PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 10 practice questions

Worthless Stock: Deemed Sale Date and Holding Period

Wholly worthless investment stock is treated as sold on the last day of the year it becomes worthless. Change the acquisition date or worthlessness year to see how that deemed sale determines capital-loss classification.

The ruleInvestment stock held as a capital asset that becomes wholly worthless is deemed sold on the last day of that tax year. Determine short-term or long-term character using that deemed sale date, not the actual worthlessness date.

Try one first

A calendar-year individual bought investment stock on July 10, Year 1. The stock became completely worthless on March 1, Year 2, and was never sold. How is the loss treated for federal income tax purposes?
Hint

For completely worthless securities, apply the rule that substitutes a year-end sale date before determining holding period.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Mara, a calendar-year taxpayer, buys Aster stock for $12,000 on July 10, Year 2. The stock is a capital asset and does not qualify for ordinary loss treatment. On October 1, Year 2, Aster completes liquidation and cancels all shares without any shareholder distribution. The stock becomes wholly worthless that day. Mara never sells it.

Answer: $12,000 short-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.

The deemed sale occurs at year-end, not on October 1. From July 10 through December 31, Year 2 is less than one year.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Change only the acquisition date to December 10, Year 1.

Answer: $12,000 long-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.

The holding period exceeds one year at December 31, even though it was less than one year at the October 1 liquidation.

Change 2Change only the liquidation and resulting worthlessness date to October 1, Year 3.

Answer: $12,000 long-term capital loss in Year 3, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 3.

The deduction moves to Year 3. The July 10, Year 2 purchase is held more than one year through the deemed sale.

Change 3Change only the acquisition date to December 31, Year 1.

Answer: $12,000 short-term capital loss in Year 2, with a deemed sale on December 31, Year 2.

The holding period is exactly one year. This boundary matters: long-term treatment requires more than one year.

Key points

  • Remember: Measure the holding period through December 31, even if the stock became worthless earlier that year.
  • Long-term treatment requires more than one year; exactly one year is short-term.
  • The $12,000 basis stays the same across these versions. Only the loss year or holding-period classification changes.

How the exam traps you

  • For the December 10, Year 1 purchase, stopping at October 1, Year 2 gives a short-term loss. Use December 31, Year 2: the $12,000 loss is long-term because the holding period exceeds one year.
  • Treating December 31, Year 1 through December 31, Year 2 as more than one year. That interval is exactly one year. The loss is short-term.
  • Keeping the Year 2 deduction when complete worthlessness moves to Year 3. Use December 31 of the year the stock becomes wholly worthless: Year 3.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Mara, a calendar-year taxpayer, buys Aster stock for $12,000 on July 10, Year 2. It is a capital asset ineligible for ordinary loss treatment. On October 1, Year 2, Aster completes liquidation and cancels all shares without a shareholder distribution. The stock becomes wholly worthless that day. Mara never sells it. What is the federal tax treatment?

Question 2

Same facts, except Mara bought the stock on December 10, Year 1. What is the loss treatment and deemed sale date?

Question 3

Same facts, except Aster's liquidation and the stock's resulting complete worthlessness occur on October 1, Year 3. What is Mara's loss treatment?

Question 4

Same facts, except Mara bought the stock on December 31, Year 1. What is the loss treatment and deemed sale date?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

An individual wants to claim a Year 1 capital loss for stock that became worthless. Which Year 1 development best supports treating the stock as completely worthless by December 31?
Hint

Look for an identifiable event showing both no present value and no reasonable future value by year-end.

Question 3

Mara bought common stock for $48,000. By Dec. 31, Year 1, the issuer was in bankruptcy, and Mara estimated the stock was worth only $12,000. She kept the stock. In Year 2, the bankruptcy ended and the stock became entirely worthless. Assume the stock is a capital asset. What loss treatment applies?
Hint

Ask whether holding a security through a decline in value creates a deduction before it is sold or becomes wholly worthless.

Question 4

In Year 1, Lee lent a friend $12,000 under a signed note. The loan was a bona fide debt, was unrelated to Lee's trade or business, and became completely uncollectible in Year 1. How is Lee's loss from the worthless debt characterized for federal income tax purposes?
Hint

First decide whether the debt is business or nonbusiness, then apply the character rule for a wholly worthless nonbusiness debt.

Question 5

An accrual-method retailer included a $18,000 customer account receivable in income in Year 1. In Year 2, after unsuccessful collection efforts, the receivable became wholly worthless. How should the retailer treat the $18,000 in Year 2?
Hint

Decide whether the debt arose from the taxpayer's trade or business or from a nonbusiness relationship.

Question 6

In Year 1, Quinn transferred $24,000 to his adult sister for living expenses. She orally promised to repay him after her finances improved. Quinn charged no interest, set no due date, requested no collateral, and kept no repayment records. She made no payments and entered bankruptcy in Year 3. Quinn claims a bad-debt loss. What is Quinn's Year 3 federal income tax treatment?
Hint

For family advances, first decide whether objective facts show a real debtor-creditor relationship.

Drill all 87 Capital gains and losses and netting questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the deemed sale date for worthless stock?

Wholly worthless investment stock is deemed sold on the last day of the tax year it becomes worthless. For Mara, an October 1, Year 2 liquidation produces a December 31, Year 2 deemed sale.

Is worthless stock held exactly one year a short-term loss?

Yes. A December 31, Year 1 purchase deemed sold December 31, Year 2 produces a short-term loss. Long-term treatment requires more than one year.

Does moving stock worthlessness to the next year change the loss?

It moves the deduction and deemed sale date to that later year. For Mara's July 10, Year 2 purchase, worthlessness in Year 3 also changes the $12,000 loss from short-term to long-term.

Watch it solved

A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Capital gains and losses and netting, worked step by step.

REG Simulation: Capital Gain and Loss Netting on YouTube

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Capital gains and losses and netting

All Capital gains and losses and netting practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.