AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 5 practice questions
Contradictory Audit Evidence: Resolve Conflicts Before Reporting
When audit evidence conflicts, the auditor must obtain additional evidence to resolve the inconsistency before concluding. Below, a revenue cutoff timeline shows why customer payment and numerous internal records do not resolve a contradictory confirmation.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether the bankruptcy, discovered before the report date, provides evidence about conditions existing at the balance sheet date and what the auditor must do before issuing the report.
Answer B. Because the bankruptcy was discovered before the report date, the auditor must determine whether it provides evidence about conditions that existed at the balance sheet date. The auditor should perform further procedures (e.g., review filings, obtain the customer's interim financial information, extend subsequent testing, consult legal counsel) and require an adjustment or disclosure if indicated. If management refuses to make a material adjustment or add a required disclosure, the auditor should consider modifying the opinion.
Why not A: Tempting because confirmations and subsequent receipts were already performed, but incorrect: the bankruptcy occurred before the report date and may reveal conditions that existed at year‑end, so the auditor must perform additional procedures rather than simply accept management's assertion.
Why not C: Tempting because an emphasis-of-matter highlights the issue to users, but incorrect: reporting language does not replace the auditor's responsibility to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and, if an adjustment is required and management refuses, the auditor may need to modify the opinion rather than add an emphasis-of-matter.
Why not D: Tempting as a strong reaction to management refusal, but incorrect: withdrawal or immediate refusal to issue the report is an extreme and usually unnecessary step. The auditor should first perform additional procedures and attempt to resolve the matter, considering an opinion modification if unresolved.
The timeline
- December 31, Year 1A manufacturer records a large sale in December.
Weak year-end shipping controls make cutoff a high-risk area. The auditor needs evidence supporting the period of recognition.
- January 2, Year 2The auditor observes warehouse dispatch activities.
Observing dispatch activities does not establish the timing of this specific sale.
- January 3, Year 2The goods are placed with the carrier.
The customer later confirms that the executed sales terms provide for title to pass on this date, contradicting December cutoff.
- January, Year 2The customer pays for the sale.
Collection does not resolve the conflict about when the sale should be recognized.
- During year-end fieldworkThe auditor inspects 60 internal shipping logs and related invoices and obtains management's written representation.
The records cover the last five business days of Year 1 and first three of Year 2. Neither their quantity nor management's representation resolves contradictory evidence.
- Before the report dateAn authentic customer confirmation contradicts the recorded cutoff.
Inspect the executed contract and obtain reliable carrier or other shipping evidence. Resolve the timing conflict before deciding whether the sale needs correction.
- Before concluding on cutoffThe auditor evaluates the results of the additional procedures.
Evaluate whether the additional procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the cutoff conclusion, and consider the implications for other audit evidence.
Key points
- Remember: More evidence does not cancel contradictory evidence; resolve the specific conflict.
- Evidence must address cutoff, not merely show that the customer paid.
- A written management representation does not replace corroborating evidence.
- Investigate the conflict before deciding whether the recorded sale needs correction.
How the exam traps you
- Treating numerous internal records as enough to outweigh the customer confirmation. Obtain reliable evidence addressing the disputed sale's timing.
- Using January payment to prove December revenue cutoff. Payment does not establish when the sale belongs in revenue.
- Accepting management's written representation that cutoff was proper. Corroborate management's assertion and resolve the conflicting confirmation.
Question 2
Hint
Ask whether the November sale materially changed assessed risks and whether evidence obtained at the September interim date remains relevant; related‑party involvement and special payment terms are red flags that often require prompt corroboration.
Answer C. The $2.4M sale is individually material relative to overall materiality ($2.4M vs $300k) and introduces extended payment terms and a newly disclosed related party, increasing risk and potentially rendering interim evidence insufficient. Certain evidence (contract terms, third-party corroboration, collectibility assessments, disclosure) may be perishable or require prompt evaluation, so the auditor should perform immediate, transaction-specific procedures and then adjust roll‑forward plans.
Why not A: Enlarging samples and relying on inquiries addresses sampling risk but does not substitute for transaction‑specific evidence; complex contract terms, collectibility, and related‑party issues often require documentary or third‑party corroboration obtained promptly.
Why not B: This is tempting because roll‑forward testing is ordinarily efficient, but it fails here: a materially large, complex related‑party sale with extended terms increases risk and may require timely corroboration that could be lost by deferring.
Why not D: A management representation may be convenient but is not independent evidence; it cannot replace documentary or external corroboration needed for an unusual, material related‑party transaction.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the post-balance-sheet bankruptcy provides information about conditions that existed at the balance sheet date and whether there were year‑end indicators of customer distress that create a need for further corroboration.
Answer C. A bankruptcy filing after year-end can provide evidence about conditions that existed at the balance sheet date (a potential Type I event), especially when there are prior indicators of distress (90 days past due and only partial payment). The auditor must obtain sufficient, appropriate corroborative evidence (e.g., bankruptcy filings, subsequent cash receipts, contemporaneous management documentation) before deciding whether an adjusting entry or disclosure is required.
Why not A: Tempting because the bankruptcy occurred after year-end, but incorrect: given the year‑end indicators of customer distress, the post‑balance‑sheet bankruptcy may reflect conditions that existed at the balance sheet date and requires corroborative audit procedures rather than simply accepting management's assertion.
Why not B: Tempting because bankruptcy is strong evidence of insolvency, but incorrect and overly absolute: the auditor must first perform procedures to determine whether the bankruptcy reflects conditions existing at year‑end and evaluate evidence before directing or concluding an immediate write‑off.
Why not D: Tempting because legal opinions can be persuasive, but incorrect: a legal opinion may not address the customer's financial condition at the balance sheet date and cannot substitute for the auditor's need to obtain direct corroborative audit evidence about collectibility and conditions at year‑end.
Question 4
Hint
Do not focus first on how much evidence was gathered or how many procedures were used. Ask which evidence is most persuasive for the specific assertion being tested.
Answer C. Sufficiency is not determined by quantity alone; appropriateness (relevance and reliability) matters. An authentic customer confirmation that directly contradicts management's internal records in a high-risk cutoff area is highly persuasive. When evidence is inconsistent, the auditor must resolve the inconsistency, typically by obtaining additional reliable external corroboration, rather than relying on the volume of internal documents or varied procedures.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often equate more testing with sufficient evidence. However, quantity affects only sufficiency, not appropriateness; many internal records do not automatically overcome a specific, reliable external contradiction about timing.
Why not B: This distractor appeals because candidates may overvalue subsequent cash receipts and management representations. But payment timing does not establish when title passed under the sales terms, and management representations cannot substitute for independent corroboration of the cutoff assertion.
Why not D: Using multiple procedures can strengthen evidence but does not guarantee that the evidence is relevant and reliable for the specific assertion. Procedural variety does not resolve a clear external contradiction about the timing of revenue recognition.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what the auditor should do when evidence from different sources does not agree.
Answer C. When audit evidence from different sources is inconsistent, the auditor must perform further procedures to resolve the conflict before drawing a conclusion. Although observation and document inspection provide persuasive evidence, management's reconciliation contradicts those findings and cannot be accepted without corroboration. The auditor should obtain additional appropriate evidence (for example, more detailed cut-off testing, review of receiving/shipping records, and corroborating documentation) to determine whether an adjustment or other response is necessary.
Why not A: Physical observation is strong evidence, but conflicting evidence should be investigated rather than immediately acted on. The auditor may ultimately propose an adjustment, but only after performing additional procedures that provide sufficient appropriate evidence to support that conclusion.
Why not B: A client-prepared reconciliation that ties to the general ledger is not automatically dispositive when it conflicts with other audit evidence. Agreement to the ledger does not resolve an inconsistency; the auditor needs corroborating evidence before accepting the balance, especially if the possible misstatement could be material.
Why not D: Inquiries and representations from management are part of audit evidence but are not sufficient by themselves to resolve a material inconsistency. The auditor should obtain independent corroborating evidence rather than relying solely on management's assurances.
Common questions
What should an auditor do when audit evidence is inconsistent?
Modify or add procedures to resolve the inconsistency. For this sale, inspect the executed contract and obtain reliable shipping evidence addressing the customer's confirmation.
Does subsequent cash collection prove revenue cutoff is correct?
No. January payment shows collection, but it does not resolve whether the sale belongs in December when the customer confirms January transfer terms.
Can an auditor issue an unmodified opinion with an unresolved cutoff conflict?
Perform the necessary additional procedures before concluding. Do not treat an unresolved, potentially material cutoff conflict as sufficient appropriate evidence supporting an unmodified opinion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.
Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.