AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions
Public Warehouse Inventory: Evidence of Existence and Rights
Material inventory at a public warehouse needs its own evidence of existence and rights; observing the main location does not cover it. Below: a decision tree for evaluating warehouse evidence and deciding when further procedures are needed.
Try one first
Hint
Think about both reliability and relevance to the specific year-end assertion. External evidence tied to the balance-sheet date is usually stronger than internal records or earlier-period documents.
Answer C. A direct written confirmation from an independent warehouse is both highly relevant to the year‑end existence assertion and more reliable than internally generated evidence. Because the inventory is material and held by a third party, confirmation addressed to the auditor at the balance-sheet date ordinarily provides strong, persuasive evidence of existence.
Why not A: Management representations are a required part of the audit file but are not a substitute for independent evidence. They are less reliable on their own and should support, not replace, direct external evidence.
Why not B: This is internally generated client evidence and is therefore less reliable than an external confirmation. It can support the auditor's procedures but is not the best single piece of evidence for third‑party‑held inventory.
Why not D: Shipping documents may show that goods were sent to the warehouse, but because they reflect an earlier date they do not prove the goods remained on hand at December 31. Relevance to the period‑end date is essential for the existence assertion.
Decide it in order
T1Kellan Co. has material inventory at a public warehouse. The auditor observed the main-location count. Does warehouse-specific evidence, such as a direct written confirmation, support year-end existence beyond Kellan's internal schedule?
T4Do custody terms and supporting ownership documents establish Kellan's rights to the warehouse inventory, including resolution of any consignment concerns?
T5Are there no unresolved contradictions, such as a bill of lading showing a transfer before year-end that conflicts with Kellan's records?
YesThe evidence supports existence and rights for the material public-warehouse inventory. This conclusion does not address other inventory assertions.NoGo to T6T6Can further warehouse-specific procedures address the missing or conflicting evidence, such as direct confirmation, observation, or inspection of third-party custody and transfer records?
YesPerform those procedures and reassess existence and rights. Do not conclude until the evidence gaps and contradictions are resolved.NoSufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable. Evaluate a scope-modified opinion based on the materiality and pervasiveness of the possible effects.
Key points
- Remember: Evidence from the main warehouse does not prove inventory exists at a separate public warehouse.
- A quantity confirmation supports existence, but ownership may require custody terms and supporting contracts.
- Resolve conflicting transfer records before accepting the warehouse balance.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting an internal schedule because most inventory was observed elsewhere. Obtain persuasive evidence specifically for the material public-warehouse balance.
- Treating confirmed quantities as proof of ownership. Examine custody terms and ownership documents, especially when consignment is possible.
- Accepting management's explanation for a conflicting bill of lading. Corroborate the explanation with warehouse or other third-party records.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the reliability of the evidence currently available and what the auditor must do when it is not enough.
Answer B. The auditor lacks sufficient appropriate evidence about the existence and location of the missing items. An oral explanation by warehouse personnel is not adequate for high-value items when documentary evidence or direct observation should be available. The auditor must perform further procedures (inspect transfer/shipping records, obtain access to or observe the off-site inventory, or confirm with the custodian) before reaching a conclusion.
Why not A: Tempting because the explanation comes from someone with direct knowledge, but inquiry alone is less reliable than documentary evidence or observation. For missing high-value items the auditor must obtain corroborating evidence rather than accept an oral explanation.
Why not C: This is tempting since missing high-value inventory could indicate a serious problem, but the auditor should not jump to a reporting conclusion without first performing further procedures to gather evidence. Reporting decisions follow the evaluation of evidence, not immediate assumptions.
Why not D: Tempting as management's records may be incomplete, but passively waiting does not address the current lack of evidence. The auditor should proactively obtain or verify transfer documentation or observe/confirm the off-site items now.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which procedures most directly address physical existence at the locations the auditor did not attend, and then weigh the reliability of the remaining evidence sources.
Answer A. Physical observation and independent evidence are most persuasive for the existence assertion. For the 10 unobserved locations the auditor only has client-prepared count sheets, reconciliations, and manager-recorded videos, and tested controls were ineffective, reducing reliability of that evidence. Analytics and reperformance of reconciliations do not, by themselves, provide persuasive evidence that inventory physically existed at those locations on the count date; therefore additional substantive procedures directed at existence are needed.
Why not B: Reperformance of reconciliations can provide assurance about the accuracy of the client's compilation and the mathematical linkage to the ledger, but it does not address whether physical inventory actually existed at the locations on the count date. The underlying source evidence remains client-generated and its reliability is compromised by ineffective controls.
Why not C: Tempting because coverage percent and analytics give comfort, but observing 58% does not prove existence of the remaining 42%, especially when the remaining evidence is largely client-generated and controls were ineffective. Analytics are indirect and less persuasive about physical existence.
Why not D: Management representations cannot substitute for substantive audit evidence and are among the least persuasive forms of evidence. Even with written representations about completeness, the auditor would still lack sufficiently reliable evidence of physical existence at the unobserved locations.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which source of evidence is most reliable for a material existence assertion when the original count was missed.
Answer C. When the auditor cannot observe the physical inventory count, the auditor should obtain evidence through alternative procedures that directly address existence. Examples include observing a later count and rolling quantities back, testing intervening purchases and sales, and inspecting receiving/shipping and inventory movement documents. Management representations and reconciled records are supportive but are not sufficient by themselves for a material existence assertion.
Why not A: This is tempting because written representations and reconciliations seem persuasive, but management representations are only complementary evidence and internally generated records alone are insufficient when inventory is material and existence must be verified.
Why not B: This choice appeals to candidates who view missed observation as fatal. However, the auditor should first attempt alternative procedures to obtain evidence; issuance of an adverse opinion is not the automatic or typical first response to a missed count or scope limitation.
Why not D: Analytical procedures may identify anomalies and provide some evidence, but analytics alone generally do not provide sufficiently persuasive evidence of physical existence for material inventory when direct observation or other detailed procedures are available.
Question 5
Hint
Identify which assertions are still not directly supported and whether doing more of the same procedure would actually resolve the contradictory evidence.
Answer B. The existing procedures address quantity information only partly; they do not resolve rights and obligations or condition/valuation for a material offsite balance. The adverse gross-margin analytics are contradictory evidence that increase audit risk and the need for assertion-targeted procedures. The auditor should confirm custody terms with the warehouse and perform procedures (e.g., inspect contracts, test for liens, assess salability and impairment) to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not A: This is tempting because confirmations are external and persuasive about quantities, but confirming quantities alone would leave unresolved whether Kellan has rights to the goods or whether they are damaged or encumbered. Quantity confirmation does not address condition/valuation or ownership assertions.
Why not C: Reconciliation to the general ledger and a warehouse statement that lists quantities do not establish ownership or condition, and they do not resolve the contradictory gross-margin analytics. Accepting the current evidence would risk concluding without addressing material unresolved assertions.
Why not D: Doing more of the same internal procedures increases quantity evidence from the client's records but does not address the specific gaps for inventory held offsite, rights, liens, consignment status, or condition, so it would not resolve the key uncertainties.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on when an alternative-date inventory count can substitute for year-end observation and what must be true about the records between the two dates.
Answer A. An alternative-date inventory observation can provide sufficient appropriate evidence only if the auditor can obtain reliable roll-back (intervening) evidence by testing transactions between the count dates. The auditor obtained such reliable intervening evidence for finished goods (complete, sequenced shipping and receiving records) but did not for raw materials, where production logs showed overrides, missing tickets, and unreconciled differences. Because raw materials are material on their own and no additional procedures are available, sufficient appropriate evidence was not obtained for that balance.
Why not B: Physical observation on 1/10 establishes quantities on the date observed, not automatically on 12/31. Without trustworthy roll-back evidence to bridge 1/10 back to 12/31, a later observation cannot substitute for year-end quantities for the raw materials class.
Why not C: This choice correctly restates the general rule that alternative-date observation may be used, but it incorrectly applies the rule to all inventory. The exception requires reliable testing of intervening transactions; that reliability exists for finished goods but not for raw materials, so the blanket conclusion for all inventory is unsupported.
Why not D: This distractor overstates the consequences of missing a year-end count. A missed count due to unforeseen circumstances does not automatically create a scope limitation if alternative-date observation plus reliable intervening tests can provide sufficient evidence. Here, that approach works for finished goods but fails for raw materials.
Common questions
Does observing the main warehouse cover inventory at a public warehouse?
No. A separate material public-warehouse balance needs evidence directed at that location. Main-location observation does not replace that evidence.
Does a warehouse confirmation prove the client owns the inventory?
A quantity confirmation supports existence, not necessarily rights. Examine custody terms and ownership documents to address whether the goods belong to the client.
What should an auditor do if a public warehouse does not confirm inventory?
Perform alternative procedures directed at the warehouse balance, such as observation or inspection of third-party records. If sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable, evaluate a scope-modified opinion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.
Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.