REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Capital Gain Netting Order: 28%, 25%, and Regular Gains
A net short-term capital loss reduces long-term gains in this order: 28%, 25%, then 0%/15%/20%. Below, follow one taxpayer's loss through each group to find the gain that remains.
Try one first
Hint
First combine gains and losses by holding-period group, then combine the two group results if they have opposite signs.
Answer A. The short-term group nets to a $12,000 gain, and the long-term group nets to an $8,000 loss. Those opposite results must then be netted against each other. The larger side is short-term, so the final result is a $4,000 net short-term capital gain.
Why not B: This comes from stopping after the short-term group is netted. The long-term group also must be netted and then combined with the short-term result. The $8,000 long-term loss reduces the $12,000 short-term gain to $4,000.
Why not C: This reflects getting the $4,000 magnitude right but assigning the wrong character. When a net short-term gain is combined with a net long-term loss, the final character follows the larger absolute amount. Because $12,000 exceeds $8,000, the result is short-term.
Why not D: This comes from treating the long-term group as the final answer by itself. A taxpayer does not report separate final short-term and long-term net amounts when they have opposite signs. The $12,000 short-term gain offsets the $8,000 long-term loss.
Step by step
- Sort the facts
Avery has $2,000 of short-term gains and $12,000 of short-term losses. Avery also has a $6,000 long-term collectibles gain, $3,000 of unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, an $8,000 regular long-term stock gain, and a $3,000 regular long-term stock loss, with no other capital items or carryovers.
- Net the short-term items
Subtract $12,000 of short-term losses from $2,000 of short-term gains. Avery has a $10,000 net short-term capital loss.
- Net each long-term group
The 28% group has $6,000, and the 25% group has $3,000. The regular 0%/15%/20% group has $8,000 minus $3,000, or $5,000.
- Reduce the 28% group first
Apply $6,000 of the short-term loss against the entire collectibles gain. The 28% group falls to zero, leaving $4,000 of loss to apply.
- Reduce the 25% group next
Apply $3,000 of the remaining loss against the unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. The 25% group falls to zero, leaving $1,000 of loss.
- Reduce the regular group last
Apply the final $1,000 of loss against the $5,000 regular long-term gain. That leaves $4,000 in the 0%/15%/20% group.
- Report the surviving gain
Avery has a $4,000 net long-term capital gain, entirely in the regular rate group. The 28% and 25% labels are maximum rates, but neither group has any gain left to tax.
Key points
- Remember: use the loss against the highest-rate group first, not proportionally across all groups.
- Identify each long-term rate group before combining short-term and long-term results.
- The 28% and 25% labels are maximum rates, not automatic tax rates.
- When opposite-sign short-term and long-term totals offset, the excess keeps the larger side's character.
How the exam traps you
- Spread the short-term loss proportionally across all long-term groups. Reduce the 28% group completely before moving to the 25% group.
- Use the short-term loss against regular long-term gains first. Reach the 0%/15%/20% group only after exhausting the 28% and 25% groups.
- Stop after netting within each group. Apply the net short-term loss to the long-term gains before reporting the remaining gain.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on both who transferred the shares and what the shareholder gave in exchange.
Answer B. QSBS generally must be acquired at original issuance directly from the issuing corporation, or through an underwriter, for money, property other than stock, or services to the issuing corporation. Shares issued directly by the corporation as compensation for consulting services satisfy the acquisition requirement, assuming the other QSBS requirements in the stem are met.
Why not A: This answer treats providing services as enough by itself. Services count for the acquisition requirement only when the issuing corporation issues the stock as compensation.
Why not C: This answer focuses on the later holding period and the seller's original ownership. A private purchase from an existing shareholder is not an acquisition at original issuance from the issuing corporation.
Why not D: This answer treats any direct issuance by the corporation as sufficient. The acquisition requirement does not cover stock issued in exchange for other stock, because property for this purpose excludes stock.
Question 3
Hint
Exclude the acquisition day and determine the first day the stock has been held for more than five years.
Answer C. Section 1202 requires the stock to be held for more than five years. The holding period starts on the day after acquisition, so stock acquired on January 15, Year 1 begins its holding period on January 16, Year 1. The first date that is more than five years later is January 16, Year 6.
Why not A: This answer comes from stopping one day before the fifth anniversary. That date is still short of more than five years because the holding period began on January 16, Year 1.
Why not B: This answer comes from adding an extra day after the rule is already met. Once the stock reaches more than five years on January 16, Year 6, waiting until January 17 is unnecessary.
Why not D: This answer comes from counting the acquisition date as part of the holding period or treating the anniversary date as enough. The acquisition day is excluded, and Section 1202 requires more than five years.
Question 4
Hint
Measure qualified dividends against the capital gain brackets after stacking them on top of other taxable income.
Answer A. Qualified dividends are taxed using the same preferential rate brackets as net capital gains. Dana's taxable income before the dividends already uses $44,000 of the $50,000 0% bracket, leaving $6,000 of room. The remaining $4,000 of dividends is taxed at 15%.
Why not B: This comes from assuming all qualified dividends get 0% whenever pre-dividend taxable income is below the cutoff. That fails because the dividends themselves fill the remaining 0% bracket space.
Why not C: This comes from treating qualified dividends like ordinary income that never receives preferential rates. That fails because qualified dividends use the capital gain rate structure.
Why not D: This comes from subtracting the wrong amount when finding the unused 0% bracket. The available 0% space is $50,000 minus $44,000, not $10,000 minus $6,000.
Question 5
Hint
Compute both limitation amounts for the same issuer, then use the larger one, but never more than the realized gain.
Answer C. Section 1202 limits excludable gain to the greater of two amounts. The first is $10,000,000 reduced by prior excluded gain from the same issuer, which is $7,000,000 here. The second is 10 times Lee's adjusted basis in the stock sold, or $9,000,000. Because the greater amount is $9,000,000, that is the maximum exclusion.
Why not A: This answer assumes the entire realized gain is excludable once the stock qualifies. Section 1202 still caps the exclusion, and Lee's limitation is $9,000,000 rather than the full realized gain.
Why not B: This answer comes from using only the $10,000,000 limitation reduced by prior exclusions from the same issuer. That produces $7,000,000, but Section 1202 requires comparing that amount with 10 times basis and using the greater amount.
Why not D: This answer treats the fixed limitation as an unreduced $10,000,000 amount. The statute reduces that amount by prior excluded gain from Maple Corp, so the fixed side of the comparison is only $7,000,000.
Question 6
Hint
First net the short-term bucket and the long-term bucket separately, then combine the two net amounts if they have opposite signs.
Answer B. Lila's short-term items net to an $18,000 short-term capital loss, and her long-term items net to a $25,000 long-term capital gain. Those opposite-sign net amounts are then offset against each other. The remaining $7,000 keeps the character of the larger category, so it is long-term gain.
Why not A: This comes from netting only the long-term transactions and ignoring the short-term net loss. A net short-term loss offsets a net long-term gain. After that offset, only $7,000 of long-term gain remains.
Why not C: This comes from netting only the short-term transactions and stopping there. The long-term transactions also must be netted, and then the short-term and long-term net amounts must be combined. That additional step eliminates the short-term loss and leaves a net gain.
Why not D: This comes from offsetting the two net amounts correctly but assigning the final character to the short-term side. The final character does not follow the loss category. It follows the category with the excess amount after offset, which is long-term gain here.
Common questions
What is the capital gain netting order for a short-term loss?
First net short-term items and each long-term rate group separately. Apply the net short-term loss to 28% gains, then 25% unrecaptured Section 1250 gains, then regular 0%/15%/20% gains.
Are long-term collectibles gains always taxed at 28%?
No. The 28% rate is a maximum, and losses can reduce the collectibles group before tax is calculated. Avery's collectibles gain is fully absorbed in the example.
Does a short-term loss make the remaining gain short-term?
No. When the long-term gain exceeds the net short-term loss, the remaining gain is long-term. Avery's remaining $4,000 stays in the regular long-term rate group.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Capital gains and losses and netting, worked step by step.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Capital gains and losses and netting
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.