AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 11 practice questions
AU-C 580: Required Written Representations
Management must provide required written representations even when other audit evidence supports the same matters. Below: one audit scenario with topic-specific refusals, showing why corroborating evidence does not cure a missing representation.
Try one first
Hint
Decide whether the refusal prevents obtaining required audit evidence, then identify the standard reporting option for that inability to obtain evidence.
Answer C. AU-C 580 requires certain written representations as audit evidence, including representations about fraud. Management's refusal to provide a required written representation prevents the auditor from obtaining required evidence and ordinarily results in a scope limitation. The usual reporting consequence is to disclaim an opinion or withdraw if withdrawal is practicable; the refusal also raises concerns about management's integrity.
Why not A: Tempting because evidence obtained through other procedures can be persuasive, but AU-C 580 requires specific written representations; other procedures do not eliminate that requirement. Management's refusal creates a scope limitation rather than a permissible omission.
Why not B: Tempting because inquiry is a standard audit procedure, but AU-C 580 specifically requires written representations. An oral statement does not satisfy the written representation requirement and would leave a scope limitation.
Why not D: Tempting because refusal may suggest concealment that could cause misstatement, but refusal alone does not prove a material misstatement. The immediate issue is inability to obtain required evidence (a scope limitation); an adverse opinion is appropriate only when the auditor concludes a material misstatement exists, not simply from a refusal to provide a representation.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Kline Co.'s nonissuer audit under U.S. GAAS is complete. Management provides all required written representations, including financial statement and information responsibilities, litigation and claims, related parties, fraud, and its belief that uncorrected misstatements are immaterial individually and in the aggregate. Counsel's response, board minutes, fraud tests, and a misstatement schedule support the audit conclusions. All other evidence supports an unmodified opinion.
Answer: Issue an unmodified opinion. No representation-related scope limitation exists.
Management supplied the required written representations, and the other audit evidence supports the opinion. Neither source replaces the other.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Management refuses only the litigation and claims representation, citing counsel's response.
Answer: Discuss the refusal, reassess management's integrity and evidence reliability, and evaluate the effect on the report.
Counsel's response does not supply management's required assertion. The refusal creates an evidence limitation, even with external corroboration.
Change 2Management refuses only the related-party representation, citing board minutes.
Answer: Treat the refusal as an evidence limitation. Discuss it, reassess management's integrity and other evidence, and evaluate reporting implications.
Board minutes may identify related parties, but they do not replace management's required written representation about relationships and transactions.
Change 3Management refuses only the representation about known or suspected fraud involving management or employees with significant internal control roles.
Answer: Discuss the refusal, reassess management's integrity and evidence reliability, and evaluate whether reporting changes or withdrawal are necessary.
Fraud tests do not replace the required statement. Refusal also raises broader questions about whether management's other assertions are reliable.
Change 4Management refuses only to state that uncorrected misstatements are immaterial individually and in the aggregate.
Answer: Discuss the refusal, reassess management's integrity and evidence reliability, and determine the reporting effect. Do not assume an automatic disclaimer.
The schedule does not express management's belief about immateriality. The auditor's own materiality conclusion does not eliminate this written representation.
Key points
- Remember: Other audit evidence supports management's written representations; it does not replace them.
- Refusal can undermine the reliability of management's other representations and audit evidence.
- A missing representation is an evidence problem, not proof that the financial statements are misstated.
- For these topic-specific omissions, evaluate the reporting effect rather than assuming an automatic disclaimer.
How the exam traps you
- Use counsel's response, board minutes, or fraud tests instead of the missing representation. Those procedures provide corroboration but do not satisfy management's written representation requirement.
- Automatically disclaim whenever management omits a topic-specific representation. Discuss the refusal, reassess integrity and evidence, and evaluate the resulting reporting implications.
- Treat refusal as proof of a GAAP departure. Refusal creates an evidence limitation; it does not itself establish a misstatement.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 2
Hint
Focus less on whether the auditor already has some documents and more on what management's refusal itself may imply.
Answer B. When management refuses to provide a requested written representation, the auditor must evaluate the significance of the omitted representation. The key governing consideration is whether the refusal calls management's integrity into question, because that doubt can affect the reliability of other written and oral representations and audit evidence and may lead to a modification of the auditor's report.
Why not A: This is tempting because written representations do not replace substantive procedures and are generally less persuasive than other evidence. However, the existence of some corroborating evidence does not eliminate the significance of management's refusal, the refusal itself may indicate a broader integrity or reliability issue that must be evaluated.
Why not C: Candidates might think disclosure-related items are less critical, but representations about completeness of disclosures (including related-party matters) can be important. The governing issue is the significance of the refusal and its implications for management integrity and audit evidence reliability, not merely whether the matter is a disclosure.
Why not D: This distractor leverages the role of governance, but those charged with governance cannot substitute for management's written representations. Management is responsible for the financial statements and for providing required written representations; governance agreement may be relevant to discussions but does not replace management's representation.
Question 3
Hint
Consider whether other audit evidence can substitute for a required written representation from management, and how materiality and pervasiveness affect the auditor's reporting options.
Answer D. Auditing standards require written representations from management for matters for which management is responsible; a refusal to provide a requested written representation constitutes a scope limitation. Although a legal counsel response is relevant, it does not eliminate the need for the management representation. Because the limitation involves litigation that is material and pervasive, a disclaimer of opinion is the ordinarily appropriate response and the auditor should also consider withdrawal when allowed.
Why not A: This is tempting because an external counsel response can be persuasive evidence, but auditing standards still require a written representation from management for matters under management's responsibility; an external response does not substitute when management refuses the required written representation.
Why not B: Documented oral statements are useful audit evidence, but they do not replace the formal written representation required from management; documentation of an oral statement does not cure management's refusal to provide the written representation.
Why not C: A qualified opinion may be appropriate for some limited scope limitations, but a refusal to provide a required written representation about a matter that is material and pervasive typically creates a pervasive scope limitation; in that situation a disclaimer is generally the appropriate response.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether this representation is merely helpful evidence or one that management is ordinarily required to provide.
Answer A. Management is ordinarily required to provide a written representation that the effects of uncorrected misstatements are immaterial, individually and in the aggregate. Management's refusal to include that representation is treated as a refusal to provide a required written representation; the auditor should reconsider management's integrity and the reliability of other evidence and determine the appropriate effect on the auditor's report.
Why not B: Written representations complement but do not replace other audit evidence. Having other evidence that supports immateriality does not cure management's refusal to provide a required representation; the refusal must be treated and evaluated.
Why not C: Although the auditor assesses materiality for the opinion, management is still expected to provide representations about the financial statements, including the immateriality of uncorrected misstatements. That responsibility is not optional simply because the auditor also forms a judgment.
Why not D: A statement from the controller does not substitute for the required management representation. The representation must come from management with overall responsibility for the financial statements; a separate controller statement does not resolve management's refusal.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what written representations are intended to do under GAAS and whether other evidence can fully replace a required management representation.
Answer D. Under AU-C 580 (written representations), management's written representations are required audit evidence and oral explanations do not substitute. A refusal to provide a required representation creates an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and is treated as a scope limitation; the auditor should discuss the matter, reassess management's integrity, and if the matter remains unresolved ordinarily disclaim an opinion or withdraw when withdrawal is permitted.
Why not A: Tempting because the stem notes corroborating evidence, but written representations are required evidence and cannot simply be ignored; an unresolved refusal is a scope limitation and is not automatically cured by other procedures.
Why not B: Oral explanations cannot replace required written representations. Even a single unresolved required representation can undermine the auditor's ability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and may have broader implications for the audit opinion.
Why not C: This distractor assumes a GAAP departure; refusal to provide a representation does not by itself prove the financial statements are misstated. The primary issue is lack of required audit evidence, which points to a scope-limitation response (disclaimer or withdrawal) rather than automatically to a GAAP-departure opinion.
Question 6
Hint
Think about whether an attorney's reply replaces management's own written commitment or instead serves as corroborative evidence, and what steps GAAS requires when management refuses a requested representation.
Answer B. Under U.S. GAAS (AU-C 580), the auditor should discuss management's refusal to provide a requested written representation, reconsider management's integrity, and evaluate whether the refusal affects the sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence and the audit report. An external attorney's response is corroborative evidence about litigation but does not automatically substitute for the specific management representation or eliminate the need to evaluate reporting implications.
Why not A: Tempting because attorney responses are persuasive about litigation, but incorrect because a requested management representation is not simply replaced by counsel's reply; the auditor must still address the refusal and its implications for evidence and the report.
Why not C: Appealing because failure to obtain required representations can lead to disclaimers or withdrawal, but those outcomes are not automatic; the auditor must first discuss the matter, seek the representation or alternative evidence, and then determine appropriate reporting.
Why not D: Attractive because a clean attorney letter reduces substantive concern, but incorrect because it overlooks the auditor's obligation to evaluate management's refusal and whether it affects other representations or the audit conclusion.
Common questions
Can an attorney letter replace management's litigation representation?
No. In Kline's audit, counsel's response supports the litigation evidence but does not replace management's required written statement.
Must management state that uncorrected misstatements are immaterial?
Yes. Management must state its belief that their effects are immaterial individually and in the aggregate. Kline's misstatement schedule alone does not satisfy that requirement.
Does refusing a topic-specific representation automatically require a disclaimer?
No. The auditor discusses the refusal and reassesses management's integrity and the reliability of evidence. The reporting effect depends on the resulting evidence limitation and integrity concerns, not merely on which topic was omitted.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Written Representations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.