AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 14 practice questions
AU-C 580: Deleting Management Responsibility Representations
Refusing a core AU-C 580 representation creates a scope limitation that other evidence cannot cure. Compare a complete management letter with single-statement deletions, then test the reporting effect.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on two issues: who is ultimately responsible for the financial statements, and whether the omitted paragraph is merely helpful or actually required.
Answer A. Management's acknowledgment of responsibility for the financial statements and for the design, implementation, and maintenance of relevant internal control is a required written representation under auditing standards. An outside preparer cannot substitute for management's required representation. When management refuses to provide required written representations, the auditor should disclaim an opinion or withdraw from the engagement if withdrawal is permitted.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates may focus on who physically drafted the statements rather than who is responsible for them. Under auditing standards, management remains responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements and related internal control even when an outside CPA assists. The auditor cannot accept a missing required representation on that basis.
Why not C: This distractor narrows the issue to a scope limitation requiring only a qualification. However, deletion of a required representation is a refusal by management to provide required evidence and is more severe than a typical scope limitation that leads to a qualified opinion; the appropriate response is disclaimer or withdrawal.
Why not D: Although the outside CPA may know how the statements were prepared, written representations must come from management with responsibility for the financial statements. A third-party preparer's representation cannot substitute for management's required acknowledgment.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
North Co.'s fully substantive nonissuer audit otherwise supports an unmodified opinion. Management signs a letter dated the auditor's report date confirming it fulfilled its responsibilities for preparing and fairly presenting the financial statements under U.S. GAAP and designing, implementing, and maintaining relevant internal control. It confirms all relevant information and personnel access were provided and all transactions recorded and reflected in the statements. Withdrawal is permitted.
Answer: Issue an unmodified opinion.
Management provided every core written representation, and other audit evidence supports the opinion. The fully substantive approach does not create a scope limitation.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Management deletes its financial statement preparation and fair presentation responsibility statement and refuses to restore it.
Answer: Discuss the refusal with management and those charged with governance; reassess management's integrity. If unresolved, disclaim an opinion or withdraw.
Management's written acknowledgment is required. Its refusal creates an evidence limitation, not proof of a GAAP departure.
Change 2Management deletes its internal control design, implementation, and maintenance responsibility statement and refuses to restore it.
Answer: Do not accept the shortened letter. If management still refuses, disclaim an opinion or withdraw.
The fully substantive approach does not excuse this representation. Management's internal control responsibility remains a required written acknowledgment.
Change 3Management deletes its statement confirming all relevant information and personnel access were provided and refuses to restore it.
Answer: Do not accept the shortened letter. If management still refuses, disclaim an opinion or withdraw.
Access during fieldwork cannot replace management's required written confirmation that all relevant information and access were provided.
Change 4Management deletes its statement that all transactions were recorded and reflected and refuses to restore it.
Answer: Do not accept the shortened letter. If management still refuses, disclaim an opinion or withdraw.
Complete transaction recording requires management's written confirmation. Refusal affects the audit as a whole, not just one paragraph.
Key points
- Remember: Strong audit evidence cannot replace a required core written representation from management.
- A fully substantive approach does not remove the internal control responsibility representation.
- Discuss unresolved refusals with management and those charged with governance; reassess management's integrity and evidence reliability.
- The refusal is an evidence limitation, not proof of a financial statement misstatement.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting a shortened letter because substantive testing supports the balances. Other evidence cannot replace the missing core representation.
- Dropping internal control responsibility because the auditor did not rely on controls. Management must provide that representation even in a fully substantive audit.
- Qualifying the opinion because management deleted only one statement. A core refusal affects the audit broadly; disclaim or withdraw if permitted.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. All core representations are present, and other audit evidence supports an unmodified opinion.
Why not B: Incorrect. A fully substantive approach does not itself create a scope limitation.
Why not C: Incorrect. Management has already supplied the required representation; an audit committee statement is not a substitute.
Why not D: Incorrect. Management's internal control responsibility representation remains required without reliance on controls.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. The unresolved refusal creates a fundamental scope limitation, and withdrawal is permitted.
Why not A: Incorrect. Other evidence cannot replace management's required written acknowledgment of responsibility.
Why not C: Incorrect. One missing core statement can affect the audit as a whole.
Why not D: Incorrect. Refusal creates an evidence limitation; it does not establish a GAAP departure.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. Management refused a core representation, creating an unresolved scope limitation.
Why not A: Incorrect. The representation is required regardless of the auditor's reliance on controls.
Why not B: Incorrect. Additional substantive testing cannot replace this required written acknowledgment.
Why not D: Incorrect. The refusal concerns a fundamental management responsibility, not a confined internal control reporting issue.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. Other evidence cannot cure the unresolved refusal of this fundamental representation.
Why not A: Incorrect. Actual fieldwork access does not eliminate the required written confirmation.
Why not B: Incorrect. Governance oversight cannot substitute for management's required representation.
Why not C: Incorrect. Refusing this core confirmation affects the audit broadly, not merely one access issue.
Question 5
Answer A. Correct. Management refused a required core representation about complete transaction recording.
Why not B: Incorrect. Oral confirmation cannot replace the required written representation.
Why not C: Incorrect. More testing does not cure management's refusal to provide this representation.
Why not D: Incorrect. Signing the remaining statements does not narrow the effect of a core refusal.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the statement is a required management representation and whether other procedures or third-party statements can legitimately substitute for management's own representation.
Answer C. AU-C 580 requires written representations from management and they cannot be substituted by other audit procedures or third-party statements. Management's refusal to provide a required representation is a scope limitation that raises questions about management's integrity and the reliability of other representations; if withdrawal is permitted the auditor should withdraw, and if not permitted the auditor should disclaim an opinion.
Why not A: Tempting because substantive procedures were performed over revenue, but AU-C 580 requires the management representation itself and other evidence does not cure management's refusal; accepting would leave the auditor without a required management acknowledgment.
Why not B: Plausible if one views the matter as a limited scope issue, but refusal to furnish a required written representation is more serious and typically leads to withdrawal or a disclaimer rather than a qualified opinion under AU-C 580.
Why not D: It may seem reasonable to seek representation from oversight or counsel, but AU-C 580 requires the representation to come from management responsible for the financial statements; third-party statements do not substitute for management's written representation.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether this is a financial reporting problem or an audit evidence problem, and ask whether the missing representation is optional or required.
Answer A. AU-C 580 requires certain written representations, including that management has provided all relevant information and that transactions have been recorded. Management's refusal to provide these required representations creates a limitation on the auditor's ability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and calls the matter a scope limitation. Absent legal or regulatory constraints, the auditor ordinarily disclaims an opinion or withdraws from the engagement and should reassess management's integrity.
Why not B: Tempting because written representations alone are not usually sufficient evidence, but certain representations are required. Other evidence does not eliminate the need for required management representations; refusal creates a significant scope problem.
Why not C: Some may view this as a limited exception, but the omitted representations concern management's fundamental responsibilities and completeness of information. That type of refusal is ordinarily pervasive enough to preclude only a qualified opinion and instead leads to a disclaimer or withdrawal.
Why not D: This confuses a reporting departure with an evidence issue. Refusal to provide required written representations is an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence (scope limitation), not a GAAP departure, so an adverse opinion is not the correct response.
Question 4
Hint
Decide whether the deleted language is one of the specific written representations the auditor must obtain from management or merely corroborative evidence.
Answer A. AU-C 580 requires certain written representations from management (including responsibility for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements and for internal control relevant to those statements). Required written representations cannot be supplanted by other audit evidence or oral statements. If management refuses to provide a required written representation, the auditor must evaluate the implications for the audit and the report, which may preclude an unmodified opinion or require withdrawal if permitted.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates may view written representations as merely corroborative evidence that substantive procedures can replace. However, when a representation is specifically required by the standard, other audit evidence does not eliminate the need for that written representation.
Why not C: Tempting because governance has oversight responsibilities and their acceptance might seem helpful. But AU-C 580 requires written representations from management itself; an oral acknowledgment by those charged with governance does not substitute for the required written statements from management.
Why not D: Tempting because candidates may think matters limited to internal control are less critical than specific account representations. In reality, management's responsibility for internal control relevant to the financial statements is itself a required written representation and cannot be omitted if management refuses to provide it.
Question 5
Hint
Decide whether the omitted statement is one of the required representations about completeness of information and access; if so, determine whether its absence is an evidence (scope) limitation or a GAAP departure.
Answer C. The representation that management has provided all relevant information and access is a required written representation. Management's refusal prevents the auditor from obtaining assurance about completeness and unrestricted access to personnel, which is an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence (a scope limitation). When unresolved, such a scope limitation ordinarily results in a disclaimer of opinion or withdrawal if withdrawal is permitted.
Why not A: This is tempting because written representations are not usually the sole source of evidence and auditors often perform alternative procedures. However, the specific representation about providing all relevant information and access is fundamental to completeness; alternative procedures generally cannot assure the auditor that management has not withheld relevant information or denied access.
Why not B: This distractor tempts by conflating report modifications with serious issues, but the situation is an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence (a scope limitation), not a misstatement arising from a GAAP departure. Therefore, reporting follows scope-limitation guidance rather than GAAP-departure rules.
Why not D: This is tempting because auditors should communicate significant matters and document them, but communication and documentation do not cure the lack of a required representation. A management refusal to provide that required representation creates a scope limitation that ordinarily affects the auditor's report if unresolved.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on whether the missing representation covers management's basic responsibilities and completeness of information, not just whether other evidence exists.
Answer B. AICPA standards (AU-C 580) require written representations from management on its responsibilities and the completeness of information as necessary audit evidence. If management refuses to provide these fundamental representations, the refusal constitutes a scope limitation so significant that the auditor must disclaim an opinion; withdrawal may be appropriate if allowed by law or regulation. Other audit evidence does not eliminate the requirement for these specific written representations.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates recall that representations don't replace audit procedures, but certain representations (management's responsibility and completeness) are required audit evidence; their absence prevents an unmodified opinion.
Why not C: Appealing since refusals often suggest a scope limitation, but when the refusal concerns management's core responsibilities and completeness of information the limitation is pervasive, leading to a disclaimer rather than a qualification.
Why not D: Looks reasonable because governance oversees reporting, but required written representations must come from management responsible for the financial statements; those charged with governance cannot substitute unless they also have management responsibility.
Question 7
Hint
Decide whether the deleted statement is a required written representation under AU-C Section 580 and recall the standard's prescribed action when management refuses and withdrawal is not possible.
Answer A. AU-C Section 580, Written Representations, requires management to provide certain written representations, including that all transactions have been recorded and are reflected in the financial statements. When management refuses to provide a required written representation and the auditor cannot withdraw, AU-C 580 indicates the refusal is a limitation on the scope that generally results in a disclaimer of opinion. Oral explanations or supporting schedules do not cure management's refusal to furnish the required written representation.
Why not B: Candidates may be misled by the existence of oral explanations and schedules, but AU-C 580 requires the written representation itself for certain matters; oral statements or additional schedules do not substitute for management's required written representation, so an unmodified opinion is not appropriate.
Why not C: This is tempting because scope limitations sometimes lead to a qualified opinion when the effect is material but not pervasive. However, AU-C 580 treats a refusal to provide a required written representation more severely: the auditor should withdraw when possible, and if withdrawal is not possible the standard indicates a disclaimer rather than a qualification.
Why not D: This is plausible as a lure, but an adverse opinion requires affirmative evidence that the financial statements are materially misstated. A refusal to provide a required written representation produces a scope limitation, not proof of misstatement, so an adverse opinion is not supported when withdrawal is not possible.
Question 8
Hint
Ask whether the omitted sentence is just helpful wording or one of the core representations management must provide for the auditor to complete the audit.
Answer B. Management's written representation that it has provided all relevant information and access is one of the core required representations under U.S. GAAS. Written representations are necessary audit evidence, and refusal to provide this fundamental representation is not cured by the auditor's belief that access was actually provided. Because management refused a required fundamental representation, the appropriate response is to disclaim an opinion or withdraw from the engagement if withdrawal is permitted.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often remember that written representations do not replace other audit evidence. However, other evidence does not substitute for required written representations. When management refuses a fundamental required representation, the auditor cannot simply treat it as redundant.
Why not C: This is tempting because a scope limitation can sometimes lead to a qualified opinion. But the particular representation at issue is a required, fundamental management representation; refusal is treated more severely and ordinarily leads to a disclaimer of opinion or withdrawal rather than a mere qualification.
Why not D: While auditors may obtain representations from those charged with governance in some circumstances, those representations do not substitute for management's own required written representations, especially when those charged with governance do not have management responsibilities.
Question 9
Hint
Ask whether the missing statements are optional supporting representations or part of the core written representations the auditor must obtain from management.
Answer A. The omitted statements are core written representations the auditor is required to obtain (including management's acknowledgment that it provided all relevant information and that all transactions have been recorded and reflected in the financial statements). Other audit evidence cannot substitute for required written representations. Refusal to provide these required representations raises concerns about management's integrity and ordinarily results in a disclaimer of opinion or withdrawal when withdrawal is available.
Why not B: Some representations are framed as 'knowledge and belief,' but the specific statements about providing all information and recording all transactions are affirmative responsibilities of management and are required in definite form; softening them does not resolve management's refusal.
Why not C: Tempting because additional procedures can provide evidence, but AU-C 580 treats these written representations as required. The absence of required representations is significant and cannot simply be cured by more testing.
Why not D: A scope limitation can sometimes lead to a qualified opinion, but refusal to provide required written representations under AU-C 580 is treated more seriously and ordinarily leads to a disclaimer of opinion or withdrawal rather than a mere qualification.
Common questions
Can management delete its financial statement responsibility representation?
No. Management must confirm its responsibility for preparation and fair presentation in writing. If management refuses, the auditor must disclaim an opinion or withdraw if permitted.
Is the internal control representation required in a fully substantive audit?
Yes. Management's responsibility for relevant internal control does not depend on whether the auditor relies on controls.
Does deleting one core representation require only a qualified opinion?
No. The number of deleted statements does not determine the reporting effect. An unresolved refusal of a core representation requires a disclaimer or withdrawal if permitted.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Written Representations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.