PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 6 practice questions

Public Warehouse Inventory: Evidence of Existence and Rights

Material inventory at a public warehouse needs its own evidence of existence and rights; observing the main location does not cover it. Below: a decision tree for evaluating warehouse evidence and deciding when further procedures are needed.

The ruleObtain sufficient appropriate evidence of existence and rights specifically for material inventory held at a public warehouse; evidence from the main location does not substitute for that evidence.

Try one first

During the audit of 20X5 inventory, a material portion of a retailer's inventory is stored at an independent public warehouse. The auditor needs evidence about whether this inventory existed at December 31, 20X5. Assume no unusual fraud indicators and that the auditor can obtain any of the following. Which item would generally be classified as the most appropriate audit evidence?
Hint

Think about both reliability and relevance to the specific year-end assertion. External evidence tied to the balance-sheet date is usually stronger than internal records or earlier-period documents.

Decide it in order

  1. T1Kellan Co. has material inventory at a public warehouse. The auditor observed the main-location count. Does warehouse-specific evidence, such as a direct written confirmation, support year-end existence beyond Kellan's internal schedule?

  2. T4Do custody terms and supporting ownership documents establish Kellan's rights to the warehouse inventory, including resolution of any consignment concerns?

  3. T5Are there no unresolved contradictions, such as a bill of lading showing a transfer before year-end that conflicts with Kellan's records?

    YesThe evidence supports existence and rights for the material public-warehouse inventory. This conclusion does not address other inventory assertions.
  4. T6Can further warehouse-specific procedures address the missing or conflicting evidence, such as direct confirmation, observation, or inspection of third-party custody and transfer records?

    YesPerform those procedures and reassess existence and rights. Do not conclude until the evidence gaps and contradictions are resolved.
    NoSufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable. Evaluate a scope-modified opinion based on the materiality and pervasiveness of the possible effects.

Key points

  • Remember: Evidence from the main warehouse does not prove inventory exists at a separate public warehouse.
  • A quantity confirmation supports existence, but ownership may require custody terms and supporting contracts.
  • Resolve conflicting transfer records before accepting the warehouse balance.

How the exam traps you

  • Accepting an internal schedule because most inventory was observed elsewhere. Obtain persuasive evidence specifically for the material public-warehouse balance.
  • Treating confirmed quantities as proof of ownership. Examine custody terms and ownership documents, especially when consignment is possible.
  • Accepting management's explanation for a conflicting bill of lading. Corroborate the explanation with warehouse or other third-party records.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During the year-end inventory observation, the auditor notes that several high-value items included on the client's inventory listing are not on the warehouse floor. The warehouse manager says the items were transferred earlier that day to an off-site storage location, but management has not yet provided transfer records, shipping documents, or access to that location. Assume no other procedures have yet addressed these items. What is the auditor's required response?
Hint

Focus on the reliability of the evidence currently available and what the auditor must do when it is not enough.

Question 3

During the audit of a retailer with 12 locations, inventory is material. The auditor attended the year-end physical counts at the two largest warehouses, which together held 58% of total inventory, and performed test counts there with no significant exceptions. For the other 10 locations, the auditor obtained local count sheets prepared by client personnel, reconciliations from those sheets to the perpetual records, and timestamped video walkthroughs recorded by store managers on the count date. The auditor tested cycle-count controls at those 10 locations and found deviations above tolerable rate, so control reliance was not supported. Year-over-year gross margin and shrinkage analytics were consistent with expectations. Assume no other procedures were performed on inventory at the 10 unobserved locations. Which conclusion is best supported regarding whether sufficient appropriate evidence has been obtained for the existence assertion of year-end inventory?
Hint

Focus on which procedures most directly address physical existence at the locations the auditor did not attend, and then weigh the reliability of the remaining evidence sources.

Question 4

An auditor was engaged after a client's Year 1 year-end and therefore could not observe the physical inventory count. Inventory is material to the financial statements. Management provided a signed representation that the ending inventory existed, and the perpetual records agree to the general ledger. What is the auditor's best action to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence about inventory existence?
Hint

Focus on which source of evidence is most reliable for a material existence assertion when the original count was missed.

Question 5

In the Year 1 audit of Kellan Co., inventory stored at an independent public warehouse represents 30% of total inventory and includes the client's highest-value product line. The auditor attended the year-end physical count at Kellan's main location, tested the perpetual inventory report for mathematical accuracy and agreement to the general ledger, and obtained a year-end warehouse statement listing quantities held for Kellan. The warehouse statement does not address whether any of the goods are held on consignment, damaged, or subject to a lender's lien. In addition, gross-margin analytics for this product line are significantly below expectation, and management's explanation is only that pricing was 'temporarily aggressive.' Assume no other procedures have been performed on this portion of inventory and the balance is material. What is the auditor's best action to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence before concluding?
Hint

Identify which assertions are still not directly supported and whether doing more of the same procedure would actually resolve the contradictory evidence.

Question 6

In an audit of a manufacturer, inventory is material. The auditor was unable to attend the client's 12/31 physical count because a government-ordered facility shutdown was imposed the morning of the count. Access was restored on 1/10, and the auditor then observed a full physical count. For finished goods, the auditor found the 12/31-1/10 shipping and receiving records to be complete, sequence tested, and free of unexplained adjustments. For raw materials, however, production-usage logs for the same period contained numerous manual overrides, missing transfer tickets, and unreconciled quantity differences. Raw materials comprise 45% of total inventory and are material on their own. Assume no other alternative procedures are available beyond those described. Which conclusion about whether sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained for year-end inventory quantities is best supported?
Hint

Focus on when an alternative-date inventory count can substitute for year-end observation and what must be true about the records between the two dates.

Drill all 122 Sufficient Appropriate Evidence questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does observing the main warehouse cover inventory at a public warehouse?

No. A separate material public-warehouse balance needs evidence directed at that location. Main-location observation does not replace that evidence.

Does a warehouse confirmation prove the client owns the inventory?

A quantity confirmation supports existence, not necessarily rights. Examine custody terms and ownership documents to address whether the goods belong to the client.

What should an auditor do if a public warehouse does not confirm inventory?

Perform alternative procedures directed at the warehouse balance, such as observation or inspection of third-party records. If sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable, evaluate a scope-modified opinion.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.

Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence

All Sufficient Appropriate Evidence practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.