PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 7 practice questions

Weak AP Controls and ITGCs: How to Change the Audit Plan

When control weaknesses make accounts payable controls unreliable, do not plan to rely on them; increase substantive procedures. Below: an audit-planning scenario with possible responses and explanations.

The ruleWhen weak access controls and incompatible duties undermine an automated AP match, do not plan control reliance. Reduce planned detection risk with more persuasive substantive evidence, larger samples, and more testing near year-end.

Try one first

An auditor is planning the Year 2 financial statement audit of a privately held manufacturing company (financial statement audit only; the auditor is not engaged to audit internal control). During preliminary risk assessment the auditor identifies: (a) management frequently approves manual journal entries that bypass application controls, (b) turnover in key finance positions during Year 2, (c) a mid‑year ERP implementation with IT general controls not yet fully operating, and (d) weak segregation of duties over cash receipts. Assuming no material misstatements have yet been identified, what is the most likely effect of these findings on the auditor's planned nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures?
Hint

Think about how increased control risk from override, personnel turnover, and ineffective ITGCs affects the auditor’s acceptable detection risk and then map that to changes in nature, timing, and extent of procedures.

What should you do?

The situation

During planning for Harbor Manufacturing's financial statement audit, you find an ERP three-way match that blocks unmatched invoice payments. The controller can change vendor records, approve payments, and post year-end AP adjustments. ERP administrators share a login, and activity logs are missing. The owner reviews monthly expense totals but not vendor changes or payment details. No effective compensating controls have been identified.

  1. Avoid control reliance; expand year-end AP tests of details, cutoff tests, and journal-entry testing.

    Best Larger samples and testing near year-end reduce detection risk when access weaknesses and conflicting duties undermine the match.

  2. Rely on the automated match and reduce substantive AP testing.

    Wrong Automation does not overcome access weaknesses or the controller's ability to change vendors, approve payments, and post adjustments.

  3. Treat the owner's expense review as compensating and retain planned control reliance.

    Wrong The review does not address vendor changes or payment details, so it does not resolve the identified weaknesses.

  4. Replace AP tests of details with trend analysis of monthly expenses.

    Wrong High-level trends alone do not adequately address unauthorized payments or manual AP adjustments in this weak control setting.

  5. Wait for management to repair controls before performing substantive AP testing.

    Wrong The auditor should revise procedures now, not postpone substantive testing while waiting for remediation.

Key points

  • Remember: An automated match cannot support reliance when weak access controls let people bypass or alter it.
  • Higher assessed risk calls for lower planned detection risk, not smaller substantive samples.
  • Reviewing expense totals does not automatically compensate for unchecked vendor changes and payment approvals.

How the exam traps you

  • Assuming an automated three-way match makes AP controls reliable. Evaluate the access controls and conflicting duties that can undermine the match.
  • Treating the owner's high-level expense review as an effective compensating control. Determine whether the review actually addresses unauthorized vendor changes and payments.
  • Waiting for management to repair controls before expanding substantive testing. Revise the plan now; expand substantive AP testing rather than postponing it for remediation.

6 more, each from a different angle

0 of 6 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During planning, an auditor is obtaining an understanding of an entity's control environment and cash disbursement business process. The auditor learns that the accounts payable manager can add new vendors to the master file, approve purchase orders up to $25,000, and release electronic payments. The controller receives monthly budget-to-actual reports but does not review vendor-change reports or bank reconciliations. Assume there are no other compensating controls. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Focus on whether the same person controls multiple key steps in the transaction cycle and whether management monitoring actually addresses that risk.

Question 3

You are planning the Year 2 audit of MidCo. During planning you obtain these facts about MidCo's control environment and revenue process: recent turnover (new CEO and CFO within the last 6 months, CFO formerly controller); the audit committee is formally independent but meeting minutes show little oversight of related-party or unusual transactions; a prior-year material misstatement related to revenue was corrected but management has not completed documented remediation testing; the whistleblower hotline has not been monitored for eight months and the code of conduct was not reissued after leadership changes. MidCo implemented a new ERP order-to-cash system in Year 2; internal IT staff both develop and deploy code, change-management procedures are informal, and ITGC documentation is incomplete. Revenue increased ~28% in Year 2 and revenue policy now permits bill-and-hold arrangements for custom products; many revenue-related adjustments are recorded through manual journal entries prepared by the accounting manager and only occasionally reviewed by that manager's subordinate. Transactional controls exist (sales > $50,000 require sales director approval; credit approvals documented for some new customers), but discounts/returns and reconciliations remain largely manual and lack independent, authoritative review. Based on these facts, which planned audit response for revenue-related assertions is most appropriate?
Hint

Consider how unresolved prior‑year misstatements, weak monitoring/tone at the top, and inadequate IT general controls for a new ERP affect whether process-level controls can be relied upon, especially for manual, judgmental, or cut‑off risk areas.

Question 4

While obtaining an understanding of a small manufacturer's control environment and business processes, the auditor notes that the CEO can post manual journal entries without independent review, sales managers receive large bonuses for meeting month-end targets, and employee conduct violations are rarely investigated. No compensating monitoring controls are identified. What is the most likely consequence for the auditor's risk assessment and planned response?
Hint

Focus on what a weak tone at the top means for the auditor's willingness to trust other controls.

Question 5

An auditor is planning the Year 2 audit of GreenCo, a privately held manufacturer. During risk assessment the auditor notes these facts: (1) The accounts payable (AP) system enforces an automated three‑way match (purchase order, receiving report, invoice) that blocks payment unless all three match. (2) The IT administrator uses a shared generic administrative account for system administration and backups, and user activity logs for the ledger/AP application have not been retained for the past 9 months. (3) Cash receipts are handled by one clerk who opens mail, records receipts, and prepares deposits; the controller reviews monthly bank reconciliations but does not reperform them and also has authority to sign checks. (4) The purchasing manager approves purchase orders and receiving is overseen within purchasing; the same clerk who enters AP invoices also performs vendor statement reconciliations. Management says limited staff necessitates these arrangements and that the controller's review plus the automated three‑way match compensate. Which of the following best describes an exception or limiting condition that most significantly reduces the effectiveness of the company's controls and would most likely prevent the auditor from relying on the affected control(s)?
Hint

Identify which fact undermines foundational assurance over system‑enforced controls (think IT general controls and the ability to detect or prevent unauthorized activity).

Question 6

An auditor planning the Year 2 audit of AlphaCo notes these facts: the CEO is closely involved in daily operations and occasionally approves unusual, nonrecurring transactions; the CFO reviews all journal entries and significant accounting estimates and directly supervises the assistant controller; the internal audit function was disbanded in Year 1; segregation of duties is limited, the assistant controller both prepares reconciliations and clears reconciling items; management asserts the accounting system performs nightly automated bank reconciliations that reconcile to the general ledger and route exceptions to the assistant controller; there are no documented entity‑level policies for significant estimates. What is the most likely effect of these control‑environment and process characteristics on the auditor's planned approach?
Hint

Ask whether a single automated control handled by the preparer/clearing person and a weak oversight environment is sufficient to reduce substantive testing.

Question 7

During planning, an auditor obtains the following understanding of a closely held distributor's control environment and revenue-related business processes: - The owner-manager reviews daily cash balances and personally signs all checks over $10,000. - There is no independent board or equivalent oversight body. - The controller position has turned over twice in the last year, and the current controller has limited GAAP reporting experience. - In the revenue cycle, the same employees can create customer accounts, enter sales returns, and issue credit memos. - The owner-manager frequently directs quarter-end top-side journal entries based on oral explanations, with little documented support. Assume no other compensating controls have yet been identified. Which is the most appropriate treatment of these observations in the auditor's risk assessment?
Hint

Focus on whether entity-level weaknesses can affect the reliability of more specific process controls, even before any tests of operating effectiveness occur.

Drill all 99 Understanding an Entity's Control Environment and Business Processes questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can an auditor rely on an automated AP match when ITGCs are weak?

Not when the relevant IT general control weaknesses undermine that match. Here, shared administrator access and missing logs undermine assurance that unauthorized changes would be prevented or detected.

How do weak AP controls change substantive audit procedures?

Use more persuasive evidence, increase sample sizes, and perform more testing near year-end. Target AP transaction details, cutoff, and manual journal entries that can bypass the automated match.

Must management fix weak AP controls before substantive testing starts?

No. Expand substantive testing now rather than waiting for repairs. Any later control reliance requires evidence that the relevant controls operate effectively.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Understanding an Entity's Control Environment and Business Processes, worked step by step.

Control Deficiencies and Audit Response | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Understanding an Entity's Control Environment and Business Processes

All Understanding an Entity's Control Environment and Business Processes practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.