PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 9 practice questions

Accounts Receivable Confirmation Nonresponses: Audit Evidence

A nonresponse to a positive confirmation provides no evidence of customer agreement, so perform alternative procedures. Below: follow a decision tree to evaluate evidence for one unanswered customer balance.

The ruleFor positive-confirmation nonresponses, perform alternative procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence. Evaluate whether the evidence supports the specific year-end receivable, considering its relevance, reliability, and the assessed risk of material misstatement.

Try one first

During the Year 2 audit of Harlow Co., the auditor selected 60 customer accounts for positive confirmation of accounts receivable (sample total $2.9 million). The auditor received 36 confirmations; 24 did not respond despite follow-up. Among the nonresponses are three customers with combined balances of $650,000, and each of those three balances is near the auditor's tolerable misstatement. Shipping documents and subsequent cash-receipt records are readily available for the nonresponding accounts. Management provided a signed representation letter attesting that receivable balances are fairly stated. Control risk is assessed as moderate. Based on requirements for obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence, the auditor's best next step is:
Hint

Recall the auditor's required response to nonresponses to positive confirmations and that management representations are not independent corroboration.

Decide it in order

  1. T1Lark's $100,000 year-end customer receivable received no positive-confirmation reply. Have appropriate alternative procedures been completed?

    NoPerform alternative procedures. For example, test subsequent receipts, if available, and match them to year-end invoices and shipping evidence, or examine other relevant supporting documentation. An aging schedule and management representations alone do not replace this work.
  2. T2Does the evidence address Lark's specific year-end receivable, with any subsequent receipts matched to the related invoices and shipping evidence?

    NoObtain evidence linked to the year-end receivable. A January receipt for a later sale does not support this balance.
  3. T3Is the evidence sufficient and reliable for Lark's balance, considering assessed risk and any portion not covered by subsequent receipts?

    YesThe alternative procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the assertion tested. The missing confirmation reply does not, by itself, require more procedures.
    NoPerform targeted additional procedures on the unsupported portion. Assess its possible effects individually and together with other unresolved matters. A partial collection does not support the entire balance, and an evidence gap is not automatically material.

Key points

  • Remember: Silence is not agreement; replace the missing confirmation with evidence about the specific year-end receivable.
  • A subsequent receipt helps only when linked to the receivable being tested.
  • No subsequent payment does not automatically prevent other appropriate procedures from providing sufficient evidence.
  • Management representations cannot replace needed substantive procedures.

How the exam traps you

  • Accepting an aging schedule and management's assurance instead of performing alternative procedures. Obtain corroborating evidence for the unanswered customer balance.
  • Treating any January receipt as proof of the year-end receivable. Match the receipt to the related year-end invoices and shipping evidence.
  • Using a partial collection to support the entire balance. Evaluate the unpaid portion separately and obtain further evidence where needed.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

While auditing Year 2 accounts receivable, an auditor sends positive confirmations to selected customers. Several customers respond with balances lower than the amounts recorded by the client. Management explains that the differences are only timing differences related to year-end shipments, but management has not yet provided shipping documents, customer remittance support, or other corroborating evidence. Under GAAS, what is the auditor's required response?
Hint

Think about what an auditor should do when one source of evidence raises a question and management's explanation has not yet been corroborated.

Question 3

While auditing accounts receivable, an auditor has obtained mainly client-prepared aging schedules and copies of internal sales invoices. Several unusual past-due balances remain unresolved, and no external confirmations have yet been returned. Under the concept of sufficient appropriate audit evidence, which factor should primarily govern whether the auditor needs to perform additional procedures?
Hint

Focus on what drives how much evidence the auditor needs, not on scheduling, prior-year comparisons, or management's preferences.

Question 4

During the audit of Year 2 accounts receivable, an auditor sends a positive confirmation to Customer Z for a $84,000 year-end balance. After a second request, no confirmation is returned. Management states that the balance is valid and gives the auditor an internally prepared aging schedule showing the account as current. Which additional procedure would provide the most appropriate audit evidence about this receivable?
Hint

Focus on which procedure gives the strongest evidence for one specific receivable when a confirmation does not come back.

Question 5

During the audit of Lark Co.'s 20X5 financial statements, accounts receivable is a material balance concentrated in three large customer accounts. The auditor reviewed the client-prepared aging schedule and inquired of Lark's credit manager about collectibility, but did not send confirmations, inspect subsequent cash receipts, or examine customer correspondence. No restriction prevented performing those procedures. Which conclusion about the evidence obtained is best?
Hint

Consider the independence and reliability of the evidence obtained, not just whether the procedures performed appear relevant.

Question 6

During the Year 2 audit of Maxwell Company the auditor identified a significant risk of material misstatement in revenue recognition because of an unusual late‑year sales increase and a year‑end promotion. The auditor performed positive external confirmations covering 90% of recorded accounts receivable by dollar, observed the year‑end inventory count, and performed substantive analytical procedures. Cut‑off testing identified several sales recorded in Year 2 for which the shipping documents were dated after year‑end. Management supplied supporting documents for the questioned items, but several were photocopies and several significant sales‑allowance journal entries were made manually and authorized by senior management after year‑end. For customers with confirmed receivables, subsequent cash receipts were lower than expected. What is the primary issue the auditor must address regarding sufficient appropriate audit evidence?
Hint

Consider whether the current evidence is internally consistent and what the auditor should do when confirmations are contradicted by cut‑off exceptions, manual adjustments, and weak supporting documents.

Question 7

During the Year 2 audit of Delta Company, the auditor planned to confirm accounts receivable and selected an initial sample of 50 customer accounts. Subsequent procedures indicate that customer collections have deteriorated and Delta's internal control over receivables has materially weakened. To obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding accounts receivable, the auditor should most appropriately:
Hint

Consider how an increase in assessed risk of material misstatement and weaker controls affects both the amount of evidence needed and the preferred reliability (source) of that evidence.

Question 8

During the audit of 20X5 accounts receivable, the auditor identified side agreements affecting return rights as a significant risk in one product line. Year-end receivables from six distributors totaled $8.4 million. The auditor sent positive confirmations to all six distributors; five replied agreeing to balances totaling $7.1 million. The sixth distributor, with a $1.3 million balance, did not respond, and the auditor examined January 20X6 cash receipts covering that full amount. The auditor also tested related sales invoices and shipping documents for all six balances. However, one of the five confirming distributors stated that a separate email from the client's sales manager granted an extended right of return not reflected in the signed master contract. Management said the email was a one-time accommodation and that historical returns have been insignificant, but management did not provide an analysis of whether similar side agreements existed with other distributors. Assume the possible effect of similar undisclosed terms could be material. Based on the sufficiency and appropriateness of the audit evidence obtained so far, which is the best conclusion?
Hint

Ask which assertion the confirmations and cash receipts actually support, then consider what the side-agreement email does to the overall persuasiveness of the evidence.

Question 9

Falcon Co.'s year-end accounts receivable balance is material. During the audit, the auditor assessed control risk as high in the sales and billing cycle because invoices could be issued without matched shipping documents. The auditor is obtaining evidence specifically about whether recorded receivables exist at year-end. Which procedure would ordinarily provide the most appropriate audit evidence?
Hint

Match the procedure to the specific assertion being tested, then think about which source of evidence is most reliable when risk is high.

Drill all 122 Sufficient Appropriate Evidence questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a nonresponse to a positive AR confirmation mean the customer agrees?

No. Silence provides no evidence of agreement. Perform alternative procedures for the nonresponse.

What alternative procedures can an auditor perform for AR confirmation nonresponses?

Test subsequent cash receipts, if available, and match them to year-end invoices and shipping evidence. Other relevant supporting documentation may also provide evidence.

Does a partial subsequent payment support the full year-end receivable?

Not by itself. Determine which invoices the payment covers, then evaluate whether sufficient appropriate evidence supports the remaining balance.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.

Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence

All Sufficient Appropriate Evidence practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.