PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 5 practice questions

Contradictory Audit Evidence: Resolve Conflicts Before Reporting

When audit evidence conflicts, the auditor must obtain additional evidence to resolve the inconsistency before concluding. Below, a revenue cutoff timeline shows why customer payment and numerous internal records do not resolve a contradictory confirmation.

The ruleWhen evidence conflicts or its reliability is doubtful, determine what modified or additional procedures are needed to resolve the matter. Consider the implications for other aspects of the audit.

Try one first

An auditor is completing the Year 1 audit for Company X (year‑end December 31, Year 1). The auditor performed positive confirmations of accounts receivable on January 10, Year 2, and tested cash receipts through January 31, Year 2. On February 1, Year 2, before the auditor's report date, Company X's largest customer (receivable at December 31 of $1.2 million, about 18% of net sales) filed for bankruptcy. Management asserts the bankruptcy arose after December 31 and refuses to change the allowance for doubtful accounts. Which action best responds to this timing-triggered event to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence?
Hint

Focus on whether the bankruptcy, discovered before the report date, provides evidence about conditions existing at the balance sheet date and what the auditor must do before issuing the report.

The timeline

  1. December 31, Year 1A manufacturer records a large sale in December.

    Weak year-end shipping controls make cutoff a high-risk area. The auditor needs evidence supporting the period of recognition.

  2. January 2, Year 2The auditor observes warehouse dispatch activities.

    Observing dispatch activities does not establish the timing of this specific sale.

  3. January 3, Year 2The goods are placed with the carrier.

    The customer later confirms that the executed sales terms provide for title to pass on this date, contradicting December cutoff.

  4. January, Year 2The customer pays for the sale.

    Collection does not resolve the conflict about when the sale should be recognized.

  5. During year-end fieldworkThe auditor inspects 60 internal shipping logs and related invoices and obtains management's written representation.

    The records cover the last five business days of Year 1 and first three of Year 2. Neither their quantity nor management's representation resolves contradictory evidence.

  6. Before the report dateAn authentic customer confirmation contradicts the recorded cutoff.

    Inspect the executed contract and obtain reliable carrier or other shipping evidence. Resolve the timing conflict before deciding whether the sale needs correction.

  7. Before concluding on cutoffThe auditor evaluates the results of the additional procedures.

    Evaluate whether the additional procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the cutoff conclusion, and consider the implications for other audit evidence.

Key points

  • Remember: More evidence does not cancel contradictory evidence; resolve the specific conflict.
  • Evidence must address cutoff, not merely show that the customer paid.
  • A written management representation does not replace corroborating evidence.
  • Investigate the conflict before deciding whether the recorded sale needs correction.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating numerous internal records as enough to outweigh the customer confirmation. Obtain reliable evidence addressing the disputed sale's timing.
  • Using January payment to prove December revenue cutoff. Payment does not establish when the sale belongs in revenue.
  • Accepting management's written representation that cutoff was proper. Corroborate management's assertion and resolve the conflicting confirmation.

4 more, each from a different angle

0 of 4 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Delta Co.'s year-end is December 31, Year 1. The audit team performed substantive procedures on accounts receivable and revenue as of September 30, Year 1 and planned to roll those procedures forward to year-end with cut‑off tests, limited confirmations, and inquiries. On November 10, Year 1, the company entered a long-term sales contract and recorded a $2.4 million receivable related to the sale; the contract has extended payment terms and involves a newly disclosed related party. Overall audit materiality is $300,000 and the pre-transaction receivable balance was $6.0 million. Which timing decision about obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence for receivables and revenue is most appropriate now?
Hint

Ask whether the November sale materially changed assessed risks and whether evidence obtained at the September interim date remains relevant; related‑party involvement and special payment terms are red flags that often require prompt corroboration.

Question 3

During the Year 2 audit of Meridian Corp. (fiscal year ended December 31, Year 2), the auditor is completing fieldwork but has not yet issued the report. Meridian's December 31 accounts receivable balance is $3,600,000, of which $900,000 (25% of receivables) is from a single customer, Apex Co. Apex's receivable was 90 days past due at December 31 and Meridian received only partial payment in late December. On January 15, Year 3 (before the auditor's report date), Apex filed for bankruptcy. Management asserts that the bankruptcy resulted from events in January and believes no adjustment to the December 31 financial statements is necessary; management has not provided contemporaneous documentation showing Apex's condition at December 31. According to auditing standards on sufficient appropriate evidence and subsequent events, what is the auditor's most appropriate next step?
Hint

Focus on whether the post-balance-sheet bankruptcy provides information about conditions that existed at the balance sheet date and whether there were year‑end indicators of customer distress that create a need for further corroboration.

Question 4

In auditing year-end revenue cutoff for a manufacturer, the auditor assessed the risk of material misstatement as high because shipping controls were weak near year-end. The auditor then inspected 60 internally generated shipping logs and related sales invoices for the last 5 business days of Year 1 and the first 3 business days of Year 2, observed warehouse dispatch activities on January 2, noted that January cash was collected on a large December 31 sale, and obtained management's written representation that cutoff was proper. For that large December 31 sale, however, the customer confirmation response stated that under the executed sales terms title passed when the goods were placed with the carrier on January 3, Year 2. Assume the confirmation is authentic, accurately reflects the contract terms, and no other external shipping evidence has yet been obtained for that sale. In deciding whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence has been obtained for the cutoff conclusion, which factor should govern?
Hint

Do not focus first on how much evidence was gathered or how many procedures were used. Ask which evidence is most persuasive for the specific assertion being tested.

Question 5

During the audit of Harper Co.'s Year 1 inventory, the auditor observes the year-end physical count and traces selected counted items to receiving reports dated before year-end. Those procedures suggest inventory on hand is greater than the amount included in the client's final inventory listing. Management responds that its internally prepared reconciliation to the general ledger is correct and says no further work is necessary. Assume the possible difference could be material. What is the correct treatment?
Hint

Focus on what the auditor should do when evidence from different sources does not agree.

Drill all 122 Sufficient Appropriate Evidence questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What should an auditor do when audit evidence is inconsistent?

Modify or add procedures to resolve the inconsistency. For this sale, inspect the executed contract and obtain reliable shipping evidence addressing the customer's confirmation.

Does subsequent cash collection prove revenue cutoff is correct?

No. January payment shows collection, but it does not resolve whether the sale belongs in December when the customer confirms January transfer terms.

Can an auditor issue an unmodified opinion with an unresolved cutoff conflict?

Perform the necessary additional procedures before concluding. Do not treat an unresolved, potentially material cutoff conflict as sufficient appropriate evidence supporting an unmodified opinion.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.

Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence

All Sufficient Appropriate Evidence practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.