REG · Business Law · 8 practice questions
Bankruptcy automatic stay: what stops when you file
Filing a bankruptcy petition immediately stops most collection of prepetition debts against the debtor and actions to seize estate property. Follow one equipment loan to separate barred collection from permitted bankruptcy procedures.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what event triggers the automatic stay in a voluntary bankruptcy case, not on later administrative steps.
Answer B. Under 11 U.S.C. ยง362(a), the automatic stay arises upon the filing of a bankruptcy petition and halts most efforts to collect prepetition claims, including pending lawsuits. No separate court order, listing on schedules, or actual notice to the creditor is required for the stay to take effect, although notice can affect enforcement and remedies for willful violations.
Why not A: Tempting because many injunctions require a court order, but the bankruptcy automatic stay is statutory and takes effect on filing, a separate stay order is not generally needed to stop collection litigation.
Why not C: This plays on the idea that scheduling a creditor triggers protections; schedules are important for claims and notice, but the automatic stay begins when the petition is filed regardless of whether the creditor is listed.
Why not D: Notice matters for a creditor's ability to assert rights and for assessing willfulness of violations, but lack of notice does not prevent the automatic stay from arising at the moment the petition is filed.
Step by step
- Set the loan facts
Reed, a sole proprietor, files a voluntary Chapter 7 petition while a bank's state-court lawsuit on a prepetition secured equipment loan is pending. No statutory exception applies, and the court has not granted stay relief.
- Start at filing
The stay starts when Reed files, before the bank receives notice. No separate stay order or trustee action is needed.
- Check collection against the debtor
The bank seeks payment of a prepetition debt from Reed, so its pending lawsuit stops. It cannot continue merely to obtain a judgment.
- Apply the same collection test
Garnishment and payment demand letters on that loan are also barred. The stay covers collection acts, not just lawsuits.
- Check the estate property
Reed's equipment is estate property, so the bank cannot repossess it despite its security interest and Reed's default. Secured status does not bypass the stay.
- Use permitted bankruptcy procedures
The bank may file a proof of claim or request stay relief within the bankruptcy case. Requesting relief is not permission to repossess; the court must grant it.
- Separate the stay from discharge
Filing pauses the bank's collection efforts; it does not discharge Reed's loan. The stay does not require permanent dismissal of the pending lawsuit.
Key points
- Remember: Filing stops outside collection, but creditors can still pursue claims inside the bankruptcy case.
- Use the debt's origin, not the lawsuit's stage, to identify a prepetition claim.
- A creditor's right to collateral and permission to repossess are separate questions.
How the exam traps you
- Waiting for notice, a separate order, or a discharge. The stay begins at filing, not at any of those later events.
- Treating a security interest as permission to repossess. The bank must obtain stay relief before repossession when no exception applies.
- Assuming the lawsuit may proceed if judgment enforcement waits. The stay stops the collection lawsuit itself, not just enforcement.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on what the bankruptcy filing generally does to collection activity after the petition date, not just on whether the creditor already had a judgment.
Answer C. The bankruptcy filing triggers an automatic stay that bars most collection actions to recover a prepetition debt unless the court authorizes relief. Apex had notice of Lee's Chapter 7 filing but instructed the employer to continue the prepetition garnishment without court relief, which generally constitutes a violation of the automatic stay.
Why not A: This is tempting because the garnishment predated the petition, but the automatic stay generally prevents enforcement of prepetition judgments and collection orders after filing unless relief is obtained from the bankruptcy court.
Why not B: Candidates may recall that some postpetition earnings are not estate property in Chapter 7, but that does not authorize a creditor to continue collecting a prepetition debt after notice of the filing; continuing the garnishment is a collection act restricted by the automatic stay.
Why not D: This distractor misstates the law: the automatic stay broadly restricts collection activity by unsecured and secured creditors alike. Unsecured status does not permit continued collection after the debtor files and the creditor receives notice.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what the bankruptcy filing does to creditor collection and repossession efforts, even when the creditor is secured.
Answer C. The filing of a bankruptcy petition triggers the automatic stay, which prevents most collection efforts, including repossession of collateral, without court permission. Although a secured creditor's lien generally survives the filing, the creditor ordinarily must obtain relief from the stay from the bankruptcy court before enforcing the lien against the collateral. Asking the court for stay relief is the proper, timely step to recover the equipment.
Why not A: This is tempting because secured creditors retain lien rights in bankruptcy, but retaining a lien is not the same as having the right to enforce it postpetition. The automatic stay bars unilateral repossession after the petition date absent court relief, so immediate self-help repossession would violate the stay.
Why not B: This may seem like a softer approach, but postpetition collection or recovery efforts by a creditor are still restricted by the automatic stay. Turnover under the bankruptcy code generally involves estate property and the trustee; a secured creditor should seek stay relief rather than attempt to pressure the debtor into surrendering collateral outside the court process.
Why not D: This ignores the creditor's immediate goal of enforcing its lien against the equipment and misunderstands bankruptcy effects on timing. Waiting to sue delays recovery, and the debtor's personal liability may be discharged; the correct first step is to request relief from the automatic stay to proceed against the collateral.
Question 4
Hint
Do not assume the automatic stay halts every legal or governmental action. Focus on whether the act is a collection effort on a prepetition claim or falls within a statutory exception.
Answer B. The automatic stay generally prohibits the commencement or continuation of civil actions against the debtor that seek to recover prepetition claims. A pending lawsuit to collect an unsecured debt is a collection action and is therefore stopped by the stay unless the bankruptcy court grants relief. Other listed actions fall within common exceptions to the stay.
Why not A: Criminal prosecutions are generally excepted from the automatic stay, so continuing a criminal case against the debtor is typically allowed and not barred by the stay.
Why not C: Family-law proceedings to establish paternity (and certain other domestic relations matters) are commonly excepted from the stay. The option is limited to establishing paternity rather than seeking postpetition collection of support.
Why not D: An audit to determine tax liability, without any collection steps, is generally not treated as a stay-prohibited collection action. Actual collection measures (e.g., levies) would be subject to the automatic stay.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what happens immediately when the bankruptcy petition is filed, not on what may happen later in the case.
Answer B. Filing a bankruptcy petition generally triggers the automatic stay, which immediately stops most efforts to collect prepetition debts, including garnishment to enforce a judgment. The stay is the primary immediate effect; discharge, if granted, occurs later in the case and lien avoidance requires separate statutory grounds and procedures.
Why not A: Tempting because the creditor already has a judgment, but enforcement of prepetition judgments is stayed by the automatic stay unless the bankruptcy court grants relief from the stay or a statutory exception applies.
Why not C: This confuses filing with discharge: the petition triggers the automatic stay immediately, but discharge (which permanently bars collection of dischargeable debts) is entered later if the debtor qualifies and the debt is dischargeable.
Why not D: Some liens can be avoided in bankruptcy, but lien avoidance is not automatic upon filing; it depends on specific statutory provisions and court proceedings. The immediate effect of filing is the stay, not automatic elimination of liens.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what happens immediately upon filing, not what may happen later in the bankruptcy case.
Answer C. The filing of a bankruptcy petition generally triggers the automatic stay immediately, which halts most efforts to collect prepetition debts, including wage garnishment and repossession, unless a statutory exception applies or the court grants relief from the stay. The fact pattern excludes exceptions and relief, so the stay operates to stop those actions at filing.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the practical notion of notice, but legally the automatic stay arises upon filing of the petition and does not depend on separate notice being sent to each creditor.
Why not B: This is tempting because secured creditors often pursue remedies, but the automatic stay applies to most secured and unsecured creditor collection efforts on filing; the secured lender cannot repossess without court permission or a statutory exception.
Why not D: This confuses the automatic stay with discharge: the stay is a temporary injunction that takes effect on filing, while discharge (which may eliminate certain debts) occurs later and is not automatic at the moment of filing.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on what happens immediately when a bankruptcy petition is filed and whether that protection depends on the creditor being secured or unsecured.
Answer C. A bankruptcy petition triggers the automatic stay, which halts most creditor collection and enforcement actions tied to prepetition claims, this includes repossession of collateral by a secured creditor. Because the lender had notice, did not obtain relief from the court, and repossessed equipment solely for a prepetition default (with no exception claimed), the repossession likely violated the automatic stay.
Why not A: This plays on the misconception that bankruptcy only helps unsecured creditors. In fact, the automatic stay is broader and generally restricts both secured and unsecured creditors from taking collection or enforcement actions after the petition is filed.
Why not B: Tempting because outside bankruptcy secured creditors often have state-law self-help remedies after default. But the bankruptcy filing imposes the automatic stay, which generally bars self-help repossession once the debtor files unless the creditor first obtains relief or an exception applies.
Why not D: Some may think the automatic stay is primarily a Chapter 11 reorganization tool, but it also arises in Chapter 7 cases. The chapter filed does not make postpetition repossession permissible on these facts.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on what happens immediately when a bankruptcy petition is filed, not on whether the creditor already had a judgment.
Answer D. A bankruptcy petition generally triggers the automatic stay immediately upon filing, which halts most efforts to collect prepetition debts, including scheduled enforcement actions such as a sheriff's sale. Because no exception applies and the court has not granted relief from the stay, the creditor must stop the sale.
Why not A: This is tempting because a prepetition judgment might seem to lock in rights to enforce, but the automatic stay ordinarily stops continued enforcement of prepetition judgments once the petition is filed. A prepetition judgment does not by itself overcome the stay.
Why not B: This mixes up the automatic stay with other injunctions. The stay arises automatically on filing the petition; a debtor does not need to file a separate motion to create it (though the debtor may later seek enforcement if a creditor continues actions).
Why not C: This distractor confuses lien status with the stay's scope. The automatic stay applies to collection efforts on both secured and unsecured prepetition claims; secured creditors may seek relief from the stay, but absent such relief the sale cannot proceed.
Common questions
When does the automatic stay begin in bankruptcy?
It generally begins immediately when the debtor files the petition. The bank need not receive notice, and no separate stay order is required.
Does bankruptcy stop lawsuits, garnishment, and repossession?
Generally, yes, when they seek to collect prepetition debt against the debtor or seize estate property. In Reed's example, those actions stop because no exception applies and no stay relief has been granted.
Can a creditor file a proof of claim during the automatic stay?
Yes. A proof of claim seeks payment through the bankruptcy case rather than through outside collection, so filing it does not violate the stay.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Bankruptcy, worked step by step.
Chapter 7 Priority Waterfall | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Bankruptcy
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.