AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 9 practice questions
Accounts Receivable Confirmation Nonresponses: Audit Evidence
A nonresponse to a positive confirmation provides no evidence of customer agreement, so perform alternative procedures. Below: follow a decision tree to evaluate evidence for one unanswered customer balance.
Try one first
Hint
Recall the auditor's required response to nonresponses to positive confirmations and that management representations are not independent corroboration.
Answer C. When positive confirmations are not returned, auditing standards require the auditor to perform alternative procedures (such as inspecting shipping documents and subsequent cash receipts) to obtain independent corroboration. The auditor should expand testing for individually significant nonresponding balances. Management representations are not independent corroboration; only if alternative procedures and expanded testing still fail to provide sufficient appropriate evidence should the auditor consider a modification of the opinion.
Why not A: Why tempting: Management provided a signed representation and confirmations were originally sent. Why wrong: Written representations are not independent corroboration and cannot substitute for required alternative procedures, especially for large or near‑tolerable balances.
Why not B: Why tempting: A high number of nonresponses can appear to limit the audit scope. Why wrong: Jumping to a qualified opinion is premature, auditing standards require performing alternative procedures and expanding testing before concluding that a scope limitation prevents obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not D: Why tempting: Direct customer responses are persuasive, and additional contact methods sometimes yield confirmations. Why wrong: The stem indicates follow-up was already performed; when nonresponses include individually significant balances and assessed risk is not low, repeating confirmations or calls does not replace the required alternative procedures.
Decide it in order
T1Lark's $100,000 year-end customer receivable received no positive-confirmation reply. Have appropriate alternative procedures been completed?
YesGo to T2NoPerform alternative procedures. For example, test subsequent receipts, if available, and match them to year-end invoices and shipping evidence, or examine other relevant supporting documentation. An aging schedule and management representations alone do not replace this work.T2Does the evidence address Lark's specific year-end receivable, with any subsequent receipts matched to the related invoices and shipping evidence?
YesGo to T3NoObtain evidence linked to the year-end receivable. A January receipt for a later sale does not support this balance.T3Is the evidence sufficient and reliable for Lark's balance, considering assessed risk and any portion not covered by subsequent receipts?
YesThe alternative procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the assertion tested. The missing confirmation reply does not, by itself, require more procedures.NoPerform targeted additional procedures on the unsupported portion. Assess its possible effects individually and together with other unresolved matters. A partial collection does not support the entire balance, and an evidence gap is not automatically material.
Key points
- Remember: Silence is not agreement; replace the missing confirmation with evidence about the specific year-end receivable.
- A subsequent receipt helps only when linked to the receivable being tested.
- No subsequent payment does not automatically prevent other appropriate procedures from providing sufficient evidence.
- Management representations cannot replace needed substantive procedures.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting an aging schedule and management's assurance instead of performing alternative procedures. Obtain corroborating evidence for the unanswered customer balance.
- Treating any January receipt as proof of the year-end receivable. Match the receipt to the related year-end invoices and shipping evidence.
- Using a partial collection to support the entire balance. Evaluate the unpaid portion separately and obtain further evidence where needed.
Question 2
Hint
Think about what an auditor should do when one source of evidence raises a question and management's explanation has not yet been corroborated.
Answer A. When confirmation responses conflict with the client's records or explanations, GAAS requires the auditor to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence by performing additional procedures (for example, inspect shipping documents, examine subsequent cash receipts, or obtain other corroborating records) to determine whether the differences are timing issues or misstatements. Management's unsupported oral explanation alone is not adequate evidence.
Why not B: This is tempting, many exceptions do arise from timing differences, but an unsupported management explanation does not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. The auditor must corroborate the explanation with additional procedures.
Why not C: External confirmations are persuasive evidence, but an exception does not automatically prove a misstatement. The auditor should investigate the exception before concluding an adjustment is necessary; relying solely on the responses and forcing immediate adjustments is inappropriate.
Why not D: While unresolved exceptions could affect the audit opinion, the auditor is not required to modify the opinion immediately. The appropriate response is to perform additional procedures to resolve the exceptions and obtain sufficient appropriate evidence; only if the auditor cannot resolve the issues and they are material would a modification be considered.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what drives how much evidence the auditor needs, not on scheduling, prior-year comparisons, or management's preferences.
Answer B. The amount and type of audit evidence needed depend primarily on the assessed risk of material misstatement and on the appropriateness (reliability) of the evidence already obtained. Because the auditor currently has mainly client-prepared documents and unresolved past-due items, higher risk or lower reliability would generally require more persuasive procedures (for example, external confirmations or testing subsequent cash receipts).
Why not A: A larger balance may draw attention, but size alone is not the primary determinant of sufficiency. Materiality and risk considerations may be affected by changes in balances, but the governing factors are risk of misstatement and the persuasiveness of the evidence obtained.
Why not C: Written representations are part of the audit evidence mix but are relatively low in reliability and cannot substitute for more persuasive evidence when risk or evidence weakness exists. Management's representation does not remove the need for external or corroborating procedures when warranted.
Why not D: Practical constraints like budget or time do not determine whether sufficient appropriate evidence has been obtained. Audit conclusions must be based on the evidence needed to support the opinion, not on whether the team is over budget.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on which procedure gives the strongest evidence for one specific receivable when a confirmation does not come back.
Answer C. When a positive confirmation is not returned, the auditor should perform alternative procedures. Examining subsequent cash receipts and tracing them to the specific year-end invoice and shipping documents provides direct, external evidence that the sale occurred and the receivable was collectible at year-end. This procedure is more persuasive than management representations or broad analytical evidence for a specific customer balance.
Why not A: This may seem tempting because the credit manager knows the customer, but oral representations are internally generated and weaker evidence. They do not independently verify the existence or collectibility of the specific year-end receivable.
Why not B: Prior-year confirmations do not constitute evidence for the current-year balance; the auditor needs current-period evidence to support existence and collectibility as of the current year-end.
Why not D: Analytical procedures like gross margin comparisons are indirect and may identify anomalies, but they do not provide strong, specific evidence about an individual customer's receivable. They are less persuasive than tracing subsequent cash receipts to source documents.
Question 5
Hint
Consider the independence and reliability of the evidence obtained, not just whether the procedures performed appear relevant.
Answer D. Audit evidence must be both sufficient (quantity) and appropriate (relevance and reliability). Internal records and inquiry of client personnel are generally less reliable than independent external evidence. For a material receivable balance concentrated in a few customers, the auditor ordinarily needs more persuasive external corroboration, such as positive confirmations, inspection of subsequent cash receipts, or customer correspondence, so the procedures performed are likely insufficient and not appropriately reliable.
Why not A: This is tempting because confirmations are a common and persuasive external procedure. It fails because the error is treating the omission of confirmations in isolation, confirmations are not categorically required in every case; the broader issue is the overall lack of sufficient, reliable external corroboration.
Why not B: This is tempting because the aging schedule and the credit manager's explanations are directly relevant to valuation and collectibility. It fails because relevance alone does not ensure reliability: the aging schedule is internally prepared and inquiry of management is not independent, so external corroboration is usually needed for material, concentrated receivables.
Why not C: This distractor tempts candidates who equate documentation and management representations with reliable evidence. It is wrong because a management representation letter and careful documentation do not substitute for independent external corroboration when collectibility is in question.
Question 6
Hint
Consider whether the current evidence is internally consistent and what the auditor should do when confirmations are contradicted by cut‑off exceptions, manual adjustments, and weak supporting documents.
Answer D. The scenario presents conflicting evidence that reduces the reliability (appropriateness) of the positive confirmations: cut‑off exceptions (sales recorded before shipping), photocopied support, manual post‑year‑end adjustments, and lower‑than‑expected subsequent receipts. Auditing standards require the auditor to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, so contradictory results require additional substantive procedures (inspect original documents, expand testing, re‑test subsequent receipts) to corroborate or refute the confirmations. Only if those further procedures fail to resolve the concerns should the auditor consider modifying the opinion.
Why not A: This is tempting because unreliable evidence can ultimately lead to a scope limitation and a modified opinion. It is incorrect here because a modification is required only if the auditor, after performing all appropriate further procedures, cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence; the scenario indicates evidence can be pursued further, so immediate modification is premature.
Why not B: This is tempting because large‑dollar positive confirmations are persuasive and coverage of 90% seems strong. It is wrong because confirmations can be undermined by other contradictory evidence (cut‑off exceptions, questionable supporting documents, manual post‑year‑end entries, and unexpected collection patterns); the auditor must resolve those contradictions rather than accept confirmations alone.
Why not C: This distractor tempts because manual, post‑year‑end entries and senior management authorization can indicate override of controls. It fails as the primary response because the immediate issue is the sufficiency and appropriateness of substantive evidence for the account balances; control testing and committee notification may be appropriate, but they do not substitute for performing additional substantive procedures to resolve contradictory evidence.
Question 7
Hint
Consider how an increase in assessed risk of material misstatement and weaker controls affects both the amount of evidence needed and the preferred reliability (source) of that evidence.
Answer C. Weaker controls and deteriorating collections increase the assessed risk of material misstatement, so the auditor needs more evidence (sufficiency) and higher-quality evidence (appropriateness). Increasing the number of confirmations raises the quantity of external evidence, and performing corroborative procedures such as testing subsequent cash receipts improves the reliability of conclusions about the collectibility of receivables.
Why not A: Analytical procedures can be useful, but when risk is elevated and receivables are at stake, confirmations and direct corroboration are generally more persuasive than analytics alone; substituting analytics would likely reduce the quality of evidence.
Why not B: Tempting because it mentions controls, but weaker controls increase risk and call for more, not fewer, external evidence. Management reconciliations are internal and less reliable than independent confirmations, so relying on them would reduce evidence appropriateness.
Why not D: Client-prepared documents lack the independence of external confirmations, and confirming only a few accounts would not provide sufficient evidence given the increased risk and weakened controls.
Question 8
Hint
Ask which assertion the confirmations and cash receipts actually support, then consider what the side-agreement email does to the overall persuasiveness of the evidence.
Answer A. Sufficiency is not just a matter of how much evidence was obtained; appropriateness also requires relevant, reliable evidence for the assertions at risk. The confirmations and subsequent collections are strong evidence about existence, but the side-agreement exception creates contradictory evidence relevant to valuation, cutoff, and possible revenue reversal through returns. Because the possible effect could be material, the auditor needs further procedures to determine whether similar undisclosed terms exist and whether the recorded balances are misstated.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often over-weight the quantity of external evidence and the successful alternative procedure on the nonresponse. It is wrong because one confirmation exception can be highly significant when it reveals a potentially material side agreement affecting the nature of the receivable and related revenue. Contradictory evidence reduces persuasiveness and triggers additional work.
Why not C: This distractor is appealing because it lists several common audit procedures that sound comprehensive. But shipping documents and invoices are largely internal evidence and do not resolve whether extended return rights existed outside the formal contract. The issue is not that management is speculating; the issue is that external evidence has already identified a term that could materially affect valuation and related assertions.
Why not D: This choice is tempting because management representations alone are never sufficient for a material matter. It is still wrong because management's oral explanation can be considered as audit evidence; it is just not persuasive enough to overcome the contradictory external evidence here. The deficiency is not a categorical prohibition on considering management's statement, but the need for additional corroborating procedures.
Question 9
Hint
Match the procedure to the specific assertion being tested, then think about which source of evidence is most reliable when risk is high.
Answer C. To test the existence assertion for accounts receivable, evidence obtained directly from third parties is most reliable. When control risk is high and the balance is material, positive confirmations provide strong, direct evidence of existence; following up on significant nonresponses is needed to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not A: Tracing the aged trial balance to the general ledger tests internal consistency and completeness of recordkeeping, but the aging is client-generated and less persuasive about actual existence of receivables, especially when controls are weak.
Why not B: Inquiry of the credit manager addresses collectibility and valuation more than existence; internal inquiry alone is not sufficient appropriate evidence for a material existence assertion.
Why not D: Management representation letters are required but are corroborative rather than primary evidence and cannot substitute for independent substantive procedures when a material balance is at risk.
Common questions
Does a nonresponse to a positive AR confirmation mean the customer agrees?
No. Silence provides no evidence of agreement. Perform alternative procedures for the nonresponse.
What alternative procedures can an auditor perform for AR confirmation nonresponses?
Test subsequent cash receipts, if available, and match them to year-end invoices and shipping evidence. Other relevant supporting documentation may also provide evidence.
Does a partial subsequent payment support the full year-end receivable?
Not by itself. Determine which invoices the payment covers, then evaluate whether sufficient appropriate evidence supports the remaining balance.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence, worked step by step.
Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Sufficient Appropriate Evidence
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.