REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
Chapter 7 Fraud Debts: When Does a Loan Survive Discharge?
A lender with timely bankruptcy notice must file a timely adversary complaint and prove the fraud exception to keep Rae's loan from discharge. Sort the same loan by complaint timing and the court's ruling.
Try one first
Hint
Decide whether each category is statutorily nondischargeable by its terms or instead requires a timely adversary proceeding (or a debtor-initiated undue-hardship action) to avoid discharge.
Answer D. Debts arising from materially false written statements fall under 11 U.S.C. §523(a)(2)(B) and are preserved as nondischargeable only if a creditor timely brings a nondischargeability (adversary) action; because no such proceeding was filed here, the Chapter 7 general discharge will ordinarily include this debt. By contrast, the other items are governed by separate statutory presumptions or timing rules (student loans under §523(a)(8) require an undue-hardship determination by the debtor; certain DUI-related personal-injury claims are excepted under §523(a)(9); recent income taxes depend on specific timing and filing tests).
Why not A: Tempting because some income taxes can be discharged, but dischargeability depends on several timing and filing tests (commonly a 'three-year' rule for the return due date among others); a return first due only 18 months before filing ordinarily fails those tests.
Why not B: Certain personal-injury judgments tied to intoxicated driving are specifically excepted from discharge by statute (see 11 U.S.C. §523(a)(9)) and therefore remain nondischargeable even without a creditor's adversary complaint.
Why not C: Student loans are presumptively nondischargeable under 11 U.S.C. §523(a)(8); creditor inaction does not discharge the loan, the debtor must commence and prevail in an undue-hardship adversary proceeding to obtain a discharge.
Sort it
The lender received timely notice but missed the complaint deadline, or its timely complaint failed on the merits.
The lender timely filed and proved the borrowing-fraud exception.
The lender timely filed an adversary complaint, but the court has not decided whether the fraud exception applies.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Rae obtained a personal loan. The lender alleges a materially false written financial statement, intent to deceive, and reasonable reliance. Rae accurately scheduled the loan in Chapter 7. The lender received timely notice but filed no adversary complaint. No deadline extension applies. Rae received a general discharge. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedThe lender's fraud allegations do not preserve the exception without a timely adversary complaint. |
| Same facts, except the court in the awaiting-decision scenario now finds every required borrowing-fraud element proved. Where does the loan belong? | Survives dischargeThe lender timely filed and proved the exception. This loan survives Rae's general discharge. |
| Same facts, except the lender already held a state-court fraud judgment on this loan before bankruptcy. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedThe judgment does not replace the required timely adversary complaint. |
| Same facts, except the lender timely filed an adversary complaint that remains undecided (the awaiting-decision scenario). Where does the loan belong? | Awaiting decisionTimely filing preserves the issue. The court must still decide whether the lender proved the exception. |
| Same facts, except the lender filed a proof of claim before the complaint deadline. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedA proof of claim seeks payment from the estate; it does not replace a nondischargeability complaint. |
| Same facts, except the court in the awaiting-decision scenario now rules that the lender failed to prove reasonable reliance. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedTimely filing is not enough. Reasonable reliance is required for this written-financial-statement exception. |
| Same facts, except the lender filed its adversary complaint after the unextended deadline. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedA late complaint does not preserve the fraud exception when the lender received timely notice. |
| Same facts, except the court in the awaiting-decision scenario now rules that the lender failed to prove material falsity. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedThe lender loses because material falsity is a required element of this exception. |
| Same facts, except the court in the awaiting-decision scenario now rules that the lender failed to prove intent to deceive. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedThe lender must prove intent to deceive. A timely complaint cannot cure missing proof. |
| Same facts, except the lender orally accused Rae of borrowing fraud at the creditors' meeting before the complaint deadline. Where does the loan belong? | DischargedAn oral accusation does not replace a timely adversary complaint. |
Key points
- Remember: Fraud alone does not save the loan; the lender must timely file and win.
- A pending complaint leaves the loan's discharge status undecided, even after Rae receives a general discharge.
- A written-financial-statement claim requires material falsity, intent to deceive, and reasonable reliance.
How the exam traps you
- Treating fraud as automatically nondischargeable. Check whether the lender timely filed and proved its exception.
- Treating a judgment or proof of claim as enough. Neither replaces a timely adversary complaint.
- Treating a timely complaint as an automatic win. The lender still must prove every required borrowing-fraud element.
Question 2
Hint
Identify which debt category receives special protection from discharge, rather than which bill seems most important or most burdensome.
Answer B. Domestic support obligations, such as child support arrearages, are generally nondischargeable in an individual's Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The stem excludes common nondischargeability grounds (fraud, luxury goods, willful and malicious injury) that might affect the other listed unsecured debts, so those other obligations are typically discharged.
Why not A: Medical bills are generally unsecured consumer debts that are dischargeable in Chapter 7 absent some special circumstance; the item explicitly removes fraud or other exceptions that could make medical debt nondischargeable.
Why not C: Although utilities have practical rules about deposits for continued service, an ordinary prepetition utility bill is typically an unsecured debt that can be discharged in Chapter 7 when no special exception applies.
Why not D: Credit card debt is commonly dischargeable in Chapter 7; the stem rules out misconduct (fraud, luxury goods) that could otherwise keep particular charges nondischargeable.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the type of debt, not the identity of the creditor. Some obligations tied to family support are treated differently from ordinary consumer debts.
Answer A. Domestic support obligations (for example, child support) are generally nondischargeable in an individual's Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The question removes fraud and reaffirmation issues, so ordinary unsecured consumer debts, such as credit card balances, medical bills, and signature loans, are typically dischargeable absent special facts. Therefore past-due child support is the least likely obligation to be discharged.
Why not B: Why tempting: candidates sometimes overgeneralize exceptions to discharge and recall disputes over credit card fraud. Why wrong: the stem rules out fraud and reaffirmation, and ordinary prepetition credit card debt is generally dischargeable in Chapter 7.
Why not C: Why tempting: medical debts feel serious and unavoidable. Why wrong: ordinary prepetition medical bills are unsecured consumer debts and are generally dischargeable in Chapter 7 unless special circumstances exist (none are alleged here).
Why not D: Why tempting: a bank loan sounds formal and documented, leading some to think it survives bankruptcy. Why wrong: a standard unsecured personal (signature) loan is generally dischargeable in Chapter 7 absent fraud, nondischargeability litigation, or other exceptions not alleged here.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the substance of the debt from the procedure required to keep that debt from being discharged.
Answer D. Although debts obtained by fraud may be excepted from discharge, a creditor who receives timely notice generally must seek a judicial determination (typically by filing a nondischargeability complaint) to preserve that exception. Because the creditor here had adequate notice but did not initiate the required proceeding, that procedural failure is the controlling factor on whether the debt survives the Chapter 7 discharge.
Why not A: This is tempting because fraud is the substantive basis for §523(a)(2) exceptions, but the presence of fraud alone is not dispositive here: when a creditor has notice, it normally must timely commence a nondischargeability action to keep the debt from being discharged.
Why not B: A prepetition judgment may assist proof and sometimes has collateral estoppel effect, but it does not automatically prevent discharge if the creditor fails to pursue the statutory nondischargeability process.
Why not C: Estate assets affect distributions (how much creditors receive), but dischargeability is a separate issue governed by statutory exceptions and creditor procedure, not by whether the estate can pay unsecured claims.
Question 5
Hint
Decide whether each obligation is a domestic support obligation (nondischargeable) or an ordinary unsecured/property-division claim (generally dischargeable).
Answer D. Past-due child support is a domestic support obligation and is excepted from discharge under bankruptcy law; domestic support obligations (e.g., child support, alimony) survive a Chapter 13 discharge. The other listed items are typically ordinary unsecured or property-division claims that Chapter 13 can discharge.
Why not A: This distractor tempts because credit card debt arises from a domestic consumer transaction and often appears in bankruptcy examples. It fails because ordinary, nondischargeable-exception-free credit card balances are generally dischargeable in Chapter 13 as unsecured consumer obligations.
Why not B: This option tempts since it stems from a divorce judgment and could be confused with spousal support. It fails because a payment that functions as a property-division (a property settlement) is usually treated as a general unsecured claim and is typically dischargeable in Chapter 13 unless it is characterized as domestic support.
Why not C: This distractor tempts because deficiencies tied to secured collateral can feel special, but it fails because a prepetition deficiency after repossession and sale is an unsecured claim and, absent a statutory exception, is generally dischargeable in Chapter 13.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the remedy that targets one debt from the remedy that targets the debtor's entire Chapter 7 discharge.
Answer C. The key distinction is between denying a debtor's overall Chapter 7 discharge and excepting a particular debt from discharge. Debtor 2's knowing, material false oath in the bankruptcy case is the type of misconduct that can support denial of discharge. By contrast, Debtor 1's fraudulent loan application more directly supports nondischargeability of that specific loan, not denial of the debtor's entire Chapter 7 discharge.
Why not A: This is tempting because intentional borrowing fraud feels serious enough to justify the harshest remedy. But prepetition loan fraud typically leads to nondischargeability of that particular debt rather than automatic denial of the debtor's entire Chapter 7 discharge, especially where the debtor subsequently filed accurate schedules.
Why not B: Although both actions involve dishonesty, the law distinguishes between misconduct that taints the bankruptcy process (e.g., false oaths or omissions in schedules) and fraud limited to a specific prepetition transaction. Only the former is the classic basis for denying the entire discharge.
Why not D: Economic loss to the estate is not a prerequisite for denying discharge when a debtor makes a knowing, material false oath in the case. The focus is on the integrity of the bankruptcy process, not solely on quantifiable estate loss.
Common questions
Are fraud debts discharged in Chapter 7 bankruptcy?
For Rae's properly scheduled loan, the lender received timely notice. The loan is discharged unless the lender timely files an adversary complaint and proves the fraud exception.
Does a state-court fraud judgment automatically survive bankruptcy?
No. Even with a prepetition judgment, Rae's lender must timely file the required adversary complaint to preserve the fraud exception.
Does filing a fraud complaint make a loan nondischargeable?
No. A timely complaint preserves the lender's opportunity to prove the exception. The loan's status remains undecided until the court rules.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Bankruptcy, worked step by step.
Chapter 7 Priority Waterfall | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Bankruptcy
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.