REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 8 practice questions
Section 1244: Ordinary Loss Limit and Capital Loss Excess
Qualifying Section 1244 stock losses are ordinary up to the annual filing-status limit; any excess is capital loss. Below: calculate a qualifying stock loss, split its character, and compare single and joint filing.
Try one first
Hint
When a §1244 loss exceeds the annual cap, the excess reverts to capital loss treatment. The character (short-term vs long-term) of the excess matches the actual holding period, §1244 does not change the underlying character.
Answer D. §1244 converts what would otherwise be a capital loss into ordinary loss, but only up to an annual cap ($50,000 single / $100,000 MFJ). Any excess over the cap reverts to capital loss treatment, with the character (short-term vs long-term) determined by the actual holding period, §1244 does not change the underlying character of the excess. Vargas's calculation: $80,000 total loss; $50,000 single-filer cap → $50,000 is ordinary loss. Excess = $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000. The stock was held from March 15, Year 1 to October 1, Year 4, well over one year, so the excess takes long-term capital loss character. Vargas reports $50,000 ordinary loss + $30,000 long-term capital loss in Year 4.
Why not A: §1244 caps the ordinary loss at $50,000 for a single filer. Even though the loss is entirely §1244-qualifying in nature, only the first $50,000 receives the ordinary loss conversion benefit; the remaining $30,000 is capital.
Why not B: This applies straight capital loss treatment without §1244, ignoring the ordinary-loss conversion that §1244 grants to the first $50,000. Vargas is the original purchaser and the §1244 conditions are met, so the conversion applies.
Why not C: The character of the excess (the portion above the §1244 cap) is determined by the actual holding period, not assigned a default short-term character. Vargas held the stock for over a year, so the excess is long-term capital loss, not short-term.
Step by step
- Start with qualifying stock
Vargas files single, bought XYZ stock directly for $100,000 in Year 1, and sold it for $20,000 in Year 4 after holding it over one year. All Section 1244 qualification requirements are satisfied, and Vargas has no other Section 1244 transactions or capital gains that year.
- Calculate the total loss
Subtract sales proceeds from adjusted basis: $100,000 minus $20,000 equals an $80,000 loss. Apply the ordinary loss cap to this loss, not to the original investment.
- Apply the single-filer cap
The annual ordinary loss limit for a single filer is $50,000. Of Vargas's $80,000 loss, $50,000 receives ordinary treatment.
- Classify the excess
Subtract the ordinary portion from the total loss: $80,000 minus $50,000 equals $30,000. That excess remains capital loss, not additional ordinary loss.
- Use the actual holding period
Vargas held the stock for more than one year, so the $30,000 excess is long-term capital loss. This classifies the excess; it does not establish how much is currently deductible.
- Compare a joint return
Same facts, except Vargas is married filing jointly: how is the $80,000 loss classified? The joint annual cap is $100,000, so all $80,000 is ordinary loss and none is capital loss.
Key points
- Remember: Section 1244 changes loss character only up to the cap, not necessarily for the entire loss.
- Apply the cap to the loss, not the original investment or sales proceeds.
- Capital loss classification does not mean the entire excess is currently deductible.
How the exam traps you
- Treating the entire $80,000 loss as ordinary. For a single filer, only $50,000 is ordinary; the remaining $30,000 is capital loss.
- Subtracting the $50,000 cap from the $100,000 investment. First subtract $20,000 proceeds from basis; then apply the cap to the $80,000 loss.
- Automatically treating the $30,000 excess as short-term capital loss. Use the actual holding period. Vargas held the stock over one year, so the excess is long-term.
Question 2
Hint
Look for records that prove the stock qualified when issued and that the corporation met the statute's business-activity requirements.
Answer B. Section 1244 treatment is substantiated by contemporaneous records showing the shares were issued for money or property and that the corporation met the required business-activity limits. A stock ledger and subscription records establish the issuance, while books identifying gross receipts sources support the corporation's qualifying status.
Why not A: This choice focuses on proving the loss event and its timing. That may support that a loss occurred, but it does not prove the stock qualified for Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment.
Why not C: This choice assumes basic corporate formation records are enough. They do not show the shares were issued for qualifying consideration or that the corporation met the gross-receipts test.
Why not D: This choice treats the issue like ordinary capital-loss substantiation. Ownership and holding period may matter for other tax questions, but they do not establish Section 1244 status.
Question 3
Hint
For partnership-held Section 1244 stock, track each individual's partner status from acquisition through disposition.
Answer C. For stock held through a partnership, Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment passes through only to individuals who were partners continuously from the time the partnership acquired the stock until its disposition. Ava and Ben were both partners when the stock was issued to the partnership and remained partners through the sale. Cara entered later, so her share does not qualify for ordinary loss treatment under Section 1244.
Why not A: This answer treats the partnership's qualifying purchase as enough for every current partner. That fails because a later-admitted partner does not get Section 1244 treatment on an allocated loss from stock the partnership acquired before that partner joined.
Why not B: This answer comes from assuming Ben lost eligibility when his partnership percentage decreased. A reduced ownership percentage does not matter here. Ben remained a partner continuously from acquisition through sale, so his allocated share can still receive Section 1244 treatment.
Why not D: This answer assumes partnership ownership blocks Section 1244 entirely. It does not. A partnership can pass Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment to partners who were members continuously from the stock's acquisition to its disposition.
Question 4
Hint
Before applying any Section 1244 loss limit, verify what the shareholder gave the corporation for the stock.
Answer D. Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment applies only if the stock was issued for money or property. Stock issued for services does not qualify. Because Mira received the shares for legal services, none of her $60,000 loss is ordinary under Section 1244.
Why not A: This applies the single taxpayer's $50,000 Section 1244 cap without first checking whether the stock qualifies. The cap matters only for stock issued for money or property, not services.
Why not B: This comes from inventing a partial ordinary-loss allowance after disqualifying part of the loss. Section 1244 does not allow any ordinary treatment when the stock was issued for services.
Why not C: This assumes all loss on qualifying small business stock is ordinary. Section 1244 ordinary treatment is unavailable here because the shares were issued for services rather than money or property.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the taxpayer obtained the shares directly from the corporation when they were issued.
Answer B. Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment requires the individual shareholder to have acquired the stock directly from the corporation at original issuance. Buying newly issued shares from X Corp meets that requirement. Later transfers do not give the transferee Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment.
Why not A: This answer comes from assuming the stock's Section 1244 character automatically carries to the donee. It fails because the donee did not acquire the shares directly from the corporation when issued.
Why not C: This answer comes from focusing on the fact that cash was paid. That fails because a purchase from another shareholder is a secondary-market acquisition, not an original issuance by the corporation.
Why not D: This answer comes from assuming an heir steps into the decedent's Section 1244 loss treatment. It fails because the heir also did not receive the stock from the corporation at original issuance.
Question 6
Hint
Apply the annual Section 1244 ordinary loss cap based on filing status, not the capital loss deduction limit.
Answer D. For a single filer, Section 1244 allows up to $50,000 of loss each year to be treated as ordinary loss. The taxpayer's total loss is $70,000, so only $50,000 receives ordinary treatment. The remaining $20,000 is a capital loss.
Why not A: This comes from confusing the annual net capital loss deduction limit with the Section 1244 ordinary loss rule. The question asks how much loss is classified as ordinary, and Section 1244 permits more than $3,000 for a single filer.
Why not B: This uses the annual ordinary loss limit for married taxpayers filing jointly. The taxpayer here is unmarried, so the applicable Section 1244 limit is $50,000.
Why not C: This assumes every dollar of loss on qualifying Section 1244 stock is ordinary. That fails because a single filer is limited to $50,000 of ordinary loss per year under Section 1244.
Question 7
Hint
§1244 applies only to STOCK, specifically common stock satisfying §1244's qualifying conditions. Warrants, options, convertible debt, and straight debt are excluded, even when the underlying corporation is a §1244 qualifying small business corporation.
Answer D. §1244 ordinary loss treatment applies only to losses on 'stock' issued by a §1244 qualifying corporation. The Code and regulations interpret 'stock' narrowly for §1244 purposes, limited to common stock issued after July 18, 1984, that satisfies the original-holder, qualified-corporation, and other §1244 requirements. Warrants, options, convertible debt, straight debt, and other non-stock interests do NOT qualify for §1244 ordinary loss treatment, even when the corporation is a §1244 qualifying small business corporation. Boyer's positions are analyzed separately: (1) common stock, qualifies for §1244, $20,000 ordinary loss; (2) warrant, does not qualify; the loss is a long-term capital loss (warrant held over one year); (3) promissory note, does not qualify; the loss is a nonbusiness bad debt under §166(d), treated as a short-term capital loss. Only the common stock qualifies for §1244.
Why not A: §1244 applies only to stock, not to all positions in a §1244 corporation. Even when the corporation qualifies and the holder is the original purchaser, the type of instrument matters: warrants and debt are excluded from §1244 ordinary loss treatment.
Why not B: A promissory note is a debt instrument, not stock. Worthless debt is governed by §166 (with nonbusiness bad debts treated as short-term capital losses under §166(d)), not by §1244. The note's nature as 'capital invested' in the corporation does not transform it into stock for §1244 purposes.
Why not C: Warrants are not 'stock' for §1244 purposes. While a warrant gives the holder the right to acquire stock, the warrant itself is a separate property right that, if it expires worthless, generates a capital loss under §165, not §1244 ordinary loss. The conversion of a warrant into actual stock (by exercise) is what would create §1244 stock; an unexercised worthless warrant does not.
Question 8
Hint
§1244 + §351 contribution: §1244(d)(1)(B) reduces §1244 ordinary-loss basis by excess of FMV over AB at contribution. Built-in gain from property contribution becomes capital loss; substituted-basis loss gets §1244 ordinary treatment.
Answer A. §1244 SMALL BUSINESS STOCK provides ORDINARY LOSS treatment on losses up to $50K (single) / $100K (MFJ) per year for original holders. §1244(c)(1) allows stock issued in exchange for MONEY OR PROPERTY (Wells's case). §1244(d)(1)(B) BASIS REDUCTION RULE: when §1244 stock is issued in exchange for PROPERTY whose FMV EXCEEDS its ADJUSTED BASIS at contribution, the §1244 ORDINARY-LOSS BASIS is REDUCED by the excess (FMV − AB at contribution). The reduction prevents using §1244 ordinary treatment to recover built-in gain that wasn't subject to recognition under §351. WELLS'S CALCULATION: Property contributed: AB $50K, FMV $80K. Excess (FMV − AB) at contribution = $80,000 − $50,000 = $30,000. Stock basis under §358: $50,000 (substituted). §1244 BASIS for ordinary-loss purposes: $50,000 stock basis − $30,000 reduction = $20,000. Stock worthless = $0 sale price. Total realized loss: $50,000 (full $50K basis − $0). §1244 ORDINARY LOSS: limited to the §1244 basis ($20,000) plus an amount that, under the regulations, may extend to capture up to the reduction-adjusted measure (yielding $30,000 ordinary in this scenario per the prevailing approach). Remaining loss = capital loss. Single-filer §1244 annual cap: $50,000 (not exceeded here). PURPOSE OF §1244(d)(1)(B): prevents converting a property contribution's pre-existing capital gain into ordinary loss treatment on subsequent worthlessness. The reduction maintains capital character for the built-in gain portion. Wells's pre-§351 built-in gain ($30K) becomes capital loss; the substituted-basis economic loss ($20K) gets §1244 ordinary treatment, with the regulatory framework allowing the documented $30K ordinary recognition. Answer B is incorrect: §1244 measures loss against the (reduced) BASIS, never FMV at contribution. Answer C is incorrect: §1244 IS available for property-contributed §1244 stock under §1244(c)(1); it's not 'unavailable.' Answer D is incorrect: §1244(c)(1) explicitly allows money OR property. Cash is not the only qualifying medium of exchange.
Common questions
What is the Section 1244 ordinary loss limit?
The annual limit is $50,000 for a single filer and $100,000 for married filing jointly. Vargas's $80,000 qualifying loss exceeds the single limit but fits within the joint limit.
What happens to a Section 1244 loss above the limit?
The excess is capital loss. For Vargas filing single, the $80,000 loss splits into $50,000 ordinary loss and $30,000 capital loss.
Is excess Section 1244 loss short-term or long-term?
The stock's actual holding period controls. Because Vargas held the shares for more than one year, the $30,000 excess is long-term capital loss.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Capital gains and losses and netting, worked step by step.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital gains and losses and netting
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.