REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 10 practice questions
Worthless Stock: Deemed Sale Date and Holding Period
Wholly worthless investment stock is treated as sold on the last day of the year it becomes worthless. Change the acquisition date or worthlessness year to see how that deemed sale determines capital-loss classification.
Try one first
Hint
For completely worthless securities, apply the rule that substitutes a year-end sale date before determining holding period.
Answer C. A security that becomes completely worthless is treated as sold or exchanged on the last day of the taxable year in which worthlessness occurs. Because the deemed sale date is December 31, Year 2, the holding period runs from July 10, Year 1 to that date, which is more than one year. The loss is therefore long-term capital.
Why not A: This results from treating the actual worthlessness date as the sale date and then measuring the holding period to that date. The rule instead deems a sale on December 31, Year 2, which produces a long-term capital loss here.
Why not B: This comes from remembering the year-end deemed sale rule but mismeasuring the holding period. From July 10, Year 1 through December 31, Year 2 exceeds one year, so the loss is not short-term.
Why not D: This reflects getting the capital character right but using the actual worthlessness date. Worthless securities are not treated as sold on the date they became worthless; they are treated as sold on the last day of that taxable year.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Mara, a calendar-year taxpayer, buys Aster stock for $12,000 on July 10, Year 2. The stock is a capital asset and does not qualify for ordinary loss treatment. On October 1, Year 2, Aster completes liquidation and cancels all shares without any shareholder distribution. The stock becomes wholly worthless that day. Mara never sells it.
Answer: $12,000 short-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.
The deemed sale occurs at year-end, not on October 1. From July 10 through December 31, Year 2 is less than one year.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Change only the acquisition date to December 10, Year 1.
Answer: $12,000 long-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.
The holding period exceeds one year at December 31, even though it was less than one year at the October 1 liquidation.
Change 2Change only the liquidation and resulting worthlessness date to October 1, Year 3.
Answer: $12,000 long-term capital loss in Year 3, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 3.
The deduction moves to Year 3. The July 10, Year 2 purchase is held more than one year through the deemed sale.
Change 3Change only the acquisition date to December 31, Year 1.
Answer: $12,000 short-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.
The holding period is exactly one year. This boundary matters: long-term treatment requires more than one year.
Key points
- Remember: Measure the holding period through December 31, even if the stock became worthless earlier that year.
- Long-term treatment requires more than one year; exactly one year is short-term.
- The $12,000 basis stays the same across these versions. Only the loss year or holding-period classification changes.
How the exam traps you
- For the December 10, Year 1 purchase, stopping at October 1, Year 2 gives a short-term loss. Use December 31, Year 2: the $12,000 loss is long-term because the holding period exceeds one year.
- Treating December 31, Year 1 through December 31, Year 2 as more than one year. That interval is exactly one year. The loss is short-term.
- Keeping the Year 2 deduction when complete worthlessness moves to Year 3. Use December 31 of the year the stock becomes wholly worthless: Year 3.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. Correct. The deemed sale is at year-end, and the holding period is less than one year.
Why not A: The classification is short-term, but the deemed sale date is December 31, not October 1.
Why not C: The holding period from July 10 through December 31, Year 2 is less than one year.
Why not D: Complete worthlessness triggers a deemed sale even without an actual sale.
Question 2
Answer C. Correct. December 10, Year 1 through December 31, Year 2 exceeds one year.
Why not A: Stopping at liquidation uses the wrong date and incorrectly produces short-term treatment.
Why not B: The deemed sale date is correct, but the holding period exceeds one year.
Why not D: The classification is correct, but the deemed sale occurs December 31, not October 1.
Question 3
Answer D. Correct. The deemed sale is December 31, Year 3, more than one year after acquisition.
Why not A: The stock becomes worthless in Year 3, not Year 2.
Why not B: Long-term character is correct, but the deduction belongs in Year 3.
Why not C: The holding period through December 31, Year 3 exceeds one year.
Question 4
Answer A. Correct. The year-end deemed sale creates a holding period of exactly one year, which is short-term.
Why not B: Exactly one year does not qualify as more than one year.
Why not C: The classification is correct, but October 1 is not the deemed sale date.
Why not D: Worthlessness fixes the deduction year. A short holding period does not delay the loss.
Question 2
Hint
Look for an identifiable event showing both no present value and no reasonable future value by year-end.
Answer B. A worthless security loss requires complete worthlessness, not just severe decline or uncertainty. A completed liquidation with shares canceled and no distribution to shareholders is an identifiable event showing no current or future value by year-end. That fact pattern best supports a Year 1 capital loss.
Why not A: This answer comes from focusing on business failure alone. Efforts to obtain new financing indicate possible future value, so the stock is not shown to be completely worthless yet.
Why not C: This answer comes from assuming bankruptcy automatically makes stock worthless. If shareholders still might receive something, complete worthlessness has not been established by December 31.
Why not D: This answer comes from treating a major market collapse as enough by itself. Suspension and a steep decline may show distress, but they do not prove the stock had no remaining value or recovery potential by year-end.
Question 3
Hint
Ask whether holding a security through a decline in value creates a deduction before it is sold or becomes wholly worthless.
Answer B. A mere decline in a security's value does not create a deductible loss while the taxpayer still holds it. Partial worthlessness is not deductible for securities. When the stock becomes wholly worthless in Year 2, Mara recognizes a capital loss for her full $48,000 basis.
Why not A: This answer correctly delays the deduction until complete worthlessness but uses only the Year 1 decline. When a security becomes wholly worthless, the deductible capital loss is the owner's full unrecovered basis, not just the earlier decline.
Why not C: This answer treats the Year 1 drop in value as a deductible partial worthlessness loss. That fails because securities cannot be written down for partial worthlessness while still held.
Why not D: This answer assumes a sale is always required before any loss can be recognized. That fails because a security that becomes wholly worthless is treated as generating a deductible capital loss in the year of worthlessness.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether the debt is business or nonbusiness, then apply the character rule for a wholly worthless nonbusiness debt.
Answer D. A bona fide debt unrelated to the taxpayer's trade or business is a nonbusiness bad debt. When it becomes wholly worthless, the tax law treats the loss as a short-term capital loss regardless of how long the debt was outstanding.
Why not A: This answer comes from assuming the debt's age controls the character, as it often does for capital assets. Nonbusiness bad debts do not use an actual holding period and are always treated as short-term capital losses.
Why not B: This answer comes from treating every failed personal loan as a personal, nondeductible loss. A bona fide debt that becomes wholly worthless is deductible, but a nonbusiness one is deductible only as a short-term capital loss.
Why not C: This answer results from confusing a nonbusiness bad debt with a business bad debt. Ordinary loss treatment applies to business bad debts, not to a bona fide personal loan unrelated to the taxpayer's trade or business.
Question 5
Hint
Decide whether the debt arose from the taxpayer's trade or business or from a nonbusiness relationship.
Answer C. A customer receivable from the retailer's normal sales activity is a business debt. When a business bad debt becomes worthless, it is deductible as an ordinary loss rather than a capital loss. Because the receivable became wholly worthless in Year 2, the deduction is taken in Year 2.
Why not A: This answer assumes an uncollectible receivable is simply a failed sale with no tax effect. Because the retailer uses the accrual method and already included the receivable in income, the worthless amount is deductible when it becomes worthless.
Why not B: This answer treats the receivable like a capital asset sold after a holding period. A business bad debt does not receive capital loss treatment at all, so the long-term category does not apply.
Why not D: This answer comes from confusing a business bad debt with a nonbusiness bad debt. Nonbusiness bad debts are treated as short-term capital losses when wholly worthless, but a customer receivable arising from operations is a business bad debt and is ordinary.
Question 6
Hint
For family advances, first decide whether objective facts show a real debtor-creditor relationship.
Answer B. Advances between family members are closely scrutinized to determine whether a true debtor-creditor relationship existed. An oral promise to repay after finances improve, with no interest, due date, collateral, records, or payments, is generally treated as family assistance rather than a bona fide debt. Without a bona fide debt, Section 166 does not allow a bad-debt deduction when the relative later becomes bankrupt.
Why not A: This treats the passage of time as controlling once bankruptcy occurs. A worthless nonbusiness debt is not treated as a long-term capital loss, and the facts do not establish a bona fide debt.
Why not C: This treats the advance as an existing debt and then classifies it as ordinary. The threshold problem is that the family transfer lacked the objective features of a bona fide debt.
Why not D: This applies the rule for a bona fide nonbusiness bad debt that becomes wholly worthless. That rule is not reached because the related-party advance was not shown to be a true debt.
Common questions
What is the deemed sale date for worthless stock?
Wholly worthless investment stock is deemed sold on the last day of the tax year it becomes worthless. For Mara, an October 1, Year 2 liquidation produces a December 31, Year 2 deemed sale.
Is worthless stock held exactly one year a short-term loss?
Yes. A December 31, Year 1 purchase deemed sold December 31, Year 2 produces a short-term loss. Long-term treatment requires more than one year.
Does moving stock worthlessness to the next year change the loss?
It moves the deduction and deemed sale date to that later year. For Mara's July 10, Year 2 purchase, worthlessness in Year 3 also changes the $12,000 loss from short-term to long-term.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Capital gains and losses and netting, worked step by step.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital gains and losses and netting
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.