AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Yellow Book reports: omitting sensitive information
A public Yellow Book report must disclose when confidential, sensitive, or legally protected information is omitted and why. Follow a state agency's security finding through the public report and a separate, limited-distribution communication.
Try one first
Hint
Distinguish the auditor's public-reporting duties under GAGAS from the conditions under GAAS that require modifying a financial-statement opinion; consider how legal restrictions affect what is reported publicly versus to authorized officials.
Answer D. When performing an audit under GAGAS, the auditor must issue the required written GAGAS report on internal control and compliance. If law prohibits public disclosure of specific details, the public GAGAS report should describe reportable findings to the extent permitted, note that certain specifics are withheld and explain why, and make fuller restricted details available to authorized officials consistent with applicable law or regulation. A legal restriction on public disclosure does not, by itself, require modifying the financial-statement opinion; GAAS requires an opinion modification only if there is a material misstatement of the financial statements or a scope limitation that prevents obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
Why not A: Tempting because of confidentiality concerns, but GAGAS does not permit silently omitting reportable matters from a required public report; at minimum the public report should indicate that reportable findings exist and explain that some specifics are withheld and why.
Why not B: Although limiting disclosure preserves confidentiality, failing to issue the required public GAGAS report when one is required by GAGAS would not satisfy public-reporting obligations; the public report should note omitted specifics and the reason for withholding, with fuller details provided to authorized recipients as permitted.
Why not C: Misleading: significant control or compliance findings under GAGAS do not automatically require modifying the financial-statement opinion. Opinion modification under GAAS depends on a material misstatement or a scope limitation that affects the financial statements, not solely on the existence of GAGAS reportable matters.
Step by step
- Identify the protected information
A state agency's GAGAS audit identifies a material weakness in IT access controls. State law prohibits public disclosure of its detailed network-security configurations.
- Separate the finding from its details
The law protects the configurations, not the entire finding. Describe the material weakness publicly to the extent the law permits.
- Disclose the omission and reason
The public report could state: "Detailed network-security configurations have been omitted because state law prohibits public disclosure."
- Restrict the separate communication
The omitted configurations may be provided in a separate report or communication. Distribute it only to officials authorized to receive that information.
- Check the public report
Confirm that removing the configurations does not distort the finding or conceal improper or illegal practices. A separate communication does not replace the public report's omission disclosure.
Key points
- Remember: You may withhold protected details, but you must disclose the omission and its reason.
- The omission explanation should identify the restriction without revealing the protected configurations.
- Calling a separate report restricted does not authorize every agency employee to receive it.
How the exam traps you
- Remove the entire material weakness from the public report. Describe the finding as law permits; withhold only the protected details.
- Send details privately without explaining the omission publicly. State in the public report that information was omitted and why.
- Publish protected configurations because Yellow Book reports are public. Keep legally protected details out of the public report; limit separate communication to authorized recipients.
Question 2
Hint
Separate two GAGAS expectations: present the views of responsible officials (and the auditors' evaluation when appropriate) and make reports publicly available to the extent possible while withholding only genuinely sensitive details and using restricted communications for those specifics.
Answer B. GAGAS expects auditors to present the views of responsible officials when obtained and, where appropriate, include the auditors' evaluation of those comments. GAGAS also calls for making reports publicly available to the extent possible, but permits withholding genuinely sensitive details (for example, exploit-enabling cybersecurity specifics) and conveying them via restricted communications to those with a need to know to avoid harm. Therefore the most appropriate approach is a public report that fairly presents management's comments while omitting detailed vulnerability information and sharing that information through a restricted communication.
Why not A: Tempting because GAGAS emphasizes public availability, but GAGAS does not require public disclosure of information whose release would create security risks; exploit-enabling details may be withheld and shared through restricted communications.
Why not C: Incorrect because GAGAS generally expects the views of responsible officials to be fairly presented when obtained, even if auditors find those comments unpersuasive; omitting management's disagreement would misrepresent the record.
Why not D: Incorrect: withholding specific sensitive details does not automatically require restricting the entire report. GAGAS calls for making reports public to the extent possible and using restricted communications for genuinely sensitive specifics.
Question 3
Hint
Distinguish the separate GAAS financial-statement opinion from the auditor's separate statement about compliance with GAGAS, and consider whether the departure is significant enough to make referencing GAGAS misleading.
Answer B. When an auditor intends to comply with GAGAS and a departure is isolated and not significant to the engagement, the auditor may still reference GAGAS but should modify the GAGAS compliance statement (typically a separate compliance paragraph) to disclose the nature of the departure. The GAAS opinion on the financial statements remains unmodified because sufficient appropriate evidence supported that opinion; the modification pertains only to the auditor's statement about GAGAS compliance. Omission of a GAGAS reference is reserved for departures so significant that mentioning GAGAS would be misleading.
Why not A: Tempting because the GAAS opinion is unmodified, but an unqualified GAGAS compliance statement implies full compliance with all applicable GAGAS requirements. Because a departure occurred, the compliance statement should be modified rather than left unqualified.
Why not C: This overstates the rule. Omission is appropriate only when a departure is so pervasive or significant that referencing GAGAS would be misleading; for an isolated, non-significant lapse, a modified compliance statement is the appropriate response.
Why not D: Incorrect because the GAAS opinion on the financial statements is based on whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence supports the FS opinion. The facts state sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained for an unmodified GAAS opinion; the reporting consequence concerns the GAGAS compliance statement, not the GAAS opinion.
Question 4
Hint
Remember that GAGAS requires reporting of significant deficiencies and significant abuse, but consider how a separate legal prohibition on disclosure affects what can be included in the public Yellow Book report versus nonpublic communications.
Answer A. GAGAS treats significant deficiencies and abuse that are significant to audit objectives as reportable matters for the Yellow Book report and they should be presented or at least referenced in that public report. When another law prohibits public disclosure of a matter, the auditor should communicate the matter in a nonpublic written communication to appropriate officials (for example, those charged with governance) and indicate in the public report that certain matters were omitted from public disclosure because disclosure was prohibited by law. This approach balances GAGAS reporting requirements with legal restrictions on disclosure.
Why not B: This is tempting because auditors often use separate written communications to governance, but it is incorrect to publicly state 'no reportable findings' when a significant deficiency exists. GAGAS requires that significant deficiencies (and significant abuse) be reported or referenced in the Yellow Book report; merely omitting them from the public report would be inconsistent with that expectation.
Why not C: This option is tempting because abuse is significant and material weaknesses get broader attention under GAAS. However, it is inconsistent with GAGAS to present a legally restricted abuse matter publicly when law prohibits disclosure. Also, GAGAS treats significant deficiencies as reportable matters for the Yellow Book report even if they are not material weaknesses, so they should not be withheld from the public report without appropriate reference.
Why not D: This distractor appeals to GAGAS's transparency principle, but it ignores legal limits on disclosure. When a separate law prohibits public disclosure of a finding, the auditor should communicate the matter nonpublicly and note its omission in the public report rather than publicly disclosing the details.
Question 5
Hint
Apply the 2018 Yellow Book: report noncompliance that is material or that warrants the attention of those charged with governance, put lesser control deficiencies in a written communication to officials, and remember that abuse is no longer a reportable finding, only a possible indicator of fraud or noncompliance.
Answer B. Under the 2018 Yellow Book, the auditor's written GAGAS report describes the scope of testing of internal control over financial reporting and of compliance, and it includes as findings significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in internal control, instances of fraud, and noncompliance with provisions of laws, regulations, contracts, or grant agreements that is material to the financial statements or that otherwise warrants the attention of those charged with governance. The recurring grant violation warrants the attention of those charged with governance because it could jeopardize future funding, so it is reported even though the dollar amount is immaterial. Abuse, however, is no longer a reportable finding under the 2018 Yellow Book. The auditor considers abuse and waste only as possible indicators of fraud, noncompliance, or control deficiencies, so the abusive travel practice, which is neither illegal nor fraudulent, is excluded from the report. The control deficiency does not rise to a significant deficiency or material weakness, so it is not included in the report but is communicated in writing to officials of the audited entity. Because the engagement objectives do not include opinions on internal control or compliance, no such opinions are expressed.
Why not A: This overbroad option both reports the abusive practice, which is no longer a reportable finding, and reports the control deficiency, which does not rise to a significant deficiency or material weakness and therefore belongs in a written communication to entity officials rather than in the GAGAS report.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to candidates who assume every control deficiency must be reported and that a compliance finding requires an opinion. The immaterial control deficiency is not included in the report, and because the engagement does not include a compliance opinion, issuing a qualified opinion on compliance would be inappropriate.
Why not D: This is tempting because prior versions of Government Auditing Standards treated abuse as a distinct reportable category when it was quantitatively or qualitatively significant. The 2018 Yellow Book eliminated that requirement; abuse is now only a possible indicator of other problems and is not itself included in the report.
Question 6
Hint
Treat the GAAS opinion and the GAGAS compliance conclusion as separate reporting determinations; a GAAS modification does not by itself permit an unmodified GAGAS statement.
Answer C. A GAAS opinion modification addresses only the GAAS opinion on the financial statements and does not resolve the separate question of whether the auditors may state the engagement was conducted in accordance with GAGAS. Because not all applicable GAGAS procedures were performed, the auditors may still refer to GAGAS, but the compliance statement should be modified to identify which requirement(s) were not followed and to explain the reason for, and effect of, the departure. That modified compliance statement provides the appropriate transparency.
Why not A: Plausible for candidates who think cross-referencing the GAAS opinion suffices, but GAGAS guidance requires a modification that specifically identifies the unmet requirement(s) and describes the reason and effect; a general cross-reference or vague paragraph without those specifics is insufficient.
Why not B: Tempting because the GAAS-qualified opinion does disclose a scope limitation, but the GAGAS compliance conclusion is a separate reporting decision; failing to perform applicable GAGAS procedures means an unmodified GAGAS compliance statement is not appropriate.
Why not D: Appealing because auditors must inform those charged with governance, but restricting disclosure solely to a confidential communication while omitting or leaving unchanged the public compliance statement fails to provide appropriate public transparency; if the auditors intend to refer to GAGAS, the public compliance statement must be modified to reflect the departure.
Common questions
What must a GAGAS report disclose when sensitive information is omitted?
It must state that information was omitted and explain the circumstances making omission necessary. Here, state law prohibits public disclosure of detailed network-security configurations.
Can omitted Yellow Book information go in a separate report?
Yes. The protected details may be provided in a separate report or communication limited to authorized recipients, but the public report must still disclose the omission and its reason.
Can auditors omit an entire finding for security reasons?
A restriction on configuration details does not justify deleting the entire material weakness. Describe the finding to the extent permitted and withhold the protected specifics.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards, worked step by step.
GAGAS and Uniform Guidance Findings | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.