AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions
When to Identify Significant Audit Risk in Year-End Sales
When a late sale creates a significant revenue risk, revise the audit plan immediately rather than relying on clean interim testing. Follow Ridgeway's sale through risk identification and targeted year-end procedures.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether the December 30 sale creates a "significant risk" for revenue recognition and whether interim testing substitutes for period‑end substantive evidence, also remember when evidence must be obtained relative to the report date.
Answer A. The December 30 sales are both large and to a related party with undocumented return/pricing terms, creating a significant risk of material misstatement for revenue recognition and cut‑off. Interim testing does not eliminate the need for period‑end substantive procedures for significant, unusual year‑end transactions; the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence (cut‑off testing, document inspection, confirmations, related‑party evaluation) at or near year‑end and complete those procedures before issuing the report.
Why not B: This is tempting because controls were effective at an interim date, but it is wrong: a large, unusual year‑end related‑party sale raises significant risk that requires detailed period‑end substantive testing beyond analytics to support recognition and cut‑off.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to shipment terms, but FOB shipping point alone doesn't address the substance of the transaction. Related‑party affiliation and undocumented return/price terms raise doubts about whether the sale is genuine or properly measured, so immediate cut‑off testing and confirmations are still required.
Why not D: This option confuses subsequent‑event procedures with the need to gather evidence for amounts recognized at the balance sheet date. The auditor must complete necessary procedures to support recognition and measurement of year‑end amounts before issuing the report; deferring them until after the report would not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence for the period under audit.
Step by step
- Spot the late sales red flags
Interim testing at Ridgeway found effective controls on September 30. On December 30, Ridgeway records a large FOB shipping point sale to a CEO-affiliated distributor with undocumented return and pricing terms.
- Identify the significant risk now
The unusual related-party sale and missing terms create a significant revenue-recognition risk. Identify that risk when the facts become known, without waiting for a misstatement.
- Move substantive testing to year-end
Revise the planned response to include substantive procedures at or near year-end. Effective September control testing does not establish whether this December sale occurred or belongs in the current year.
- Test the sale's cutoff
Inspect the December 30 sale's invoice and shipping documents, including shipping records spanning December 31. Determine whether the evidence supports recording the sale in the year ended December 31.
- Test occurrence and confirm terms
For occurrence, confirm the sale directly with the distributor and inspect supporting documents; also confirm return and pricing terms. FOB shipping point alone does not resolve those undocumented terms.
- Finish before issuing the report
Do not replace these tests of details with analytics alone or defer them until after report issuance. Obtain sufficient appropriate evidence addressing the significant revenue risk before issuing the report.
Key points
- Remember: Effective interim testing does not cover a new significant risk concentrated at year-end.
- Risk assessment drives the testing plan; a detected misstatement is not the trigger.
- Cutoff asks when to record the sale; occurrence asks whether the sale happened.
How the exam traps you
- Wait until testing finds a misstatement before identifying a significant risk. Identify the risk when the unusual sale and undocumented terms become known.
- Rely on effective interim controls and use only year-end analytics. Perform targeted period-end tests of details for the newly identified revenue risk.
- Treat FOB shipping point as proof that revenue recognition is correct. Inspect shipping evidence and investigate undocumented return and pricing terms.
Question 2
Hint
Identify where the misstatement risk is concentrated (which period and which assertion) and consider whether the evidence needed (e.g., shipment date) is best obtained at or near the period end rather than at interim or solely by analytics.
Answer D. The facts show a concentrated cutoff risk at period end (large late‑December sales, FOB shipping point, and untested changes to shipping controls). Auditing standards require substantive procedures at or near period end when cutoff risk is significant; focused cut‑off testing of shipping documents and related subsequent receipts directly addresses the timing assertion. Testing the revised shipping controls at year‑end also helps determine whether control changes can be relied upon.
Why not A: This is tempting because interim testing is efficient and sometimes acceptable, but it's wrong here: the cutoff risk is concentrated at year‑end and the client changed shipping controls (untested). Interim procedures plus limited roll‑forward could miss misstatements tied to accelerated year‑end shipments.
Why not B: Analytical procedures can assess plausibility and trends but do not provide direct evidence of shipment dates or occurrence of specific transactions near year‑end. Therefore analytics alone are insufficient to address concentrated cutoff risk; targeted cut‑off testing is still required.
Why not C: Subsequent cash receipts can be persuasive for collectibility but do not prove shipment or the correct period of recognition. Collections may relate to multiple periods or occur despite improper period recognition, so relying on receipts alone does not adequately address FOB shipping‑point cutoff risk.
Question 3
Hint
Separate two issues: what facts are enough to require a going-concern evaluation, and what date starts the one-year look-forward period under current U.S. GAAS.
Answer A. Under U.S. GAAS, the auditor must perform a going-concern evaluation when conditions or events identified during the audit indicate possible substantial doubt about the entity's ability to continue as a going concern. The combination of recurring losses, negative cash flows, a callable debt with only a short waiver, and loss of a major customer collectively trigger that evaluation now. The auditor's look-forward period is one year after the date the financial statements are available to be issued, so the evaluation covers through 4/15/Year 3.
Why not B: Tempting because a callable debt is a clear liquidity threat, but the auditor's responsibility is triggered by indicators of possible substantial doubt, not only by formal acceleration. The timing is also incorrect, current U.S. GAAS uses the one-year look-forward from the date the financial statements are available to be issued, not from year-end.
Why not C: Attractive because management has primary responsibility for the assessment, but the auditor does not wait passively for management's documentation before responding to identified risk conditions. The timing stated (one year after available-to-be-issued date) is correct, but the trigger described is wrong.
Why not D: This lures candidates who recall older guidance or anchor on year-end conditions. While the evaluation is triggered now, under current U.S. GAAS the relevant period is one year after the financial statements are available to be issued, so ending at 12/31/Year 2 is too short.
Question 4
Hint
For each event, ask: does the information provide evidence about a condition that existed at Dec 31 (adjusting) or did the condition arise after Dec 31 (nonadjusting)?
Answer B. Event 1 presents evidence about a condition that existed at the balance sheet date: missed payments and a formal collection notice before Dec 31 indicate the receivable was impaired at year‑end, so management should adjust the receivable/allowance. Event 2 (the tornado) arose after the balance sheet date and does not provide evidence about conditions at Dec 31, so it is a nonadjusting event that requires disclosure if material.
Why not A: Tempting because both events are material and both occurred before issuance; however, the tornado occurred after year‑end and does not shed light on conditions that existed at Dec 31. Only Event 1 has pre‑year‑end indicators of impairment and therefore requires adjustment.
Why not C: Tempting for candidates who focus on the bankruptcy filing date rather than earlier indicators. It is incorrect because missed payments and a formal collection notice before Dec 31 show the customer's deterioration existed at year‑end, making Event 1 an adjusting event; Event 2 arose after year‑end and is nonadjusting.
Why not D: Tempting if one treats both occurrences as purely post‑balance‑sheet events. This fails to account for the pre‑year‑end evidence (missed payments and collection notice) that indicates Event 1 was a condition existing at Dec 31 and therefore requires adjustment.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what must be true before management's plans can actually reduce a going-concern problem, not just what management says or hopes will happen.
Answer B. U.S. auditing standards require persuasive evidence that management's plans are probable of being effectively implemented and probable of mitigating the conditions that raised substantial doubt before the auditor can conclude the doubt is alleviated. Evidence such as management's intent, forecasts, or written representations alone is insufficient without corroborating support that the plans will be carried out and will likely resolve the adverse conditions.
Why not A: Intent and lender discussions are relevant but do not by themselves show the plans are probable of effective implementation or that they will mitigate the going-concern conditions; the auditor needs stronger corroborating evidence.
Why not C: Forecasts can be useful but are not sufficient alone to prove that plans are probable of being implemented or that they will mitigate the adverse conditions; forecasts require corroboration and evaluation of implementation feasibility.
Why not D: Written representations are part of audit evidence but cannot substitute for persuasive, corroborated evidence that management's plans will likely be implemented and will mitigate the conditions creating substantial doubt.
Question 6
Hint
Identify whether the facts point to more than one distinct risk (e.g., financial‑distress indicators versus characteristics of an unusual related‑party sale) and think about what specific evidence each risk requires.
Answer D. The near‑year‑end sale to a newly formed entity owned by the CEO's sibling, at below‑cost pricing with extended terms and no evidence of collectibility, raises heightened related‑party and revenue‑recognition risks requiring targeted substantive procedures and disclosure review. Separately, recurring losses, negative operating cash flow, a low current ratio, and an unresolved covenant breach are clear indicators of potential going concern that require written evidence from the lender and corroboration of management's financing plans. Both areas must be addressed concurrently.
Why not A: This option focuses correctly on the unusual related‑party sale but is wrong because it ignores the company's clear financial‑distress indicators (recurring losses, negative cash flow, low current ratio, and covenant breach) that require a formal going‑concern evaluation and corroborative evidence from the lender.
Why not B: While the financial condition clearly indicates going‑concern risk, this choice is wrong because the December 28 sale exhibits features (related party, below‑cost price, extended terms, new purchaser, lack of supporting documentation) that create separate heightened revenue‑recognition and disclosure risks needing targeted procedures beyond routine testing.
Why not C: Although related‑party transactions and unusual year‑end sales can indicate fraud risk, this option is wrong because fraud‑focused procedures alone do not replace the specific substantive testing required for the related‑party sale or the formal evidence needed to evaluate going concern; the facts point to two distinct audit risks that both require tailored responses.
Common questions
When should an auditor identify a significant revenue risk?
When the facts supporting that assessment become known. Ridgeway's unusual late sale and undocumented terms require action without waiting for a detected misstatement.
Can effective interim controls replace year-end cutoff testing?
Not for Ridgeway's newly identified year-end risk. The auditor must revise the response and perform targeted period-end substantive procedures.
Does FOB shipping point prove a year-end sale is valid?
No. Shipping terms help assess cutoff, but the auditor must also verify the sale and evaluate return and pricing terms.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk, worked step by step.
Revenue Fraud Risk & Audit Procedures | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.