PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Security and Confidentiality and Privacy · 10 practice questions

Compensating Controls for Unpatched Vulnerabilities

When a critical vulnerability creates exposure above risk tolerance, reduce exposure immediately rather than wait for a patch or confirmed compromise. Below, one scenario changes a single fact at a time to show which immediate control fits.

The ruleIf exposure exceeds risk tolerance, implement feasible compensating controls immediately while the patch is unavailable. Use controls that reduce exploitable access, support them with monitoring, and apply the vendor fix as soon as safely possible.

Try one first

A company uses an internet-facing application that stores customer personal information. On Monday, management learns of a newly disclosed critical vulnerability affecting that application. The vulnerability is being actively exploited in the industry, but the software vendor will not release a patch for 10 days. The application cannot be shut down because it supports essential daily operations. Assuming the risk is above the company's acceptable level, what is the most appropriate mitigation action to take now?
Hint

Focus on what management should do before the permanent fix is available when the current risk exceeds tolerance.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Harbor's customer portal stores PII. A critical SQL injection flaw affects its essential reporting module. Exposure exceeds risk tolerance; no compromise is confirmed. A tested vendor patch is due in 10 days. The portal must stay available. Targeted WAF rules can block the exploit now without disrupting operations. Access can also be limited to required users.

Answer: Deploy the targeted WAF rules immediately, enhance logging and alerts, and apply the vendor patch as soon as safely possible.

The WAF reduces exploitability now while preserving essential reporting. Monitoring supports detection, but neither monitoring nor patch planning alone blocks the exploit.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The tested vendor patch is available now and can be installed safely without disrupting operations.

Answer: Apply the vendor patch now and continue monitoring.

The permanent fix is now safe and available. There is no reason to leave the flaw unpatched behind temporary controls.

Change 2Targeted WAF rules cannot block this exploit.

Answer: Immediately restrict access to required users, enhance monitoring, and apply the vendor patch as soon as safely possible.

An ineffective WAF rule cannot compensate for the flaw. Restricting access reduces reachable attack paths while essential operations continue.

Change 3The vulnerable reporting module is nonessential rather than essential.

Answer: Temporarily disable the reporting module, enhance monitoring, and patch it before restoring it.

Disabling the nonessential module removes the vulnerable function from service without interrupting essential portal operations.

Key points

  • Remember: A patch delay is not a mitigation delay; reduce exposure while the permanent fix is pending.
  • No confirmed compromise does not justify waiting when exposure already exceeds risk tolerance.
  • A WAF virtual patch blocks exploit traffic; it does not repair the vulnerable code.
  • Choose controls that preserve essential operations, not necessarily every feature.

How the exam traps you

  • Wait for the patch because no compromise is confirmed. Act on the known exposure now; confirmation of harm is not the trigger.
  • Increase logging without using available preventive controls. Block exploit traffic, restrict access, or disable the vulnerable feature; use logging to support those controls.
  • Keep the virtual patch indefinitely after a safe vendor fix becomes available. Apply the vendor fix promptly; temporary protection does not remove the underlying flaw.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Harbor's customer portal stores PII. A critical SQL injection flaw affects its essential reporting module. Exposure exceeds risk tolerance; no compromise is confirmed. A tested patch is due in 10 days. The portal must stay available. Targeted WAF rules can block the exploit without disruption. Access can also be restricted to required users. What is the best immediate response?

Question 2

Same facts, except the tested vendor patch is available now and can be installed safely without disrupting operations. What is the best immediate response?

Question 3

Same facts, except targeted WAF rules cannot block this exploit. What is the best immediate response?

Question 4

Same facts, except the vulnerable reporting module is nonessential rather than essential. Which response most directly removes the vulnerable function from service while preserving essential operations?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A company processes customer refund claims in a legacy on-premises application that stores names, SSNs, and bank account numbers. Internal audit found that the server runs an unsupported operating system and cannot be patched or replaced until Year 2. Sensitive data is already encrypted at rest and in backup media, and the company already carries cyber-liability insurance. However, the application is reachable from broad internal user subnets, and system administrators still use a shared privileged account with password-only access. Management has approved funding for one near-term control initiative this quarter. Assuming the application must remain in service until replacement, which action is the best mitigation?
Hint

Focus on which choice most directly reduces exposure created by an unpatchable system that still must stay online.

Question 3

Year 1: A mid-sized company's security team discovers a legacy customer database server is directly reachable from the Internet via Remote Desktop (RDP). The server stores unencrypted personally identifiable information (PII) and uses vendor-supplied remote access credentials. The vendor confirms no security patch will be available until Year 2. Business users require continued remote access for CRM tasks, so the server cannot be taken fully offline without major disruption. Which of the following is the most appropriate immediate mitigation to reduce confidentiality risk while minimizing business disruption?
Hint

Which choice most quickly reduces the server's exposure and the likelihood of unauthorized access now, without taking the service fully offline or relying only on financial transfer?

Question 4

A security team discovers a SQL injection vulnerability in a third-party patient-portal plugin during routine internal scanning. The vendor rates the flaw CVSS 8.6 and warns that exploitation could expose protected health information (PHI). Current server logs show no confirmed exploitation, but logging was incomplete for the prior week. The vendor has not yet released a patch. The organization's standard change control requires a 5-business-day approval window for production patches, but the incident response plan permits 'emergency changes' to be applied immediately with CISO approval to contain or mitigate security incidents. Which timing/trigger for mitigation actions is most appropriate now?
Hint

Focus on reducing exposure to PHI now and check whether the incident response plan allows emergency, targeted changes rather than waiting for full confirmation or routine change windows.

Question 5

Year 2 Q1: A company operates a customer web portal hosted by a third-party cloud provider. A routine test uncovered a SQL injection vulnerability that allowed unauthorized queries against the customer database. Forensics indicate that personal information (names, postal addresses, and partial payment card numbers) for about 800 of the portal's 8,000 customers was likely exfiltrated. The cloud provider has committed to deliver a permanent patch in 10 days. The company can immediately deploy a web application firewall (WAF) rule that will block the specific exploit but will temporarily degrade a noncritical portal feature for about 5% of users. Company policy and the applicable data-breach notification law require notifying individuals and regulators without unreasonable delay when personal information is likely compromised. Which of the following is the best conclusion about the company's next steps?
Hint

Think about which immediate control directly prevents the current exploit, what investigative and legal steps are required when data is likely exfiltrated, and how to balance continuity with risk reduction.

Question 6

A company (TechCo) uses a third-party vendor's API to serve customer PII. On Day 0 TechCo's security team discovers an authentication-bypass vulnerability in the vendor-managed API. TechCo's internal risk judgment rates the vulnerability as likelihood = 4 and impact = 5 on a 1-5 scale (baseline risk score = 20). The vendor will release an official patch in 10 days and TechCo cannot replace the vendor quickly. TechCo needs to reduce risk while preserving customer-facing availability until the vendor patch is applied. The security team estimates the following immediate mitigation alternatives (post-mitigation likelihood and impact shown): Which mitigation option is the most appropriate immediate response to reduce risk while preserving availability until the vendor patch is applied?
Hint

Compare the provided post-mitigation residual risk scores and implementation time/operational impact; prefer rapid, preventive compensating controls that significantly lower likelihood while keeping services running.

Drill all 151 Mitigation questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Should mitigation wait until exploitation is confirmed?

No. Harbor's exposure exceeds risk tolerance even without a confirmed compromise. Available controls should reduce that exposure immediately.

Is a WAF virtual patch a permanent fix?

No. It can block exploit traffic while the code remains vulnerable. Harbor should still apply the vendor patch as soon as safely possible.

What if a WAF rule is unavailable for an unpatched vulnerability?

Use another feasible control that reduces exposure. In Harbor's scenario, restrict access to required users and increase monitoring until the patch can be applied.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Mitigation, worked step by step.

IT Risk-to-Control Mapping | CPA ISC Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Mitigation

All Mitigation practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.