PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions

Are Management Representation Letters Required Audit Evidence?

AU-C 580 requires written representations from responsible management, and other audit evidence cannot replace them. Compare Apex's signed management letter with the same representations given orally or signed by a nonmanagement chair.

The ruleWritten representations from responsible management are required audit evidence under AU-C 580. They do not replace other procedures, and oral statements, other evidence, or a nonmanagement chair's signature cannot replace them.

Try one first

During the Year 2 audit of Apex Co., management gave the auditor full access to records, and the auditor obtained sufficient corroborating evidence for the major account balances and disclosures tested. The controller then asks whether the signed management representation letter can be omitted because "you already verified everything important." Assuming no special reporting framework issue applies, which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Ask whether written representations are merely optional paperwork or a required part of the audit evidence package.

Side by side

Management's signed letterManagement's oral statementsNonmanagement chair's signed letter.
Apex: other audit evidence obtained; representations providedResponsible management signs representations acknowledging responsibility for the financial statements and complete information.The same responsible management gives the same required representations orally.A nonmanagement audit committee chair signs the same required representations.
In writing?Yes.No.Yes.
From management responsible for the financial statements?Yes.Yes, but only orally.No. The chair is not management responsible for the financial statements.
Satisfies AU-C 580's written representation requirement?Yes.No. Oral statements cannot substitute for responsible management's written representations.No. The chair's signature cannot substitute for responsible management's written representations.
Evidence valueNecessary audit evidence that supports, but does not replace, other evidence.Does not provide the required written confirmation from responsible management.Does not provide the required written confirmation from responsible management.
Other audit proceduresStill required. The signed management letter cannot replace them.Still required. Responsible management's signed letter is also needed.Still required. Responsible management's signed letter is also needed.

Key points

  • Remember: Other evidence cannot replace the management letter, and the management letter cannot replace other audit procedures.
  • When an answer says 'other evidence is enough,' look for an attempt to omit a mandatory item.
  • Do not confuse oversight of financial reporting with management's responsibility for preparing the financial statements.

How the exam traps you

  • Other evidence is sufficient, so Apex can omit the letter. The management letter is required even when other evidence supports the financial statements.
  • Management's oral statements satisfy the requirement because the content is identical. AU-C 580 requires written representations from responsible management.
  • The audit committee chair can sign because the letter is written. A nonmanagement chair cannot replace the management members responsible for the financial statements.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

In an audit of a private company's Year 2 financial statements performed under AICPA auditing standards, management refuses to sign the written representation letter. Management says the auditor already has board minutes, legal responses, and other supporting evidence, so the letter is unnecessary. What is the most appropriate auditor response?
Hint

Think about whether written representations can be replaced by other audit evidence, and who is responsible for making them.

Question 3

At the completion stage of the audit of Redd Co., the CEO and CFO sign a management representation letter dated the same date as the auditor's report. The letter states that management has disclosed all known fraud involving employees with significant roles in internal control. The auditor also has payroll change logs, exception reports, and internal emails indicating that the payroll supervisor, who approves payroll master-file changes and reviews payroll exceptions, bypassed review controls to process fictitious overtime entries. Management has not resolved the matter and argues that any possible misstatement is well below materiality. Which factor most directly governs the auditor's evaluation of the written representation on this issue?
Hint

Do not stop at the fact that the letter was signed and dated correctly. Ask what matters most when management's written statement conflicts with evidence the auditor already has.

Question 4

At the end of the audit of Huron Co., management signs a written representation letter acknowledging its responsibility for the financial statements and stating that all known related-party transactions have been disclosed. The auditor has also performed other audit procedures relevant to related-party transactions and is not aware of any contradictory information. How should the auditor classify this written representation?
Hint

Focus on whether a written representation stands alone or works together with other audit evidence.

Question 5

In the audit of Ralston Co.'s Year 1 financial statements, the auditor completed planned procedures and believes sufficient appropriate evidence has been obtained in every significant area. Before the auditor's report is dated, Ralston's CEO and CFO refuse to sign the standard management representation letter acknowledging management's responsibility for the financial statements and for providing complete information. They assert their oral statements suffice, and the audit committee chair (who is not part of management and is not responsible for preparing the financial statements) offers to sign instead. Management's refusal remains after further discussion. What is the auditor required to do?
Hint

Identify who must provide the written management representation and whether oral statements or signatures from those not performing management's functions can replace it.

Question 6

In an audit of a nonissuer under U.S. GAAS, management gave the auditor full access to records and answered questions throughout the engagement. At the end of the audit, however, management refused to sign the required written representation letter because it believed its oral statements and the other audit evidence should be enough. Assuming no law or regulation requires the auditor to remain on the engagement, what is the correct treatment?
Hint

Ask whether required written representations can be replaced by oral statements or by other audit evidence.

Drill all 117 Written Representations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Are management representation letters required audit evidence under AU-C 580?

Yes. They are necessary audit evidence, even when the auditor has other supporting evidence, but they do not replace other procedures.

Can oral representations substitute for a management representation letter?

No. Management's oral statements do not meet the written representation requirement, even if the content is identical.

Can an audit committee chair sign instead of management?

Not when the chair is not management responsible for the financial statements. Apex still needs written representations from responsible management.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Written Representations

All Written Representations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.