosure, not unrestricted access to the file.
Why not D: A validly issued and enforceable summons also qualifies for the legal-compulsion exception.
Question 2
Hint
Identify which requests, if any, fall within the confidentiality rule's named exceptions (for example, compliance with legal process) versus which require client authorization.
Answer A. The AICPA confidentiality rule prohibits voluntary disclosure of client information without client authorization except in limited circumstances; a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons is a recognized exception that permits disclosure without the client's consent. Therefore Grant may comply with request (1). Communications to a prospective successor CPA and providing tax returns to a lender are not covered by that exception and generally require the client's authorization (or separate legal process).
Why not B: Tempting because successor-predecessor communications commonly occur during client transitions and often involve discussing disagreements with management. It is wrong because such communications are voluntary disclosures that generally require the client's consent; the subpoena exception only applies to legally compelled disclosures, not routine successor inquiries.
Why not C: Tempting because lenders routinely request tax returns to evaluate creditworthiness and one might assume business need permits disclosure. It is wrong because the confidentiality rule does not allow releasing tax returns to a third-party lender without the client's authorization; absent a subpoena or other legal compulsion, the CPA should not disclose them.
Why not D: Tempting as an appropriately cautious application of confidentiality, but incorrect because it ignores the established exception for legally compelled disclosures. A validly issued and enforceable subpoena authorizes disclosure without client consent, so request (1) may be complied with.
Question 3
Hint
Ask which request is supported by a legal order (legal compulsion) rather than by third-party assurances, successor cooperation, or ownership claims.
Answer D. The AICPA Confidential Client Information Rule prohibits disclosure of client information without the client's specific consent except in limited circumstances such as legal compulsion. A validly issued and enforceable subpoena is legal compulsion, so Mills may produce the requested records in response to the court's subpoena without separate consent from Dale.
Why not A: Tempting because the lender's confidentiality promise and business relationship might suggest disclosure is appropriate. Wrong because a third party's promise of confidentiality does not substitute for the client's specific consent and no exception is stated in the stem.
Why not B: Tempting because successor CPAs routinely need prior records to provide continuity of service. Wrong because the predecessor CPA generally must obtain the client's consent before releasing the client's information; the stem expressly says Dale has not communicated consent.
Why not C: Tempting because majority ownership might be assumed to confer access to corporate records. Wrong because ownership alone does not authorize disclosure of an entity client's confidential records, Mills needs the company's authorization or another recognized exception.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the two requests. Ask whether each one independently fits a recognized exception to the confidentiality rule.
Answer B. Under the AICPA confidentiality rule, a CPA generally may not disclose confidential client information without the client's specific consent. However, disclosure is permitted to comply with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or summons. The fact that the engagement ended and a fee dispute exists does not eliminate the confidentiality obligation, so the bank request still requires West's consent.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may think confidentiality weakens once the engagement is over or when a third party has a legitimate business purpose. But the duty of confidentiality continues after the engagement ends, and a bank's business need does not replace the client's specific consent. Only the subpoena fits a recognized exception in these facts.
Why not C: This choice reverses the rule. A CPA does not get to disclose confidential information merely because the disclosure might help the client obtain financing. By contrast, a validly issued and enforceable subpoena is a recognized basis for disclosure without first obtaining client consent.
Why not D: This option is partly true and therefore tempting: confidentiality does continue after the engagement ends. But it goes too far by ignoring the subpoena exception. Legal process does matter here because the subpoena is stated to be validly issued and enforceable.
Question 5
Hint
Test each choice against both frameworks named in the stem, not just one. Ask which option has an explicit legal-process exception rather than relying on implied permission or business convenience.
Answer C. A valid and enforceable federal grand jury subpoena is a legal-process exception to the confidentiality obligations under the AICPA rules and the federal tax-preparer rules. Pat may comply and disclose only the information specifically demanded by the subpoena; client consent is not required to comply with valid legal process.
Why not A: This is tempting because client consent generally permits disclosure, but federal preparer rules require appropriate authorization for third-party disclosures and oral phone approval alone is not a sufficient, reliable basis for disclosure.
Why not B: Paying the engagement fee or managing household finances does not make the spouse Pat's client or otherwise authorize disclosure when the spouse did not file a joint return; actual client authorization or a valid exception is required.
Why not D: Although the services might benefit Diaz, using confidential tax return information for unrelated marketing is not a permitted purpose under the preparer confidentiality rules or the AICPA code, and potential benefit does not create an exception.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether each disclosure is merely helpful to another professional or instead is compelled by a recognized exception to confidentiality.
Answer D. The AICPA confidentiality rule prohibits disclosure of client information without the client's consent except for recognized exceptions such as compliance with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena. A successor CPA's request is not itself an exception, so Maple's consent is required before providing workpapers.
Why not A: Tempting because a successor CPA needs information for continuity, but the confidentiality rule does not create an exception for another accountant's routine request; a subpoena, not client consent, authorizes compelled disclosure.
Why not B: This overstates the rule: confidentiality is strong but not absolute. A validly issued and enforceable subpoena is an established exception allowing disclosure without client consent.
Why not C: Although both requests may appear legitimate, the rule distinguishes legally compelled disclosure (subpoena) from a successor CPA's routine request; only the subpoena permits disclosure absent client consent.
Question 7
Hint
Ask which numbered request, if any, fits an AICPA-recognized exception to client confidentiality rather than whether the disclosure would be convenient or helpful.
Answer B. The AICPA confidentiality rule forbids disclosure of confidential client information without the client's specific consent except for limited, recognized exceptions. Typical exceptions include complying with a validly issued and enforceable subpoena or court order, disclosures required by law or regulation, and disclosures for professional practice/peer-review or ethics/disciplinary investigations. On these facts, only the subpoena (request 3) fits a recognized exception; requests 1 and 2 would require Apex's consent.
Why not A: Tempting because both requests concern the client's affairs and appear helpful, but the confidentiality rule does not permit disclosure merely because it benefits the client. Absent client consent or an applicable exception, neither a successor CPA's informal request nor a lender's request authorizes disclosure.
Why not C: Tempting because practitioners sometimes assume successors can automatically obtain a predecessor's workpapers, but successor access requires the client's authorization (or another recognized exception). Being the successor accountant alone does not permit disclosure without the client's consent.
Why not D: Tempting because confidentiality does survive the engagement, but this choice is too absolute. The AICPA rule includes limited exceptions, such as complying with a valid subpoena, legal mandates, or professional/ethics reviews, that can permit or require disclosure without client consent, so some disclosures (like a subpoena) may be allowed.
Common questions
Can a CPA disclose client information after an attorney threatens a subpoena?
No. A demand letter or threat to seek a subpoena does not authorize disclosure without consent when no other exception applies.
Does a client's objection prevent disclosure under a valid subpoena?
No. Under the AICPA rule, a validly issued and enforceable subpoena permits disclosure without client consent. Produce only what it requires.
Can a CPA comply with an IRS summons without client consent?
Yes, if the summons is validly issued and enforceable. In Dale's non-tax consulting example, Mills may produce the specified schedules despite Dale's objection.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Confidentiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.