AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 8 practice questions
Audit Significant Risks: Unusual Related-Party Transactions
A significant related-party transaction outside the normal course of business must be treated as a significant risk. Sort changes to one equipment sale to see which facts change that requirement and which do not.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on which facts most strongly indicate special audit consideration under risk assessment standards: unusual, related-party, nonroutine, subjective, or fraud-linked matters tend to outrank routine areas with stable patterns.
Answer C. This fact pattern combines classic significant-risk indicators: a related-party transaction, nonstandard financing and a repurchase side agreement, timing immediately before year‑end, a transaction outside the normal course of business, and management's incentive to highlight the gain. Those features materially increase the risk of misstatement or fraud and ordinarily require special audit consideration at the assertion level under AICPA risk-assessment guidance. Therefore option C is the strongest basis for identifying a significant risk.
Why not A: Candidates may recall the presumed fraud risk in revenue and find A tempting. However, when the auditor performs the required fraud inquiry and documents a supportable rebuttal (standardized contracts, automated processing, and no side agreements or manual entries), the presumption is addressed and this situation is a weaker basis for a significant-risk designation than the unusual related‑party transaction in C.
Why not B: A material estimate can suggest risk, so B can appear concerning. But long-term stability, routine quarterly true‑ups, and narrow variability reduce estimation uncertainty and subjectivity; under these facts the estimate does not rise to the level of a significant risk requiring special audit consideration compared with the indicators present in C.
Why not D: Segregation-of-duties weaknesses can be tempting distractors. However, compensating controls (owner approval above the threshold and independent monthly bank review) and the routine nature of the activity lower the likelihood that this alone represents a significant risk at the assertion level compared with C's unusual related‑party, year‑end transaction.
Sort it
The transaction is significant, involves a related party, and is outside the normal course of business.
The facts do not establish every element of that requirement; assess other risks and resolve missing facts.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Delta Co. records a material, one-time equipment sale outside its normal course of business on December 30. The buyer is an LLC owned by Delta's CEO's brother. The contract has standard terms and no side agreements. | Required significant riskThe significant, nonroutine related-party transaction triggers the requirement even though its contract terms look ordinary. |
| Same facts, except the buyer is an unrelated entity. | Assess remaining riskThe related-party requirement no longer applies. The material, nonroutine year-end sale still needs assessment for other significant risks. |
| Same facts, except the board approved the sale. | Required significant riskApproval does not remove the required classification. The sale remains significant, related-party, and outside normal business. |
| Same facts, except the sale is within Delta's normal course of business. | Assess remaining riskThe outside-normal-course element is gone. Related-party involvement still requires attention, but this rule no longer determines significant risk classification. |
| Same facts, except a side letter gives Delta a fixed-price repurchase option. | Required significant riskThe classification remains required. The repurchase option adds a substance and recognition concern that calls for inspecting the side letter. |
| Same facts, except an independent appraisal supports the sales price. | Required significant riskPrice support does not remove the classification. An appraisal does not establish the transaction's business purpose or substance. |
| Same facts, except the buyer's ownership has not yet been established. | Assess remaining riskInvestigate ownership during risk assessment. An unidentified relationship is not evidence of independence, and it does not justify postponing assessment. |
| Same facts, except the sale uses a new bill-and-hold arrangement. | Required significant riskThe classification remains required. Inspect the bill-and-hold terms and obtain evidence supporting control transfer before accepting the recorded sale. |
| Same facts, except the sale is below overall materiality; assume it remains qualitatively significant. | Required significant riskOnly quantitative size changes. Qualitative significance, related-party involvement, and the nonroutine nature remain, so the required classification still applies. |
| Same facts, except the notes disclose the relationship and all transaction terms. | Required significant riskComplete disclosure does not remove recognition or substance concerns. The significant, nonroutine related-party transaction still requires significant risk treatment. |
| Same facts, except the sale occurs on June 30 rather than December 30. | Required significant riskYear-end timing is not required. Significance, related-party involvement, and the transaction's nonroutine nature still determine the classification. |
| Same facts, except the sale includes an immediate leaseback. | Required significant riskThe classification remains required. Evaluate the sale and leaseback together to understand their business purpose and accounting substance. |
| Same facts, except the contract specifies FOB shipping point. | Required significant riskShipping language does not remove the required classification or replace evaluating all terms and evidence of control transfer. |
Key points
- Remember: The trigger is a significant related-party transaction outside normal business, not a missing approval or an unfair price.
- Removing the related-party relationship removes this automatic requirement, not every possible significant risk.
- Year-end timing strengthens concern, but the required classification does not depend on that timing.
- Investigate missing ownership information during risk assessment. Do not assume the buyer is unrelated.
How the exam traps you
- Board approval makes the transaction routine. Approval is relevant evidence, but it does not change the relationship or the transaction's nonroutine nature.
- An amount below overall materiality cannot create a significant risk. Consider qualitative significance. A smaller amount does not automatically remove the required classification.
- FOB shipping point proves the recorded sale is appropriate. Evaluate all terms and control transfer. Shipping language alone does not resolve recognition or the significant risk.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on which combination of facts changes the auditor's duties during the risk-assessment phase itself, not on procedures that might follow later if problems persist.
Answer C. The facts present multiple high-risk indicators together: an unusual, material transaction with unusual terms and evidence of an undisclosed related party. Under AU-C 550 (Related Parties) and AU-C 240 (Fraud), that combination obligates the auditor to obtain an understanding of the transaction's business purpose and to reassess risks of material misstatement (including fraud) during risk assessment rather than deferring action to later substantive testing.
Why not A: This is tempting because material items naturally draw more audit scrutiny and candidates may overgeneralize that materiality alone drives timing. It fails because materiality alone does not change the timing of risk assessment; the unusual nature, terms, and apparent undisclosed related-party relationship are what require immediate reassessment and expanded procedures.
Why not B: This distractor attracts candidates since side letters are classic red flags. It fails because legal confirmation is not an automatic first response; the auditor must first obtain an understanding, inspect relevant documents, and reassess risk, legal confirmation may be appropriate later but is not universally required immediately.
Why not D: This is tempting because management evasiveness increases concern and influences professional skepticism. It fails because a request to postpone does not automatically mandate withdrawal; instead it heightens the need to expand risk-assessment procedures and testing, and withdrawal is considered only if issues cannot be resolved or evidence cannot be obtained.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the facts point to a routine revenue balance or to a higher-risk area that needs a more direct audit response.
Answer D. This fact pattern contains classic revenue fraud risk indicators: management incentive pressure, unusual year-end transactions, bill-and-hold terms, and customer acceptance provisions. Those facts support treating the area as a significant risk and designing a focused response. The planned response should directly test whether revenue recognition criteria were actually met, especially contract terms and cutoff.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because analytics are commonly used in planning and bonus pressure is a known fraud factor. Still, disclosure of management incentives does not reduce the underlying engagement risk. Given the specific high-risk revenue facts, analytical procedures alone would be too weak a planned response.
Why not B: This is tempting because post-year-end cash receipts can provide useful evidence and management representations are part of an audit. However, neither is sufficient as the primary response to a significant revenue risk. Payment after year-end does not by itself prove that bill-and-hold and customer acceptance conditions were satisfied at Year 1 year-end.
Why not C: A candidate might think fewer transactions means less work. But a small number of large, unusual year-end transactions can increase audit risk, not reduce it. Ease of tracing invoices does not address whether the revenue was recognized in the proper period or met the contract requirements.
Question 4
Hint
Identify the fact pattern that is both nonroutine and closely tied to possible management influence, not just the fact pattern that suggests a general incentive to misstate.
Answer B. The facts describe a nonroutine, material related-party sale with unusual terms at year-end and indications of a possible repurchase, conditions that raise concern about economic substance and management override. The auditor should treat that transaction as a specific area of heightened engagement risk and perform focused procedures on its substance, terms, collectibility if recognized, and related-party disclosure.
Why not A: This is tempting because the transaction was recorded at year-end, so cutoff is a reasonable concern. However, the situation points to one material, unusual related-party transaction rather than a broad cutoff problem across the whole sales population, so the specific related-party transaction is the higher-risk area.
Why not C: Favorable terms can raise collectibility questions, which makes this attractive. The more fundamental issue here is whether the transaction should be recognized as a valid sale given the related-party nature and potential repurchase agreement, so the unusual transaction itself is the primary heightened risk.
Why not D: Earnings pressure and incentive compensation can increase fraud risk, so this is a plausible general concern. Still, those are broader, company-wide risk factors; the most clearly identified specific area of heightened engagement risk in the facts is the material related-party transaction near year-end.
Question 5
Hint
Look for the item that is outside the normal course of business and could be influenced by related-party relationships or unusual terms.
Answer A. This transaction combines key engagement-risk indicators: a related-party relationship, occurrence at year-end, and unusual financing terms (which may not reflect market terms). Those factors increase the risk of material misstatement and warrant focused procedures to evaluate business purpose, authorization, valuation, and disclosure. Compared with the other items, this one is clearly outside the ordinary course of business and more susceptible to management bias or intentional misstatement.
Why not B: Purchases can be material, but the facts describe routine transactions with unrelated parties and normal terms. Absent other red flags, these create less specific engagement risk than a related-party, year-end transaction with unusual financing.
Why not C: Use of a service organization can present control considerations, but here the arrangement is longstanding and unchanged, so there is no new or heightened risk signal that outweighs the related-party, year-end sale.
Why not D: Allowances are judgmental and can be risky, but the consistent methodology and stable aging trends reduce concern in this scenario. Without additional warning signs, this is less likely to require the same heightened attention as the unusual related-party transaction.
Question 6
Hint
Look for the fact pattern that combines unusual terms, year-end timing, and a higher opportunity for intentional misstatement.
Answer A. A large related‑party sale recorded near year‑end with unusual terms and extended return rights raises the risk of improper revenue recognition or intentional misstatement. The combination of related party, timing (near year‑end), and nonstandard contract terms is a classic trigger for treatment as a significant risk that requires special audit consideration and additional substantive procedures. Auditors should design focused procedures to address the heightened risk in this area.
Why not B: This is tempting because inventory discrepancies attract attention, but small, promptly corrected differences generally indicate a control or procedural issue rather than a significant risk of material misstatement by themselves. Such findings may change the nature or extent of planned procedures but typically do not by themselves warrant designation as a significant risk.
Why not C: Students may focus on estimates and assume all are significant risks, but an increase explained by higher sales with an unchanged, consistent estimation method does not automatically indicate a significant risk. Significant risk is more likely when estimates involve new or aggressive assumptions, high subjectivity, or inconsistency, none of which are present here.
Why not D: This describes a segregation‑of‑duties deficiency and is therefore a control weakness, which can be tempting to label a significant risk. However, because the account is small and low volume, the magnitude and likelihood of material misstatement are limited; the issue usually requires control remediation rather than classification as a significant risk.
Question 7
Hint
Which item most directly affects whether revenue should be recognized in Year 2? Focus on contract terms that affect transfer of control and compare the dollar amounts involved.
Answer C. Revenue recognition is the primary risk. The $3.0 million late‑year shipment (25% of annual revenue) combined with a 60‑day return right and a separate repurchase side letter may indicate that Atlas retained significant exposure to the goods or created a repurchase obligation or consignment‑type arrangement, conditions under ASC 606 that would preclude recognizing revenue at shipment. The related‑party sale, covenant issue, and inventory valuation concerns merit attention but are secondary given the size and direct effect of the $3.0M transaction on reported Year 2 revenue.
Why not A: Tempting because covenant violations can signal financial distress and may affect audit planning and disclosures. However, management reports an informal likely waiver and the most pressing audit risk in the facts presented is the potential misstatement of revenue from the large year‑end shipment; going concern is a relevant but secondary concern unless further adverse evidence emerges.
Why not B: This is tempting because related‑party sales on extended terms can be used to misstate revenue or hide collectibility problems, so they require careful audit scrutiny. It is not the primary issue here because the amount ($1.2M) is smaller and was disclosed; the more immediate, large‑magnitude question concerns whether the $3.0M year‑end shipment met transfer‑of‑control criteria and was appropriately recognized.
Why not D: Plausible because unsold goods subject to return or repurchase can create inventory valuation or obsolescence issues for Atlas. Nevertheless, the immediate audit question is whether revenue should have been recorded for the $3.0M shipment; if control had not transferred, revenue recognition (not just subsequent inventory valuation) would be the primary misstatement risk.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on the area with unusual terms, heightened judgment, and the strongest risk of material misstatement near period-end.
Answer D. A bill-and-hold arrangement entered at year-end outside the entity's normal sales terms is a classic higher-risk area because it involves unusual revenue recognition facts and increased potential for premature or improper revenue recognition. Revenue is a fraud-sensitive account, and the unusual timing and negotiated terms near period-end increase the risk of material misstatement and the need for targeted audit procedures.
Why not A: Depreciation involves estimates, but when the method and useful lives are consistent with prior years and no new assumptions are introduced, it is typically a routine, lower-risk area compared with an unusual year-end revenue transaction.
Why not B: Automated monthly amortization under an established policy is predictable and recurring; automation and long-standing procedures reduce the likelihood of a material misstatement relative to an unusual, high-value revenue transaction.
Why not C: Although cash is inherently susceptible to misappropriation, a small, fixed-fund petty cash system with regular reconciliations typically poses low risk of a material misstatement compared with complex, high-value revenue recognition issues.
Common questions
Are all related-party transactions significant risks?
No. The required classification applies to significant related-party transactions outside the normal course of business. An ordinary-course transaction still needs assessment for other risks.
Does board approval eliminate a related-party significant risk?
No. Approval does not remove the required classification. An independent appraisal also does not, by itself, resolve the transaction's business purpose or substance.
Can a transaction below overall materiality be a significant risk?
Yes. In the below-materiality version, the sale remains qualitatively significant, related-party, and outside normal business. Its smaller amount does not remove the required classification.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk, worked step by step.
Revenue Fraud Risk & Audit Procedures | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.