PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 9 practice questions

Auditing Year-End Revenue With Related-Party Fraud Risk

Significant revenue fraud risks require substantive procedures that directly address the suspected misstatement. Below, compare audit responses to a year-end related-party sale with return rights and a manual revenue entry.

The ruleUnder AU-C 240 and AU-C 330, perform substantive procedures specifically responsive to significant revenue fraud risks and test journal entries for override. Analytics, management representations, or untested controls alone are insufficient.

Try one first

An auditor planning the Year 2 audit notes that the company recognizes revenue on long‑term product‑installation contracts using the percentage‑of‑completion method. Planning activities revealed that management compensation is heavily tied to revenue targets; contracts are sometimes modified by undocumented side agreements; contract cost estimates have been repeatedly adjusted; and several material revenue journal entries were recorded by senior accounting personnel shortly after month‑end without clear support. The auditor assesses the risk of material misstatement due to fraud in revenue recognition as significant. Which one of the following responses is required under auditing standards?
Hint

Consider what type of evidence standards require when a fraud‑related risk is judged 'significant', detailed, corroborative tests or primarily high‑level procedures and representations?

What should you do?

The situation

Harbor records a material $3 million sale on December 28 to a business owned by its CEO's brother. A side letter allows returns for 60 days. The CFO posts the revenue entry manually. The board approved the sale, and payment arrives in January. Draft statements omit the relationship. The auditor assesses a significant revenue fraud risk.

  1. Inspect terms, test cutoff and returns, corroborate confirmations, test the entry, and evaluate disclosure.

    Best Use the contract, side letter, shipping evidence, and auditor-controlled confirmations. Independently corroborate the related party's reply and test the CFO's entry for override.

  2. Treat January payment as sufficient evidence for the December sale.

    Wrong Payment supports collection. It does not establish December transfer of control, reveal all side agreements, or resolve the return right's effect on revenue.

  3. Rely on board approval and management representations, with control testing replacing substantive procedures.

    Wrong Approval and representations do not establish the sale's substance or proper disclosure. Control testing cannot replace substantive procedures specifically responsive to the significant fraud risk.

  4. Expand revenue analytics and routine samples without testing the CFO's manual entry.

    Wrong Larger samples do not address the suspected manipulation by themselves. Test the manual entry and target the side letter, cutoff, returns, and related-party disclosure.

Key points

  • Remember: Significant fraud risk requires targeted evidence, not simply larger routine samples.
  • January payment supports collection, not December transfer of control or proper accounting for return rights.
  • A related party's confirmation needs independent corroboration.
  • Board approval does not establish proper revenue recognition or complete related-party disclosure.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating January payment as proof of December revenue. Test transfer of control and return terms at year-end; payment supports collection, not recognition timing.
  • Treating board approval and management assurances as sufficient. Inspect the agreement, corroborate terms, and evaluate the missing related-party disclosure.
  • Expanding analytics while skipping the manual revenue entry. Test the entry and supporting evidence directly for management override.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During planning for the audit of Nova Equipment Co., the auditor learns that in the last week of Year 1 Nova sold a warehouse to an entity wholly owned by Nova's CEO. Assume the transaction is material, outside Nova's normal course of business, and was approved outside the company's usual authorization process. Which planned audit response is most appropriate?
Hint

Ask what makes this transaction different from an ordinary sale, and think about what audit work would address that added risk.

Question 3

Alpha Co., a privately held manufacturer, recorded $2.4 million of revenue in the final week of Year 1 from shipments to Beta LLC; that amount represents 22% of Alpha's Year 1 revenue and 35% of year‑end accounts receivable. Beta LLC is owned and controlled by the CEO's brother (a related party). There were no cash receipts from Beta through year‑end, and the controller provided an undated side letter stating Beta may return goods through February Year 2. Management asserts the sales are routine and that controls over sales are effective. As engagement partner planning the Year 1 audit, which auditor response is most appropriate?
Hint

Consider how the combination of related‑party ownership, material year‑end sales/receivable concentration, no cash receipts, and an undated return agreement affects the persuasiveness and type of evidence you should plan to obtain.

Question 4

During risk assessment for the audit of Harbor Co., the auditor learns that several material year-end sales were made to an entity controlled by Harbor's majority shareholder. Management says the sales were in the ordinary course of business and at market prices. What is the most appropriate audit treatment of these transactions at this stage?
Hint

When a transaction involves an owner or an entity under common control, think about what extra risk assessment work is needed before relying on management's description.

Question 5

During planning for the Year 3 audit of a privately held manufacturer, the auditor notes these facts: the CEO is a majority shareholder and the company has several material transactions and outstanding balances with entities owned by family members; collectively those balances represent a material percentage of total assets; there is no formal process for identifying related parties, some contracts are informal or oral, and accounting personnel were unaware of some prior arrangements; management's accounting for several of the balances involves judgment about collectability. Given these facts, which is the most appropriate additional audit response to address the engagement risk?
Hint

For material related‑party issues with weak identification controls, think about what type of evidence standards require for a significant risk, are controls or management representations alone adequate?

Question 6

Assume a nonissuer audit under U.S. GAAS. During planning for the 20X6 audit, the auditor learns that 10 days before year-end, Delta Co. sold inventory to an entity owned by the CEO's brother. The transaction increased pretax income by approximately 16% and helped Delta meet a debt covenant. It was approved by the board and processed through Delta's normal sales system, but the auditor also identifies emails indicating Delta may repurchase any unsold goods at the original price plus carrying costs. Delta has never entered into this type of transaction before. Which is the correct treatment of this matter in assessing risk and developing planned audit responses?
Hint

Identify which facts should dominate the risk assessment: unusual transaction, related-party involvement, year-end timing, covenant pressure, and evidence of side terms.

Question 7

During planning for the Year 2 audit of a privately held manufacturing client, the auditor notes the following: management's annual bonus is tied to achieving a specified net income target; sales increased 40% in the last two weeks of Year 2, mostly to a single reseller that is 100% owned by the CEO's brother and was not previously identified as a related party; management made several large manual journal entries just before year‑end that reduced the allowance for doubtful accounts; internal controls over sales, receivables, and journal entries are weak (limited segregation of duties and little supervisory review); and management refused the auditor's initial request to send confirmations to the reseller, citing confidentiality. Based on AU‑C guidance on specific engagement risks, which of the following is the most appropriate auditor response?
Hint

Focus on the combination of incentive/pressure, an unexplained period‑end sales spike to an undisclosed related party, manual period‑end adjustments, weak controls, and management's restriction on confirmations, what do the AU‑C risk standards require when these fraud risk factors are present?

Question 8

While planning the Year 2 audit of ABC Co., the auditor notes revenue recognition risks: management's bonus plan ties to meeting Year 2 sales targets; three large invoices totaling $2.5 million were recorded on December 31, Year 2, yet the related goods were observed in ABC's warehouse at year‑end and shipping documents show shipment dates of January 3, Year 3. Management asserts bill‑and‑hold, but no written side agreements or customer acceptances were provided, and segregation of duties between sales and shipping is weak. Which auditor response is most appropriate?
Hint

Which procedures most directly verify shipment dates, customer acceptance, and contractual terms, and how should control weaknesses or a management override incentive affect reliance on controls?

Question 9

Alpine Pump Co., a privately held manufacturer, sells primarily through independent distributors. During the year under audit, 58% of Alpine's sales were to one distributor, Streamline Distributors. The auditor discovered that Streamline is owned by the CEO's brother (a related party that was not clearly disclosed). In December, Alpine recorded $3.2 million of sales to Streamline (about a 15% increase in annual revenue). Several December sales invoices contain handwritten notes granting extended return privileges, and management's bonuses are tied to achieving revenue targets. The auditor is concerned about risk of material misstatement related to revenue recognition and undisclosed related-party transactions. Which of the following is the most appropriate planned response?
Hint

Focus on what evidence most directly addresses both the occurrence/valuation of late-year sales and the risk of undisclosed related-party transactions rather than on representations, analytics alone, or relying primarily on controls.

Drill all 93 Specific Areas of Engagement Risk questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What audit procedures address significant year-end revenue fraud risk?

Inspect the contract and side letter, test year-end cutoff and returns, and corroborate confirmations. Test the manual revenue entry and evaluate related-party disclosure.

Does subsequent cash collection prove year-end revenue was valid?

No. January payment supports collection, not December transfer of control or proper accounting for the return side letter.

Is a related-party receivable confirmation enough?

No. The relationship can weaken the reply's reliability. Corroborate balances and terms with independent evidence, and evaluate related-party disclosure.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk, worked step by step.

Revenue Fraud Risk & Audit Procedures | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Specific Areas of Engagement Risk

All Specific Areas of Engagement Risk practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.