REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
Automatic Stay: Criminal Prosecution Exception
The automatic stay generally halts collection of prepetition debts, but criminal prosecutions may commence or continue. Sort actions after Lane files Chapter 7: all debts and underlying events predate filing, and no stay relief has been granted.
Try one first
Hint
Apply the automatic‑stay rule to each pending matter separately and test for statutory exceptions (governmental police/regulatory enforcement and domestic‑support withholding) instead of assuming the stay applies uniformly.
Answer A. The automatic stay (11 U.S.C. § 362(a)) stops creditors from collecting prepetition debts, so First Bank's collection action must halt. The Code expressly excepts governmental actions to enforce their police or regulatory powers from the stay (11 U.S.C. § 362(b)(4)), so the environmental agency may pursue injunctive relief and penalties that relate to ongoing or continuing violations; however, efforts to collect prepetition monetary penalties remain subject to the stay. The Code separately excepts domestic‑support income withholding from the stay (11 U.S.C. § 362(b)(2)), so the employer may continue wage deductions for support obligations.
Why not B: This is tempting because the automatic stay is broad, but it is incorrect: the Bankruptcy Code contains statutory exceptions (including for governmental police/regulatory enforcement and for domestic‑support withholding) that permit certain government actions and support withholdings to continue.
Why not C: This distractor plays on the idea that wage withholding is a collection that the stay halts; it is wrong because domestic‑support income withholding is expressly excepted from the automatic stay and therefore may continue.
Why not D: This choice mixes plausible points but is incorrect: governmental police/regulatory enforcement can include penalties tied to ongoing conduct (not just injunctive relief), and domestic‑support withholding is separately excepted from the stay despite Chapter 13 treatment of wages as estate property.
Sort it
Is the action a criminal prosecution rather than an ordinary effort to collect a prepetition debt?
Does the action seek to establish or collect Lane's prepetition debt without stay relief?
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| The county prosecutor continues a pending criminal check-fraud case against Lane. | May proceedCriminal prosecutions may continue even when the alleged offense occurred before bankruptcy. |
| A supplier continues its state-court lawsuit against Lane for an unpaid invoice. | StayedContinuing a lawsuit to collect a prepetition debt is generally barred. |
| A bank continues its loan lawsuit against Lane solely to obtain a money judgment. | StayedSeeking only a judgment does not avoid the stay on ordinary debt litigation. |
| A trade creditor files a new lawsuit against Lane for an unpaid invoice. | StayedThe stay bars starting a collection lawsuit as well as continuing one. |
| A customer pursues civil fraud damages against Lane for issuing bad checks. | StayedThe claim seeks private money damages. Calling the conduct fraud does not make the lawsuit a criminal prosecution. |
| A secured bank repossesses Lane's delivery van for missed loan payments. | StayedCollateral rights do not let the bank repossess after filing without stay relief. |
| The district attorney starts a criminal prosecution against Lane for issuing bad checks. | May proceedThe criminal exception permits a new prosecution, not just continuation of a pending case. |
| The state tax agency levies Lane's assets to collect prepetition income taxes. | StayedThis is debt collection. The collector's government status does not turn the levy into a criminal prosecution. |
| A bank applies Lane's estate checking-account balance against Lane's prepetition loan. | StayedApplying the deposit against the loan is a postpetition setoff, which is generally stayed. |
| A judgment creditor continues garnishing Lane's wages for a credit card judgment. | StayedAn existing judgment does not permit continued collection of a prepetition debt after filing. |
Key points
- Remember: The action controls: prosecuting bad checks may proceed, but suing to collect the same debt is stayed.
- Filing a collection suit and continuing one are both generally stayed.
- Seeking only a money judgment does not bypass the stay.
- Secured status does not permit repossession without stay relief.
How the exam traps you
- Stopping prosecution because the alleged offense occurred before bankruptcy. The criminal exception covers both starting and continuing a prosecution.
- Letting a civil fraud suit proceed because it involves criminal conduct. A private claim for money damages remains a civil collection action.
- Allowing repossession because the lender has collateral. The lender generally needs stay relief before repossessing.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on what the automatic stay usually stops, then ask whether one option falls under a recognized exception rather than ordinary debt collection.
Answer D. The automatic stay stops most civil collection efforts, lawsuits, repossessions, and garnishments, that seek to collect or enforce prepetition claims. Criminal prosecutions are a recognized exception to the stay and may be commenced or continued by a prosecutor. Therefore the criminal case against Rivera may proceed despite the bankruptcy filing.
Why not A: Tempting because it sounds like 'just establishing liability,' but filing or continuing a civil action to recover a prepetition debt is generally stayed; the creditor must obtain relief from the bankruptcy court before proceeding.
Why not B: Secured status alone does not permit postpetition repossession; taking possession of collateral after the petition date is normally stayed unless the creditor first gets relief from the stay or another specific exception applies.
Why not C: A garnishment to collect a prepetition debt is a collection action directed at the debtor's earnings and is generally barred by the automatic stay; serving the employer does not avoid the stay.
Question 3
Hint
Do not stop with the general rule that a stay protects the debtor. In Chapter 13, ask whether the nonfiling party is liable on a consumer debt of the debtor.
Answer A. Under Chapter 13, a separate codebtor stay bars collection against a nonfiling co-debtor only for debts that are consumer debts of the debtor. The $15,000 loan used to repair Taylor's personal residence is a consumer debt, so collection against Taylor's sister is stayed. The $20,000 note financed equipment for Taylor's sole proprietorship (a business debt), so the codebtor stay does not protect Taylor's friend.
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate focuses only on co-signer status, but the equipment loan financed the debtor's business and is not a consumer debt, so the codebtor stay does not bar collection against the friend.
Why not C: Overbroad: this treats all prepetition co-signed debts the same. The Chapter 13 codebtor stay applies only to consumer debts of the debtor, so it applies to the residence loan but not to the business equipment loan.
Why not D: Incorrect because Chapter 13 includes a specific codebtor stay that can protect nonfiling co-debtors on consumer debts; the sister is protected for the personal-residence loan even though she did not file.
Question 4
Hint
Distinguish actions directed at the debtor (estate property) from actions against a nondebtor guarantor, and note whether any setoff was already effected before the petition.
Answer C. The automatic stay under 11 U.S.C. §362 ordinarily bars actions against the debtor and acts to obtain or control property of the bankruptcy estate. A nondebtor guarantor is not automatically protected by the stay, and because the court has not extended the stay to nondebtors, Ridge Bank may generally proceed against Delta's president on the personal guaranty. By contrast, repossession of collateral or litigation against the debtor itself would require relief from the stay.
Why not A: Tempting because Ridge is secured, but repossessing collateral after the petition is an act to obtain estate property and is stayed under §362 absent relief from the bankruptcy court.
Why not B: Misleading: the automatic stay generally halts continuation of prepetition litigation against the debtor itself; a creditor ordinarily must obtain permission or relief from the court before prosecuting such actions to judgment or collection.
Why not D: Attractive because 11 U.S.C. §553 preserves prepetition setoff rights, but the stem specifies that Ridge Bank did not exercise setoff before the petition. An attempt to unilaterally set off the deposit after the filing may be treated as an act to obtain estate property and can be barred by §362 unless the court permits it or the setoff was already effected prepetition.
Question 5
Hint
First identify which claim is a domestic support obligation and then ask whether the creditor is trying to reach property that is part of the Chapter 7 estate.
Answer B. Under 11 U.S.C. §362(b)(2), collection of a domestic support obligation from property that is not property of the estate is excepted from the automatic stay. The fact pattern here assumes the arrearages are a domestic support obligation and that postpetition wages are not estate property, so the former spouse may garnish those wages without first obtaining relief from the stay. Other collection efforts that target property of the estate or seek to enforce prepetition property claims remain stayed.
Why not A: This is tempting because the debt is a domestic support obligation, but the checking account balance on the petition date is estate property (absent exemption or abandonment). Attempting to levy estate property after the petition date would violate the automatic stay unless the creditor obtains stay relief.
Why not C: A property equalization payment is a prepetition property-settlement obligation, not a domestic support obligation. Recording a lien or otherwise attempting to obtain or perfect an interest in the debtor's property to collect that prepetition claim is barred by the automatic stay absent relief.
Why not D: Initiating new litigation to collect a prepetition property-settlement debt seeks to enforce a prepetition claim and therefore is stayed unless the bankruptcy court authorizes the action.
Question 6
Hint
Start with the broad rule that bankruptcy filing pauses most collection efforts, then ask which option falls within a well-known statutory exception to that rule.
Answer B. The automatic stay generally halts most efforts to collect prepetition debts and to enforce liens or recover possession of estate property. Criminal prosecutions are an exception to the stay and may continue despite a bankruptcy filing. Therefore, the state's criminal prosecution for alleged check fraud is generally not stopped solely because Lopez filed Chapter 7.
Why not A: A lawsuit to recover a prepetition debt is typically stayed by the automatic stay because it is an effort to collect money owed; the creditor must obtain relief from the stay to proceed.
Why not C: Repossession to obtain possession of collateral or to enforce a lien is ordinarily halted by the automatic stay unless the creditor receives permission from the bankruptcy court to proceed.
Why not D: Wage garnishment to collect a prepetition consumer debt is generally stopped by the automatic stay because it is an ongoing collection effort; the garnishment normally cannot continue without court approval.
Common questions
Does bankruptcy stop a criminal prosecution for bad checks?
No. A criminal prosecution may begin or continue despite the automatic stay, even when the alleged offense occurred before filing.
Is a civil fraud lawsuit exempt from the automatic stay?
No. A customer's state-court suit for money damages based on prepetition fraud is generally stayed, even if the same conduct supports a criminal charge.
Can a creditor get a judgment during the automatic stay?
Generally, a creditor cannot continue a state-court suit to establish liability for a prepetition debt without stay relief. The stay stops the lawsuit itself, not just collection of the judgment.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Bankruptcy, worked step by step.
Chapter 7 Priority Waterfall | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Bankruptcy
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.